Pinned Tweet
Every storage store financed in a public CMBS deal reports its actual income to the SEC. Almost nobody checks it.
I checked the store Extra Space ($EXR) manages in South Glens Falls, just listed at $6.34M, an alleged 6.08% cap. The SEC file and the OM's own P&L both put it lower.
Good store. The number behind the price is built from its best six months. #selfstorage 📍
2
4
727
NYC public transportation is hilarious.
Just saw a lady refuse to pay for a ticket, conductor says I guess we’ll have the cops come drag you off.
The guy in front of her says I think she might be retarded I’ll just pay for her, and they’re like alright whatever.
Then a random person comes up to apologize that she had to go through that situation.
What an insane run of events
17
Absolutely insane the @Buccaneers are gonna win a game without completing a pass.
@grok has this happened before?
1
3
134
The lenders on two NYC storage stores, Heitman's HCF entities, took both back in Feb 2024. ACRIS records $63.1M for the pair. Now they're selling them store by store.
Everyone will bid Avenue M in Brooklyn. It's the obvious one.
The deal is 2036 Webster Ave in the Bronx. It sits on a ground lease with an option to buy the land, and that option decides who wins. #selfstorage 🏙️
1
2
100
Until then, Webster has room to run on its own.
Its storage is 92.5% occupied, so there's space to fill. Its rents sit 10–12% under nearby stores, about the gap the listing claims.
The ICAP credit is $236K a year. It stays at 100% through fiscal 2037 and is gone after 2046: 25 years, against Avenue M's 15.
About 661 stacked lockers rent at around $35.50 a month as their own line. That count is my estimate from the locker square footage, and the unit mix will confirm it.
That's what the building earns before the option. Here's what I'd pay for it. 📈
1
2
17
My number on Webster is $11.24M, or $217 a rentable foot including lockers. That's the full-tax NOI at a 6.25% leasehold cap, plus the ICAP credit still to run.
My max bid is $8.95M, set at 1.35x debt coverage on the full-tax NOI. At $8.95M you get a $5.82M loan at 1.91x coverage and a 13.9% debt yield, with about $3.13M of equity.
The land option isn't in either number. It's the upside.
What I don't know yet: the option's price clause, the ground-rent escalations, the unit mix and true locker count, and the rent roll.
2
22
The 6.08% rests on two choices.
Revenue is March through August annualized, the six busiest months of the year.
Expenses start from the owner's books, which carry no management fee and no payroll. That's likely why every store on the loan cut costs at once last year: the fee came off the property statement. The broker then adds a 5% fee and cuts $24K of actual contract and marketing spend.
Put the actual costs back, charge 6% to manage it, and take 3% off a summer run rate: $397K before tax.
Then tax: $56K a year, 79% of it school. Moreau assesses at full value, so the price resets it. 🧾
1
3
35
My number: $4.70M, about $124 a rentable foot.
Start from the OM's own lines. Revenue $521K: the broker's T-6 less 3% for summer (my assumption), within $3K of the SEC's full-year 2025. Actual expenses restored, 6% management, tax reset at my price: NOI $329K, 36.9% opex.
At a 7.0% cap, between the sponsor's portfolio ask (6.0% on the SEC file's NOI) and the 7.7% my cap model gives this store, that's $4.70M. Range $4.44–4.84M at 7.5–6.75%.
It finances at 60% loan-to-value at 1.35x. At the ask, with tax reset, it's a 4.8% cap.
What I don't know: the T-12 by month, the rent roll by move-in date, what the house out front could rent for, and what it costs to release one store from the loan.
What would you buy this property for?
2
36
An Extra Space store in South Glens Falls went under LOI 15 days after listing at $12.7M.
It has the cheapest street rate in town at every unit size: $90 for a 10x10 against a $120 average at the seven stores around it.
That's not the weakness. It's the reason to buy it. The tenants already inside show why. 📍
1
2
112
One: the revenue is a T-3 ending in July, annualized. May through July are storage's busiest months. Get the full T-12 before you bid.
Two: the OM pitches building on the 45 outdoor parking spaces. The town approved the 2022 expansion with a note: no further development of the site. It was at its 40% impervious limit.
Price neither, and here's what's left. 🧾
1
1
15
My number: $10.8M, about $112 a rentable foot.
Start from the OM's $815K NOI. Take tax to the OM's own $142K. Trim 3% of revenue for a summer T-3 (my assumption). That's $753K. I cap it at 7.0%, between the sponsor's 6.75% ask on the sister portfolio and the 7.45% my cap model gives this county.
The ask is 18% above that. At the ask you pay today for rent increases nobody has made yet. At $10.8M you keep them, and the plan is worth $14.4M if it works.
What I don't know: the full T-12, the rent roll by move-in date, and the school tax bill.
If you own a store like this and want it priced off what tenants actually pay, I'll run the same work on yours.
1
21










