Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
Europe still faces internal divisions and must overcome decades of dependence on the U.S. However, given its central role in the region, Washington is well-positioned to help unlock Europe's considerable defense potential.
Read Non-Resident Fellow @TcavannaP's new explainer: defensepriorities.org/explai…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
In a recent interview, Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia, former grand chancellor of the John Paul II Institute on Marriage and Family Life, confirmed the worst suspicions that many of us had.
He admitted that the changes he made at the Institute during the Pope Francis years were designed to initiate a "very profound" reform of the idea of the natural law.
Instead of absolute moral norms grounded in a keen understanding of the basic goods, he and his colleagues were proposing a moral theory rooted in historical discernment of subjective and cultural experience--not an "armchair theology" but one operating "within history and within people's lives."
This, of course, is the language of trendy postmodernism, and it is dangerous indeed.
Allow me to illustrate the principle with one example. Is slavery wrong?
Intrinsically wrong? Wrong no matter what public opinion polls say about it, no matter what the current consensus on it might be? I imagine any decent person would say yes.
But that yes is predicated upon precisely what the tradition calls the natural law and the basic goods. There are some values so fundamental that acts repugnant to them are by their very nature wicked.
If you want a highly articulate presentation of this idea, go to St. John Paul II's Veritatis Splendor.
If we say that this is just "armchair theologizing" and that morality is a function of ever-shifting cultural and experiential data, then why couldn't slavery be justified?
One of the very smartest persons that ever lived, the philosopher Aristotle, thought it was; extremely bright and morally upright persons in our country, well into the 19th century, thought it was permissible.
Who is to say whether the consensus might shift back again? Who is to say that "lived experience" might come to justify it?
What any truly coherent moral program requires is the very thing that Archbishop Paglia and his colleagues were endeavoring to eliminate, namely, absolute moral norms.
Ridding ourselves of these in the name of freedom or pastoral sensitivity actually renders moral discourse dysfunctional, just as relativizing the basic principle of logic would render any rational conversation impossible.
The Archbishop's interview, frankly, reminded me of the discussions I had at the Synod on Synodality with some of my German colleagues. Under the rubric of the development of doctrine, they were eager to relativize or radically change the principles undergirding classical morality. If this was and is truly the game, we have ventured onto perilous seas.
Link to the article below.
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
I like the Freedom Caucus, but attaching the SAVE Act to warrantless spying is dumb. Why would we let the government spy on us in exchange for anything?
After we trade the Fourth Amendment for parliamentary advantage, what shall we trade the First and Second Amendments for?
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
This framework agreement between the United States and Iran is a stopgap measure to buy time for a longer, technically complicated negotiation on Iran's nuclear program, the very issue that purportedly compelled Trump to wage the conflict about four months ago, @DanDePetris writes in @MSNOWNews. ms.now/opinion/iran-us-war-d…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
Fox correspondent: "I asked the president what will happen if the Iranians don't sign an agreement that was put forward by American negotiators. President Trump said, 'We'll bomb the s**t out of them tomorrow night.'"
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
The human heart is not filled by accumulating experiences, possibilities, or temporary guarantees; it is filled when it discovers a call, when it understands that life reaches fullness only if it is given. Following Christ does not impoverish existence, but expands it. #ApostolicJourney
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
The Iran War Powers Resolution that I cosponsored (opposing the war) just passed the House of Representatives.
The People’s House is sending a message: end this war.
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
In my latest @DEFP interview, I talk with Policy Director @BH_Friedman about his new explainer (link in the comments) on U.S. force posture in Europe and why it's time for the U.S. to stop bargaining and begin a phased withdrawal.
WATCH HERE: youtube.com/watch?v=iFjdfazo…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
Catholics are erecting Sacred Heart billboards across the United States, proclaiming June as the Month of the Sacred Heart of Jesus
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
Trump took us to war in Iran without public support, without Congress, without a clear mission, and without a viable plan. He doesn’t know how to exit, so every week he just resorts to bluster and hopes it works out.
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
“The situation with Iran is untenable—yet as badly as Trump needs and wants a deal to end the impasse, his own decisions continue to sabotage the bargaining process,” write @jekavanagh and @RKelanic. What would Trump’s least bad outcome look like?
foreignaffairs.com/iran/trum…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
The Trump administration has largely maintained the U.S. force posture in Europe, leveraging it to bargain for defense spending pledges.
In this explainer for @defpriorities, @BH_Friedman and I argue that this approach does not serve U.S. interests.
defensepriorities.org/explai…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
lol. Calling anyone who disagrees with your foreign policy preferences “antisemitic” is obscene, defamatory and counterproductive. Pro-Israel billionaires funded the campaign. Their political hit men said why thy targeted Massie, and now all of them, including Israeli papers are gloating about it. But no one else is allowed to say it? “The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”
From @WSJFreeEx via @WSJOpinion: After losing a primary election Tuesday night, Rep. Thomas Massie peddled the oldest antisemitic trope in the book: that conniving Jews hold secret power, writes @matthennessey
on.wsj.com/4fygtbZ
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
There's been some confusion over my argument in this week's episode, so I'll spell it out: despite its modern reputation as being an anti-Semitic dog whistle, the phrase “Christ is King” is one that makes perfect sense within both Christian and Jewish theology.
God is King, and the Messianic Son of David shares in this divine kingship. Rather than a point of disunity, this theology gives us a framework in which to make sense of Jesus's claim to Messiahship and Kingship.
youtube.com/watch?v=7so8w0Vm…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
The total collapse of the Trump GOP began the day Trump invaded Iran. All he can do now is defeat his own partymates.
The collapse will be completely obvious by September to everyone besides the die-hard MAGA. By the morning of November 4, they will have to admit it.
NEW: Trump’s revenge tour is increasingly imperiling his midterm agenda on the Hill.
“Those so-called victories over the last couple weeks are just a mirage. They are self-owns,” one senior Senate Republican operative told me. “We’re not actually beating Democrats, and we’re not actually advancing legislation. Instead, gas is up 45% due to our actions and the President’s decision to go to war with Iran. He’s focused on the ballroom. He’s announced a $1.8 billion restitution fund with zero details or congressional authority to do so. It just is crazy.”
My latest with @adamwren and @sambbenson.
politico.com/news/2026/05/20…
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
Whatever disagreements one might have with @RepThomasMassie, this is who he is, which is why he must be supported and must win
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
The problem with the administration rocking back and forth in its chair repeating “Iran can’t have a nuclear weapon, Iran can’t have a nuclear weapon” is that Iran was nowhere near getting a nuclear weapon.
Bob DiCostanzo retweeted
STATEMENT: President Trump departed Washington yesterday and is now in Beijing to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping. @lylegoldstein, DEFP Asia Program Director, issued the following statement in response:
defensepriorities.org/press-…


























