
Independent investment research focused on public company interactions with the SEC, since 2000. Now @DIReports. @JohnPGavin, CFA, publisher.
Plymouth, Minnesota USA
Joined January 2014
- Tweets8.1K
- Following726
- Followers10.3K
- Likes1.2K
In 2022, Disclosure Insight became the lead brand for Probes Reporter. To keep getting our alerts on undisclosed SEC probes, and updates on disclosed investigations you can follow us now @DIreports.
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Since Trump’s return, undisclosed SEC investigations tracked by Disclosure Insight are down 75%.
Our October Watch List had just 30 U.S.-registered companies with confirmed, undisclosed SEC investigations - Lowest in our 26-year history.
Full report: disclosureinsight.com/since-…
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Hey @SECPaulSAtkins - We know you're busy, carrying all that water for the #crypto bros and such, but what say you about this?
Who Made Paul Atkins King? The SEC Won 200 Crypto Cases in Ten Years. Paul Atkins Just Forfeited All of Them. The Senate Wouldn’t Touch the Crypto Bill, So He’s Gleefully Passing It Himself, as a Rule. Lee Reiners and I Filed 33,000 Words Explaining Why Vacating This Atkins Travesty Will Be the Easiest Decision Any Court Will Ever Write.
Introduction. On August 18, 2026, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman Paul Atkins proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, a rule that would let crypto issuers sell unregistered tokens to anyone: up to $5 million with no financial statements and no SEC or state review, up to $75 million a year under a loosened version of Regulation A, with no holding period for insiders under either, plus a "safe harbor" that lets the issuer certify its own token out of the securities laws on a form no one reviews.
Call this monstrosity what it is: an aberration in law and an abhorrence in policy. So @leereiners and I filed a comment letter asking the Commission to withdraw it. Every word. Here's why:
For more than ninety years, the law governing the sale of securities has rested on one premise: The seller tells the truth first, and the buyer decides second. Paul Atkins proposes to reverse the order. Investor protection is not a courtesy Paul Atkins extends to markets he likes. It is the price Congress attached to the privilege of selling to the public, and Paul Atkins now proposes to waive the price and keep the privilege, for one industry, on that industry’s terms.
The SEC’s 200 crypto victories were not a policy choice that Paul Atkins inherited and may discard. They were legal conclusions, reached by Article III judges appointed by six Presidents. Those judgments cannot be disappeared by Paul Atkins. The judges who entered them are still sitting, and what they decided must be respected and enforced.
So when this rule reaches a courtroom, the hardest question will not come from the challengers. It will come from the bench:
Counsel, for ten years your agency stood at that lectern and asked this court for judgments on the ground that these offerings were securities. Now you ask us to accept the opposite. The tokens haven’t changed. The statute hasn’t changed. Howey hasn’t changed. The only thing that changed is that Paul Atkins became Chairman. So tell us: when Article III judges appointed by six Presidents apply Howey to these offerings more than two hundred times and reach the same answer every time, and Paul Atkins then announces they were all mistaken, which of those is the law of the United States? Does Paul Atkins’s vote nullify a decade of judgments? Because if the answer is yes, the next Chairman can nullify Paul Atkins the same way, and nothing your agency says to any court will ever be worth believing again.
Paul Atkins’s Release never answers that question. Across 146 pages of the Federal Register, it never explains why a decade of its own litigated positions was wrong, never cites, let alone distinguishes, a single one of the rulings it would displace, and never acknowledges those who relied on them. It simply proceeds as if none of it happened. That deafening silence is not an oversight. It's the only option available, because the honest answer is that nothing changed except the Chairman.
The Gist of Our Comment Letter. For a decade the SEC told federal judges that unregistered crypto offerings harm investors, and won more than 200 times before judges appointed by six Presidents. ICOs, SAFTs, utility tokens, lending, staking: securities offerings, every time. Now it proposes to exempt the very transactions those courts found easiest to classify.
The startup exemption combines what no exemption does: any number of retail investors, general solicitation, immediately tradable tokens, no intermediary, no investment limit, no financial statements, no SEC or state review. Insiders can sell on day one; the Release concedes a holding period could strengthen investor protection and rejects one anyway.
An issuer may raise $75M every 12 months, then exit through a safe harbor you could drive a truck through: a checkbox on a form, effective when filed, reviewed by no one, certifying that the issuer has completed, or permanently ceased, the efforts it promised. An exit visa from oversight, stamped by the traveler.
At the same time, the SEC has not applied its own interpretation to the token of the venture affiliated with the President's family. Investors, a footnote suggests, can protect themselves by contract: caveat emptor, restated by the agency created to replace it.
Sections 28 and 36 are 1996 backstop provisions, not a license to build a parallel offering regime, and with Chevron gone a court will read them de novo. The Senate declined even to take up the CLARITY Act; the SEC cannot enact by rule what Congress has declined to enact by law. The Release lists monetized benefits as n/a, never estimates investor losses, and never mentions FTX, Terra, Celsius, or any hack, theft, scam, or collapse. It does not contain the words money laundering, illicit, terrorist, or Bank Secrecy Act. It never explains its reversal of a decade of its own litigated positions, as Fox, Encino, and Regents require. It issued with no public meeting.
Who pays? Retail investors who buy unrestricted tokens. Who profits? Venture funds that buy at a discount, insiders who sell immediately, and platforms freed from state review, in an industry that spent $189M on the midterms by midyear. Nearly 18 years in, blockchain has no killer use case beyond speculation and trading; Big Tech will spend more than $700B this year, overwhelmingly on AI, and effectively nothing on blockchain. So the SEC proposes to give blockchain the one thing it never found on its own: a steady supply of retail buyers.
The Stark Reality. Paul Atkins is not deregulating crypto. He is pardoning it. Federal judges appointed by six Presidents applied the law to crypto more than two hundred times and reached the same answer every time. They did not read it wrong. Nothing in those cases has changed except the nameplate on the Chairman’s door, and a nameplate is not a legal authority.
Yet with one signature, Paul Atkins proposes to erase every one of those judgments and replace them with a vending machine: insert a form, pull the lever, and out comes a certificate declaring that the securities laws no longer apply to you. No one checks the machine, no one refills it, and Paul Atkins built it on the honor system, in an industry whose honor has already cost investors billions.
Presidents pardon people. Paul Atkins proposes to pardon an asset class. The Constitution gives him no such power, and no court will pretend otherwise.
(Fair warning to the TL;DR crowd: Reading the letter is not for the faint of heart. It runs more than 33,000 words and 235 footnotes. Pack a lunch sports fans.)
Read our comment letter here: sec.gov/comments/S7-2026-27/…
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
I was an active duty firefighter/EMT on 9-11. For years prior, mom regularly told me how proud she was of my service. That changed after she asked if I would have gone into the towers were I in NY. I said yes, of course. Mom then said she wished I stopped being a firefighter.
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Hey guys, great quarter. If only we could believe the numbers. To see why we continue to have our doubts, see our warning -
CrowdStrike: Can You Trust the Annual Recurring Revenue Numbers? $CRWD buff.ly/FmS7F44
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Long report, but worth your time - CrowdStrike: Can You Trust the Annual Recurring Revenue Numbers?
Audit Committee concerns and ongoing SEC/DOJ investigations raise questions. buff.ly/FmS7F44 $CRWD
Sign-up here to get our alerts for free buff.ly/VcqqWBL
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
The #crypto bros paid their money to help put them in office. They are now going in to remind all the players they've not done enough to weaken and change any regulations that might get in their way - despite the most pro-crypto SEC Chair and Commission in its history.
Top crypto executives are heading to the White House today as the industry presses federal regulators for answers on what's next.
Executives from Coinbase, Ripple, Robinhood and other major firms are expected to sit down with leaders from the SEC and CFTC as the CLARITY Act remains stalled in Congress.
Separately, the Justice Department charged 17 Iranians in an alleged hacking-for-hire operation that stole more than 31 terabytes of scientific research and targeted U.S. universities, companies, government agencies, and academics for the benefit of the Iranian government.
Download the FOX News app to follow this developing story and stay up to date with President Trump's White House meeting later today: foxnews.onelink.me/xLDS/z2jy…
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Since Trump’s Return, Undisclosed SEC Investigations Tracked by Disclosure Insight Are Down 70%.
DI now tracking 83 fewer undisclosed SEC investigations since April 2025. buff.ly/9iGWYgO
Subscribe here for free alerts: buff.ly/cnk019W
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Certainly acts this way -
"@SECPaulSAtkins is no watchdog. He is the [#crypto] industry’s own man, installed in the regulator’s chair."
To All Crypto Bros: Crypto Has a Ticking Clock Problem, and Almost Nobody in Finance is Talking About It (Especially SEC Chairman Paul Atkins)
Two things happened in the last two weeks that should be on every financial professional’s radar (and should be of serious concern for all crypto HODLers, especially bitcoin HODLers):
1️⃣ IBM CEO @ArvindKrishna told @jimcramer that within 3-4 years, we should all be “rather paranoid” about quantum computing’s threat to the cryptography underpinning crypto. Cramer is reportedly selling his Bitcoin in response (linked below).
2️⃣ Duke’s @leereiners published a comprehensive article in Duke's FinReg Blog arguing -- a must read -- that financial regulators need a plan for quantum-vulnerable digital assets, because right now, they don’t have one (linked below).
The Quantum Fear. Meanwhile, quantum-vulnerable blockchain infrastructure is being integrated deeper into the traditional financial system every month: spot ETFs, bank custody, stablecoin legislation.
The trend line is hard to dismiss. Research published this year cut the estimated quantum hardware needed to break current cryptographic keys by an order of magnitude. Millions of bitcoin especially reside in older, exposed and vulnerable wallet formats.
The industry insists it will upgrade before the threat materializes. But to execute a coordinated cryptographic migration across every chain, wallet and custodian is unprecedented.
Y2K Bug, Deja Vu All Over Again? Make no mistake about it -- this is no Y2K bug-like situation. I should know because I experienced the Y2K bug crisis firsthand.
I worked at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) during the Y2K bug threat and actually stood guard in the SEC Enforcement ticker room that night at 11:59 PM when the clock turned.
All went fine (thankfully) but only because the SEC spent all of 1998 and 1999 fiercely enforcing Y2K Bug disclosure from, and Y2K Bug remediation by, all SEC-registered entities, especially brokerage firms, clearing firms and national exchanges.
Specifically, the SEC strictly enforced Year 2000 (Y2K) disclosures by requiring registered firms to report their readiness and remediation progress. The SEC also initiated historic crackdowns and levied civil penalties against brokerage firms and investment advisers that failed to file or filed incomplete Y2K compliance forms. The SEC efforts were massive and extraordinarily effective -- just look at this Y2K Bug Report (one of many) from those days: sec.gov/news/studies/yr2000-…
For example, to enforce Y2K readiness across the financial sector, the SEC instituted mandatory reporting rules and released comprehensive interpretative guidance, such as:
-- Staff Legal Bulletin No. 5: The SEC issued and subsequently updated this bulletin to compel public issuers and registered investment companies to disclose material impacts the Y2K problem could have on their businesses. This included remediation costs, untimeliness risks, and third-party failures.
-- Form BD-Y2K & Form TA-Y2K: Broker-dealers and transfer agents were legally required to submit disclosure reports detailing their readiness. Firms not deemed fully compliant by the late summer of 1999 were threatened with mandatory cessation of business operations.
The SEC also famously took aggressive, sweeping enforcement actions against firms that missed statutory filing deadlines or failed to submit complete assessments:
-- Broker-Dealer Crackdowns: In late 1998, the SEC charged 37 brokerage firms for failing to file or fully complete Part II of Form BD-Y2K. Nineteen of these firms initially agreed to settle, paying civil penalties ranging from $5,000 to $25,000.
-- Investment Advisers & Transfer Agents: In the summer of 1999, the SEC brought enforcement actions against investment advisers and transfer agents (e.g., Peachtree Stock Transfer, Amervest) for missing deadlines or submitting incomplete updated TA-Y2K forms. Penalties reached upwards of $22,500 per firm, alongside cease-and-desist orders and formal censures.
Following extensive internal efforts, the SEC also imposed a moratorium from June 1, 1999, to March 31, 2000, on any new rulemakings requiring major computer reprogramming by Commission-regulated entities to allow firms to focus strictly on Y2K remediation.
Today's SEC and Quantum. Sadly, don’t expect the cavalry to ride in from the SEC. @SECPaulSAtkins spent years before his appointment on the other side of the table: co-chair of the Token Alliance, the crypto lobby’s advocacy arm; consultant to digital asset firms through his firm, whose client list included FTX, massing up to $6 million in crypto-related holdings disclosed at his nomination.
@SECPaulSAtkins is no watchdog. He is the industry’s own man, installed in the regulator’s chair. And he has governed exactly as expected: “Project Crypto,” declaring most digital assets aren’t securities at all and swapping enforcement for accommodation, all while the quantum clock ticks.
In short, when the Y2K Bug arose as an issue, the SEC spoke loudly and often, acted swiftly and aggressively and fully mobilized. Fast forward to today and the Quantum threat, there's only radio silence from the SEC and gleeful abandon from @SECPaulSAtkins.
Does Big Crypto Even Care About the Quantum Threat? Let’s be honest about who’s guarding the vault. This is an industry born in shadow and raised on anonymity, whose track record runs from collapsed exchanges to vaporized stablecoins to founders sitting in federal prison. Their answer to the quantum threat is ‘trust us—we’ll upgrade in time.’
Trust? From a den of thieves whose entire history is one long exercise in separating holders from their money. The only thing new here is that quantum computing might beat them to it.
The Stark Reality: Asking this SEC to plan for the day crypto’s cryptography cracks is asking a man to blow the whistle on the Big Crypto industry that made him. The chances are slim and none (and Slim just left town).
Fail not at your peril crypto bros. Start asking questions now. . . . And though you may not agree with my views on crypto -- my take is that crypto's only use is for criminals -- you should still heed my admonition (and please don't kill the messenger).
Lee Reiners article: sites.duke.edu/thefinregblog…
IBM Interview: cnbc.com/video/2026/07/30/ib…
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Our latest DI Watch List: 36 US Companies with Confirmed, Undisclosed SEC Investigations buff.ly/peTP5v1
Sign up here to get our alerts for free: buff.ly/bjXPG4L
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
<sarcasm> Good thing @SECGov is looking to eliminate the 10-Q because I'm finding all sorts of new risk factor disclosures in the current crop of filings. Am sure investors of all stripes will be fine without them! </sarcasm>
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
New report we posted today - DI Alert: Carvana and the SEC’s Complex Financial Instruments Unit $CVNA buff.ly/D57yc3R
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Our SEC Chair pimping for the #crypto bros, yet again.
Meanwhile, he's discouraged whistleblowers, gutted #FCPA enforcement, shut down large numbers of investigations, and drove seasoned enforcement officials out in droves.
We see you @SECPaulSAtkins. Worst SEC Chair ever.
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Courtesy heads-up @SECPaulSAtkins: We know you're all busy and such helping the crypto bros, but it might be a good idea to at least have your people look into these persistent and abusive trading patterns we keep seeing.
The peoples see it and are squawking about it now.
An epidemic of suspicious trading has emerged around Trump's most consequential decisions — each time, just minutes or hours before he rattles global markets.
It's precisely the kind of alleged corruption Trump built his political career railing against. axios.com/2026/03/25/trump-i…
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Since March 10th, our SEC Chairman @SECPaulSAtkins, has tweeted 22 times. Every single one of those 22 tweets had something to do with crypto. Nothing else.
Crypto bros are delighted.
Main Street investors are being ignored.
Fraudsters continue to wish Chair Atkins well.
Crypto markets—and the millions of Americans who participate in them—deserve long-overdue clarity.
Under President @realDonaldTrump's leadership, we are well on our way.
My latest in @CoinDesk with SEC Commissioners @HesterPeirce and Mark Uyeda ⬇️ ow.ly/5z2050YwxI5
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Correct. We've seen a meaningful slowdown in SEC enforcement activity under Trump 47. From a peak of 119 about a year ago, our March Watch List is now down to 50 companies with confirmed, undisclosed SEC probes.
For more, see our warning from Dec-2025 buff.ly/qlvP8aE
Replying to @mualphaxi
I believe this is unique to this second Trump Administration. @direports @probesreporter is the expert here.
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Replying to @mualphaxi
I believe this is unique to this second Trump Administration. @direports @probesreporter is the expert here.
Probes Reporter, Now Disclosure Insight @DIreports retweeted
Congratulations Team USA hockey.
Respect to Team Canada hockey.
A truly great game, well-played by all.
#MilanoCortinaOlympics2026



















