Pinned Tweet
βWhen Christ died, He died for you individually just as much as if you'd been the only man in the world.β
This quote is one of my favorites.
Since Christ died for billions of people, itβs easy to forget that he did not just do it for humanity collectively, like a
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Replying to @ExaminetheDay @KerrDepression
Tweet 2 of 2
The omnipotence line fails the same way, and the page defines it before you can steal it.
Richard of St. Laurence, whoever stands behind that name, says she is omnipotent because a queen shares the king's privileges. Liguori does not leave it as a second divine attribute. He says the Son is omnipotent by nature, and the mother is so by grace, and that this "omnipotence" consists in the Son denying nothing she asks. That is intercession, stated as a superlative. It is still the Son who grants. A denial he does not issue is not a power she holds apart from him. If the Son can deny her, the attribute was never hers. If he does not deny her, the freedom remains his. Either way she is not omnipotent in the sense the word has when it is said of God. Calling the metaphor by the same name as the attribute is the whole trick. Germanus's "omnipotent to save" is the same figure. You took a defined metaphor, deleted the definition, and returned it as literal divinity.
So the charge to the original question does not land. Asking the Theotokos to pray is not shirk, because she is not called upon as a god and the prayer is not latria. She names herself the handmaid. The church that called her Mother of God did it to keep the child from being split, not to enthrone a goddess beside him. A Latin preacher's excess is a real thing, and some of this rhetoric deserved to be cut down. Excess is not the dogma, and the dogma is not "God has a mother who commands him." The page you photographed says she was obeyed by her child on earth and cannot command him now. That is the opposite of the caption you wrote over it.
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Replying to @KerrDepression
Tweet 1 of 2
@KerrDepression The title is real. The inference is not. And the pages you marked already say the thing you need them not to say.
Mother of God means she bore the person who is God. That is Ephesus, 431, and it is ours as well as Rome's. It was said against the claim that she bore a mere man who was then joined to God. It is a statement about Christ. It is not a statement that the divine nature has a mother, and it is not a statement that the Trinity takes orders. "Because she is the Mother of God, God obeys her" does not follow. You slid from who the child is to a power of command over God. The council did not slide with you.
Now the book. The Glories of Mary is Alphonsus Liguori compiling medieval praises. It is not a council, and "Catholic authorities literally hold" is already too large for a devotional florilegium. Read the paragraph you put in the box. The subjection he is talking about is the incarnation on earth. The note at the bottom cites Luke: erat subditus illis, he was subject to them. The boy in Nazareth obeyed his mother. That is the kenosis, the Son having taken a real childhood. The next sentence, which you did not box, is the limit: though Mary is in heaven, she can no longer command her Son, yet her prayers are the prayers of a mother. Liguori denies the present tense of the claim you are using him for. "God obeys Mary" and "her prayers are commands" are the reading he walks back on the same page. Bernardine's line, that God listens to her prayers as though they were commands, is a figure for how willingly the Son hears her. A simile is not a transfer of sovereignty.
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Blood of a saint: Hinduism
Saliva of the prophet: Tawhid
Make it make sense.
unavailable
iβm not sure how i wouldβve accepted the idea of unconditional love towards those who hurt us had Christ not chosen to incarnate and suffer on our behalf
1
5
164
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
What the evidence actually supports is far more nuanced than the polemical crap these Muslim apologists are pushing.π§΅
Did James and Paul Preach Different Christianities? | Dr Hamza Tzortzis youtu.be/OUwN05Lki9o?si=Axww⦠via @YouTube
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Bulus (Paul) ibn Raja was a tenth-century Egyptian Muslim scholar who converted to Coptic Christianity sometime after witnessing the execution of a Christian martyr, himself a convert from Islam, whose final words prophesied his conversion. Paul went on to write a treatise attempting to refute Islam through its own scriptures, the Quran and Sunnah. His work was translated into Latin in the 13th century and became a popular source on Islam in Europe.
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Evidence from the Greek literary papyri suggests that, absent an original title/authorial attribution, there's a lack of uniformity in the transmission in this regard. None of that holds for the 4 Gospels, so why are they still regarded as anonymous?
There's nothing here to debate. You could have simply shown everybody where I misrepresented the scholarship. You didn't, because I didn't.
The scholars you cited in your videos don't stop where you stop. They say the awaited figure is distinct from Jesus, and in the same breath that he is a pre-existent heavenly being expected within that generation. Your use of scholarship is inconsistent and selective.
Demonstrate that the scholarship accepting the distinct-figure view DOES NOT hold
(A) that the Son of Man Jesus awaited was a heavenly, pre-existent, angelic, celestial being and,
(B) that his arrival was expected within that first generation, not six centuries later.
And to be quite blunt with you, I'm an ex-Muslim, and I have no intention of revealing my identity online for safety reasons.
You're more than welcome to respond to the scholarship as I've listed it in my thread. It's the better format anyway, you can put the citations up next to mine and let people compare them directly. Please be consistent.
The 3rd century bishop Dionysius of Alexandria complains that a false charge has been laid against him that he denied the Son to be homoousios with the Father. This shows that atleast by the 3rd century Alexandria concurred that the non-acceptance of 'homoousios' was shunned
π§΅ The Miracle of the Sun is the most evidentially weighty miracle claim in any religious tradition. It was announced in advance, at a fixed date and place, and before the public & reported by hostile sources.
If you have 11 hours of free time today, hereβs my comprehensive case for Catholic miracles (and various non-Catholic ones, too). The evidence is stronger than you might think! Enjoyβ€οΈβπ₯
youtu.be/Lk2W9mKTzIQ
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
The almighty God of Love bled just as much for both of these women.
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
Iβm sure @JesusandWhatnot was only trying to be funny, but this was extremely imprudent of him as someone publicly defending Christs Church. Especially the fact that, purposefully or not, he wasnβt truthful about what he actually said when he brought it up live. @JesusandWhatnot needs to publicly apologize imo
AristoCopt Ω π»π¦ πΉ retweeted
In the first-century Jewish context, if Jesusβ Jewish followers including the Apostles merely "saw" Him crucified as the Quran posits, they would have outright rejected Him as the Messiah regardless of His past miracles, due to the Old Testament curse associated with hanging on a tree.
βHowever, if the Resurrection truly took place and Jesus had previously foretold it to them, it is entirely natural that His followers accepted Him as the Messiah and proclaimed His message. Therefore, Jesus must have truly risen; otherwise, the Apostles and His Jewish followers would have had no theological or rational grounds whatsoever to acknowledge His Messiahship.
βJake Brantacella SNITCHES on OrthoDucklips!β
i genuinely donβt understand how people bring themselves to listen to any polemical content when this is the level of engagement.
Itβs like youβre more interested in drama than doing apologetics. This is just childish behavior.
there are no souls that you are going to help with your content. I personally cannot bring myself to care about an argument made when half the video is just childish chest thumping.
1
2
82



































