Pinned Tweet
I've decided to share my detransition story so that other people might benefit from it and not be harmed by transgender healthcare in the way that I was. My hope is with stories like mine the standard for trans healthcare may improve and people will be treated properly. 🧵
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
What discussions are had with 11 year old boys on puberty blockers about these risks? Is even the lifelong need to dilate explained to them? What can they at 11 possibly make of all this?
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
A friend shared this with me. Another friend has predicted that the end of harming children will be insurance. Here we go! @OsborneInk
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
I found testosterone to be extremely addicting and hard to quit. No one warned me about this when I was transitioning. I finally felt so validated when I found forums online filled with testosterone addicted men who couldn't stop injecting.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
Replying to @LoganLancing
When I started criticizing sex pseudoscience, the line of attack was:
"Are you a biologist?"
"Yes."
"Do you have a PhD?"
"Yes."
"In what?"
"Evolutionary biology."
"Where did you get your PhD?"
"At UCSB, a top-ranked university for my field."
"Oh, but are you a Christian?"
"No. I'm an atheist."
"But you're MAGA."
"No, I don't support Trump." (true at the time)
"You support JK Rowling so you're a transphobe."
"I'm... not a transph–"
"BIGOT!!"
Essentially, they only bring up your lack of a PhD because it's the quickest thing they can use to disregard your opinion. But if you had a PhD, they'd just move down the list to the next thing they can use to disregard your view. And the next...
When you get to the bottom of their list unscathed, they'll just assume you're a bigot or a grifter. You just hate trans people. Oh you just wanted to sell your book.
There's nothing you can be, do, or say to make them consider you might have a valid opinion.
I get that men are pissed, but there's this bitterness to it that I just can't stand. Women got together to have a women's march *for men*, because men basically aren't allowed to, and all the men on here are bitching about them stealing spotlight. Just accept that you need help!
6
189
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
Replying to @JillBlackpill
it's more important for boys to be socialized to empathize with anyone regardless of gender.
Also men are already more empathetic towards women more than to other men.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
This gets trotted out regularly even though it does not say what they claim it does.
They simply dont count the ppl who stop coming to the clinic, which about 45% of the total group. So the study actually says that 97% of the ppl WHO KEPT COMING BACK TO THE CLINIC TO GET TREATMENT do not regret it.
Presumably, of the 45% who stopped coming back, a large majority of them would say they regretted it.
Of course we would expect the vast majority of ppl STILL RECIEVING TREATMENT years later not to regret it. That has no relevance to the question "how high are regret rates?" tho
Nearly 97 percent of transgender people who received hormone therapy as teenagers did not regret it five years later, a study found.
Though some patients did regret medically transitioning, those rates are relatively low compared to other medical interventions. wapo.st/4C44lZp
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
A classic in the genre of medical disinformation. 👇
A new JAMA study uses surveys to assess regret among those who received hormones as teens.
42.5% did not return the surveys.
The authors nevertheless conclude that regret was “rare,” without acknowledging the 42.5% non-response in the limitations, and their conclusion is that gender Rx should not be restricted for youth (a non-sequitur). JAMA, apparently, sees this as worthy of publication.
The Washington Post (@washingtonpost) then uncritically reports the new study’s findings, also without any mention of the 42.5%.
This study will almost certainly be citation laundered, cited again and again in medical literature, media coverage, and legislative hearings, until its “findings” become “well-established truth.”
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
Some gender medicine activists are taking me to task for not recognizing that we can't infer anything from the missing data.
But that's precisely what I'm claiming. There's a difference between saying "the authors of the study and the WaPo article are making invalid inferences" (my claim) and saying, "I'm going to offer a better inference" (not my claim).
If you need it in simpler terms: this study does not support the 2.7% regret finding, but neither does it suggest a higher regret rate. The only thing it supports is the finding that prestigious medical journals are not doing their job of scientific gatekeeping.
A classic in the genre of medical disinformation. 👇
A new JAMA study uses surveys to assess regret among those who received hormones as teens.
42.5% did not return the surveys.
The authors nevertheless conclude that regret was “rare,” without acknowledging the 42.5% non-response in the limitations, and their conclusion is that gender Rx should not be restricted for youth (a non-sequitur). JAMA, apparently, sees this as worthy of publication.
The Washington Post (@washingtonpost) then uncritically reports the new study’s findings, also without any mention of the 42.5%.
This study will almost certainly be citation laundered, cited again and again in medical literature, media coverage, and legislative hearings, until its “findings” become “well-established truth.”
Women henpecking boys over their reading choices is not the way to help them empathize with women. I'm not sure why this is difficult to understand.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
With the "damsel in distress" trope, the man saves the woman because he cares about her, not about proving his masculinity.
The 'not a damsel in distress' trope is trite because it's about the woman proving her masculinity, not about caring about the man.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
If you shape how you treat the opposite sex based on your worst common denominator experiences... that's what you're gonna keep getting.
Boundaries? Good! But if you don't assume the best of people are out there, you'll never get them :/
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
There's a double standard at the core of the "books for boys" discourse that's so severe yet unchallenged that it's making me feel crazy.
When mostly boys like a book, that means the book is bad/oppressive to girls. When mostly girls like a book, the fact that boys don't like it is proof that something is wrong with the boys.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
This is just generally the norm in education policy. If girls are behind, how do we fix the system; if boys are behind, how do we fix the boys.
There's a double standard at the core of the "books for boys" discourse that's so severe yet unchallenged that it's making me feel crazy.
When mostly boys like a book, that means the book is bad/oppressive to girls. When mostly girls like a book, the fact that boys don't like it is proof that something is wrong with the boys.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
I am also not in between sexes. I have a disorder of sexual development and I know what my sex is. Having a disorder does not magically make me sexless, in between or a third sex.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
Funnily enough, I complain regularly that I struggle to find books I enjoy.
Why? Because I prefer “boy-coded” books.
I’m also aware that, as a woman, I’m in the minority there. I think that most of the books I love are best recommended to guys.
See, conservatives generally aren’t as obsessed with genitalia as “progressives” tend to be. We accept that it’s normal and acceptable for things to be more “for boys” and “for girls” AND that sometimes, girls like “boy stuff” and vice versa.
So-called progressives, on the other hand, seem to think that breaking the “gender norms” is more important than just giving people things they naturally enjoy. To them, the idea of a gender binary is tragic and to be destroyed.
I love having men in my life who love “boy stuff.” Between my husband, dad, and male friends, I never fear for my safety (because they’d die to protect me), never feel unsupported (because they champion me), and don’t feel the need to obsessively prove myself (because I’m allowed to be feminine and soft AND successful and intelligent).
Maybe the problem isn’t the binary.
Maybe the problem is that we stopped raising good men and tried to feminize them.
You know what women suck at?
Being men.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
I am getting profoundly sick of women (many of whom possess advanced degrees in subjects that require several years of graduate study) who hate stwelve-year-old boys, explaining to the rest of civilization how we need to relate to them.
Now, before anyone gets carried away, I am also a woman. I have been one for more than fifty years. I was never a boy. I am a tomboy, which means I spent a fair amount of my childhood doing things that would cause a modern Gender Studies department to call an emergency faculty meeting.
The difference is that I don't have a PhD in anything, (worthless or otherwise) so I haven't developed the intellectual confidence necessary to believe I know absolutely everything.
I'm kind of dumb that way.
For example, I have this radical theory that boys should be encouraged to read whatever the hell interests them.
For a great many boys, this will be...
(Please sit down. This may be upsetting.)
BOY STUFF.
Sports!
Soldiers!
Hunting!
Explosions!
Airplanes!
Tanks!
Dinosaurs eating other dinosaurs!
Some boys will prefer chemistry or astronomy. Some will love cooking. Some will be fascinated by fashion. Some will want to read about ballet, and some will want to read about a Sherman tank driving through a ballet recitle while firing its main gun at a home ec class.
THIS IS FINE.
Nobody is proposing that we issue every male child a football, a rifle, and a copy of The Art of War at birth, then arrest him if he expresses an interest in soufflés.
We're suggesting that if you want boys to read, it might help to give them books about things they actually want to read about. They probably know what interests them better than the woman who spent 8 yearas at university, and written tons of papers about how awful men and boys are.
I realize this is a controversial educational theory, requiring another $400 million in federal research grants.
But here's something else I've noticed.
Whenever the subject of boys comes up, an astonishing number of women immediately begin explaining how boys need to be understood, engaged, reimagined, reconstructed, and possibly returned to the manufacturer for a firmware update.
You know who might have some useful insight into what it's like to be a boy?
MEN. Yes! MEN!
Those strange, hairy creatures who were (in most cases) ACTUALLY BOYS at one point!
I know. It's an outrageous suggestion.
Now, being a woman, I don't have firsthand experience with boyhood. But I've discovered this remarkable intellectual technique called LISTENING TO PEOPLE WHO DO.
It's fascinating. You ask someone about their experiences, and then (and this is the really important part) you SHUT UP long enough to hear the answer.
Sometimes you even learn something.
One thing I've learned is that a great many boys enjoy traditionally masculine things.
Not all boys. Not every boy. Not every minute of every day.
But enough boys that pretending otherwise requires a level of deliberate obtuseness normally associated with government procurement.
Thank you for attending my TED Talk.
That'll be $650.
I'm kidding. It's free. I haven't figured out how to get a university to pay me for stating the obvious. I'm not a Democrat anymore.
But seriously. We've spent two generations "rethinking how we engage with boys."
Judging by the educational and social problems facing young men, I think we're entitled to ask whether some of that rethinking has been an enormous, expensive failure. Maybe it's time to stop treating ordinary boyhood like a defective social construct requiring professional intervention.
Maybe it's time to let Grandpa, who was once a boy himself, take the kids fishing.
Or shooting.
Or teach them how to rebuild a carburetor, throw a football, or make something useful with their hands.
And if one of those boys wants to learn ballet or bake a cake instead?
LET HIM. MAYBE THEN we can find someone (most likely a woman) to help him otu.
That's the entire point!
Give boys opportunities.
Give them books.
Give them good male role models.
Let them discover their interests without turning every preference into an ideological emergency.
And for the love of everything holy, STOP ACTING LIKE ACKNOWLEDGING THAT BOYS AND GIRLS OFTEN HAVE DIFFERENT INTERESTS IS SOME KIND OF CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY.
I'm not suggesting women have nothing useful to contribute to raising or educating boys. I'm suggesting that perhaps, just perhaps, we should spend a little less time lecturing men about what boys need, and a little more time asking men what being a boy was actually like.
It's a crazy idea, I know.
But after fifty years on this planet, I'm beginning to suspect that the people who insist they know the most about boys are frequently the people least interested in listening to them.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
Clinical psychology and psychiatry need a "cigarette label":
WARNING: You're handing interpretive authority over your life to a flawed individual and a coercive institution.
UniquelyDefined🦎 retweeted
There was this account written by a feminist mother some years ago, who was convinced that violent play was "social conditioning". She refused to let her sons have toy guns or watch cartoons glorifying violence or otherwise be exposed to anything expressing traditional gender roles.
Then she watched them spontaneously turn a couple of sticks into swords and realized she'd been completely wrong.
It's instinct. Little girls will pick up a piece of wood and declare that it's a baby. Little boys will pick up the same stick and decide it's a death laser. No one tells them to do this. They do this because they are mammals, and mammalian juveniles instinctively play in whatever fashion their instincts tell them to in order to practice the skills that their instincts require them to develop in order to survive adulthood.
For female human juveniles, the key skills are navigating social situations, managing the homestead, attracting a mate, and raising children. For male human juveniles those skills are making and using tools, in particular weapons, hunting, and engaging in single and group combat. No one tells them to do this, there is no "social conditioning". These are human universals, across every known culture. Boys and girls engage in these forms of play spontaneously.
This is why, when boys "read whatever they want", what they want to read almost invariably involves violence, adventure, technology, monsters, and the like. It's hard wired.
The only social conditioning here is what feminists do when they try to poison the conscience of young boys by convincing them that their instincts are pathological and toxic.
Replying to @katie_campione
Like I’m not even mad if you like Hatchet. Read whatever you want!!! Enjoy whatever you want!!! But women are not rolling their eyes at you liking a book. They are rolling their eyes at the continued sociological conditioning of boys and men to be violent and destructive.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Hatchets are tools, not weapons. It is not used as a weapon in the book Hatchet.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatchet
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatchet_(…




































