
ALT First half of letter: Brian Wilson writes today that the UK Government had to block the Gender Recognition Reform Bill, because its legal advisors said they could. Of course different legal advisers will give different advice - if not, there would be no need for the courts. This was the UK Government's decision, based on its opinions about trans people's gender recognition. The GRR Bill is within devolved competence. It was a manifesto commitment of four of the five parties (in 2016 and in 2021), and was subject to years of consultation. The Parliament took evidence from 39 expert witnesses, including supporters and opponents, spent many more hours debating amendments than for most bills, and passed the bill by a large majority. The standard way for the UK

ALT Second half of letter: Government to deal with any consequential effects they think Scottish legislation has is to use a Section 104 order to make amendments to the law to regulate those effects. Blocking a bill is unprecedented. The UK Government has demonstrated the same contempt for trans people as its predecessors showed thirty-five years ago for LGB people, when it introduced the notorious section 28. The 33 other countries and states around the world which already have systems for gender recognition similar to the GRR bill will be looking on in sadness, as the UK Government further trashes the UK's reputation as a fair country. Tim Hopkins, Director, Equality Network, Edinburgh.























