Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132) header
Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132) profile picture

Random thoughts on science, technology, culture, education, research, and hydrology. Views are personal.

Mumbai
Joined October 2020
Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)Photo by Basudev Biswal (@Basudev4132)
We need a separate academic discipline to study the hate for Brahmins. For the most part of Indian history, they did not hold power. They did not hold wealth either. Then why do so many people, including our politicians and policymakers, hate Brahmins? It is basically a failure to understand the historical context. Everyone interested in the subject needs to read about the early British policies and how they helped the rise of Brahmins. While education was not restricted to Brahmins (see, for example, The Beautiful Tree by Dharampal), the British government, in its early days, established Sanskrit colleges exclusively for Brahmins. Their main purpose was to learn Indian scriptures for governance. This early British preference created a near-total monopoly of Brahmins in colonial administration, law, and education. In the Madras Presidency, for instance, Brahmins made up roughly 3% of the population but held over 70% of administrative and educational posts. This resulted in Brahmins being hated by others, which politicians focusing on caste division exploited.
"आरक्षण तब तक जारी रहेगा, जब तक कि आखिरी ब्राह्मण आत्महत्या नहीं कर लेता" -कहना है मराठा सेवा संघ के अध्यक्ष श्री खेडेकर का! और इस बात पर जोरदार तालियां भी बजती हैं! हमने fake atrocity की कहानियों से लोगों का इसकदर ब्रेनवॉश किया है कि सरेआम किसी समुदाय के खात्मे की बात करने में किसी को कोई बुराई नहीं नज़र आ रही! आरक्षण अब समाजिक न्याय नहीं, इसी घृणा पर टिका है??
56
Demystifying the Tapasya Code: Ravan did tapasya to gain the power to defeat Indra, the ruler of Heaven. Brahma was compelled to grant him the power, and he knew the power was going to be misused. Why didn't Brahma simply stop Ravan from doing tapasya in the first place? He knew clearly that Ravan would misuse the power. What is the meaning of tapasya in the first place? Indian philosophy is so complex and layered that anyone can project their understanding onto it as a pattern and convince others. Some see Ravan standing in one place for thousands of years and meditating on his goal. For a curious mind, willing to peel some layers, it may reveal something profound. To me, tapasya means hard work plus focus plus steadfast determination, which every researcher should possess. Someone's identity and background do not matter much. Ravan was not the only Asura who did tapasya to gain enormous power. He was merely following the footsteps of countless Asuras, the morally fallen ones, who came before him, and all succeeded in compelling Brahma and Shiva to give them power. Anyone willing to do tapasya will succeed. There is no divine force to stop someone willing to work hard and bear the pain with determination. How much time it takes to achieve the goal may vary, but the only way to achieve the goal is to do tapasya. That is the real beauty of Indian philosophy. Your fate is in your hands!
46
Rajiv Malhotra's works made countless people across generations aware of the dangers to Indian civilization. It is intriguing how some within the fold are now mad at him after he showed appreciation for Ramayana: Rise of a Legend. Intriguing because I see people raising questions as a positive sign. Debates make us stronger, not weaker. But calling someone who has dedicated his life to defend our civilization a sell-out is not helping any cause. Being paranoid about a threat is not a good substitute for doing the hard work to understand the threat.
1
77
Ramayan and the Rise of Puritans in India Adipurush, an otherwise well-made film, had horrible VFX. But the backlash it got on social media was for the dialogues that offended a certain group of people, who project themselves as the defenders of Indian culture. Manoj Muntashir tried his best to explain his choice of words but had to give an unconditional apology with folded hands. I understand their concerns -- Bollywood filmmakers have been attacking Indian culture for far too long. However, blind anger is not a substitute for the efforts required for understanding Indian culture. Yesterday, I went to watch Ramayan, mainly to see why it offended so many who love Indian culture. The first 15 minutes of the film made me think that it was going to be a projection of Marxist class war nonsense onto an Indian epic. Then I was truly surprised by how the makers incorporated so many nuanced view points of Indian philosophy into a commercial film made for a CGI-loving generation that hardly understands India's intellectual heritage. The VFX team has simply done a great job. Yash as Ravan has given his best. Sure, I would have liked it even more if they had worked a little harder on the acting of Ranveer. I hope this film will pave the way for future Indian films to reach audiences outside India.
125
I watched the film yesterday. The first 15 minutes made me think it was going to project the Marxist class war nonsense onto our epic. Then I was very impressed how well the makers incorporated Indian philosophical nuances into a commercial film made for a generation that hardly has an understanding of intellectual heritage. Absolutely worth watching.
8
39
1
392
10,079
LOL. Looks like a military grade weapon.
73
Sensible remark.
Welcome Step by Judge of Allahabad High Court
63
Basudev Biswal retweeted
Why do Western intellectuals so often despise Sanatana Dharma, and why do they seem to be so dismissive of (practicing) Hindus and Hindu faith? When it comes to Sanatana Dharma, there is certainly none of the romanticizing Western Orientalism that we find with regard to Islam (cf. "Lawrence of Arabia"), Shinto (despite WWII), Chinese religion (witness the highly respectful tone of most Sinology), or even Buddhism (which though originating in Sanatana Dharma is seen in the West as an elite religion). Even Western academics who study Sanskrit no longer seem to admire the religion it embodies, though things may have been different in centuries past. Elite Western antihinduism really does seem to be something "sui generis" -- of its own kind. I don't have a research-based answer, though I do have a guess. I suspect it is related to a residual iconoclasm in the post-Christian West, especially in Protestant countries. Jewish lore has it that Abraham founded his religion by smashing all the idols in his father's shop. Like most Muslims, Protestant Christians have embraced this inherent iconoclasm. Today it's not only Hindu idols that they smash; they also deface and pull down their own statues. Look at civic art in the West today: except when it explicitly defiles the Western inheritance, it is all abstract. Even Mohammed would approve. I have told Jewish audiences that elite Western antisemitism has its roots in a civilizational shame at having appropriated the Jewish God. I suspect something similar is at work with regard to antihinduism. Hindu worship is, after all, a reminder of the West's pre-Christian past. The towering classical figures of Western literature (Homer, Herodotus, Aeschylus, Sophocles, Thucydides, Plato, Aristotle, Plutarch, Virgil, Horace, Cicero, etc.) would all have felt quite at home in a Hindu temple. They would have felt equally at home performing puja in a typical Hindu home. Ancient Greco-Roman worship was essentially the same as ancient Hindu worship -- and contemporary Hindu worship. It is Hindus who have kept the classical tradition alive. There is thus, perhaps, also a deep-seated civilizational shame in the West at having repudiated the religion of our forefathers. Might we instinctively recognize that we have embraced (indeed: appropriated) a Middle Eastern god who is not our own, and adopted Middle Eastern practices (monotheism, iconoclasm, zealotry) that are not native to our culture? At first reading that just sounds crazy, but consider the fact that Christianity has repeatedly sought to cleanse itself of recurring idolatry, just as Persia (another ancient Indo-European culture) has been the focus of repeated cleansings of Islam. Might it be that the West's folk culture has always been in tension with the iconoclasm of elite intellectualism? The desire to burn a candle in front of an idol (of Mary or a saint), or to burn incense in a home shrine (not just for air purification) seems to run deep in Western folk spirituality. All of this is of course highly tenuous. But I do find it plausible that there is an inertial cultural complex (not a psychological "race mind") that, having evolved over millennia, still has not after 2000 years fully assimilated the imposition of Christianity. The very fact that the ancient (Pagan) world is considered "classical" indicates that it is still a cultural touchstone for our civilization. Yet the West (and especially the intellectual vanguard of the West) is in perpetual conflict with that classical inheritance. Just look at Nolan's Odyssey to see that. We have inherited a classical literature but we recoil at a classical morality. Hindus (or at least: the core proponents of mainstream popular Hindu faith) do not recoil at their classical inheritance, or at ours. The morality of the Bhagavad Gita does not differ much from the morality of Plato or of the Iliad, but all of these are completely at odds with the morality taught by Jesus -- or in Western schools. Traditional Christian morality and modern secular morality are very different, but they both represent a repudiation of the Indo-European classical inheritance. In short, Hindus remind us of our purer selves, or at least of our original selves. They represent the faith of the old gods from which we have strayed. Today, Western intellectuals are clearly able to admire non-Western religions that do not remind them of their own classical inheritance. They seem, however, to display a visceral aversion to Sanatana Dharma, especially in its continuing contemporary practice. Those Western intellectuals of the 18th and 19th centuries who did embrace Sanskrit literature (British orientalism, American transcendentalism, German romanticism) seemed to have done so precisely because they yearned to repudiate their Christian cultural overlay. For today's Western intellectuals, Shinto and Buddhism can feel like refinements, whereas Hindu faith seems retrograde. The colonized mind, of course, perceives this, but misinterprets the Western intellectual's revulsion at Hindu worship for mere disdain. The post-Hindu anti-Hindu looks down on the Sanatani's faith. But the post-Christian anti-Hindu recoils from it. Whereas post-Hindu intellectuals feel embarrassed by their Hindu inheritance (and Hindu neighbors), post-Christian intellectuals feel humiliated. Hindus are an unwelcome reminder of the religion they have long since lost. There are of course other elements that feed into Western intellectual antihinduism: colonialism, racism, elitism, fear of the unfamiliar, etc. But its visceral nature seems to me to be much more consistent with shame. I feel personally certain that shame lies at the core of Western antisemitism. I think it likely that a parallel but opposite shame lies at the core of Western antihinduism. With regard to Jews and Judaism, the shame of having appropriated the Hebrew god results in a combination of adulation and hatred. With regard to Hindus and Sanatana Dharma, the shame of having repudiated our own gods results in a combination revulsion and resentment. There never was a Hindu Holocaust under Western colonialism, yet neither was there much concern over tens of millions of Hindu deaths, whether due to starvation, disease, or Muslim violence. Western intellectuals don't hate Hindus the way so many of them seem to hate Jews. But they do seem to resent the mere existence of Hindus, to the point that they might prefer to see Hindus erased from history. That may sound like an extreme overstatement of Western antihinduism. If you think so, read any Western academic journal of Hindu studies and compare it to those focused on Buddhist, Shinto, Confucian, or even Muslim studies, and you'll see my point.
244
794
94
2,322
208,508
Between the devil and the deep sea.
Republicans target Indians because of their race, skin colour. Democrats target Indians because they don't like Hindus. The hate for Indians in US politics is permanent I guess.
58
Engaging students in the age of AI: When students do not want to come to the classroom, what is the responsibility of an academic? This is a question most academics, including me, are not prepared for, as we assume that students registering for a course have an interest in it. The tech academia is currently facing a number of challenges that require systemic studies to find out effective strategies to deal with them. However, within the current framework, an instructor's job is striking a balance between two conflicting interests: students' interest in just passing the course a good grade and maintaining the rigor of the course. So this time, for our course (Hydromechanics, second-year undergraduate), we experimented with a new idea: give substantial weightage to group project work and experiment with peer evaluation. The tasks were formulated to maximize interaction among students. On average, students had 12 group meetings, and they put more effort than I expected. Besides learning the fundamental concepts, they also got: Some group work spirit Public speaking skills Exposure to an interdisciplinary work culture (students learnt to use electronic control systems and wrote computer programs, which were not part of their curriculum). Skills to handle unexpected situations The submitted videos are on our YouTube channel: youtube.com/@CAMLAB-d6g/play…
85
No law should assume someone guilty before a preliminary investigation. Excellent point by @tehseenp .
1
108
Everything that is wrong with the PhD admission system: Imagine yourself as a PhD aspirant. There are so many institutions, and most conduct interviews within a span of two to three weeks. It is humanly impossible to attend all the interviews. In other words, the applicant has to give up a few opportunities, even when someone is able to afford the cost of flight tickets. One may wonder why interviews cannot be held online. After all, admissions to international universities often happen through online interviews. Here is the catch: in-person interviews are not necessarily held to select more capable applicants but rather to deter non-serious applicants. Think from the other side’s perspective. A professor secures funds after two years of applying. An applicant shows up for an interview but does not join after receiving an offer, because he or she receives a more preferred offer somewhere else later. If the professor is lucky, a waitlisted applicant may accept the offer. Otherwise, the admission cycle is lost. If you consider institution-created PhD positions, the situation becomes even more complicated. The system helps neither the applicants nor the PIs. A simple solution could be to decentralize the admission process. A professor with a PhD position should be allowed to recruit a student independently at any point during the year. In this new decentralized system, a PI would have no hesitation in conducting interviews online, as the chances of a PhD position remaining vacant would be zero if there is a demand for the position. More importantly, a decentralized system would encourage interdisciplinary research, as applicants in the current system do not have sufficient time to explore PhD positions outside their core domain. (Published first in May)
2
130
Shocked and horrified by the brazen threats to @ajeetbharti from a public platform. To single him out for his Brahmin identity and then to threaten to skin him alive, is unacceptable. The state must provide him adequate security immediately. Stay safe, Ajeet. We stand with you.
714
13,404
176
51,009
786,909
" What India wants is a true leader, a leader like Guru Gobind Singh or Guru Ramdas and Shivaji. India wants a Krishana who can give a worthy ideal, to be followed not by India alone, but buy all humanity, by all the members of this humanity with diverse temperaments and capacities. Non-violent non-cooperation movement failed not because there was sporadic outburst of suppressed feelings here and there but because the movement was lacking in a worthy ideal. The ideal that you preached was not in keeping with Indian culture and traditions. It savoured of imitation. Your philosophy of non-violence, at least the philosophy that you gave to the people for their acceptance, was a philosophy arising out of despair. It was not the spirit of kshama of the Indian rishis, it was not the spirit of ahimsa of the great Indian yogins. It was an imperfect physical mixture of Tolstoyism and Buddhism and not a chemical mixture of East and West. " From the letter of Sachindra Nath Sanyal to Gandhi. Note: In Sanyal's interpretation, ahimsa (non-violence) in Indian philosophy was strictly an individual pursuit that did not mix well with the ashram culture of Buddhism. Buddhism did not sanction top-down imposition of non-violence for political purposes.
74
Basudev Biswal retweeted
Since the 1999 Super Cyclone, #Odisha has braved nature’s fury with courage and conviction, driven by the sole principle-every life is precious. #Odisha’s transformation from vulnerability to global leadership in disaster management is not just about systems, it is the unwavering focus on people, planning and purpose which turned Odisha from vulnerability into a beacon of resilience. On #InternationalDayForDisasterRiskReduction, let’s pledge to further bolster the famed resilience and readiness to protect every precious life.
36
97
804
17,454
Technological sovereignty should be reflected in all our policies.
Replying to @elonmusk
Meanwhile your own Grok..🤭
108
What could Chanakya, Genghis Khan, and Stringer Lawrence teach us about Job Selection and Admission into Academic Institutions? The biggest faultline in India today is affirmative action, which is popularly called as quota. The proponents justify by invoking arguments for social justice, while the opponents argue for meritocracy. To avoid getting into the domain of politics, I will try to keep this discussion as academic as possible. The core of the problem is how we can identify talent. I strongly believe an effective solution to this problem holds the key to unlock India’s potential. I will try to provide some analytical tools to understand the problem, because finding an effective solution would not be very difficult if we understand the problem. Let me start by mentioning three historical personalities: i) Chanakya picks the young Chandragupta Maurya for the seemingly impossible task of dismantling the powerful Nanda Empire, and you know Chandragupta Maurya eventually succeeded and became one of the greatest emperors in Indian history. ii) Genghis Khan spots the young Jebe (Jirqo'adai) among the members of a rival tribe he had defeated in battle. Jebe had shot an arrow at him, seriously injuring him. Instead of punishing him, Genghis Khan gives him an opportunity to lead his army. Jebe went on to conquer China and many other parts of the world for him. iii) Stringer Lawrence picks the young Robert Clive for the audacious task of storming the Devikottai fort with a small contingent, in which he succeeds, showing extraordinary bravery and presence of mind. Clive eventually climbed the ranks to become the first Governor-General of India. What is the common thread that connects these three examples? Can you imagine a standardized test that could have recognized the talent of Chandragupta Maurya, Jebe, and Robert Clive? Absolutely not! Because the primary objective of a standardized test is to eliminate candidates, recognition of talent comes afterward. Chandragupta was too young to appear for a test and had no proven talent for the leadership role. Jebe would have been viewed as a potential threat – he had almost killed Genghis Khan in the battle. Clive would have been marked as mentally unstable. In fact, he tried to commit suicide twice before the battle of Devikotta; both times, his pistol failed to fire (he eventually died by suicide in Britain long after his retirement). These three decisions were possible only because the selectors relied on their intuition. Throughout history, we relied on personalized evaluation models. However, today it is hard to even have a serious discussion about the merits of these evaluation models. You will be accused of empowering Dronas who would discriminate against Ekalavyas. True, personalized evaluation systems played a major role in the formation of rigid social groups. This is perhaps one of the reasons why standardized evaluation models gained widespread trust and are seen as meritocratic. However, any argument suggesting that we should fully rely on standardized learning evaluation models is not just overly simplistic but also ignores empirical evidence. To give a brief historical overview, standardized evaluation is not new. The first large-scale standardized evaluation in recorded history was perhaps the Imperial Civil Service Examination (Keju), held in China about 2,000 years ago to fill top bureaucratic positions. Several East Asian nations, including Korea and Japan, later adopted similar systems. The first major standardized examination outside East Asia was the Indian Civil Service (ICS) examination, held in London in 1855. Ironically, the intent behind the examination was to promote meritocracy while making it extremely difficult for Indians to succeed because of geographical and language barriers. In fact, the first Indian to pass the examination was Satyendranath Tagore, who did so in 1863, eight years after the examination was introduced. Most academic admissions and job selection processes heavily rely on standardized tests. Is that working? Apparently not. If it were, we would not need quotas in educational institutions or jobs. Where does it go wrong, then? No serious study has shown a strong correlation between performance on standardized examinations and the ability to solve problems under real-world conditions. Intelligence is a multifaceted construct; each individual displays strengths as well as weaknesses across different situations. Assessing a group of people using the same set of metrics is akin to evaluating the physical abilities of a monkey and a penguin based on how well they can climb or swim. Unfortunately, after Independence, the Indian government, instead of conducting a rigorous review, expanded the scope of standardized examinations. The result is that we have raised generation after generation of students who find no purpose other than cracking exams. Standardized written examinations mainly test memorization skills. As a result, communities whose traditional occupations place greater emphasis on memorization may be advantaged by such assessments, while communities whose occupations rely less on memorization may be disadvantaged in educational admissions and job selection. Nevertheless, the quota system is a quick fix. Moreover, we cannot invoke the idea of justice while depriving students who score higher marks on an examination in favour of those who score lower marks. To conclude, neither personalized evaluation models are inherently discriminatory, nor are standardized examinations inherently meritocratic or inherently capable of cutting across social groups. Both have their strengths as well as weaknesses. It is essential to understand these nuances and design better evaluation models for admissions and job selection. In fact, the UK, which introduced standardized evaluation models in India, has gradually moved away from relying heavily on standardized examinations and now gives significantly greater importance to personalized evaluation for both job selection and admission to academic institutions. There is no reason why India should remain trapped in a colonial-era mindset that is clearly not in its best interest. (Text version of the speech given on 16th August 2026, as part of Independence Day Celebration by Bridges to Bharat, a community of students, scholars, researchers, and professionals across the US who are passionate about contributing to India's future. A few minor edits were incorporated for improving clarity.)
1
136
GROW Symposium 2026 at IIT Bombay (22–23 November) is an excellent opportunity for interacting with leading academics and practicing engineers in Remote Sensing, Ocean Engineering, and Water Resources Engineering. The main purpose of the symposium is to discuss strategies to bridge the gap between academic research and practical engineering. The program has been designed to maximize interaction among attendees while giving all participants, including student participants, adequate opportunity to present their ideas. There will be awards for student participants. We have so far got confirmation from close to 20 leading experts including: Prof. Prof. D. Nagesh Kumar (IISc Bangalore) Prof. Sharad Jain (Visting Professor, IIT Gandhinagar and former Director NIH) Prof. Dr R N Sankhua (Visiting Professor IIT Bombay and former Member KRMB, MoJS) Prof. subashisa dutta (IIT Guwahati) Prof. PL Patel (Director NIT Nagpur) We are waiting for confirmation from many leading industry experts and government engineers and will share the list shortly. We will share the list of all who have confirmed within a couple of days. Given that we have a limited number of guest house and hostel rooms to host participants (maximum of 200 in total), please fill out the Google Form (in the comment section below) as early as possible. Those filling out the form will get a separate link to register (Registration fee: Rs. 8,000 for regular participants and Rs. 4,000 for student participants). Please share the information with anyone likely to be interested.
1
1
1
223
A few days back, I gave a talk titled "Serving and Thriving in the Age of AI." The session host, a practicing civil engineer, interrupted me in between, asking me why I was talking about the history of AI. It is not only engineers from the old generations who have this view. Even the students of my second-year undergraduate hydromechanics course did not think there was any need to discuss the history of science and engineering. You can also see so many engineers on social media saying IITs should close down their humanities departments. No one should be surprised by why Indians are lagging in technological development. Most engineers in India think engineering is all about applying tools. What most do not realize is that technological development requires a multi-dimensional understanding of a subject. With AI automating routine tasks, the future will see a declining demand for engineers who know tools but lack in-depth understanding. I hope Anthropic inviting a Vedanta scholar as an expert for AI system development will generate some interest among engineers in India to read history and philosophy.
So this is the part I did not expect. Anthropic called Swami Sarvapriyananda, a Vedanta monk and flew him to the San Francisco head-office. > Closed door meeting with NDA signed. > theologians and mental health people in the same sitting, all of it aimed at training Claude. > and one of the founders stayed in the room the whole time. ---- From 'Ramakrishna Vedanta Society of North Texas" YT channel (full video link in comment)
5
585