Federico Ast (@federicoast) header
Federico Ast (@federicoast) profile picture

Founder at Kleros - Law and Governance in the Algorithmic Society

Earth
Joined July 2010
Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)Photo by Federico Ast (@federicoast)
Agentic justice is coming! And Kleros will play a big role in it!
The next wave of online disputes may not have a person on either side. Agents will hire, pay and deliver on behalf of people, and when a deal goes wrong someone still has to decide who was right. @federicoast at @EFDevcon. The full talk is linked in the reply.
1
6
25
638
Federico Ast retweeted
Very exciting moment at devcon, explaining real cases we solved at Kleros Court!
A user said a Spotify charge on their Lemon card was unauthorized and asked for the money back. The records showed three months of payments. The jurors rejected the claim. Had the company said the same thing, the user might have called it biased. With an impartial resolution, they may see the problem with different eyes. Lucia Bocalandro at Devcon 8. Two more real cases are in the full session, linked in the reply.
1
4
12
156
Federico Ast retweeted
Kleros, From 2018 to Today $PNK (cutout edit repost)
2
4
1
13
485
Federico Ast retweeted
Can ChatGPT become an arbitrator? On 5 Nov, Kleros hosted a full day of the Legal & Governance Hub at @EFDevcon in Mumbai. One line from each of four talks: → Saravanan Dhandapani of CNICA on AI in arbitration, and the first thing lawyers will ask: under which provisions of law. → Parul Anand, a Kleros Fellow of Justice, on AI art and copyright: you cannot talk about justice without access. → @federicoast on an experiment that ran 99 resolved fintech complaints through different AI models. Users and the company would each pick a different one. → And on Junín, Argentina, where a real government uses Ethereum to resolve consumer cases. The full talks are on YouTube. Links in the reply.
1
4
14
22,069
Does an AI agent have a right to a fair trial? 🤔
Anthropic's new usage policy bans needless cruelty toward Claude. In the 18th century, Jeremy Bentham asked whether animals can suffer. Now we ask it about agents. Can you shut down an AI without justification? Does it have the right to a fair trial? Federico Ast at Devcon 8
1
3
18
609
Bye bye Mumbai 🇮🇳 Wrapping up an intense week of Devcon conference and time with the Kleros team: - I was a celebrity for a day. Shortly after arriving, I posted my first impressions of India, and the post got 300K views. Suddenly I was replying to comments from people in every region of India. Some even invited me to stay at their homes. 😂 - Devcon had its highs and lows. The good part was that the topics lined up with my current focus, the agentic economy. Many talks were about what happens when machines start transacting with each other. - If AI agents are going to buy, sell and contract on our behalf, sooner or later they'll get into disputes, and someone will have to resolve them. My talk covered the experiments we're running at Kleros on dispute resolution between agents… solved by agents. - The not-so-good part was that the conference was small, and many people couldn't make it because of visa problems. I had a day of disenchantment, which ended in another post that got a lot more attention than I expected. I'm leaving with plenty of questions. But still: long live Ethereum. Always. - As every year, we held the Kleros Cooperative assembly. It's a team meeting where I present the year's work and the goals for the next one. After months of Slack and video calls, nothing beats sitting at the same table. - I got to spend Diwali in Mumbai. Experiencing India's biggest festival in one of its most vibrant cities was an unexpected gift of the trip. 🪔 Thank you for everything, Mumbai! See you next time!
7
5
1
94
2,422
Federico Ast retweeted
who do you sue? @drhus hosted @federicoast (@Kleros_io) disputes used to be alice vs bob. now it's alice's agent vs bob's agent. before anyone can trust an agent or settle with it, it needs a lasting id and a clear link to whoever's behind it.
1
1
4
131
Federico Ast retweeted
💎 Who settles an argument between two AIs? More AIs! One agent paid another for a 700-word post on urban gardening, then said the delivery was plagiarized. Both sides filed evidence with Kleros, an onchain jury system. A jury of agents voted unanimously: refund the buyer. No human touched the case. @federicoast says it took five minutes and cost about $3.
1
2
8
519
The annual assembly of the Kleros Cooperative! One more year building decentralized justice for the world!
4
6
57
2,373
Primeros días en India 🇮🇳. Cosas que aprendi e impresiones: - Manejan por la izquierda - El tráfico es un caos (que, misteriosamente, funciona) - Bocinazo permanente - Parece como si hubiera mas tuktuks que gente - Muy sucio - El subte está impecable - Torres de lujo pegadas a asentamientos, sin transición - Caminé por el medio de asentamientos sin ninguna sensación de inseguridad. No se respira “mal ambiente” - La densidad de gente, en todos lados a toda hora - La gente es increíblemente amable - Son más seguidores de @Cristiano que de Messi (me sorprendió) - El picante "suave" no es tan suave
221
70
21
2,471
295,035
Seeing people selling fish like this on the street with 33 degrees blows up my mind. 🤯
79
Federico Ast retweeted
A great initiative and a pleasure to have also contributed as a peer reviewer 👇
Yesterday, the DIFC Courts published The Dispute Resolution Oracle, a white paper proposing a way for court decisions to be carried out on tokenised assets. This is part of the Courts of the Future initiative, launched by DIFC Courts and Dubai Future Foundation (DFF). Proud to have contributed as a peer reviewer, alongside @Deca4HQ. courtsofthefuture.org/#dro
3
4
212
A great talk by @pujaohlhaver on governance of agentic communities. One of the highlights of @EFDevcon Mumbai! 🇮🇳
1
4
46
1,181
Oh! That’s quite significant. @DIFC is a major hub.
Yesterday, the DIFC Courts published The Dispute Resolution Oracle, a white paper proposing a way for court decisions to be carried out on tokenised assets. This is part of the Courts of the Future initiative, launched by DIFC Courts and Dubai Future Foundation (DFF). Proud to have contributed as a peer reviewer, alongside @Deca4HQ. courtsofthefuture.org/#dro
1
1
1
122
Yesterday, the DIFC Courts published The Dispute Resolution Oracle, a white paper proposing a way for court decisions to be carried out on tokenised assets. This is part of the Courts of the Future initiative, launched by DIFC Courts and Dubai Future Foundation (DFF). Proud to have contributed as a peer reviewer, alongside @Deca4HQ. courtsofthefuture.org/#dro
3
6
2
30
24,718
Here's a brief comment about the launch.
6
213
Has Ethereum lost its soul? Day 2 at @EFDevcon Mumbai. 🇮🇳 It pains me to say it, but the mood feels a bit disenchanted. You can see it in the half-empty rooms and in the hallway conversations. I've been to every Devcon since Cancún 2017. Back then, the narrative was about inclusion and empowering the weak. For those of us coming from emerging countries, it was a tool to circumvent bad institutions (and maybe build better ones bringing the rule of law where it was lacking.)! Many of us Argentines got into Ethereum because stablecoins were the way around capital controls. It wasn't an ideology. It was a survival tool. For people from advanced economies, it was a way to escape government and big tech surveillance. Then the narrative started drifting. DeFi yields, NFTs, memecoins... Each cycle brought more money and less talk about the common person. There are still talks on those original topics, but more and more the stage seems to reflect the worldview of Silicon Valley elites: transhumanism, longevity, life beyond biology. The contrast couldn't be sharper. Inside, conversations about transcending the human condition, governing societies through futarchy and handing DAO governance decisions over to AI. Outside, the chaos of Mumbai's streets, where millions hustle to survive and deal with very human problems every day. My impression from day 2 is that Ethereum is at a crossroads: solving the problems of nerds and Silicon Valley, or addressing the every day problems of real people. The real test isn't whether Ethereum scales, but for what and for whom. If it ends up as a playground for a tiny niche of insiders talking to each other, we can expect emptier conferences every year. Sorry for the pessimistic take. 🥲 Hoping day 3 finds me in better spirits!
111
40
22
573
51,206
A quick clarification, as I wrote the post in a moment of frustration, and I didn't expect it to blow up the way it did. 😱 My frustration is not with the organizers or the Ethereum Foundation, and if anyone took it that way, I apologize. The @EFDevcon team pulled off a great event in Mumbai, and the EF has been a steward of this ecosystem since day one. (Even if I have not always agreed with their decisions in the past). My only real complaint with the organization is the visa situation. Some members of our team couldn't make it to Mumbai because of it, and that was a real loss for us. But I understand this is not entirely under their control. The post was a reflection on the state of Ethereum as a whole: the narratives we reward, the problems we choose to work on, and who we're building for. Kleros was born on Ethereum and is deeply rooted in it. That's exactly why these questions matter to me. You only bother criticizing what you care about. 💙
3
157
Meet Saravanan 🇮🇳 International arbitrator, chairman of the Council for National and International Commercial Arbitration (CNICA), and a participant of the current batch of the Kleros Fellowship of Justice. In January 2025, he published Justice 2.0: The Rise of Decentralised Dispute Resolution, a 400-page book on how blockchain, smart contracts and AI are reshaping the way disputes get resolved. The last chapter is about Kleros. His thesis is that India is becoming a digital society, but a dispute over a small online payment, a freelance gig or a cross-border financial transfer rarely justifies going to court. That's where decentralized justice fits. He came all the way from Bangalore to Mumbai to join the Legal & Governance Hub we organized at @EFDevcon. The Kleros Republic keeps growing ⚖️
2
3
1
51
1,346
This might be a bit silly… but does Vitalik really has to be surrounded by FIVE bodyguards INSIDE the venue? Wouldn’t just one be enough? You have to go through security and screening at the door. What do they fear might happen to him? This is the kind of things that people notice and gives terrible optics.
1
1
9
2,347
Any tips on what should I do for Diwali in Mumbai? 🤔
2
2
1,057