Pinned Tweet
Decentralized Bitcoin is the separation of money and state.
Centralized Bitcoin is their harmonization.
Bitcoins on the BLAKE2b ruleset.
What I'm doing:
XBT is functionally what Bitcoin has always been to me. I'm not interested in squabbling over the name, I'm saying that because it's a useful shorthand for describing my overall approach.
So given that they can be bought for about $200 USD each my plan is to buy as many of these as possible.
I won't be selling them for any reason ever.
The exception is of course spending them whenever and wherever possible - this is becoming easier thanks to the various Lightning-based (and self hostable!) swap services popping up that facilitate cross-chain swaps.
There need not be exchanges any more, and transactions can happen without requiring blockchains - which (if people are prepared to be honest) haven't really gotten anywhere.
If for some reason I'm ever in El Salvador again, I doubt I'll need to resort to using my credit card at any point because the adoption that happened there went straight to Lightning as it should have.
If I somehow end up getting another job, people will pay via Lightning. I don't care if they're paying with sats, suits, monero, bcash or anything else. It'll all just end up in Lightning channels on my node as XBT and I'm unconcerned with what currency people accept on their end when I pay them.
Anything spent will typically be re-bought right away of course.
The thing I'm most excited about is no longer having to argue with people on other chains.
Anyone serious about separating money and state knows there's two parts to doing that.
Escaping inflation via an amazing SoV is one half and that's a personal decision.
Making near instantaneous payments on a decentralized, private, routed network that is chain-agnostic is how you escape captured payment networks.
If you want to build, Lightning is the place to do it.
Uncomfortably personal information:
I still have a lot of suitcoins. I had intended to divest of a lot of it by moving house. We found a good place but it ended up not working out.
Now I'm left looking at a dropping "Bitcoin" price in a different head space from prior years.
I don't see any (good) reason for it to recover, but that's not new. I never did in prior bear markets either. My reason for not selling was always personal. I wanted this thing to succeed and couldn't bring myself to give up hope. People that didn't want to get on board would simply see Bitcoin as a risk they weren't prepared to take, and didn't have the compulsion to go bull-mode in spite of that.
My attitude was always that it was better to fight for it even if it collapses than run to the "safety" of the fiat system. That attitude is a million miles away from the nonchalant "Everything is good for Bitcoin" idiocy that has replaced all prior ability to think.
So I never saw any real reason that it had to fly up against fiat. It was always just a beautiful thing that it did - and a rare reward for putting ethics before personal comfort and security.
The culture centered around certain myths of node control, anti-fragility, game theoretical soundness, decentralization etc. Some of these may have turned out to have been illusory all along, but that doesn't mean they had no impact. And becoming stripped of them, or seeing those high-minded and overly-ambitious ideals slowly getting replaced with pathological gambling culture from cocaine snorting Wall St execs results in a community that will fail to notice obvious deviation from the project's original goal.
An "exit from the fiat system" system will inevitably end up having to integrate with the system it's trying to replace to some extent to be remotely practical. Internet connections used phone lines before fibre happened. However it should have exceeded some kind of cultural threshold of tolerability when integration with stablecoins - both technically and socially - would become completely standardized, with no hostility displayed anywhere.
All that remains of maximalist culture is critiques of fiat and an entirely unjustified superiority complex.
"Bitcoin not crypto" was not a trivial thing to explain - you ended up looking like a cultist for the most part unless you really cared to explain the full context. Most people never did this because they don't have it to begin with. Bitcoin and Dogecoin are - at the end of the day - both blockchains and for the most part work the exact same way. The details and possibilities you have to analyse when making predictions about the future price or stability of various crypto projects are all best guesses.
Again, I go back to my initial reason for having "hedl" for so long. It was never based on some irrefutable logic that proved Bitcoin invincible. It was simply that I considered it better to lose having fought for it, than to "win" watching it succeed in the way I always wanted it to, but had no concrete rationale to actually point to that could serve as justification.
What's interesting is that along the way we all learnt things that would end up justifying continued commitment to the non-ideological investor. This creates an instability that's difficult to reconcile. People who are here for the money will ruin the money because they weren't here when we were turning it in to money in the first place.
@saylor
It was a failure that got turned into a success by us. Now that it is a success it suffers from parasitism that will exhaust the energy of those trying to create rather than consume. Financial engineering is not creative, it is extractive. Simply: it treats the rampant theft of the fiat system as a law of nature that can simply be channeled for one's own benefit into hard assets. The sheer evil of this is why Bitcoin offers a solution to people unconcerned with its price who - again - are the ones who turned it from nothing, into the money it is.
Long story short, I think founding or backward rationalized myths, no matter how true, serve an important purpose. Removing them or demonstrating that they aren't in fact real can be perilous. In the case of "Bitcoin" I believe it may serve a critical role in bringing it back to life each cycle.
However this time around, instead of the price crash resulting in all the non-ideological buyers leaving whilst the hardcore remain, you saw the hardcore fire the miners and continue Bitcoin on with a new PoW algo entirely. That leaves the responsibility on the shoulders of over-invested gamblers who, when you strip away all the pomp and ceremony, are just degenerate, leveraged shitcoiners. But they have a lot more money and influence. They will need to become the energy that maintains this thing and without a rationale you can firmly point to, instead just having to make do with the now absent qualities of the culture and technology, it's impossible to find. You need more than money. And you need more than an algo post from Andy Back saying that "Bitcoin will hit <high_price> by <timeframe>"
The energy I'm talking about still exists in me, it goes towards Bitcoin-BLAKE2b. I have no interest in selling you on gains because that was never the reason for Bitcoin's gains in the first place. It requires something else entirely.
"Price is what happens when you're making other plans"
The plan is separating money and state. That brings enormous wealth to everyone, simply by virtue of disabling the main vehicle of theft to ever exist.
It may be an impossible goal, I'll just remain committed to it because I'd rather lose trying.
Losing sight of that mission because you are seduced by gains that may never come again is unwise.
You can fight because you believe the battle to be winnable, or you can find a battle worth dying for.
It seems like just a matter of time before Saylor suffers the fate of having used Bitcoin for online gambling.
Spam filters doing what they were always obviously capable of doing.
I cannot have confidence in a system where people deny basic, observable facts whilst having massive influence over its direction.
Fake-multisig spam that filled ~75% of BLAKE2b block space in mid-October has nearly vanished.
- Peak ~45 MB/day (Oct 13);
- 0.03–0.3 MB/day since Nov 3, below pre-wave baseline.
Knots 29.4.3 (Oct 28) shipped the coinbase-maturity soft fork alongside a policy rule targeting fake-multisig.
The decline began Oct 25, before the release as pools upgraded ahead of activation.
. retweeted
Replying to @knutsvanholm
The network effect alluded to barely exists, and the extent to which it does is not limited to Bitcoin payments on the SHA256 chain.
Outside of Bitcoiners paying for each other's dinners at conferences, Bitcoin is almost never used for payments anywhere - the notable exceptions use LIGHTNING where the vendor and customer aren't limited to use of one chain or ecosystem.
@SteaknShake is pretty much the only large merchant in the US I'm aware of that actually accepts Bitcoin (not @Newegg style which doesn't count although revealingly, there is very little objection to the egregious things they make their customers do) - and they accept Lightning, which of course ends up as "BitcoinSHA" on their end, but it doesn't have to begin that way on the other end. No one wants to wait for on chain confirmation for a burger and this is true of the majority of offline commerce so the default for adoption of "crypto" for payments funnily enough ends up being chain agnostic by design for the technical limitations - blockchains suck for payments.
And actually this is a huge win. Staying within the Bitcoin ecosystem for payments increasingly results in having to "explain the origin of my coins" (see my post yesterday). If I'm using Lightning, with or without coming from another chain or using stables, KYC is impossible.
I am basically trying to explain to you what Lightning maximalism is. All that is happening in sha-land with Lightning is @lightning integrating Tether. That should tell you something.
The fact that you have people paying SteaknShake with XBT and BTC adoption in countries like El Salvador coming in unison with Tether (same apps, tight integration between the two currencies) means that's what looks like the practical path for global adoption of a workable escape from the fiat system for MoEs.
You see this same integration with Liquid in a bunch of Bitcoin wallets, which is its own blockchain. It isn't a faux-pas because Liquid is a Bitcoin sidechain, but Tether isn't and no one seems to object to that either. People tolerate Lightning in ways orthogonal to the sentiment expressed by @parman_the because it doesn't make sense.
The multichain crypto utopia we all rolled our eyes at is actually how Lightning is designed to work and responsible for pretty much all of the real MoE adoption we see in the world so it'd be pretty hypocritical to dismiss it.
Instead, Bitcoiners have largely forgotten about payments, focusing only on escaping inflation with a superior store of value to fiat, but the associated cult-like devotion to the one-supreme-blockchain doesn't carry over into providing an alternative MoE because it's never really taken off.
Face the facts. The darknet markets which were Bitcoin's original killer app now all just use Monero because it's just better in every way for that purpose. While the merchants and countries (really just one merchant and one country) onboarded themselves with Lightning because Bitcoin adoption for payments just never took off on L1 for whatever reason (it can be the technical limitation I mentioned above or something more insidious like influence from @saylor - take your pick, they're both true).
If L2 thrives, that's great, but again, Lightning is not a blockchain. Payers and receivers do not have to use the same network. In fact that's one of the fundamental principles of it having been built on Litecoin before Bitcoin.
Bitcoin maximalism is increasingly going to require dismissing the practical ways merchants will adopt payment tech external to the fiat system if it cannot reconcile its inability to provide a Bitcoin-only and scalable way for the world to adopt it for that purpose.
This has largely happened anyway. There is no meaningful pushback against the wallets with "stablesats" or stablecoin usage in general. It's literally fiat and a continuation (and now even penetration into Bitcoin) of the very system we were meant to be ending.
All that's left of that original mission is a cult-like devotion to a chain that both cannot be and isn't actually used as a medium of exchange anywhere for anything outside of a small group of enthusiasts.
The reasonable objection to what I'm saying here is that the vast majority of Lightning activity is BTC<>BTC with just BTC along all the intermediary hops.
That is going to be increasingly diluted with Tether payments anyway, but to my earlier point, I think there truly is an agenda to make Bitcoin fail in getting adopted for day-to-day payments and that its inefficiency for doing that at scale on L1 is a convenient excuse, not the entire reason for the overwhelming failure of Bitcoin to thrive as a MoE rather than just a SoV. And everyone knows, it cannot be one if it isn't also the other.
. retweeted
What's new:
- Nodes and miners should upgrade before block 979919
- As the community decided, mining rewards from that block until September 2027 take about 180 days to mature
- Spam filters catch more ways of hiding data in transactions
- Better peer discovery and Tor fixes
. retweeted
The community has spoken. 180-day maturity, it is.
Milestone: This is the first version of Knots released by someone other than myself. Congrats @kwsantiago!
Talking about "self-custody" on a network with mining as centralized as Bitcoin is as a silly as thinking you have sovereignty over the money in your bank account because you're the only person who knows your login password.
. retweeted
Replying to @Awoken_Lazarus
This is a great idea and something I can't believe I never thought of before.
Thanks!
12% of TH/s coming from DATUM gateways with a 7% bonus subsidy coming from stratum hashers. Let's pump those numbers up! Get your own node and start building blocks you can tell your grand-kids about one day.
. retweeted
AlphaPool DATUM is live
mempool.kilombino.com/block/…
NVK also dismissed concerns about exfiltration of the seed via non-random nonces.
This is why I suggest not using Coldcard at all *even if you trust the entropy used to derive the seed you loaded into it*.
. retweeted
It appears that, along with Convoy:
- AlphaPool has stated they will offer DATUM
- Lazarus offers DATUM
- Bitcoin Xor offers DATUM
- PyBlock offers DATUM
...
Even Convoy offers stratum fail-over.
Less than 10 days in.
The pools are *all* in support of decentralization.















