Calvin (@CraniumCalvin) header
Calvin (@CraniumCalvin) profile picture

Tokenomics Specialist | Token // Ecosystem // DAO - Concepts & Designs | DM/Email for inquiries | Nothing I say is Financial Advice

Web3 Native
Joined September 2021
Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)Photo by Calvin (@CraniumCalvin)
gm 🦧
1
11
1,279
This is all very true. One of the main issues is that the voting structures are commonly votes tied to number of tokens held, creating the likely event of a plutocracy. I think in some cases this is purposeful, in others it’s just naively sticking to the status quo. The “attention” or popular voices gaining more traction I feel is more an issue of the platform that is put in place to both propose changes, and/or taking them to a vote. When we have forums where proposals can go unnoticed, great ideas can get overlooked. And when there are structures with councils who decide what goes to vote, we have a potential for favouritism and bias. The truth is when we scale we fragment and our common solution is hierarchal structures, just like we see in the formation of governments and councils in the real world. Then the little people don’t get a voice, so they learn to not care. In DAOs this often leads to voter apathy, which only exaggerates the disproportionate voting power created by the 1 token = 1 vote structure. The combination of these things remove the “power in numbers” that should exist. IMO this is a bigger issue than just DAOs and how they are set up. It’s human natures response to a community that scales to a size that there are too many people for easily managed communication and trust. It goes way beyond DAOs sadly. If we look at modern ‘democracy’ (if it really exists), then every single person should vote on every issue that’s raised. But we often delegate our vote to some sort of representative. It can be argued that this prevents voter exhaustion, but often or just removes power from the voter. We often see this in DAOs too. So the question is. Should DAOs be small and never scale, or can we overcome the conditioning that leads hierarchal structures being formed? Side note: Dunbar’s number is something that often comes to mind here. “Dunbar's number is a suggested cognitive limit to the number of people with whom one can maintain stable social relationships”- Wikipedia. My take is that if we apply this to communities we could essentially have a group of people that know one another well enough to form trust amongst them. Then we don’t need intermediaries. Scale beyond that and fragmentation occurs, trust breaks down, and we end up implementing structures that separate us from the real decision making.
Replying to @CraniumCalvin
even when a DAO starts “fair,” power tends to drift toward whoever has the most tokens, the most attention, or the most time to stay active. over time that becomes functionally indistinguishable from a plutocracy, just with nicer UX @CraniumCalvin
7
12
929
We need more DAOs - but different and better DAOs. The original drive to build Ethereum was heavily inspired by decentralized autonomous organizations: systems of code and rules that lived on decentralized networks that could manage resources and direct activity, more efficiently and more robustly than traditional governments and corporations could. Since then, the concept of DAOs has migrated to essentially referring to a treasury controlled by token holder voting - a design which "works", hence why it got copied so much, but a design which is inefficient, vulnerable to capture, and fails utterly at the goal of mitigating the weaknesses of human politics. As a result, many have become cynical about DAOs. But we need DAOs. * We need DAOs to create better oracles. Today, decentralized stablecoins, prediction markets, and other basic building blocks of defi are built on oracle designs that we are not satisfied with. If the oracle is token based, whales can manipulate the answer on a subjective issue and it becomes difficult to counteract them. Fundamentally, a token-based oracle cannot have a cost of attack higher than its market cap, which in turn means it cannot secure assets without extracting rent higher than the discount rate. And if the oracle uses human curation, then it's not very decentralized. The problem here is not greed. The problem is that we have bad oracle designs, we need better ones, and bootstrapping them is not just a technical problem but also a social problem. * We need DAOs for onchain dispute resolution, a necessary component of many types of more advanced smart contract use cases (eg. insurance). This is the same type of problem as price oracles, but even more subjective, and so even harder to get right. * We need DAOs to maintain lists. This includes: lists of applications known to be secure or not scams, lists of canonical interfaces, lists of token contract addresses, and much more. * We need DAOs to get projects off the ground quickly. If you have a group of people, who all want something done and are willing to contribute some funds (perhaps in exchange for benefits), then how do you manage this, especially if the task is too short-duration for legal entities to be worth it? * We need DAOs to do long-term project maintenance. If the original team of a project disappears, how can a community keep going, and how can new people coming in get the funding they need? One framework that I use to analyze this is "convex vs concave" from vitalik.eth.limo/general/202… . If the DAO is solving a concave problem, then it is in an environment where, if faced with two possible courses of action, a compromise is better than a coin flip. Hence, you want systems that maximize robustness by averaging (or rather, medianing) in input from many sources, and protect against capture and financial attacks. If the DAO is solving a convex problem, then you want the ability to make decisive choices and follow through on them. In this case, leaders can be good, and the job of the decentralized process should be to keep the leaders in check. For all of this to work, we need to solve two problems: privacy, and decision fatigue. Without privacy, governance becomes a social game (see vitalik.eth.limo/general/202… ). And if people have to make decisions every week, for the first month you see excited participation, but over time willingness to participate, and even to stay informed, declines. I see modern technology as opening the door to a renaissance here. Specifically: * ZK (and in some cases MPC/FHE, though these should be used only when ZK along cannot solve the problem) for privacy * AI to solve decision fatigue * Consensus-finding communication tools (like pol.is, but going further) AI must be used carefully: we must *not* put full-size deepseek (or worse, GPT 5.2) in charge of a DAO and call it a day. Rather, AI must be put in thoughtfully, as something that scales and enhances human intention and judgement, rather than replacing it. This could be done at DAO level (eg. see how deepfunding.org/ works), or at individual level (user-controlled local LLMs that vote on their behalf). It is important to think about the "DAO stack" as also including the communication layer, hence the need for forums and platforms specially designed for the purpose. A multisig plus well-designed consensus-finding tools can easily beat idealized collusion-resistant quadratic funding plus crypto twitter. But in all cases, we need new designs. Projects that need new oracles and want to build their own should see that as 50% of their job, not 10%. Projects working on new governance designs should build with ZK and AI in mind, and they should treat the communication layer as 50% of their job, not 10%. This is how we can ensure the decentralization and robustness of the Ethereum base layer also applies to the world that gets built on top.
800
586
252
3,245
390,086
The main problem with many large-scale DAOs right now is that they tend to devolve into plutocracies, if they aren’t already from the outset.
3
8
287
Deflationary ApeCoin: Will it help? Personally, I think this was wrongly diagnosed as a supply issue. It's not; it's a demand issue, and always has been.
2
1
257
375
825
133
9,188
746,658
History never repeats, but it often rhymes
1
188
Everyone calls them 'memecoins', but $REKT & $PENGU are showing what happens when tokens evolve into brands & IP. Here’s the difference: most founders chase quick liquidity. They farm engagement, dump treasuries and disappear when the hype cycle ends. Consequently holders (you) are left with nothing. Then there are the rare few who actually give a damn about their communities. The ones who: 1. Funnel revenue back into the business & holders 2. Stay transparent, even in the ugly moments 3. Work quietly in the shadows during hard times, not just when it’s trending 4. Understand community success ≠ charity, it’s a sustainable business model That’s what $REKT & $PENGU have nailed. They’ve built trust by proving they’re in it for more than a quick pump and dump. They’re founders who aspire big, but remain down to earth and relatable. They know that in order for holders to thrive, the project itself must thrive. In crypto, you don’t often get the chance to 'invest' in a team the way you do in startups. Tokens are the bet we all take and most teams aren’t worth betting on. But every once in a while you find teams like these. Builders who stick around, innovate, and grind when no one’s watching. That’s where asymmetric upside lives. At the end of the day, charts go up and down… but strong founders with vision, transparency, and grit? They build things that last. That’s why brand/IP tokens like $REKT & $PENGU are winning and will continue to do so.
61
29
6
188
22,113
156
3,985
229
27,737
944,786
Throwback to Time Square 2021. Remember when this was the ultimate bull signal? We've never been one to chase the hype cycles but we may be pulling up some of our long term plans... Black Chip Dont Quit.
10
6
37
1,745
As a founder, your main priority should always be transparency and communication to your holders. Treat it like a family. Get to know them as much as you can.
21
19
2
127
3,149
The thing about the NFT market is that floors are thin. One big buyer can completely change a project. When price goes up, the community becomes super bullish and you get this self fulfilling effect and it just goes higher snd higher. There’s no real way to bet against it either.
156
67
19
830
56,723
Introducing Pinball,fisherape by trade, mischievous, adventurous, bubble gum zorbing Elton John super fan otherwise. Would appreciate the share /like etc, to give @andrejaki311 the recognition he deserves for this masterpiece. @BoredApeGazette @CryptoGarga @RidazLp2 @GordonGoner
18
20
1
109
6,412
gm degens 🦧🍌
1
61
There's a lot of chatter in the timeline about the idea that @OthersideMeta is a Roblox killer. Some of you either aren't getting it or just don't believe it's possible so allow me to double down on that thought. Otherside can very well compete with Roblox and Fortnite and migrate a massive chunk of gamers over to a better and more balenced system where everyone wins. It's a platform play and not a game. At some point soon it'll be open to the public and I'd expect countless indie dev shops like mine to start to put resources towards building on top of it. Also, Bathroom Blitz was built with my team at @cmnd_line. These are absolute facts. All it needs are two things for this to work: 1. More dev time 2. Three success stories That's it. Before I break this down for you let me paint you a picture of why - and I say this with complete and total humility - there are a handful of human beings more qualified than me to address this. I'm coming from a place of heavy catagory level expertiese. I'm not blowing smoke here, my team can cook. Command Line - the games studio / web3 division of a company I co-founded 11 years ago (@Theia3D) has been building with the metaverse in mind since 2014. We started with Unity and switched to Unreal Engine 6 months later and focused on Enterprise with a heavy emphasis on VR. Why Enterprise? Well, everything consumer starts with government and businesses first - I didn't think we'd see a ubiquitous headset for 10+ years but we already saw plenty of use cases with VR for Enterprise so that's the direction we took. It was the right move at the right time, it put us in front of Epic Games (creators of Unreal Engine) and once they heard our story (started with Unity, quickly shifted to Unreal and it allowed a small, nimble team to make great looking content at a rapid pace) we quickly were invited to be the first Unreal Engine Enterprise Partner in North America. This opened countless doors for us and from 2016 through 2023 we punched our way through 300 projects globally ranging in scale from $100m private jet interiors and training sims on repairs for an unnamed company to multi-billion dollar hotel / casinos in various parts of the world to retainer based R&D projects for Unreal Engine and Nvidia. We became a known entity at both Epic and Nvidia and I consider us lucky for having plenty of friends at both companies. One project in particular that set us up was run on an experimental internal Metaverse that Epic used during Covid. We built 6 different environments and deployed it on 6 or 7 different tech stacks over 18 months. We already had a lot of experience evaluating tech stacks on top of years of environment design but this 18 month run really accelerated our understanding of what it takes to build a platform for mass use. With the launch of Command Line in 2023 we started for focus our expertise on gaming, platform development and Blockchain. So, back to my list: 1. More dev time - every platform play has an evolution. Every single person we're working with is focused and dedicated to the success of this play. This is a MASSIVE tech lift and there's a lot of moving parts. Massive lifts take time, that's just an absolute fact. The web3 tooling they've created will enable creators to monitize experiences in a varity of ways, this will unlock a the flywheel between the platform, creators and players - it's the vision we want to see fulfilled. Creators enabled, players actually owning assets with the ability to collect or resell. Items will no longer solely benefit the platform or creator but actual ownership will be realized. 2. Three success stories - 1 success is an anomoly, 3 is a pattern. It's only a matter of time before this is achievable. Once this is achieved developers will flock to the Otherside. We've seen it with Fortnite. We've seen it with Roblox. Otherside has the foundational DNA to be everything we need it to be to revolutionize gaming. All the elements are there, Bathroom Blitz is step one and I'm fucking stoked we built it.
58
78
13
331
17,590
Regardless of what’s happened, I still think Punks Comic #1 is a grail piece, and will live on with or without Pixel Vault. The beauty of the blockchain is that even if the centralised entity behind an asset disappears, the asset lives on. Time will tell whether this becomes a sort after collectors piece, or an NFT relic that time forgot.
5
104
What Murad is now calling a “slow cook” is what we used to call Organic growth. It’s funny how it took the market this long to realise what some of us have been saying for years. Many coins and NFTs pump beyond their means on day 1. There is only one possible out come, a pump and dump. Start small and grow your community over time, and if you succeed in that, your coin or NFT price will most likely follow. I always say that if someone is only after a quick win, then let them go, they are not what you need in your community. If it that’s the founder, don’t touch it, because it’s a disaster waiting to happen. Don’t get distracted by some people’s need for instant gratification, short term wins often don’t translate into long term growth. Let the gamblers gamble, and the builders cook. This though does not mean that a coin/NFT that comes out the gate swinging can’t succeed. It just means that its true test will be what happens when the price inevitably crashes back down to earth.
If it’s not a Slow Cook — it’s a SCAM! Slow Cook Movement coins will DOMINATE over the next 6 months.
1
1
141
Can i share the best trading advice with you... Even if you dont have alot of money to deploy you can study it ? Whenever you have massive dips in BTC because of some news - (Bitcoin OG moving billions this week) Look for coins that show incredible strength, it means they have strong buy pressure and liquidity. You essentially want coins that have higher demand when price dumps. Because right when the main news event is over (the 9 Billion BTC sale already happened) these coins go up nicely. The reason this is sometimes not so obvious to people is because The problem in reading bullish takes about a coin from someone on the timeline is that its contextual - someone that bought SOL at 8$ will be insanely bullish even now however someone who did at 240 wont have the same degree of it Their token sentiment isnt based on whats happening in the moment but when they got in. Its something even i understood not long ago and it changed alot of my perspective. The trump tariff market dips played this game out like 6 times. Go check the charts, look at the coins that held in the last 3 days - these coins have a higher probability
16
4
56
2,677
What Murad is now calling a “slow cook” is what we used to call Organic growth. It’s funny how it took the market this long to realise what some of us have been saying for years. Many coins and NFTs pump beyond their means on day 1. There is only one possible out come, a pump and dump. Start small and grow your community over time, and if you succeed in that, your coin or NFT price will most likely follow. I always say that if someone is only after a quick win, then let them go, they are not what you need in your community. If it that’s the founder, don’t touch it, because it’s a disaster waiting to happen. Don’t get distracted by some people’s need for instant gratification, short term wins often don’t translate into long term growth. Let the gamblers gamble, and the builders cook. This though does not mean that a coin/NFT that comes out the gate swinging can’t succeed. It just means that its true test will be what happens when the price inevitably crashes back down to earth.
If it’s not a Slow Cook — it’s a SCAM! Slow Cook Movement coins will DOMINATE over the next 6 months.
1
1
141