If this Dallas defense shows any real improvement down the stretch, I think it’s safe to say Mike Pettine will be the DC next year regardless of who the HC is, assuming he wants the job. It’s the perfect middle ground for Jerry: maintaining continuity while having an experienced playcaller.
The bigger question is whether CP stays in Dallas as a secondary coach or goes back to Vic in Philly for the same role. With both Pettine and Fangio potentially nearing retirement, he’d essentially be positioning himself as the next DC in line at either spot.
Ultimately, I think it comes down to the fractured relationship with Shotty. If he’s still the HC, Philly might be more appealing. But if Dallas makes a change, maybe CP decides it’s worth seeing things through.
I have to say, after watching CP’s presser, I’m incredibly impressed with how he handled himself.
If you watched Shotty’s responses when asked about potentially giving up playcalling this season, then watched CP answer questions after it was actually taken away from him, you’d have a hard time guessing which one is the veteran and which is the first-time playcaller.
Both may have their issues calling plays, but I could genuinely see CP becoming a hell of a CEO-style HC one day.
Wild thought I had last night: Is it crazy to argue that, all things considered, Brian Schottenheimer has been MORE disappointing as a playcaller than CP this season?
CP has had his head-scratching moments, but context matters. He’s a first-time playcaller who’s spent much of the season relying on 3rd/4th-stringers at key positions, all while running a scheme the league seemingly figured out this year.
Despite that, we’ve started to see adjustments. More blitzing, more man coverage, and a willingness to adapt the scheme to the personnel available. There have been some bad individual performances, but also legitimate bright spots.
Now compare that to Shotty.
He has virtually his entire offense back from last season and has benefited from relatively good health, yet the unit still lacks any week-to-week consistency. We’re 10 weeks into the season and still haven’t seen GP and CD go off in the same game. The run game has regressed significantly, and his sequencing and situational mistakes have directly cost this team games.
Perhaps most concerning, there’s been little evidence of the kind of schematic or philosophical adjustments needed to counter how defenses are playing them. CP has been forced to make those adjustments all season with a depleted roster, while Shotty has largely stuck to his approach despite the offense’s persistent issues.
Shotty is supposed to be the seasoned playcaller, yet he’s making many of the same mistakes as a first-timer. The difference? He has arguably the most talented offensive roster in the league to bail him out, while CP has spent much of the year trying to make it work with practice squad players and fourth-stringers.
If CP’s performance was bad enough to warrant taking playcalling away from him, what does that say about Shotty?
He’s 100% ending up back in Philly with Vic. Once Vic retires, he’ll walk into the DC job, taking over a unit that already knows his system and is built to fit it. He’ll also have worked through the growing pains of being a playcaller with us. Wouldn’t be surprised if he eventually becomes a Cowboys boogeyman.
After researching Cowboys’ new defensive play caller Mike Pettine, I think one of his biggest immediate advantages will be his use of tight focused game plans.
In GB, Pettine said he preferred carrying just 25–30 plays into a game, down from the 50–55 he used earlier in his career. Pair that with Shotty confirming the defense will be simplified earlier this week, and the move starts to make more sense.
I’ve always been fascinated by how effective, creative, and variable Flores is with one of the seemingly smallest call sheets in the league. When you don’t have a clear talent advantage, simplicity can be a weapon. Give players fewer things to process, let them play fast, and put them in a better position to execute.
Here’s everything Christian Parker has had to deal with as a first time DC this year:
- First time calling plays at ANY level
- Completely revamped the personnel while transitioning to a 3-4
- Installed a scheme that was the league’s meta in recent years, only for offenses to start figuring out how to attack it league-wide this season
- Went without a senior advisor with NFL DC experience until 5 weeks ago
- Dealt with numerous injuries to key starters
When you put all of that into perspective, it’s hard to argue he was ever going to succeed this year
Everyone will be focused on what happened with CP and the defense today, but I think Shotty’s presser may have revealed something even more concerning about the offense.
A month ago, I wrote about the possibility that Shotty wasn’t involved enough in the offense dating back to the middle of last season, potentially explaining its regression. Today, he seemingly confirmed that theory.
He described Klayton Adams as the “boots on the ground,” handling much of the day-to-day work, while Shotty comes in and “calls the plays on game day.”
That’s concerning when you consider what we’ve seen on film. Last year, the offense did a much better job sequencing plays, marrying the run and pass games, and attacking defensive weaknesses. That cohesion between the players and play caller has largely been missing this season.
Either Shotty needs to be more involved in running the offense throughout the week, or if Klayton is going to handle most of that work, he needs to be the one calling plays on game day.
I have a theory about the Cowboys’ offensive decline that starts with why they hired Matt Eberflus in the first place.
Dallas knew Shotty was a first-time HC who would also call plays. Eberflus was supposed to be a trusted, experienced defensive voice who could run that side of the ball and let Shotty focus on the offense.
Through the first 8 games of 2025, Dallas averaged 30.8 PPG and scored at least 37 points in 4 games. After the Denver loss and Shotty’s increased involvement with the defense, they averaged 25.0 over the final 9 games and had fewer 37-point performances.
The decline wasn’t just about points. Early on, the offense seemed more intentional. Concepts were married together better, plays were set up throughout games, and there was a clearer plan for how to attack defenses as they adjusted. The offense felt more creative and Shotty seemed more dialed in as a playcaller.
As the defense struggled, Shotty took on a broader role trying to find solutions. My question is whether that came at the expense of the time and attention needed to keep evolving the offense. Less creativity, fewer counters, and less effective sequencing can make an offense predictable even with elite talent.
This year Shotty has openly talked about taking a wider scope of the team, being more involved across all three phases rather than focusing so heavily on offense. That may be what he believes he needs to do as a HC, but there’s a real balancing act when you’re also the playcaller.
That’s why the Mike Pettine hire could be so important. If Pettine can help Parker diagnose problems and develop defensive solutions, Shotty can oversee the defense without having to spend as much time solving its issues himself. Hopefully, that frees him up to get this offense back to the creativity, sequencing and identity it had early last season.
It also makes the “Mike reports to me” comment more telling. Shotty is still responsible for the entire team, but he needs to delegate effectively. The goal shouldn’t be to stop overseeing the defense; it should be to build a structure that lets him do that without losing touch with the offense.
The best offensive playcalling HCs in the league have experienced defensive coordinators they can trust to run that side of the ball. Andy Reid has Spagnuolo, Shanahan has Raheem Morris (has always had great DCs), and Ben Johnson has Dennis Allen. They still oversee the entire team, but they don’t have to personally search for every defensive solution. That’s the structure Dallas needs: let Pettine help Parker fix the defense so Shotty can focus more of his time on making sure his offense is operating at the level it was weeks 1-8 last year.
The only reason I feel bad for CP is how badly the Cowboys handled this from an optics standpoint.
They could’ve announced CP was moving to the booth and quietly let Pettine call the defense. Instead, they’ve turned it into a public debacle over the last 3 days, making both CP and the organization look incompetent.
The Cowboys aren’t winning, and nobody is seriously talking about their chances. So Jerry’s response has always been to manufacture a controversy that puts the spotlight back on the organization.
This could’ve been a quiet soft firing that allowed CP to save face and the team to find a path forward. Instead, they’ve publicly humiliated him.
Jerry may never have to worry about paying for a coach again because there’s no amount of money that would convince a young highly regarded coach to come to Dallas after watching this situation play out….
If I had to rank the reasons for the defensive struggles this season it would be like this in order:
1. Lack/misuse of personnel
2. Assignment discipline/player execution
3. Basic fundamentals (tackling, covering, block destruction etc)
4. Effort
5. Communication
6. Playcalling
Nice of them to fix the lowest thing on that list….
Some major changes for the Cowboys. Mike Pettine is now the team’s defensive play caller. Christian Parker remains DC in title, per source.
Confirming @toddarcher and @ByKimberleyA.
The cowboys will have now had 5 new defensive playcallers in the last 4 years….
Christian Parker will remain as Cowboys defensive coordinator but Mike Pettine, the senior defensive assistant, will call the defense on gamedays, sources tell me and @ByKimberleyA
1
187
This is how I think the Cowboys should deploy Caleb Downs going forward.
He’s not the ideal fit for a DeJean/Emmanwori-style nickel role, nor does he have the freak athleticism of a Derwin James or Kyle Hamilton. His biggest value is his processing and ability to control the defense mentally.
Make him the centerpiece of your disguises. Let the other 10 play fast and execute simpler assignments that fit their strengths, while Downs handles the added mental burden of orchestrating the pre-snap deception.
Right now, Fangio’s system requires nearly all 11 defenders to maintain their disguise until the snap. That creates unnecessary complexity and can force you into bizarre matchups, like leaving Von Miller 1-on-1 with one of the NFL’s best pass-catching RBs.
Put the mental burden on your smartest player, not everyone else.
This quoted post is unavailable.
Didn’t get much attention against SF, but Markquese Bell played 40 safety snaps to Alijah Clark’s 6 this week. Interesting considering Clark outsnapped Bell 38-21 vs. PHI in Week 7.
With PJ Locke back in Weeks 8-9, neither played much. But with Locke out again vs. SF, Dallas went back to Bell.
Clark has been good with his opportunities, so I’m curious about the switch. If Dallas can stabilize the safety spot opposite Hooker with Locke and Thompson out, it gives Downs more freedom to be deployed creatively in the role we saw him thrive in at IND.
Genuine question: Has there ever been an NFL DC who hadn’t been a play caller at any level and still found success in Year 1? Off the top of my head I can’t really remember any recent examples, if someone could help jog my memory….
The best solution to me at this point in time seems relatively obvious. Put him up there in the booth side by side with Pettine. They could have them effectively call plays together and no one would be the wiser from an optics standpoint. Similar to how NY calls offense with both Roman and Nagy. Sucks to say it, but what CP needs most right now is training wheels on how to play call in the NFL throughout a game.
Jerry recalling with us on @1053thefan that Sean Payton had play-calling taken away and restored over the course of his career.
Just my read: Sounds like they're greasing the wheels for some sort of defensive play-calling change.
Interesting trend with CP’s defense since he announced changes to help Dallas start faster.
He changed the practice structure, meetings and walkthroughs, while emphasizing a different play style to jumpstart games.
The results: 1H points allowed dropped from 15.5 (weeks 6-7) to 9 points (weeks 8-10). But 2H points allowed skyrocketed from 6.5 to 24.
The changes appear to have addressed the slow starts, but the defense is now struggling to sustain that level of play. Are opposing offenses adjusting at halftime, or is execution breaking down as games wear on?
Either way, fixing the first 30 minutes means little if you can’t finish the last 30.
The Cowboys have given up touchdowns on the first drive of their last four games and in five of seven games overall. Coordinator Christian Parker on what needs to change:
“I was actually studying that last night, the cut up for the first drive of each game and the first drive of the second half of each game. I think there's a couple different ways to look at it. I changed some things this week with how we practiced, how we met, how we walked through to try to jumpstart that process, going to try something different with our mock walkthrough on Saturday, just to make sure that we have that on the forefront of our mind, just with the execution and awareness to get those things done. And also with me just jumpstarting the group, if you will, with certain play style and how we're going to start the game.”
Do they fire him this week? I don’t think so, that seems like something they’d do during the bye if it continues to look this way. This week I would however expect him to be side by side with Pettine in the booth. Probably calling the plays together, like how Nagy and Roman do in NY. If he’s stubborn with being on the sidelines, then maybe they do fire him this week but I believe they try to get him going with training wheels the rest of the way
When asked about his confidence in Christian Parker; Brian Schottenheimer said he is "taking a deep dive, and looking at everything." Is this the beginning of the end for Parker's time with the Cowboys?
Is Christian Parker On The Way Out?
When asked about his confidence in Christian Parker; Brian Schottenheimer said he is "taking a deep dive, and looking at everything." Is this the beginning of the end for Parker?
Just a thought, but I’d like to see CP sprinkle in more situational 4-3 fronts.
The current 3-4 packages have done a better job stopping downhill/power runs, but outside zone and B-gap runs have been a weakness. Against a 5-down front, offenses can exploit the numbers on perimeter runs and effectively take two backside defenders out of the play.
A 4-3 can give your LBs better angles to scrape, flow laterally and funnel those runs back inside. With Barham’s versatility alongside Marist, you can even stem between 4-3 and 3-4 looks pre-snap to keep offenses guessing.
James, Winters, Overshown and Barham are all playing at a similar level right now. More 4-3 looks could help get all four involved while putting them in positions to succeed.
I’m not saying it needs to become the defense’s identity. But when an elite play-caller like Shanahan spends an entire second half spamming outside runs to exploit your base structure, having that package as an adjustment in your plan is critical.
Regardless of how this season ends, I think Jerry and the Jones family may have learned a lesson about hiring inexperienced coaches.
If you’re a middle-of-the-pack team, you can afford to let young coaches grow with the roster, learn from mistakes, and build toward future contention.
But when you declare an “all-in” window, going into the season with a HC in year 2, a OC in year 2 who’s never called plays, and a first-time DC is a recipe for disaster.
I think they keep Shotty, but the smart move is surrounding him with proven play-callers. Bring in an experienced OC like Kingsbury or Gruden and a DC with a track record of calling plays, like McDermott or Quinn.
If you’re going all-in on the roster, you can’t afford to have inexperience cost you at the coaching level.









