Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor) header
Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor) profile picture

Biblische Exegese und Theologie | Literatur und Kultur Professor für Altes Testament Youtube: https://teapawt.org/t.co/kPL2Eav2gT Amazon: https://teapawt.org/t.co/VBrmkMvoZA

Joined October 2023
Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)Photo by Benjamin Kilchör (@BenjaminKilchor)
With profound metaphysics, you can also break the 100,000 mark.
Replying to @Math_files
Every correct answer becomes incorrect simply because it is correct.
2
70
It’s a new experience for me to write a post that gets over 100,000 views—especially one that delves deeply into the Ten Commandments. I never would have thought so many people would be interested in this. Theology really is popular after all.
Replying to @iamdpassword
Today, the 007th Commandment was broken.
4
88
Die Antwort, die mich auf X am häufigsten in den Fingern juckt, ist "Danke für die Info".
98
Heute ist der zweitletzte Sonntag des Kirchenjahres. Sein Thema ist das Weltgericht: "Wir müssen alle offenbar werden vor dem Richterstuhl Christi" (2. Korinther 5,10a) Der heutige Predigttext (nach der evangelischen Perikopenordnung) ist das schwierigste aller Gleichnisse Jesu. Es findet sich in Lukas 16,1-9 mit dem Fazit (V.8-9): "Und der Herr lobte den ungetreuen Verwalter, weil er klug gehandelt hatte; denn die Kinder dieser Welt sind unter ihresgleichen klüger als die Kinder des Lichts. Und ich sage euch: Macht euch Freunde mit dem ungerechten Mammon, damit, wenn er zu Ende geht, sie euch aufnehmen in die ewigen Hütten." In der Kirche, die ich nach dem Gottesdienst bei schönstem Herbstwetter fotografiert habe, durfte ich heute die Gottesdienstvertretung halten und habe zu diesem Gleichnis gepredigt. Einige Stichworte dazu in diesem Thread. 🧵
1
4
360
Für das rechte Verstehen von Gleichnissen ist es wichtig (mit der langen christlichen Auslegungstradition und gegen moderne Gleichnistheorien), zu verstehen, dass Gleichnisse Allegorien sind. Der Schlüssel zu diesem Gleichnis ist: - Der reiche Mann (V.1) ist Gott. - Der Verwalter (V.1) ist der Mensch, also wir alle. Alles, was wir haben, gehört in Wirklichkeit nicht uns, sondern Gott. Es ist uns eine Zeit lang anvertraut, damit wir es gut verwalten. - Der Verwalter ist mit dem Besitz nicht treu umgegangen, sondern hat ihn verschleudert, d.h. für sich selbst gebraucht und nicht im Sinne des wahren Besitzers. - Dass der Verwalter entlassen wird (V.2), bedeutet, dass auch unsere Zeit, in der uns Gott vieles anvertraut hat, begrenzt ist. Irgendwann werden wir entlassen: Das letzte Hemd hat keine Taschen und daran, dass wir nichts von dem, was uns gehört, mitnehmen können, wenn wir sterben, zeigt, dass es gar nie wirklich uns gehört hat, sondern ein fremdes Gut ist, das uns zeitlebens anvertraut ist. - Der Verwalter entscheidet nun, so lange er noch im Amt ist, das Vermögen des Herrn weiter zu veruntreuen, aber nicht zu seinen eigenen Gunsten, sondern indem er Schuldnern grosszügig Schulden kürzt, damit sie ihn dann in ihren Häusern aufnehmen, wenn er entlassen ist (V.4-7). - Die überraschende Wendung des Gleichnisses ist nun, dass der reiche Herr, als er es merkt, weder einen Zornesausbruch hat, noch den Verwalter vor Gericht bringt, sondern ihn lobt, weil er klug gehandelt habe. Warum?
1
83
Der Verwalter tut endlich mit dem Vermögen des reichen Mannes genau das, was in dessen Sinne ist: Er setzt es grosszügig zum Wohl seiner Mitmenschen ein (auch wenn er es aus strategischen Überlegungen heraus tut). Was Gott uns gibt, das gibt er uns eben nicht, damit wir sein Vermögen vermehren - ihm gehört ja sowieso alles -, sondern damit wir es in den Dienst unserer Mitmenschen stellen. Wie Jesus an anderer Stelle sagt: "Was ihr getan habt einem von diesen meinen geringsten Brüdern, das habt ihr mir getan" (Matthäus 25,40). Und so erklärt Jesus das Gleichnis: Auf der Ebene der Geschichte ist der Verwalter ein "Kind dieser Welt" und er handelt im eigenen Interesse, wenn er den Mammon des Besitzers den Mitmenschen verteilt. Doch die "Kinder des Lichts" sollen davon lernen: Genau das ist es, was Gott von uns möchte: Dass wir sein Vermögen, das er uns anvertraut hat, den Mitmenschen verschenken und sie uns so zu Freunden machen. Wenn wir dann "entlassen" werden, also sterben, und alles zurücklassen müssen, dann werden Menschen vor Gott unsere Grosszügigkeit bezeugen und dafür einstehen, dass wir in die ewigen Hütten aufgenommen werden. In diesem Sinne gehört das Gleichnis zur Ars Moriendi (Kunst des Sterbens): "Herr, lehre uns bedenken, dass wir sterben müssen, auf dass wir klug werden" (Psalm 90,12). Oder in der Logik des Gleichnisses: Herr, lehre uns bedenken, dass wir als Verwalter einmal entlassen werden, damit wir dein Vermögen jetzt schon klug einsetzen.
3
50
My "art theory" was just confirmed once again by the movie "Wild Horse Nine", which has been playing in theaters here since Thursday. My second trip to the movies this year (and probably in the last ten years) was rewarded with a magnificent film by Martin McDonagh, who is not only a master of absurd dialogue but also a masterful handler of symbolism.
The longer I engage with art, the more I come to believe that in all fields—literature, visual arts, architecture, music—great art is characterized by its use of effective symbolism. This creates a deeper level of meaning that invites us to return to the artwork again and again and discover new aspects. As a theologian and exegete, I would say: Where a spiritual meaning is hidden within the literal sense, waiting to be discovered—or where the eternal Logos can be seen in the temporal and material, if one has eyes to see and ears to hear—there lies great art. Deviations are possible primarily in two directions: the complete rejection of symbolism or the misuse of symbolism. Behind the rejection of symbolism lies a materialistic, nihilistic worldview. For materialism denies the spirit within matter—the Logos—and therefore reduces everything to its literal meaning or to its functional aspect. This is why, for example, modern architecture is often so ugly: the building is reduced to its function, and any interest in design and ornamentation—through which the building points beyond itself to something greater—is absent. The misuse of symbolism, on the other hand, usually leads to cheap kitsch. The "artists" are aware of the beauty of ornamentation, but they cannot interpret it. They use symbolic elements merely to create the appearance of meaning, without, however, capturing the essence. Those who allow themselves to be drawn in by the symbolic elements and delve deeper into the work discover that these elements are merely an optical illusion and, in reality, do not point beyond themselves.
2
167
Ich war gestern im Antikenmuseum in Basel, das die grösste Sammlung antiker Kulturgüter in der Schweiz hat. Die Ägypten-Sammlung gehört zu den Highlights des Museums. Hier zu sehen ist eine Abbildung aus einem Papyrus mit dem ägyptischen Totenbuch. In der dargestellten Szene wird das Herz des Toten gegen die Feder der Ma'at (Göttin der Weltordnung) aufgewogen. Wenn das Herz zu schwer ist, senkt sich die Waage und das Herz wird von Ammit (links auf erhöhtem Podest als Krokodil-Löwen-Nilpferd) gefressen. In Exodus 7,14 sagt Gott wörtlich: "Das Herz des Pharao ist schwer. Er weigert sich, das Volk ziehen zu lassen." Möglicherweise handelt es sich um eine Anspielung auf das Totenbuch: Das Herz des Pharao ist so schwer, dass die Weltordnung (Ma'at) in den zehn Plagen aus den Fugen gerät und der Pharao untergehen muss.
8
319
Meine Rezension des Numerikommentars von @L_MMorales ist publiziert und online verfügbar: rezensionen.afet.de/?p=2837
2
2
28
2,509
The longer I engage with art, the more I come to believe that in all fields—literature, visual arts, architecture, music—great art is characterized by its use of effective symbolism. This creates a deeper level of meaning that invites us to return to the artwork again and again and discover new aspects. As a theologian and exegete, I would say: Where a spiritual meaning is hidden within the literal sense, waiting to be discovered—or where the eternal Logos can be seen in the temporal and material, if one has eyes to see and ears to hear—there lies great art. Deviations are possible primarily in two directions: the complete rejection of symbolism or the misuse of symbolism. Behind the rejection of symbolism lies a materialistic, nihilistic worldview. For materialism denies the spirit within matter—the Logos—and therefore reduces everything to its literal meaning or to its functional aspect. This is why, for example, modern architecture is often so ugly: the building is reduced to its function, and any interest in design and ornamentation—through which the building points beyond itself to something greater—is absent. The misuse of symbolism, on the other hand, usually leads to cheap kitsch. The "artists" are aware of the beauty of ornamentation, but they cannot interpret it. They use symbolic elements merely to create the appearance of meaning, without, however, capturing the essence. Those who allow themselves to be drawn in by the symbolic elements and delve deeper into the work discover that these elements are merely an optical illusion and, in reality, do not point beyond themselves.
1
3
317
I came across the book "Piranesi" by Susanna Clarke (whom I hadn't heard of before) through the quoted post, and the description piqued my interest, especially since i really enjoy C.S. Lewis's novels. The book is exciting and entertaining, and the concept is great. As for C.S. Lewis, the book evokes several of the Narnia stories, as well as the Perelandra trilogy and, finally, The Great Divorce. Still, the book somehow leaves me feeling unsatisfied, and I feel it lacks depth. I’ve been thinking about why that is, and I’ve come up with two main reasons: 1. The book is full of highly symbolic elements (e.g., the albatross, the three floors of the house, the statues, the ocean, the idea of the world’s disenchantment), yet virtually nothing is made of these elements. They have only the outward appearance of symbolism, but almost all of it is merely a relatively arbitrary embellishment of the narrative, which makes it seem a little kitschy. At first glance, this gives the appearance of depth, but if you try to delve deeper, you realize that everything remains superficial. 2. There are always elements in it that don’t quite fit—elements that, as Tolkien writes in his essay "On Fairy Stories," prevent the story’s created world from seeming real or true. Every time something like this comes up, you’re pulled out of the story and, ultimately, out of the world. There are several such elements, but the most jarring of all, in my opinion, is that Piranesi repeatedly uses phrasing that makes the house where he lives seem like a more or less personified deity (e.g., “the house takes care of me”). However, there is absolutely no plausible reason within the narrative itself for Piranesi to develop such a relationship with the house. Rather, it seems that the author is attempting to introduce a religious concept into the story to convey a message that does not, however, follow plausibly from the story itself. All in all, it's a nice and entertaining book, but it lacks depth, so I don't think I'll be picking it up a second time.
Piranesi is the best book of the 2020s. The story (about a man trapped in an endless house with an ocean on its lower floor) freely mingles Borges, The Magician’s Nephew and Doctor Who. Simultaneously nightmarish and imbued with a sense of the astonishing glory of things.
2
7
430
My timeline is currently full of posts about a Canadian theologian—whom I don’t know—who is being accused of plagiarism. My two cents on plagiarism: When an ideological opponent does it, it’s very serious; when an ideological ally does it, it’s a minor offense.
10
5
4
68
5,452
The 6th International Symposium of Biblical Exegesis (ISBE) will take place online from November 12–14 on the topic of Shechem in Scripture, History and Tradition Across the Ages. I will be speaking on November 13 on the topic of “Was There a Writing Culture in Shechem and Shiloh during the Iron Age I?” Online participation in the entire symposium is free; click this link to access it: meet.google.com/meet/odx-xyv… The detailed schedule can be found in the next tweet.
2
4
464
Tomorrow marks the start of the new European Hebrew Journal’s five-day online conference, featuring a diverse lineup of presentations. For more information and to register, click here: conference.hebrew.edu.rs/
My online lecture is one week from today: "Was there a writing culture in the heartland of Israel during the Iron Age I?" For more information and to register, click here: conference.hebrew.edu.rs/pre…
2
222
Benjamin Kilchör retweeted
This on repeat until a fair few scholars step outside of their paradigm.
Replying to @pulse38echo
Above all, Genesis 1 should not be read in isolation in this regard. Genesis 1 is essentially just the account of the temple’s construction. However, in the Old Testament and also in the Ancient Near East, texts describing temple construction are typically followed by descriptions of the worship services held there. Genesis 2 serves this function and should be read together with Genesis 1. See my article in the Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament (2022) on this topic (full text available at this link): academia.edu/86514511/The_Ei…
1
5
47
3,323
Benjamin Kilchör retweeted
Hoffnung leuchtet rot! Vom 15. bis 22. November setzen über 250 Kirchen, Klöster und öffentliche Gebäude in Österreich ein Zeichen für verfolgte Christen. Machen Sie bei der #RedWeek mit – durch Gebet und rote Beleuchtung! orlo.uk/redweek_YnD9q #RedWednesday #kircheinnot
3
3
4
114
In the last thread, I compiled some evidence of a writing culture in Jerusalem in the 10th century BC. How does this fit into the broader regional context? The Ophel Pithos inscription from Jerusalem mentioned earlier (see image) is one of a good dozen known alphabetic inscriptions from Israel dating to the 10th century. In this thread, I’ll present some of the most important 10th-century inscriptions from the border region between Israel and the Philistines (Khirbet Qeiyafa, Tel Zayit and Gezer) and discuss their significance for the debate on a culture of writing.🧵
Jerusalem thus became the center of an emerging state in the 10th century, the size of which is estimated differently by various archaeologists. But was there also a written culture in Jerusalem in the 10th century? A thread. 🧵
1
1
4
369
Gezer is one of the three cities (Hazor, Megiddo, and Gezor) mentioned in 1 Kings 9:15 alongside Jerusalem in connection with Solomon’s construction projects. The fact that archaeological evidence has been found for a city wall with a six-chambered gate in all three cities—and that the consistent dimensions of the gates (including a gate passage of 4.20 m and a wall thickness of 1.60 m) suggest a master plan devised by a central government—led Yigael Yadin (1958; 1976) to the influential thesis that these were Solomonic fortifications, all of which Yadin dated to the 10th century. Since the 1990s, these datings have been the subject of ongoing debate in the wake of Israel Finkelstein’s Low Chronology, and the six-chamber gates are now often dated to the 9th century and interpreted as structures of the Omri dynasty of the Northern Kingdom. However, the latest radiocarbon data from Gezer confirm that the monumental architecture there, including the six-chamber gate, dates to the 10th century (Webster et al. 2023: journals.plos.org/plosone/ar…).
1
31
These findings show that writing in the 10th century was not confined to Jerusalem, but was also found in locations in the border region between Judah and the Philistines, which likely were under Jerusalem’s political control in the 10th century (although this is not undisputed). At least three of the texts (the Khirbet Qeiyafa Ostracon, the Tel Zayit Abecedarium, and the Gezer Calendar) are likely writing exercises (which suggests a teacher-student relationship), with the Gezer Calendar being particularly interesting because it is an exercise similar to those known from the cuneiform curriculum. Since cuneiform schools had disappeared from the entire Levant by the end of the Bronze Age (12th century), it (along with the depiction of a 10th-century Gilgamesh scene in Jerusalem) can be interpreted as evidence that the writing tradition did not come to an end at the close of the Late Bronze Age, but rather that a curriculum based on the cuneiform model was adapted in alphabetic script. All of this supports my thesis, published in Vetus Testamentum in 2025, that we find material in the Bible—especially in the Pentateuch—that dates back to the Late Bronze Age and was transmitted through the Early Iron Age into the Monarchical Period.
35