Alan Mitchell retweeted
This would not save anywhere near $55Billion. Existing users are to be grandfathered. As soon as individual examples are brought up by media, Taylor will back peddle. It’s shoot from hip policy designed to show Coalition can be as nasty as One Nation. independentaustralia.net/pol…
Alan Mitchell retweeted
Explore this gift article from The New York Times. You can read it for free without a subscription. nytimes.com/2026/11/16/world…
Alan Mitchell retweeted
So #JessWilson confirms Jews have an enduring and ancient claim to the land of Israel, but doesn't feel indigenous Australians have that same right in Australia despite an additional 45000+ years of history. The difference can only be their skin colour. #auspol #springst
Alan Mitchell retweeted
Is this the future of political ads in the age of AI? @deemadigan
Alan Mitchell retweeted
Australia is headed for a very ugly future if Taylor and Hanson get control. Get ready for the biggest recession of modern times in which the poorest Australians, who are bring scared into voting against their own interests, will suffer the most.
Alan Mitchell retweeted
ICYMI
New dwelling supply. Building approvals have surged to a 5 year high, up 36% from the March 2023 low.
This is despite the RBA interest rate settings that are designed, explicitly, to weaken growth.
The pipeline of dwellings under construction is at a record high of just under 250,000. In the months ahead, these 250,000 dwellings will transition to completed dwellings, adding to much-needed supply.
My latest:
The housing policy is working to perfection
independentaustralia.net/pol…
Alan Mitchell retweeted
The case for leaving interest rates on hold was a strong one. Most on the MPB though viewed the case to hike as an even stronger one.
But this sentence towards the end of the minutes from November‘s board meeting — backing up the on hold case — is extraordinary.
Alan Mitchell retweeted
This latest round of offshoring this time by Bunnings is pretty outrageous. That's 350 workers who will start the New Year without a job because Bunnings decided to send jobs overseas and to AI.
Alan Mitchell retweeted
2 problems with Coalition plan to deny PRs access to NDIS. It doesn’t actually save much in medium term & the policy will unravel as more and more problem cases are identified. independentaustralia.net/pol…
Alan Mitchell retweeted
WOW! He’s no lightweight UK commentator. And his words also describe @abcnews reporting instructions under Stevens.
Veteran BBC journalist Stephen Sackur has called out the corporation’s “impartiality” on Gaza as unsustainable and one-sided.
He highlighted how the BBC was ordered from the top to attach a terrorism label every single time it reported Palestinian death tolls from the Hamas-run health ministry.
Yet when Israel officially denied bombing apartment blocks full of women and children, or striking a food kitchen and killing aid workers, the BBC never mentioned that Netanyahu is wanted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes.
“BBC’s notion of impartiality is a difficult thing to sustain… it’s difficult for me to justify the BBC talking so rigorously about impartiality and then reporting that way.”
“The BBC manual doesn’t talk about morality.”
This is what “both-sides” journalism looks like when one side is an occupying power with an ICC arrest warrant and the other is under bombardment.
Alan Mitchell retweeted
TODAY the NSW government is attempting to push through the Mt Pleasant Mine Bill tailored to appease their #coal mates and circumnavigate a recent decision in the High Court.
Call your MP now - you can also watch the debate online today.
knittingnannas.org/2026/11/1…
Alan Mitchell retweeted
GOOD STICKY TAPE?? OR NOT??
Allegra Spender suggests changing the new CGT arrangements outside of property - going back to the discount approach, but at 40% rather than 50%
That wouldn't be the best outcome, but it is probably better than what we're otherwise getting
Let me step back for a moment
Remember that it absolutely makes sense to tax capital income differently to how we tax wages
1). Partly that's because we tax wages immediately, but we only tax capital gains after they're realised. So, unless we adjust for it, part of the gain we're otherwise taxing is simply inflation
2). Partly it's because we tax a capital gain as if it has been earned all at once - even though it's usually been earned over some years. As we have a progressive tax system, that lumpiness can unfairly push people into a higher tax bracket
3). And partly it is because we need to save before we can earn a return on those savings, so taxing those returns therefore means we tax savers more than we tax spenders
That backdrop means that ideally we should:
1). adjust for inflation,
2). average out capital gains, and
3). provide a discount relative to the tax on wages
But that's not what the government has done
Yes, it has allowed indexation for inflation. But it didn't allow averaging to smooth out the lumpiness of returns. (Instead, it put in a minimum tax rate). And it didn't allow for any ongoing discount
And, although it has allowed for inflation indexation, that's only on gains - not on losses. That doesn't matter much for property. But it does for shares - effectively boosting the tax rate on portfolios
That backdrop means three things
First, that Australia has gone from taxing capital gains too little to taxing them too much, with both the old and new systems being less than ideal
Second, the Allegra option therefore needs to be compared with the government's legislation - not with perfection. And on that front the Allegra option is, in my view, the better bet
Third, it looks to me as if the government's estimates of the revenue it'll raise through its approach are too low. It has tried so hard to plug potential loopholes that it has overegged its rules and underegged its estimated tax take. In turn, that says to me that the Allegra option won't hurt the bottom line versus the costings in the budget
The bottom line?
The Allegra option isn't perfect
But perfect isn't on the menu
So count me in





























