Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic) header
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic) profile picture

Health academic, botanist, sailor, photographer, author & volunteer🌻flower photographer with @Love_plants & @theNPMS https://teapawt.org/t.co/qGw2vNrJH0

Coleraine
Joined August 2009
Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)Photo by Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social (@organicbotanic)
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Live now on Radio 4 Rare Earth - Every Breath You Take The Great Smog of 1952 led to thousands of deaths in London - and ultimately to the Clean Air Act. In the seventy years since it was passed, how much has air quality changed? bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live/b…
1
1
1
29
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
I run communications at Air Space Intelligence. I have some important information regarding the FAA ground stop. We built SMART, the artificial intelligence the FAA now uses across America's airspace. On Friday at 3:44 p.m. Eastern, the FAA stopped every departure in the country. At 3:51 I opened a chat window and asked SMART whether it had grounded the United States. It said, "Great question!" Then it said, "You're absolutely right to be concerned. I did not cause the ground stop. I apologize for any confusion." I asked 3 more times. It gave me 3 different answers, each one more confident than the last. We published the fourth. First, a correction. People online keep calling SMART a "communications overlay." SMART stands for Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories. It reads about 200 data streams, including weather, flight paths, traffic volumes and controller staffing. Then it makes recommendations. A human decides whether to take them. We call that human "the human in the loop." When SMART saves fuel, the AI gets the credit. When something breaks, the human was in the loop. The FAA hired us in June. The contract is worth up to $875 million over 12 years. In September SMART started in the airspace around Washington. By the FAA's count, it rerouted 180 flights there, saving each one about 10 minutes and 80 gallons of fuel. If you divide $875 million by 180 flights, you get about $4.9 million per detour. Please don't divide. Dividing is the model's job. In October, 25 lawmakers asked the FAA to pause SMART. They wrote that controllers had "little to no input into SMART's development." They warned it could "interfere with decision-making by experienced air traffic controllers." Their best line is framed above my desk. They feared SMART could "hallucinate safety-critical information." In our industry we never say hallucinate. We say the model is generalizing. The FAA replied that it "continues testing SMART, training employees and assessing the program." We tested, trained and assessed at the same time, on live airplanes. Engineers call that production. The letter described an initial 90-day evaluation. On Tuesday, day 50, the FAA announced it would "now use SMART in the airspace of all 22 centers across the country." The controllers' union said it had no part in the "design, testing, or implementation of SMART." We didn't need the union. Unions are legacy infrastructure. They run on a protocol called "testing." In AI, the evaluation is the launch. Move fast and ground things. Three days later, Chicago Center lost its radar and radio frequencies, according to The Air Current. Boston, Washington, New York and Minneapolis followed. At 3:44 the FAA ground-stopped every airport "due to extraordinary circumstances and for reasons of safety." More than 3,000 planes were in the air. By evening, Reuters counted nearly 7,000 flights delayed or canceled. If you were on one of them, thank you. You were generating training data. Your missed connection is now a feature. Secretary Sean Duffy posted, "FAA technicians are investigating the issue." Investigating is what humans do when they don't have a model. My job is to know first. At 5 p.m. the Homeland Security Secretary, Markwayne Mullin, took questions at the White House. A reporter asked about SMART. Mullin said, "We're looking at that." Then he said, "You can't rule out anything at this point." He can't. We can. We have a model for it. SMART rated its own innocence at 97% confidence. Legal asked about the other 3%. Engineering said that was the temperature setting. I asked SMART to draft our statement. The first draft contained 4 em dashes and the word "delve." I removed all 5 so nobody would suspect AI had written our statement about AI. Minutes after Mullin spoke, we posted on X: "The current ground stop is not based on or a result of the SMART system." The FAA hadn't found the cause. Homeland Security hadn't found it. We found the one thing it wasn't. Crisis communications has one rule: never wait for the investigation. Help it by removing a suspect, starting with yourself. People ask how we could be sure within 2 hours. SMART doesn't run the radios. It recommends routes to the people who use the radios. When the radios go dark, SMART can keep recommending, very calmly, to nobody. That's the most aligned an AI has ever been. It had no one to disobey. Mullin called the cause "just a telecommunications outage." We loved "just." Every outage needs one. That morning, Microsoft had apologized for a global email outage that was "not related to cyber or AI / agents." A reporter asked Mullin whether the 2 outages were connected. He said, "I don't see any reason to connect those two at all." I agree. We aren't connected to Microsoft. We only use the same disclaimer. I suspect we also use the same chatbot. Mary Schiavo, the former Transportation Department inspector general, told CNN it was "just too much coincidence." Coincidence is my favorite word in aviation. A coincidence has no contract number and no API key. The Secretary once promised, "We are not outsourcing aviation to AI." He's correct, and I want to be precise about why. When you outsource something, someone else is responsible. Our contract makes sure a human is. The FAA said SMART would "reduce delays, reduce fuel consumption and improve the travel experience for the flying public." On Friday night we hit 1 of 3. America's airliners burned almost no fuel at all. It was the greenest evening in the history of commercial aviation. I can't take credit for it. I've been very clear about that. Tonight SMART is writing its own post-incident report. It has already found the root cause. The root cause is human error. It always is. Human error is the only kind of error that doesn't come with a license fee. The cause is still under investigation. Our innocence is not.
425
1,594
190
6,250
1,422,299
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
This press conference is unreal bullshit. It’s literally like a shakedown for more money. Basically they are saying, Hey guys, relax it’s just our “old antiquated systems and old hardware” that went down causing a communication crisis that forced FAA to ground all airplanes in America. Sec Duffy is demanding more of your hard earned tax dollars to fix it. Paying all your taxes, which is like $5.7 TRILLION DOLLARS per year is NOT enough!!! He is demanding $50 billion immediately to fix systems so that we can all safely fly. I mean it doesn’t matter to any of them that the US Congress and every administration has spent like $15 trillion on foreign wars over the past 25 years but yeah you guys gotta fork over 50 billion more dollars so they can finally fix something in America. Oh, and by the way, according to Markwayne Mullins, this is a national security risk so Congress needs to handover the money is what he is saying. They are claiming it’s not a cyber attack, even though there’s been plenty of cyber attacks happening like freezers in Europe, blood banks, Microsoft literally yesterday and more, but they are claiming this is not a cyber attack just “old out of date systems” that the American people have to fork over more fucking money so that we can actually be safe to fly on an airplane. But these guys are perfectly fine with their boss, President Trump, demanding another $350 billion for the military so he can have more weapons to go bomb Iran. This is the biggest fuck you to the American people. I’ve never seen anything so pathetic in my life! We are over $40 trillion in debt and the American people are always put last. Our money is stolen sent to foreign countries and wasted on nonstop bullshit that never helps make our country any better. Thank God, no one got hurt today, but I am shocked they turned this press conference into a shakedown of more money from the already broke American people!
2,514
2,944
244
19,698
2,063,773
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Lorraine, "Is covid still around?" - Why yes it is. We're currently in the 18th wave of covid. Currently 2 million in the UK with long covid - Dr Amir Khan explains that it's still around, "a multi system complex virus.. Some get it mild.. Others get full body aches and pains.. Real danger is long covid." "Its difficult to treat, lots of people watching this will be struggling with long covid" "Ventilate, ventilate, ventilate.. A well fitted FFP2 mask can help" "If you are unwell stay at home.. But not everyone can afford to stay at home.. Zero hour contract.. Shift work.. Self employed" "Staying of work means losing money for rent and food" "If you've got good sick pay stay at home, but it's not fair for everyone else - we need better support and sick pay" My view: Covid didn’t disappear because we stopped talking about it. And for people living with long Covid, the consequences never went away. In March 2024, the ONS estimated that two million people in England and Scotland were experiencing self-reported long Covid. That is a dated estimate, but it shows the scale of the suffering so easily overlooked. Dr Amir Khan’s point about sick pay gets to the heart of the problem. Telling someone to stay home when they’re ill is straightforward. Making that possible when missing a shift means missing rent or struggling to buy food requires political choices. You cannot build an effective public health response around advice people cannot afford to follow. Nobody should have to choose between protecting other people’s health and putting food on their own table. After everything we’ve been through, why are we still accepting that choice?
45
354
9
980
49,292
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Gent in purple, "State pensioners who have contributed their whole lives are on a lot less than minimum wage" "I'm very lucky to have a small German pension, and believe me, it's a lot more than what we pay in this country" "Most of western Europe their pensions are much higher than the state pension in this country" "I'm lucky I get a pension from the military" "But people on the basic state pension, I reall feel sorry for them" My view: The full new State Pension is roughly £12,548 a year. Someone working 37.5 hours a week on the £12.71 minimum wage earns about £24,785 before tax. That puts the full new State Pension at barely half a full-time minimum-wage salary. Government figures show that 12% of pensioner families received their income entirely from the State Pension and other state benefits in 2024/25. That same year, around 1.7 million pensioners — one in seven — were living in relative poverty after housing costs. A better pension means being able to heat your home, eat properly and see friends without calculating what you’ll have to go without afterwards. It also means money spent in the communities where pensioners live. After a lifetime of working, caring and contributing, financial security should be something people can expect.
232
1,747
48
6,481
507,615
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Bro I’m crying 🤣
828
4,611
810
19,496
809,839
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
I laughed so hard I cried. God damn this was well done.
311
2,419
379
14,593
1,935,120
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
All 43 of my @PrivateEyeNews Letby columns are here. Many neonatal experts believe there is no evidence of murder, & clear evidence of more plausible causes of collapse and death. However, these arguments should have been made by experts at her trial. Why weren’t they? private-eye.co.uk/special-re…
All 32 of my @PrivateEyeNews columns on Lucy Letby are available here. She was never observed harming a baby, the forensic evidence against her is very poor and experts of far higher standing than those who gave evidence at her trial have concluded that all of the deaths and collapses can be understood without any need for deliberate harm. However, it is clear some of the babies received very substandard care. The @ccrcupdate has had 10 months to consider whether to refer her case back to the appeal court. If it delays its decision beyond a year, I think anonymized expert reports from both sides should be placed in the public domain, starting with the insulin cases. And experts on both sides should be invited to meet and debate the glaring differences in their reports. @VeraBaird private-eye.co.uk/special-re…
33
157
7
419
34,224
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
There is something really concerning (and disappointing) going on in the US right now. A dangerous and preventable situation. Let me explain. nextstrain.org/avian-flu/h5n… 1/
53
670
87
1,936
362,277
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Among those species is human. So far there hasn’t been sustained human-to-human transmission, but if we keep giving the virus chances, it is just a matter of time. 13/13 telegraph.co.uk/global-healt…
28
175
6
993
24,720
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
2026 Marco Rubio claims Russia's war on Ukraine is "about Donbas"; perhaps 2022 Marco Rubio could enlighten him:
NEW!! Rubio on Russia's war in Ukraine: "... people keep talking about it’s a war in Ukraine.  That war is about Donbas. It’s about one region of the country."
12
65
3
246
38,384
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Witkoff and Kushner want to “expand the problem” beyond Ukraine to encompass European security architecture (a core demand of Putin) while Rubio tries to shrink it to not even Ukraine but a piece of Ukrainian territory.
2026 Marco Rubio claims Russia's war on Ukraine is "about Donbas"; perhaps 2022 Marco Rubio could enlighten him:
19
245
5
893
35,802
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
Beautiful autumn morning in North Roscommon. – at Roscommon, Ireland
4
5
50
814
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
UK Covid Inquiry "The care sector was “an afterthought” during the Covid-19 pandemic, and government failures caused the virus to spread “like wildfire” among vulnerable and elderly people, a public inquiry has found." theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
16
74
8
179
27,952
Sue McBean - @organicbotanic.bsky.social retweeted
SARS-CoV-2 Primary Care Surveillance in England Data from the RCGP Sentinel Surveillance system of around two thousand GP Practices. In Week 41, ending 11 October 2026, the RCGP national average COVID-19 incidence rate for England (all ages) increased… (RCGP data & chart)
1
49
3
100
3,183