Every insurance agency owner who sold to private equity heard the same sentence.
"Nothing's going to change."
ya... f*ing right.
KKR bought USI for $4.3 billion in 2017.
They just sold it to Aon for $17 billion 9 years later.
Here's what happened in between.
AssuredPartners bought 500 independent insurance agencies.
Kelso bought Risk Strategies in 2015 when it was doing $130 million in revenue.
They ran 180+ acquisitions and took it to $1.7 billion in revenue.
That's 680 agencies between two firms.
Those were somebody's grandfather's agency.
Somebody's name on the building on Main Street.
And every single one of those owners signed thinking they'd found a good home for their people.
LOL...
Then the pile got sold.
AssuredPartners went to Gallagher for $13.45 billion.
Risk Strategies went to Brown & Brown for $9.8 billion.
NFP went to Aon for $13.4 billion.
Hub confidentially filed for an IPO in June after a private round that valued it at $29 billion.
They were never buying a home for your book.
They were building inventory.
And Aon just told you who the inventory is for.
Straight from the USI release: "the premier U.S. middle-market platform."
MID MARKET.
Not the roofing contractor doing $4 million, not the HVAC shop running 8 trucks, and definitely not the restaurant group your dad wrote back in 1998.
Those accounts get shoved into a service center and forgotten.
I'm not guessing at any of this.
I watched it happen to my dad's agency.
Nobody ever told him he was selling it twice.
Here's what I've seen since.
Owners I work with are picking up commercial accounts they never even pitched.
The client just got sick of leaving voicemails.
Producers are inheriting books where nobody has called the insured in months.
Nobody at the roll-up is going to fix it either, because fixing it doesn't move the multiple.
So if you're a young commercial producer sitting inside one of these things, hear me.
You are sitting on a list.
You know every orphaned account in your territory. You know exactly which ones stopped getting called.
Go take them.
Pick one to three verticals, not fifteen.
Put a producer on each one who genuinely owns it.
Build a separate digital brand for each vertical.
Then use AI where it actually matters.
I don't mean a bot answering your phone.
Please GOD don't do that.
I mean AI writing the submission, pulling the loss runs, chasing missing app info, and prepping the renewal so a HUMAN can call that client back in 60 seconds instead of six days.
The bar is on the floor, my friends.
Answer your phone during business hours.
Call people back in under a minute.
Do those two things and you will out-service a $17 billion platform.
They were never built to service a $6,000 account.
They were built to be sold.
If you're a producer thinking about jumping, or you want to see what a vertical-first digital agency actually looks like, shoot me a DM.
I'll show you the ones crushing it right now.
3
5
734
Independent insurance agents and producers, when a prospect sends you a wall of ChatGPT questions, don't answer it.
Just call them. It's as simple as that.
I saw an agency owner on X today say he got 17 paragraphs of ChatGPT questions on a basic GL policy for a painter.
I'm hearing the same thing over and over again from our clients.
I get it.
It's annoying and it sucks.
But this is going to keep happening, and we need to adjust as an industry.
One client told me he wrote back a really nice email.
He laid out his process and asked for the loss runs and dec pages.
He never heard back.
His take was "why would I put hours into a quote if they won't give me 10 minutes?"
I've heard some version of that from a lot of you guys.
"If they don't respect my time, I'm not going to respect theirs."
That's a sh*tty way to look at a lead.
Here's what I've seen....
The person on the other end didn't write those questions.
They asked ChatGPT to help them shop for insurance and it spit out a wall of text.
They copied it, pasted it, and hit send.
They couldn't tell you what half of it means.
So they don't really care about your answers.
They care about HOW you respond.
And it isn't a respect thing.
They're busy, they need coverage, and they want it handled as fast as possible.
The AI isn't buying the policy.
THEY are.
So skip every single question and pick up the phone.
If their number is in the email, call it.
If it isn't, take a minute, look at the domain in their email address, and pull the number off their website.
If they don't pick up, reply with one line asking them to call you.
Whatever you do, don't answer the questions over email.
And please don't paste them into ChatGPT and send back your own wall of text.
They will spot it in two seconds and judge you for it.
Most of these are commercial accounts, by the way.
That same email probably went to a dozen other agencies and a few carrier sites.
Almost all of them are going to reply by email or not reply at all.
You get to be the one human who called.
One of my clients went from zero email leads in October to 13 so far in November, and most of them looked just like this.
What is your team doing with them right now?
6
2
357
All in less than 72 hours....
We launched the new website for our generalist insurance agency in North Carolina, and it's already on page one of Google for 83 keywords.
31 of those are Page 1, Listing 1.
53 are in the top 3.
Those numbers come straight out of our rank tracker, not from me Googling on my own laptop.
O'Connor is an independent agency that has served North Carolina since 2000.
Before us, they were on a site from one of the popular cookie-cutter insurance website vendors.
You know the type.
Swap the logo, change the phone number, and it's the same site as hundreds of other agencies.
Here's what they're ranking # 1 for now.
On the commercial side, it's North Carolina employment practices liability, cyber, fiduciary liability, lessors risk, ocean marine, inland marine, and commercial umbrella insurance.
By industry, it's manufacturing, metal fabrication, plastics, textiles, food manufacturing, life sciences, medical devices, technology, HVAC, and landscaping.
On the personal lines side, it's North Carolina high value home, high limit umbrella, condo, and ATV insurance.
Locally, they own Charlotte workers comp, plus high value home insurance in Ballantyne, Davidson, Cornelius, Lake Norman, Waxhaw, and Weddington.
Every one of those is a search someone types when they're ready to buy.
And on day one, Google's AI Overview was already citing O'Connor as a source on 30 searches.
Google's AI is quoting a local independent agency as the authority.
Every agency owner I talk to has been told SEO takes 6 to 12 months.
On a cookie-cutter template, it's worse than that.
It never happens, because Google has no reason to rank the 400th copy of the same page.
Build the pages that match how buyers actually search, and Google doesn't need a year to figure out who you are.
To be clear, rankings on a brand-new site bounce around for the first few weeks.
This is a 72-hour snapshot, not a trophy.
But the first 72 hours tell you whether the foundation is right.
This one is.
Let the leads commence.
If you're an established agency stuck on a cookie-cutter website and sick of getting zero results from SEO, reach out.
We can get you results just like this.
I'm one DM away.
4
4
292
Most insurance agencies don't get leads from SEO and AEO because... well.... their money pages suck.
What's a money page?
It's a policy page or an industry page.
It's built to show up in Google and ChatGPT at the exact moment someone is shopping for insurance.
It's bottom of funnel and it's transactional.
A lot of agents think they need to put all their effort into blog posts.
Blog posts are largely a waste of time now.
When I say blog, I mean the top-of-funnel informational stuff.
"How to file a claim as a plumbing contractor."
"How to prepare your home for a windstorm in Ohio."
"Is my house in a flood zone in North Carolina?"
That content is helpful, and I'm not denying that.
The problem is Google and ChatGPT hand the answer to the person right there on the screen.
Nobody clicks through to your site to read it.
It works differently when someone is actually searching for insurance.
I know how stupid this sounds, but.... Google and ChatGPT don't sell insurance.
They have to send that person to somebody who does.
I'm also watching the AI tools create the demand.
Someone asks ChatGPT for a specialist or an agency in their area, and it shows them three or four names.
Then they copy one of those names, paste it into Google, and look at the website and the Google Business Profile.
I've been reviewing agency sites all week, and so many of them are built by cookie-cutter web vendors.
Their policy pages are carbon copies, word for word, from one agency to the next.
That content won't rank, because it goes against Google's guidelines.
Google is trying to show the most relevant page, and it can't pick one when every agency's page is verbatim the same.
So build your content strategy around the money pages FIRST.
Make the most badass policy page for a particular location, and the most badass page for a particular industry.
Then put the two together, like cyber insurance for restaurants in Colorado, and cover everything a restaurant owner in Colorado would want to know before buying.
Now you're showing up at the exact point someone is searching for insurance.
A blog post about God knows what meets them when they're nowhere near their renewal and aren't buying anything.
Everything else comes after the money pages are built.
Pull up your site and count your policy and industry pages against your blog posts.
Which number is bigger?
5
6
132
Independent insurance agencies...
If a "prospect" asks for a quote and then insists you join THEIR Zoom link.... do not click it.
Two of my clients brought this up on calls this week.
One is in South Carolina and the other is in Texas.
They've never met each other.
This is a cybersecurity problem, and it's showing up in your inbox dressed as a lead.
An email comes in asking for a quote.
It reads like AI wrote it, which isn't a red flag by itself anymore because real buyers are sending AI bots out to shop for insurance right now.
Your team replies and asks when they can talk.
The "prospect" says they're out of the country and can't take a phone call.
Or they want their spouse on the call, so it has to be Zoom.
So your team offers to send over a Zoom link.
And they say no, we're going to use ours.
That link is the entire attack.
From what I've read on these, it opens a page that looks like Zoom and asks you to install an update before you can join.
The "update" is remote access software, and whoever sent it now has control of that computer.
Think about what's sitting on a CSR's computer.
Your AMS is on there, along with the carrier portals, the saved passwords, and every client's personal information.
My South Carolina client told me how his team handles it.
They host the call on their own link or they get on the phone, and if the "prospect" won't do either, there's no meeting.
My Texas client told me a lot of what came into his agency over the last two weeks was AI and fraud, with people trying to set up a Zoom.
I asked him if a carrier had sent out any kind of warning.
He hadn't seen one.
So I'm telling you guys.
Send this to your CSRs and producers TODAY, because the newest person on your team is the one who's going to click.
Quick rule of thumb....
A real buyer will take a phone call.
Has this one hit your inbox yet?
Drop your insurance agency's URL.
I'll judge the site and tell you if ChatGPT and Google would recommend you.
No f*cking mercy.
1
1
108
Insurance agency owners…
Get your ChatGPT business profile set up TODAY!
openai.com/index/introducing…
Now in beta: Businesses in ChatGPT.
Claim your business, manage your information, and get insights on how people engage with you.
Eligible businesses can also build a Business Agent to answer customers’ questions and help them explore what you offer.
openai.com/index/introducing…
1
1
105
More and more of our clients are generating leads from AI helper bots like Meta Muse, Grok Bot, ChatGPT Dots, and now Claude Duet.
I’ve been getting emails from our insurance clients like this for the past few weeks.... (see below).
Their site has only been live for a few weeks, BTW...
Here’s what we're seeing across 45 agencies.
Somewhere between 10% and 15% of our clients’ inbound leads are now coming from large language models.
Not Google.
A chatbot that read our client’s website, decided they were the right agency, and sent the buyer over.
Of those AI leads, 70% to 80% are COMMERCIAL requests.
Contractors, restaurants, trucking, real estate.
People aren’t asking ChatGPT to find them a cheaper auto policy.
Business owners are asking it who insures their type of business in their area, and the AI is naming our clients.
And a small but growing slice of those leads aren’t even humans anymore.
They’re AI agents acting on behalf of a human.
Somebody says “get me three quotes for my landscaping business” and the agent goes out and does it.
What’s interesting is that the agents are NOT filling out the quote form on the website.
It's not really an efficient way for them to interact with your agency.
They scan the site, or other third party directories, find an email address like hello@, service@, or quotes@, john@ and email the agency directly with the quote details written out in a paragraph.
That’s what my client’s email below is about.
So here’s what we deployed across every client site.
I can’t prove it has changed anything yet, so consider this a live test.
We're calling it an AI Hub or Booth.
It’s a dedicated page engineered for the bots, not for people.
It says, essentially, “Hey Mr. or Mrs. AI Agent, here is exactly how to reach us, here is who to email, and here is every piece of information we need from you to quote this risk.”
Business name, operations, location, revenue, payroll, prior coverage, effective date, all of it.
We’re basically designing lead form fields for a visitor that will never click a form.
Two years ago the job was getting your agency to rank for “commercial insurance [city].”
Now the job is making sure that when a business owner’s AI agent goes looking for an agency, your site is the one it can actually talk to.
If you’re trying to grow the commercial side of your agency and stay ahead of this, send me a DM. I’ll walk you through our process.
14
5
437
Hills I’ll die on after 6 years marketing insurance agencies with Convirtue:
- Google Ads rarely makes sense for an independent agency.
- Cookie-cutter website vendors are the worst thing to happen to the independent insurance industry.
- SEO and AEO leads are the best digital marketing leads in insurance. Period.
- Blogs are mostly BS. Your money pages are where the time should go.
- YouTube is still criminally underrated. Almost no agencies do it well.
- A specialist beats a generalist online every time.
- Your producers’ social profiles matter more than your agency’s business page.
- Likes from other agents feel great and make you broke.
- Calling your leads back in under 1 minute will 10x your conversion rates
What insurance marketing hills are you dying on?
3
173
Colorado didn’t tax the rich this week.
It taxed the two people in the house who both go to work.
For the past decade, Democratic politicians have ran on “the rich need to pay their fair share.”
The same politicians who are rich btw...
Those who rental properties, sit on the boards, cash the book deals, and get richer every single year while they’re on the Capitol payroll telling you who the villain is.
Not one of them ever said exactly who the rich are though....
They let you picture a guy with a PJ flying to Aspen.
Then they wrote a bill, and the number was $500K.
500,000?!?
That’s not a jet.
That’s a well-off dual-income family in Colorado, that's fairly comfortable.
But not RICH.
That’s a couple who both commute, both pay the nanny, both have zero ways to hide a W-2.
That’s the owner of a 12-person insurance agency showing $650K on paper after reinvesting half of it back into the business.
Those are the “rich” they were demonizing the whole time, and they never told you.
The actually rich don’t earn $600K.
They own things.
Buildings, equity, a business they sold a decade ago, loans against assets that never show up as income.
A guy worth $20M can show $150K of taxable income on paper.
He just got a tax cut.
So did the politician who wrote the bill.
And look at the “help for working families” that was supposed to justify all this.
First $25K drops from 4.4% to 3.7%.
Next $75K drops to 4.2%.
Everything above $100K stays at 4.4%.
Someone with $40K of taxable income saves about $205 a year.
$205???
Nobody in the entire state saves more than $325.
That’s $27 a month.
They are going to save $200 a year on taxes????
On the other side of the trade:
$600K household: $2,675 more.
$1M household: $15,925 more.
And the brackets are not indexed to inflation.
Every raise you get for the next twenty years walks you closer to the $500K line while the $205 “cut” stays frozen in 2027 dollars.
Now think about what this state already knows about taxes.
Colorado taxes cigarettes so fewer people smoke.
It taxes nicotine vapes so fewer kids vape.
It taxes us on fucking plastic bags for godsack so fewer people use plastic bags.
And you know what... it WORKS.
In 2020 it put Prop EE on the ballot and wrote the purpose right into the measure: raise the nicotine tax to reduce smoking.
You tax a thing, you get less of the thing.
This week it voted to tax earning above $500K at 7.4%, 7.9%, and 8.4%, and the same people will tell you it won’t change anyone’s behavior.
Both can’t be true.
I already know the reply.
“Three points doesn’t move anybody.”
The surgeon isn’t quitting over three points.
That was never where the damage happens.
Here’s what I’ve seen with 40 agency owners.
The guy netting $480K looks at the $500K line and stops growing.
He doesn’t hire the sixth producer.
He doesn’t open the second office.
The guy already at $900K calls a CPA in Texas and changes his address.
And the two-income household that was going to cross the line in three years from two normal raises now has a real conversation at the kitchen table about whether the second job is worth it after daycare and the new rate.
Sometimes the answer is no.
None of that shows up in an elasticity study.
All of it shows up in the tax base five years later.
And that base was already leaving.
In 2015 Colorado gained almost 69,000 people a year from migration, 5th fastest-growing state in the country.
In 2025, for the first time since 2004, more people LEFT Colorado for other states than moved in.
Net loss of 12,100.
42nd in the nation.
Every other Mountain West state gained people.
Colorado was the only one losing them.
That was BEFORE this passed.
I think the outflow triples in the next two to five years.
And it won’t just be the 64,000 who got the bill.
The people “saving” $205 are getting hit too.
That’s a f*cking slap in the face.
The state hands you $17 a month and calls it relief, while your rent went up $200, your car insurance went up $40, your grocery bill went up $150, and every new fee, mandate, and regulation out of the Capitol gets passed straight down to you by the landlord, the carrier, and the grocery store.
They didn’t make your life cheaper.
They made it $205 less expensive on one line and a few thousand more expensive on every other line.
So the family at $60K leaves for the same reason the family at $600K leaves.
The math stopped working, and the state keeps acting like it’s doing us a favor.
The ones who stay are the ones who can’t afford to move.
And the $2 billion hole gets filled by whoever is left.
Which is you.
I’d consider voting for a line at $2M.
I’d have voted for one at $5M.
That’s where “rich” lives.
That’s where the people who wrote this live.
Nobody put that on the ballot, because that’s not who they were ever coming for.
You don’t get to tax ambition and then act surprised when you get less of it.
Fuck these politicians.
And FUCK this state.
2
330
Insurance agencies.... time to claim your ChatGPT Business Profile.
Yup... OpenAI is developing an analytics and business management tool (part of an upcoming "Business "Hub"/Webmaster-style feature) that allows you to claim and verify ownership of your business.
1
98
Insurance agencies... time to claim your ChatGPT Business Profile.
Yup... OpenAI is developing an analytics and business management tool (part of an upcoming "Business "Hub"/Webmaster-style feature) that allows you to claim and verify ownership of your business.
2
93
An AI bot called one of my insurance clients asking for insurance.
Yup......
My clients are now getting actual CALLS from people using AI agents to handle their insurance.
For the past month we've been seeing AI agents email quote requests to a few of our agencies.
This one actually called.
My client runs a generalist shop in New York.
He answers the phone and the first thing it says is "Quote."
Then it asks if there's someone in commercial lines or new business it can speak with.
It was calling on behalf of a guy who owns a small private steam room and cold plunge rental.
And it knew exactly what it wanted.
General liability at $1M per occurrence and $2M aggregate, sexual abuse and molestation coverage included (not excluded), plus property coverage on the equipment.
That's a cleaner submission than a lot of humans give you guys!
Halfway through, my client asks it where it comes from because he likes it so far and wants one for himself.
It wouldn't say what service it was built on.
The follow-up email came from a tab.bot address, so the secret didn't last long.
It wasn't perfect either.
It spelled the owner's name so fast my client had to ask it to slow down.
It made him read the email address back, corrected him, and the address it gave him was still wrong.
Then less than two hours later it emailed the agency on its own.
Fixed the email address. Answered the two things it couldn't answer on the call, the square footage and the equipment value.
So it hung up, went back to its human, got the answers, and followed up before most agencies would have even started the quote.
It also kept pushing my client for an indicative premium range on the call.
He told it the honest answer, he can't give a number until he runs it through a carrier.
Here's what I keep thinking about.
That bot never filled out a form.
It didn't care what the website looked like.
It wanted a person in commercial lines, a coverage answer, and an email address to send the quote to.
So we're testing something on our clients' sites we're calling AI Info Booths.
A section of the site that tells these agents exactly what info to send and where to send it.
So the next one shows up with the square footage and equipment values the first time.
If an AI agent called your agency tomorrow, would your team know what to do with it?
4
2
186
The only traitor is you, @profgalloway.
You moved away from America in 2022, but still get behind a microphone every week to talk shit about the country that helped make you rich.
All while publicly calling yourself a Florida resident and talking up the tax savings that helped build your wealth.
Then you lecture everyone about paying their fair share.
You’re a raging HYPOCRITE.
What have you done to contribute to the United States economy over the last five years?
Musk’s companies employ people to build cars, manufacture batteries, launch rockets and deliver satellite internet.
Your contribution to American industry doesn’t come close to his.
Yet you have the nerve to call him a traitor and invoke the Rosenbergs’ execution.
It’s disgusting and disgraceful.
You can keep trading smug takes with Kara and having @edels0n laugh at your jokes.
An audience clapping at your bullshit doesn’t make you America’s moral authority.
Spare the rest of us the fucking moral superiority.
.@RetentionAdam was one of the biggest reasons I started posting on LinkedIn and X.
He gave a lot to the B2B marketing and startup space, and he shared all of it openly.
I’m absolutely gutted. Thinking about his family and everyone who knew him.
RIP Adam.
222
The first protest in my lifetime that’s actually important 😂😂
Liberty Biberty is the worst insurance campaign I’ve ever seen.
1
2
737
Most insurance agencies hear "you need to create content for SEO" and immediately start writing blog posts.
"Is my home in a flood zone?"
"How do I file a claim as a plumbing contractor?"
"My home has galvanized pipes. How does that affect my home insurance?"
Helpful?
Ya...
Did any of them ever actually write a policy?
HELL NO...
Even 10 years ago, when those posts pulled real traffic, they barely converted.
Slap a lead magnet on it, build a nurture sequence, whatever.
It's really hard to nurture someone into buying insurance.
Nobody buys a BOP because your blog taught them something on a Tuesday morning.
They buy when they need it.
A lot of you guys still latch onto "They Ask, You Answer" by Marcus Sheridan.
It's a solid book. It came out of a pool company.
But honestly... it was never that great a fit for insurance.
And now the traffic those posts used to get is gone too.
68% of US Google searches now end without a click to anything (SparkToro, 2026). Ten years ago it was about 45%.
On informational searches with an AI Overview, organic CTR fell from 1.76% to 0.61% (Seer Interactive).
And ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini just answer the flood zone question themselves.
Here's the part you guys miss.
Google and the LLMs don't sell insurance (at least for now haha!).
At some point they have to hand the person off to someone who does.
Someone asks "Do I need cyber insurance for my restaurant in Colorado?"
The AI explains why they probably do.
Then it recommends who to talk to.
That recommendation gets pulled from money pages.
If you're not sure what the difference is, a blog post answers a question someone's curious about. A money page is your policy and industry pages, the ones that say exactly what you write, who you write it for and where. That's what someone reads right before they ask for a quote.
And most of you guys have it backwards.
You over-index on blogs and under-index on money pages.
Half-assed, cookie-cutter, carbon-copy policy pages. Barely any industry pages.
Then you wonder why you don't get rewarded for the content that actually matters.
It should be the opposite.
Hyper-specific, hyper-localized money pages, built at scale.
Cyber liability for restaurants in Denver.
Workers' comp for roofers in Colorado Springs.
General liability for HVAC contractors in Fort Collins.
When someone asks the AI that exact question, the agency with that exact page gets recommended.
And those people are ready. Invoca found ChatGPT-referred phone calls converted to sales leads at 49%, the highest of any channel they measured.
So here's the order we build in for our clients.
First, money pages. The content that actually converts.
Then navigational content. "Is State Farm better than Nationwide for auto insurance in Colorado?"
Then, and only then, informational blog posts.
They never converted.
Now they don't even get traffic.
What's the last blog post that actually wrote you a policy?
It's funny... I made this post almost 2 years ago.
And the insurance-famous guys clowned me out in the comments.
Actual quotes, still up on the post:
"Zero percent chance this happens."
"Are you going to tell us AI agents are going to run all the back office? If so, ya lost me right there."
"Who cares about reality when you can just make bold statements on LinkedIn?"
WELP.....
Here we are in 2026.
Go look at those same guys' feeds.
AI agents answering the phones. AI handling renewals. AI doing certs. AI running the back office they said couldn't be run.
It's legit all they post about now.
The "ya lost me right there" crowd is now beating their chests on podcasts about the exact thing that lost them.
I'm not mad about it (i know I kinda sound bitter about it).
But I actually think it's great.
But let's be honest about what it means.
If AI runs the back office, the only thing left that matters is attention.
And attention doesn't need 20 producers and a bullpen of CSRs.
It needs one person with a niche, a point of view, and the stomach to post every day.
We're still a couple years out and maybe a few million dollars off.
But the thing I got laughed at for is now the thing everybody's scrambling to build.
1
81
I always find it funny when people base their marketing strategies around third-party market research.
By the time a study gets published, it's measuring outdated behavior.
And it's measuring whatever's easiest to measure.
I saw someone post this past week telling insurance agents that AEO is just SEO, that there really aren't any clicks coming from ChatGPT, and that it's not worth your time and effort to focus on AEO.
The click data is accurate.
That "ChatGPT barely sends anyone to your website."
But clicks ARE NOT the right way to measure what ChatGPT is doing for you guys.
Here's what we're actually seeing across our clients.
12% to 15% of leads now tell us on the quote form that they found the agency through ChatGPT or another LLM.
We know this because we ask it in every insurance lead form.
And that's just the ones who admit it.
Someone asks ChatGPT who they should talk to about insuring their business.
It names a few agencies, with the name and phone number right there in the answer.
Some of those people just call. No click, no website visit, nothing in analytics.
The rest copy the agency name, Google it, check the Google Business Profile, read the reviews, and then click through to the website.
Your analytics credit Google.
Branded search.
Or "direct."
On top of that, we're seeing more and more emails from AI agents.
They find our clients, find their email address, and send the request directly.
Almost impossible to attribute, and it's climbing every month.
Add it all up and AI search is realistically driving 15% to 20% of our clients' leads.
And it's going up.
Here's the part that should get your attention.
70% to 80% of those leads are commercial.
If you write commercial lines, do not sleep on this.
Think about your best referral partner.
Your top CPA has probably sent you a dozen clients over the years and never once sent you a "click."
Nobody would say referrals don't work.
That's what these models are. A referral source, not a traffic source.
Ask any of your friends how they research a purchase these days.
ChatGPT comes up almost every time.
Then go read a stat saying it doesn't.
I don't know who the hell these studies are interviewing, but every single person I know uses an LLM before they buy something.
That's why we don't run our business off third-party research. We test, and we look at what's actually showing up on our clients' quote forms.
Whoever is telling you not to bother with AEO probably hasn't actually tried it.
ChatGPT is sending you leads.
It's just not putting its name on them.
How are you guys tracking where your leads actually come from?
Or is everything just "Google"?
5
3
166
Me to the cookie-cutter insurance website vendors after I take a client they’ve been lying to about SEO for years and get them more quote requests from SEO/AEO in one month than they got all of last year.
1
2
162
A client of mine got back from an owners-only conference a few weeks ago.
75 agency owners in a room, a dozen vendors, a lot of roundtables on SEO.
One of the vendors was pitching the all-in-one thing.
The website, SEO, intake forms, CRM, all integrated with the management system.
He asked them one question.
"If you're working with three or four agencies in my area, and someone asks Google or ChatGPT for a top-rated agency near them, how am I the one getting picked?"
Their answer was "we're not sure."
Uhhhh… WHAT.
He told me that on our monthly reporting call, it's been bugging me since, because that one question is the whole game.
So if you're about to hire a marketing agency for your insurance agency, specifically for SEO or AEO, ask these two questions before you sign anything.
Question 1.
Can I talk to four or five of your clients who've been with you for a few months or a few years?
Not a testimonial page.
Not a case study they wrote themselves.
Actual calls with agency owners who've been paying them long enough to know what the service is really like.
If they won't set that up, walk. There's no good reason to say no to that.
Question 2.
How many insurance agencies are you working with in my state?
If it's more than 10, walk. If it's more than 6, I'd still walk.
Here's why, and nobody is going to tell you this on a sales call.
Page one of Google has 10 organic listings.
The map pack has 3.
When someone asks ChatGPT or Claude or Perplexity for an agency, it usually names 3 or 4.
Those are the only spots that get calls. Nobody goes to page two.
Now think about the vendors charging a couple hundred bucks a month.
For that math to work they need 50, 100, 200 agencies in a single state.
Every one of them wants to rank for "home insurance California" or "general liability insurance."
Every one of them is competing with each other for the same 10 spots, and the vendor is collecting from both sides of the fight.
Even if that vendor did incredible work and owned pages one and two, who out of the 200 is supposed to get spot one?
So they tell you SEO takes time. And the invoice keeps going out.
That's not a service.
It's a marketing ploy with a monthly subscription.
1
124


















