Compass Man 🧭 (@Compass_mann) header
Compass Man 🧭 (@Compass_mann) profile picture

🎬 Talking movies, TV & anime 🧠 Theories | Hot takes | Debates, 🍿 If you love fiction, you’re home. ChelseaFC/🥷/30BG..Victor Osimhen number 1 fan ✌🏽

Lagos, Nigeria
Joined January 2024
Question: when is the moment when Paul's actions change the fate of Jamis? Throughout all of Paul's visions before he fights Jamis, Jamis is his mentor, ally, and friend. Chani is alternately his ally or his murderer but Jamis is absolutely his ally. Yet Jamis is hostile towards allowing the Atreides to live from the beginning. So how could Jamis and Paul both survive the Amtal that Jamis seems committed to from the outset? Is it that Stilgar was the one Jamis was actually challenging and who would have died had Paul not stepped in? After all, Stilgar is not shown in Paul's visions before the Amtal and Stilgar fills some of the moments previously seen with Paul (Chani steps in to others). Is this then where Paul begins to see that the future is not fixed and that the free will of all impacts the outcome? If that is the case, why then does Paul adopt such a fatalist attitude about the jihad? He already knows he can change things. Or am I misreading the whole sequence? Help please.
3
3
284
Oscar Isaac's beard is so powerful he made a space nun fall in love and give birth to Mega Hitler
2
4
212
Some of you have completely missed the core messages of the first two books. Dune is warning about populist movements and their charismatic leaders, particularly within religion. Frank Herbert was so concerned by millions of readers of Dune seeing Paul as a potential spiritual leader, he wrote Dune Messiah and even turned Paul into a loser of sorts. Now there was nothing wrong with Paul. It was the zealotry in the Fremen that caused the genocidal Jihad -- one that even the Kwizatz Haderach could not stop. Paul was as heroic than any human being alive. At least in the books, he can be forgiven for triggering a Jihad in his name. He became a demigod in human form. I call him an anti-hero not because he isn't heroic -- he really is written that way. I call him that because of the Jihad and because of what FH himself talked about repeatedly after the book was published. Paul is a charismatic leader and FH specifically warns about that in interviews. He's so concerned about it, he says it's the main thrust of his books when it's just one of many. He's not warning about it because of Paul himself, who is fine, but because of the susceptibility to demagoguery that he perceived in American responses to Paul. It's not just charismatic leaders that FH is warning about. It is much clearer in the first two books that the Fremen Jihad doesn't even need a leader to become a genocidal movement. It is human to want to be surrounded by like-minded people. They make us feel we are right. But the latter is pure ego gratification. Propaganda is part of it, but the notable feature of such movements is the members can't spot the movement's own propaganda. The movement tells you it's the other side which is producing propaganda whilst producing propaganda of their own. So Herbert is basically saying don't be in the movement. Even if you don't think you're in a movement, the mere act of being around and listening to people who agree with you means that you are. You could waste 20 years of your life not knowing you're being tricked for the benefit of others and not your own. These are the core messages of the first two books.
41
Did Stilgar tune the thumper to intentionally call a bigger worm so he could justify the prophecy? It's just one of the small details I noticed while rewatching.
1
2
2
310
I don’t know what the people are screaming at. I’ve read the books like a dozen times and I think the film was bloody brilliant. Sure they had to drop Thufir Hawat, Chanis first baby, Barons pederasty and Alia out for the simple time constrains. Still, Rebecca Ferguson did hell of a job as Jessica, far better than anyone else before. Irulan was fine for the job she had and Feyd-Rautha was as menacing as intended. Not sure about Chani, though. Zendaya is a fine actress and took the role she was given well. I’m just not sure about the script. In any case I like it.
1
2
199
'How Dune: Part Two erases its Middle Eastern, North African and Muslim influences' From the use of beads and prostration in prayers by the Fremen, to the almost-Arabic language, phrases pulled from religious texts and the wearing of veils, it felt like Dune takes a heavy amount of inspiration from Islam, Middle Eastern and North African cultures yet simultaneously erases us from screen Phrases, names and words like 'Muad'Dib', 'Shai-Hulud', 'Lisan al-Gaib', 'jinn' and 'Mahdi' aren't simply made-up from a make-believe language – they come from and are inspired by Arabic and Islam. The Mahdi, for example, is a revered religious and spiritual figure who Muslims believe is a messianic deliverer that will fill the earth with justice and equity. Unsurprisingly, Timothée Chalamet isn't exactly who I envisioned to bear such a name. Another word from the book that is notably left out in the film is 'jihad', the Arabic word for 'struggle'. Instead, the phrase chosen by scriptwriters is "holy war", likely due to being in a time where 'jihad' is now unfortunately synonymous with violence and terror. For me, to leave it out of the script is an intentional choice which shows that creators recognise their influences, yet choose not to highlight them on screen if it didn't serve an aesthetic purpose. Like, Dune can be Muslim, but not too Muslim.
1
1
2
321
Why were the Fremen storing so much water to transform Arrakis into a lush forest planet? I'm sure they knew the worms would not survive in such an ecosystem. With spice addiction tied to so many critical functions in the known universe, why would the people most addicted to spice strive for this outcome?
1
1
2
319
Why does Dune end so abruptly? Because in a very real sense, that is the end of the story. Paul Atreides now has the ability to see and select whichever possible future he wants to, and there is in fact only one possible future in which the human race survives. It’s not a brilliant future - it involves, for example, a galactic jihad and the brutal suppression of any dissent - but it does actually preserve the species. There is no way to beat Paul at this point or to prevent the future he’s chosen from happening. The stuff that we’ve been reading about up to his awakening - spies, assassins, warfare, treachery, plots within plots - none of that will work against him any more, because he is basically God. There’s no possible conflict from which to generate story. Now: obviously, there are multiple sequels to Dune. But really the story of these sequels is people struggling against the end of stories. Paul decides he no longer wants to be part of this universe, and hands off the responsibility of steering humanity through the story that he’s written to his son Leto; other factions like the Guild and the Ixians do their best to overthrow prescience and return free will to humanity; but it feels a lot like a bleak cautionary tale about what life feels like after God shows up, and I don’t think anyone feels that any of the sequels are as much fun as the first book.
3
7
1,799
In the Dune novel series why wasn't Paul Atreides able to stop the Fremen Jihad or at least tone it down a bit? Fundamentally, because Frank Herbert wanted it that way. Paul can see the future. Paul does not see a path that prevents or cuts the Jihad short not because of some character flaw or lack of ability, but because Frank wanted to be inevitable. This allows Frank to skip showing why the jihad is resilient to attempts from the top to shorten or prevent it. The important part Frank wants you to get is that Paul stops trying to avoid the skulls that line this path and instead accepts them as the price of revenge and the imperial throne. The two required ingriedents are shown on the page: Paul builds up an unstoppable army that sees him as their prophet, and Paul secures unfettered access to space transportation by threatening the guild. The least clear part is that the unstoppable army wants to invoke “comvert or die” on the rest of the imperium, but Frank says it’s going to happen so it doesn’t exactly matter that it’s not a huge part of Paul’s story of revenge. This is all gleanable (if not the most clear) from Dune. No need for sequel materials that give some post-hoc imperative “this must happen or everyone dies” reason for the jihad. Frank doesn’t want to tell the story of failing to control a religious crusade despite your precognitive powers, so he doesn’t. Far eaiser to just say that it would fail.
3
5
1,232
Once and for all..
1
5
6
435