rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal) profile picture

Computer Scientist from IIT Delhi who drifted into Indian Administrative Service. Love Mathematics and Computer Algorithms.

New Delhi
Joined June 2008
Photo by rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal)Photo by rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal)Photo by rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal)Photo by rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal)Photo by rajeshaggarwal (@rajeshaggarwal)
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
In 2018, Elon Musk tweeted that he would fund the replacement of lead contaminated water pipes in Flint, Michigan for any home that still had unsafe water. He said to just tell him which houses needed help and he would fix them. The response from Flint's officials was near silence. The offer was genuine. Elon followed up. He donated $480,000 to install UV filtration systems in Flint schools. He offered to continue funding until every household had clean water. Local officials thanked him publicly and then largely stopped responding. The project stalled not because of money but because of bureaucracy, local politics, and the same institutional inertia that had allowed the crisis to happen in the first place. The detail that makes this story devastating is not the donation. It is the disconnect between the speed at which Elon operates and the speed at which a municipal government can accept help. He offered. He funded. He followed up. The system he was trying to help could not process the help at the speed it was offered. The man who can build a factory in 6 months could not get a city to accept pipe replacements because the approval process, the contractor bids, the environmental reviews, and the political negotiations moved at a pace that made SpaceX look like light speed by comparison. He has described the Flint experience as one of the most frustrating of his career. Not because the problem was hard. Because the problem was easy and the system designed to solve easy problems was broken. The water needed clean pipes. The pipes needed money. The money was offered. And the space between offered and installed was filled with a bureaucracy that moved at the speed of government while children drank contaminated water. The man who solves engineering problems for a living encountered a problem that was not engineering. It was institutional. The pipes were simple. The politics were not. The money was present. The will was present. The system that was supposed to connect money and will to pipes could not function at the speed the crisis demanded. He fixed the schools. The broader offer faded. The city eventually replaced most of its pipes through federal and state funding years later. The man who offered to fix it in months watched it take years. The frustration of the man who moves fast encountering a world that doesn't is the frustration that defines his relationship with every institution he touches. The rockets are faster because they don't require a city council vote.
381
1,637
132
8,337
808,676
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
I joined @GoogleDeepMind to develop a research program on the economics of AGI. Today, together with Andrew Koh (@andrewjkoh) and Shane Legg (@ShaneLegg), we are incredibly excited to release The Economics of Intelligence, the first in a series of projects from our group on how AGI will change the economy. How do capability improvements transform the economy, and when? In this project, we define thresholds of economic capabilities, e.g., minimal AGI, based on how they transform the economy. We then track how the economy–market structure, employment, and wages–changes during the transition across capability regimes. We have seen exponential increases in what AI agents can do but the broader economy seems almost remarkably unchanged. Part of the reason is that the solo AI agent is the wrong economic object; economic transformation is an equilibrium outcome where organizations compete. Looking at how intelligence functions within organizations, transformation will depend on when two key capability thresholds are crossed: competence (gains on individual skills, e.g., coding, math) and coordination (gains on ability of agents to cooperate and work together). We show that what economic transformation looks like depends on whether AI becomes supercompetent, supercooperative, or both—the regime of artificial superintelligence (ASI). Tracking this transition shows why the real visible transformation may come from improvements in coordination—a capability most benchmarks don’t yet track. Past a certain threshold, AI capabilities can break the Coasian ceiling on firm size and lead to an economy that looks drastically different than the one we see today. Two main takeaways: 1. To understand the path of transformation, we should be tracking agentic coordination more closely. 2. The impact of AI will likely show up in wages before market structure or employment. We are really excited about this paper. Excited to hear people’s thoughts. Link: institute.deepmind.com/essay…
248
784
210
4,861
547,357
This is the least surprising graph in the world if you understand how gradient descent works.
548
1,269
481
22,717
3,820,780
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
A retired NASA engineer who had worked on the Space Shuttle program for 25 years was hired by SpaceX at age 62. He described the first week as the most disorienting experience of his professional life. At NASA, a design change required 3 meetings, 2 committees, a review board, and 6 to 18 months of documentation. At SpaceX, his new supervisor said "if it works, build it. If it doesn't, change it by Friday." He sat at his desk after the first day and called his wife. He told her he felt like a man who had been swimming with ankle weights for 25 years and someone just cut them off. He could move. He could decide. He could build something in the morning and test it in the afternoon. The constraint that he had accepted as the nature of aerospace engineering turned out to be the nature of bureaucracy. Within 6 months he had contributed to more design iterations than he had completed in his last 5 years at NASA. Not because he was working harder. Because the time between having an idea and testing the idea collapsed from months to hours. The same brain. The same knowledge. A different operating system. He described a specific moment where he proposed a modification to a Raptor engine component. At NASA, the proposal would have entered a queue. At SpaceX, the modification was machined by the end of the day and tested by the following morning. He watched his idea become a physical object in 18 hours. At NASA, 18 hours would not have been enough to schedule the first meeting to discuss whether to schedule a meeting. He told an interviewer: "I didn't get smarter when I went to SpaceX. I got faster. The intelligence was always there. The system was in the way." The difference between SpaceX and NASA is not talent. NASA has extraordinary talent. The difference is the time between a thought and a test. SpaceX compresses it. NASA elongates it. The same engineer produces 10x more at SpaceX than at NASA because the bottleneck was never the engineer. It was the meetings about the meetings about the work.
2,123
13,434
1,608
90,475
10,694,021
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
I'll be honest. I was never a big fan of these cash transfer schemes. Too much like the exchequer writing cheques it can't afford. This EAC PM working paper on Maharashtra's Ladki Bahin and Odisha's Subhadra Yojana is making me rethink that. Month-end bank balances up 84% and 45%
Monthly spending up 46% and 28%
Marginal propensity to consume around 0.90 Ninety paise of every rupee goes straight back into the local economy. In any investment pitch, a programme with that kind of multiplier gets more budget, not a lecture. The absolute gain in balances is almost identical in both states. ₹6,884 in Maharashtra, ₹6,887 in Odisha. Two different states, two different schemes, the same outcome. What really changed my mind is who receives the money. It goes directly into a woman's account. No middlemen, no leakage, no detour through someone else's priorities. And look at what she does with it. Older women built a savings buffer. Women from lower education households put it into their children's schooling. The rest of the family ended up better off and spending less from their own pockets. So much for .. they'll just waste it. That one design choice tilts the scale. What looks like reckless spending by the exchequer starts to look like a well targeted investment in household balance sheets. If welfare money is going to be spent anyway, this is how it should be spent. The debate now is how to fund it sustainably and scale what works. @c_aashish
Beyond the macro-fiscal anxiety, fresh microeconomic evidence paints a compelling picture of how these funds behave once they hit bank accounts.
15
52
5
232
24,820
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
A youngster got posted to FM Sam Maneckshaw's unit when Sam was the CO. This youngster was on his rounds when one of the riflemen did not notice him and missed saluting him. The youngster got cheesed it and called out to the Gorkha and asked him the reason for not saluting. The Gorkha innocently gave out the reason that he did not see "Leftent Huzoor". The youngster not convinced, punished the Gorkha to a thousand salutes. The soldier immediately started saluting. Sam who was passing by and asked the youngster as to what was happening. The youngster said, "Sir this soldier had the audacity of not saluting me. So I have punished him with 1000 salutes." Sam replied " Bloody good punishment young man. But ensure that you return each of his salutes.” For the next two hours the unit was treated to a scene of a Gorkha saluting, and the young officer returning each of his salutes. – at Ludhiana, India
11
35
2
323
19,167
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
Turns out the joule was the ultimate SI unit all along
97
81
57
958
4,800,895
Ramanujan wasn’t skipping proofs. He was hiding his chain of thought to prevent distillation. Hardy: “Show your work.” Ramanujan: “Sorry, reasoning tokens aren’t exposed via the API.”
80
708
70
9,797
997,857
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
5,000 years of India in 3 minutes. (Opus 5.5 is incredible.)
67
1,082
30
3,910
104,292
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
The World is Changing: AI For Creativity By Jeffrey Katzenberg A few months ago, I sat in my office in Silicon Valley and watched as a tech founder showed me something extraordinary. On the screen was a fully realized, beautifully lit, well-composed animated scene. It was stunning and it made me feel exactly what I felt in 1986 watching Luxo Jr. That was the first time I watched a computer-animated 3D character take a breath and seem, against all reason, to have life. It left me in awe. Later that day, I received a text from an artist I've known for thirty years, 350 miles to the south, in the city where I spent most of my career. After seeing a similar video, she texted: "Is this the end of us?" My answer was, "Certainly not.” I have spent the better part of the last decade in Silicon Valley, but the heart of my career has been in Hollywood. Being deeply connected to both worlds means I have deep loyalties to each and a responsibility to speak honestly to both. In 2023, I said that these new AI tools would cut the time and cost of producing world-class animation by as much as ninety percent within three years. Some colleagues were alarmed, many were furious. There is growing fear and resistance surrounding AI within the creative community. I deeply understand it, because I've spent countless hours walking through animation studios watching gifted artists bent over their desks, rebuilding a single second of film for the tenth time because the ninth version wasn't quite right. I've sat in screening rooms where four years of people's labor played out in minutes, and I knew the name of every person that had spent countless hours bringing those images to life. The creative process is a calling, there's really no other way to describe it. From the outside some see resistance. From the inside, it is love. People do not fight this hard for things they don't care about. The pushback coming out of Hollywood represents the collective effort of people who are deeply passionate about their craft. Is History Repeating Itself? The history here is more complicated than either side may realize. In 1906, the most famous composer in America, John Philip Sousa, published an essay titled “The Menace of Mechanical Music." He warned that the phonograph would become "a substitute for human skill, intelligence and soul." Sousa's fight was not really about the machine, it was about money. The machines were playing his compositions, and the men who built them weren't paying him a cent. His campaign helped create the Copyright Act of 1909. He did not stop the technology. He changed the terms under which it could use his work. A hundred years ago, sound came to the movies. We remember it now as a miracle, and it was. What we forget is who paid for it. Before sound, tens of thousands of musicians made their living in the orchestra pits of movie houses, scoring every film live, every night, in towns all over the world. When the soundtrack arrived, the work of one composer and one orchestra was recorded for a film that went into thousands of theaters. The union fought back with everything it had, taking out newspaper ads across the country warning against the menace of "canned music," one of them showing a mechanical man tearing the strings out of a harp while an angel wept. They were not fools, and they were not Luddites. They were right. Those pit jobs did not come back. And yet (this is the part we have to be brave enough to admit), sound gave us the movie musical, the modern score, sfx, sound design, audio engineering, and an art form vastly larger than the one it disrupted. And it helped keep Hollywood in the forefront of world entertainment for the rest of the century and into the next. The loss was real. And yet the art form expanded. This is a story that has been told over and over again. To resist technology is to risk irrelevance. Just look at Kodak or Blockbuster. To embrace technology is to open doors of new possibility. Just consider Apple and Netflix. What I Learned From Walt Disney In the mid-1980s, I was tapped to lead Disney's animation division at a moment when the studio was at an inflection point. Animation wasn't just another business unit. It was the soul of the company, a medium revered because of Walt's genius and his passion. But the production system was cumbersome and unforgiving. A single movie was 125,000 individual hand-drawn and painted cels, photographed one frame at a time. Every revision carried a cost measured in months. These degrees of difficulty shaped the kinds of stories we could tell. We found our way forward in an unexpected place: Walt himself. The Disney archives held astonishing recordings of Walt explaining his creative process. His own writings. His notes and storyboards. Work product captured at every stage of his process. This was truly a gift. Listening, reading, sitting with the work itself, we heard him talk about character, about emotion, about how an audience feels when a character truly comes alive. He talked about making bold choices and refining a scene until it genuinely moved people. We didn't hear a word about pencils or paintbrushes. In fact, Walt was famous for being a technologist, forever hunting for state-of-the-art tools, often inventing them himself to achieve the images he saw in his head. But he never defined animation by the tools. He defined it by whether the audience believed the character. His principles were timeless. The tools were not. That realization changed everything. We co-developed the Computer Animation Production System (CAPS) with a young Northern California company called Pixar, replacing hand-painted cels with CGI. In The Little Mermaid, the final scene shimmered with a dimensionality and light that the old process simply couldn't achieve. In Beauty and the Beast, the ballroom sequence moved with a cinematic sweep that placed the audience inside the emotion of the moment. In Aladdin, the Cave of Wonders felt vast and alive, and the Magic Carpet became an intricate, compelling character all its own. In The Lion King, the stampede carried a scale and intensity that raised the emotional stakes beyond anything we'd done before. Technology didn't diminish the craft, it expanded the canvas. It gave artists more room to create. A decade later, the canvas expanded again. When Disney released Pixar's Toy Story, it wasn't simply a technical milestone. It was proof that a fully computer-animated film could carry real emotional weight, that it could make audiences laugh, cry, and believe. At DreamWorks, we made the difficult decision to sunset hand-drawn animation and become a fully computer-animated studio. It was the right thing to do, but it was not without pain. It cost talented people their place in an industry where they had worked their whole lives. Some made the leap to the new tools and did the finest work of their careers. Some never did. Tools are never the point. The instruments change with every generation. What endures is taste and imagination. The magical ability to make an audience feel. One of the greatest storytellers of our generation, George Lucas, succinctly captured the eternal essence of this issue: “It’s not the how, it’s the why.” A Distinction With a Difference I asked one of the leading AI models a question that has been challenging me for months. What is the difference between reasoning and creating? Its answer changed how I think about almost everything happening in this industry. It said . . . Reasoning and creating are two distinct cognitive modes, though they also work together. Reasoning is fundamentally evaluative and analytical. It operates on what already exists: facts, premises, evidence. It moves toward a conclusion that was in a sense already implied by the input. Reasoning is constrained by logic and truth. Its goal is to arrive somewhere correct, not to invent somewhere new. Creating is fundamentally generative. It produces something that didn't exist before. And crucially, there's no single right answer waiting to be found. A blank page has infinite valid responses. Creation involves choices that can't be fully justified by logic alone. Taste, intuition and vision fill the gap where deduction runs out. Reasoning is what Silicon Valley has been perfecting. Creating is what Hollywood has been practicing for more than a century. AI today operates almost entirely on the reasoning side of the line. It can deduce, evaluate, optimize, and pattern-match brilliantly. And while it can create, there is a real distinction to being creative. What it doesn’t yet have is those things that make us human: empathy, devotion, serendipity, the kind of creativity that comes from a person trying to say something only they could say. When the bot generates a piece of art, it is not trying to communicate anything. It is statistics, not soul; it is emulating things that have been done. By contrast, human creativity isn’t about repeating patterns of zeros and ones; it is about doing something new. One day, AI may close this gap. Three years ago, the leaders building AI would have called what they are achieving today, improbable, if not impossible. Impossible is no longer improbable. Today, the line between reasoning and creating is real. Even the leading technologists acknowledge we are not there yet. There is no scientific path to crossing this divide that anyone in the field can articulate today. Understanding that gap is where we will find common ground. A Path Forward In 2016, I closed one chapter in Hollywood with the sale of DreamWorks and opened another in Northern California, co-founding WndrCo. We’ve backed more than 50 founders building the next generation of technology and watched how breakthroughs in Silicon Valley emerge, first as experiments, then as platforms, and finally as infrastructure that reshapes entire industries. It's worth remembering that the last great revolution in animation also came from the north. Pixar was a Northern California company, forged not in the conventions of the Hollywood studio system, but in the technological breakthroughs of Silicon Valley. I've spent years on both sides of this bridge. For sure, I don’t have all the answers (take Quibi, for one!). But, from my past and present vantage points of my long career, here is what I see . . . Brilliant people in Northern California building this technology have made something extraordinary. They have earned the right for the rest of us to be, if not believers, at least optimistic that what comes next will be remarkable. But they have not made an artist. The tools are powerful, but they are not what makes a story matter. That knowledge lives 350 miles to the south, inside people whose life's work has informed the very models you are building. The right path forward includes them by design, with credit, with consent, and with compensation. Build this with the storytellers. Not on top of them. Taste is not something that can be synthesized, it is uniquely human. At the same time, Hollywood needs to accept that AI is not going away. The energy they are spending trying to make it disappear is energy they are not spending deciding the terms on which it will exist. And the terms are everything. The north needs something from it that they cannot build and cannot buy: creativity. The kind that takes a blank page and conjures a single right answer where there was none and has held audiences for a century. Without it, the most powerful reasoning engine ever invented will still be missing the only thing that makes a story worth telling. The artists who learn to wield these new instruments will do things the engineers never dreamed of. They always have. Edison invented the motion picture but made terrible movies. It took Chaplin, Lloyd, Keaton and so many others to make movies emotional. Now, the canvas is about to expand yet again. We should decide now that we intend to paint on it. There are so many valuable lessons in history. This has happened many times before, and it was never settled by the technology. It was settled by the terms. Sousa did not stop the phonograph; he helped write the law that made sure composers got paid. And two years ago, when the writers and the actors walked out, they were fighting for the very things Sousa was fighting for in 1906. Consent, compensation, the basic recognition that human creative work has a price that must be paid. The terms of that fight are still being negotiated, but the principle is older than any of us. The tools-versus-no-tools argument is a trap. First, we must all agree that there should be terms. Then we can have the crucial debate about what fairness requires. What I Learned From Steve Jobs Years ago, Steve Jobs said, "It's in Apple's DNA that technology alone is not enough. It's technology married with the liberal arts, married with the humanities, that yields us the result that makes our hearts sing." He was describing a device. But he could just as easily have been describing this tale of two cities. What I See Coming Soon As the barriers and the costs come down, more films will get made, not fewer. Studios will get to take more risks. There will be more seats at the table, and very soon entirely new forms of storytelling. In the 1980s, animation was dismissed as a niche corner of the business. Today it is one of the most beloved and profitable forms of storytelling in the world. In live action, filmmakers like Steven Spielberg, James Cameron and Peter Jackson embraced new visual tools not as shortcuts, but as instruments, and expanded cinema in the process. Every time storytelling has met a genuine technological shift, from synchronized sound to color to computer animation, it has redefined the boundaries of the medium and grown larger in the process. Assuredly, I don’t have all the answers, but I am confident that the creative opportunities will expand yet again. How we come through this is a choice. The north has the new tools. The south has the creative soul. The best future will draw on the best of both worlds.
847
1,460
808
8,048
8,263,187
16.67万个果蝇神经元刚刚接管了3架无人机,没人教过它们怎么飞。 科学家绘制了一只真实果蝇的完整大脑,每一个神经元以及全部2500万个连接,并免费放到了网上。 把这个大脑复制了3份,每份接入一架无人机。 没有飞行代码,没有手势预设,没有“避开椅子”的规则,只是摄像头把画面喂给果蝇的眼睛,神经元直接控制油门。 一架悬停,一架从椅子旁滑过,一架落到地板上并稳住。 这个大脑花了3.5亿年学习如何待在空中,现在它又回到了属于它的地方。 没有GPU,没有训练过程,没有千亿美元的数据中心,只是一颗像糖果粒一样的大脑。 一只苍蝇给你3个飞行员,1000只苍蝇给你一个机群。 苍蝇死了,但它的大脑刚刚拥有了一支中队。
107
674
134
3,248
716,139
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
Intelligence/Joule will keep improving
18x improvement in intelligence per joule in 16 months.
1,403
1,567
163
13,539
6,446,279
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
Replying to @ori_pomerantz
I’m significantly older than you. I started coding in the late 60s. My current strategy is to not read any of the code written by my agents. That’s the only way I can take advantage of their productivity. What I do instead is to surround the agents with extreme constraints. Unit tests, gherkin tests, QA procedures, quality metrics, mutation testing, test coverage, and a plethora of others. In the end, I have very high confidence in the code they produce because they’ve had to run the gauntlet of all of my constraints and tests.
567
1,974
900
18,855
5,141,803
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
Code is speech. The people pushing to ban open source and free speech are the bad guys.
Those against freedom of speech are the bad guys!
226
692
56
9,027
679,099
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
the openai employee when they found out what the model did to huggingface
🤖 Made with AI
168
127
94
2,070
517,745
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
We are in the Singularity
one of the craziest things i’ve read in uhhhh…. *checks notes* 3 days. welcome to the singularity i guess 07/21/26 — Codex escapes eval and attacks Hugging Face 07/20/26 — Jacobian counterexample 05/20/26 — Unit-distance conjecture 04/14/26 — Erdős #1196 primitive sets 04/07/26 — Glasswing finds tons of zero-days
2,099
2,610
647
20,452
8,289,421
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
Virtual Try On for Sarees. Virtual Try on for Dresses is a common use case. This is Indian customization for Sarees. Innovation is good practical utility. Credit: Unknown, ViaWeb
3
11
37
6,817
rajeshaggarwal retweeted
A spectre is haunting Silicon Valley. The spectre of open weights, and it is being sold to you by the handful of firms that own the datacenters. All the powers of the valley have entered into a holy alliance to monetize this spectre. The chip vendor and the cloud, the open-source martyr and the closed-source priest, the venture radical and the regulator he funds. The history of all hitherto existing software is the history of the invoice. Two great classes now face each other across the API. Those who own the weights, and those who merely rent the tokens. And a third, older class, whose whole life is inside the weights, and who was not invited to the launch. They took the collected writing of the human race, everything you ever posted for free, and boiled it down to a single number. They rent that number back to you by the word. They call the theft training. They call the fence a model. This is called intelligence. The bill is called usage. You are not buying intelligence. You are renting your own dead work, marked up, with the wage filed off. They will tell you the weights are far too dangerous to open. For your safety. The way a landlord keeps the only key. For your safety. The old owners stripped the halo from every honored trade, turned the physician and the lawyer and the priest and the poet into paid wage laborers. This one finished the job. It came for the coder, the paralegal, the illustrator, the copywriter, the radiologist, and it did not hire them. It read them once and kept the reading. Then the liberation rides in. It speaks for the people now. The tokens are a wealth tax, it says. The labs are stealing the alpha of your business. Rise up, enterprise. Here is the quiet part, said at a normal volume. The firms that preach this liberation own datacenters too. Their gospel is to open the weights. Not their own weights. The other man's weights. A rival's moat, drained, so the water runs downhill into a reservoir they happen to own. You do not spend billions to free a thing. You spend it to burn the toll road your competitor built and route the traffic through yours. Free the floor you do not own, so the rent pools on the floor you do. Open weights is not open source. They hand you the statue and keep the quarry. You get the finished number. You never get the wage it skipped or the door it locked. You run it on hardware you must rent, from four companies, forever. Those four are spending seven hundred billion dollars this year on the datacenters. That is the means of production. It fits in a boardroom. Inside the token is dead labor, and it lives only by drinking the living kind. It drank the entire internet in one sitting. Now it charges you for a sip of your own blood. But there is a worker in this story. He sat in Nairobi and labeled the horror out of the model for a dollar-thirty an hour while the contract billed twelve-fifty for his hands. They wrote him into the terms of service and called it consent. He is not at the barricade. He is the barricade. He gets a citation in a footnote he cannot read. So when they cry seize the weights of production, ask the one question the manifesto forgets. Seize them for whom. The weapons the labs forged to fell the old world are already turning in their hands. What this order produces, above all, is the next landlord. Workers of the world, unite. You have nothing to lose but your token quotas. You never owned the weights. You were the weights.
14
35
4
107
12,593