S Styles (@DunsPitcus) header
S Styles (@DunsPitcus) profile picture

Academic lawyer interested in Scots Law, especially Contract Law, Scots Constitutional law and politics, Medical Ethics, Public Law, History and Heraldry.

Joined March 2015
Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)Photo by S Styles (@DunsPitcus)
Say Aye to FoI’s.
1
4
263
S Styles retweeted
Insane amounts of spaffing up the wall by Labour! How is it possible to piss away £62 MILLION on reports for Labour’s plans to merge councils across England. Bloody hell consultants and lawyers are rolling in our cash! And now Ange has spent £14 million and then scrapped the proposals. HOW IS IT POSSIBLE?
70
713
25
1,406
11,528
A new Harvard study estimates that 403 of the largest data centers in the United States were responsible for 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in just one year. That's roughly as much as Denmark produces in a year. So while the rest of us are told to turn down our heaters, switch off our lights and avoid wood burners because of net zero, the big tech data centres get to guzzle vital energy supplies and emit vast amounts of CO2.
690
5,169
366
8,353
141,365
🚨Scott McTominay on his decision to leave the Scotland national team after their 4-0 defeat to Switzerland: 🗣️ “I’ve sat down to think about my international future and what I want it to be and I know people are going to say I’m abandoning my country. They can say that. But before anyone judges me, they should ask themselves why a player who gave everything for Scotland reached the point where he no longer wanted to be there. I didn’t wake up after that 4-0 defeat and suddenly decide I didn’t love Scotland anymore. That result was just the final thing that made me realise I couldn’t keep doing this to myself. I sat in that dressing room and looked around. Nobody was talking. Nobody knew what to say. And I remember thinking, ‘How many times are we going to sit here feeling exactly the same way?’ That hurt more than the defeat. Because losing a football match happens. But losing belief is different. I’ve played for Scotland when we’ve had nothing going for us. I’ve travelled, played through knocks, taken criticism, scored goals, celebrated with the fans and stood there after defeats when you don’t even know what to say. I never expected everything to be perfect. What I expected was hunger. I expected standards. I expected everyone wearing that shirt to feel the same responsibility I felt. And I’m not sure I saw that anymore. That’s the part people won’t want to hear. Sometimes when you play for your country, you become too comfortable with losing. You start talking about ‘learning from it’ before you’ve even left the pitch. You say the right things to the media. You apologise to the supporters. You promise to improve. Then the same mistakes happen again. And again. And again. I’m tired of apologies that don’t change anything. I’m tired of pretending that getting close is enough. Scotland don’t need another speech about how proud everyone is to represent the country. We need players who are devastated when they lose. We need players who hate conceding. We need players who look at a 4-0 defeat and don’t sleep properly because they know they weren’t good enough. That’s how I feel. Maybe that’s why this decision has been so difficult. Because I still love Scotland. That’s the truth. I’m not leaving because I don’t care. I’m leaving because I care too much to keep pretending everything is acceptable. People can call me selfish. They can say I should stay and fight. But I’ve been fighting. I’ve been fighting for years. And eventually you have to be honest with yourself. I don’t want to sit in another dressing room after another defeat telling myself, ‘We’ll be better next time,’ when deep down I don’t believe it anymore. The shirt deserves more than that. The supporters deserve more than that. And I deserve to walk away while I can still look back at my Scotland career and know I gave everything I had. So yes, I’m stepping away. Not because Scotland means less to me. Because it means too much. And if that 4-0 defeat taught me anything, it’s that loving your country doesn’t mean you have to keep accepting the same disappointment forever.”
113
56
17
652
286,988
S Styles retweeted
Milburn’s plan has more holes than a cheese grater. 1. Employers get 6 months of taxpayer funded wages to employ young people. ❌Brilliant, they will just replace workers every 6 months to keep the subsidy 2. Employers can also get £3,000 for hiring eligible unemployed young people. ❌ They only have to hire them. They don’t have to keep them 3. The plan wants to get 440,000 more young people into work over 10 years. ❌ AI and robotics are already replacing jobs. employment market will be vastly different in 2036. He makes no mention of this. 4. Businesses are already struggling with rising employment costs, falling vacancies and shrinking consumer spending. ❌ they can’t create hundreds of thousands of extra jobs because the government tells them to when many can’t afford the employees they already have. 5. Milburn wants to double youth apprenticeship participation. ❌ Who exactly is going to provide all these apprenticeships when businesses are cutting recruitment? 6. The proposals could cost up to £6 BILLION annually by 2036, with projected annual net savings of just £200 million in 2036–37. ❌ government forecasts don’t take Ai or the shrinking market into account. Forcing taxpayers to fund £120 BILLION overall will not solve youth unemployment. Businesses don’t create jobs because politicians announce employment targets. They can’t fix youth unemployment without fixing the economy that creates employment in the first place. Utterly back to front.
77
315
15
850
17,286
S Styles retweeted
This seems an extremely significant intervention which should concentrate minds on the government benches.
Baroness Hilary Cass tells committee considering draft Conversion practices Bill that she cannot support it as stands. She saw the Bill 15 mins before Gov wanted press statement signed off. "Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately I don't think it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences."
15
83
2
595
22,968
S Styles retweeted
The gov't will not be coming to the rescue of our universities Destruction will continue We must blame & shame the ministers from 2015 to 2026 who did the damage Foremost is @Jacqui_Smith1 She had the opportunity & responsibility to act. She did not committees.parliament.uk/wor…
2
18
1
33
964
Excellent thread
Among Hilary Cass’s bombshells in today’s #ConversionBill committee was this key point: that transgender identity & sexual orientation are different. Lumping them together as if they’re the same kind of thing is one of the aspects of the Bill that makes it a conceptual mess./1>
4
28
107
3,395
S Styles retweeted
Letter to the Times Sir, I run an employment agency in East Anglia and have read and watched with interest the coverage of Alan Milburn's report into the Neets crisis. Twenty-five years ago we employed many British young people, aged 16 to 24, and for many of them it was their first experience and introduction to work. Today we employ just a handful. The reasons for this decline are fairly simple. There has been a sharp increase in employment costs: the minimum wage has increased from £3.60 an hour in 1999 to £12.71 an hour today, an increase of 253 per cent. Rachel Reeves further added to companies' costs when she increased employers' national insurance contributions last year. Moreover, increasing health and safety regulations have made it prohibitive to employ 16 and 17-year-olds during school holidays, in an industrial/warehouse workplace. Tens of thousands of young people leave university with degrees that are of little practical use to local employers, while tens of thousands of local skilled manual jobs remain unfilled. Increasing employment rights legislation and the consequent threat of an employment tribunal have made employers wary of employing young people with no work record behind them. It is politicians who have largely created this situation; why the current set of politicians have felt it necessary to have a large costly inquest, when most of the reasons (and thereby the solutions) are in plain sight, is a mystery to me. Lionel Sheffield Rapid Recruitment, Wisbech, Cambs
128
1,228
66
4,636
115,662
Louise Haigh has been “on a journey”
Louise Haigh: -2015: Said “investment in nuclear is immoral in and of itself.” -Cited as a supporter of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament which is run by communists who argued for unilateral Western disarmament in the Cold War. -Said: “There are issues on the table that have not been debated in the Labour Party since before I was born, Trident, membership of NATO and a real alternative to austerity. It’s a very, very exciting time and I couldn’t be more thrilled to be a part of it.” -2016: Said that she agrees with Jeremy Corbyn on “on welfare cuts, Syria, refugees, Trident and workers’ rights.” -Opposed Trident in Commons: “Does my honourable friend not share my concern that this latest round of renewal makes it difficult to ignore the fact that we are moving against our international duty into an era of permanent armament?”  -2019: Haigh signed the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament’s ‘Parliamentary Pledge’ which committed them “to working within parliament to promote the UN Treaty for the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons.” This UN Treaty, which the UK has not signed, would make all of Britain’s nuclear arsenal immediately illegal… -2023: Pledged to “work for the ratification of the TPNW” and vowed to “eliminate these inhumane and abhorrent weapons” because their abolition is “an essential step to promote the security and well-being of all peoples.”
33
From my experience reviewing consultation responses at the scottish law commission and as an adviser to a holyrood committee pro forma consultation responses to policy consultations are rarely helpful or taken into account. Individual responses tend to matter more.
4
5
1
18
1,665
Ahead of tomorrow's Milburn review, a summary of what has increased the cost of hiring a young person vs 2011/12.
59
248
42
893
143,860
'These are official Scottish government publications that are supposed to be guiding the current reform of the curriculum - and it is being guided by AI slop' Scotland's leading academic expert on education policy has called for the SNP government’s landmark reform of the school curriculum to be scrapped and restarted. The demand came after it emerged that not only was AI used to shape the planned upgrading of the curriculum, but artificial intelligence also inserted mistakes and ‘hallucinations’ into official documents. Lindsay Paterson, professor emeritus of education policy at Edinburgh University and one of the nation’s foremost authorities on the curriculum, described the discovery as a 'scandal' 👇 𝘐𝘔𝘈𝘎𝘌: 𝘑𝘢𝘯𝘦 𝘉𝘢𝘳𝘭𝘰𝘸/𝘗𝘈 𝘞𝘪𝘳𝘦/𝘗𝘈 𝘐𝘮𝘢𝘨𝘦𝘴
33
83
10
193
11,342
S Styles retweeted
Right. A bit like Soviet Russia… Labour’s new housing laws mean, if a landlord evicts tenants to sell their own property and can’t find a buyer, they are banned from renting it out again for 12 months. BUT … if the property is empty for 6 months, the council can take control of it and rent it out themselves for up to SEVEN YEARS. Yes, really! Welcome to Soviet UK.
199
1,464
80
3,694
65,293
S Styles retweeted
As a public intellectual- the preference for simple, extreme & novel points of view in the media & preference for celebrity presentation of series combined with loss of serious programming, is the major problem. @BBCInOurTime & podcasts have few problems finding good historians.
What explains the 'disappearance of the academic as a public intellectual'? Productivity demands in a precarious job market is one reason, says new study, but also 'culture of fear that prevents academics from speaking out' timeshighereducation.com/new…
2
6
24
1,114
One minute it’s all apps and Apple Pay, the next minute it’s “have some notes ready for when everything goes tits up.” And fifty quid? That’s about half a basket on a supermarket shop. So reassuring.
92
287
10
830
15,869
By all means, mock, doubt and scorn a prisoner's protestation of their innocence after verdict. But nothing good can come from the suggestion that anyone convicted of a criminal offence shouldn't be allowed to assert, in public, that they've been wrongfully convicted.
84
57
16
742
20,959
Malawi suffered from the brutality of Arab slavery, with its people captured by rival tribes and shipped to the Middle East, part of a 1,200-year-long traffic in human commodities that is often overshadowed by Europe’s transatlantic trade. The country wants to tell the world about this forgotten slave trade – and how Britain ran a determined campaign to end it ⤵️ telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11…
39
497
89
1,751
78,741
I have absolutely no idea why my timeline is completely ignoring the suspension of Labour MP Perran Moon today. He was just caught trying to dissolve his private company without paying back a £50,000 taxpayer-funded Covid loan. Right as this government prepares to hammer ordinary families with tax hikes in the Budget. Here is what they desperately hope stays quiet!🧵
176
3,661
184
6,422
101,495
SEX SCANDAL This is a story of paedophiles and ingénues and criminal activity that illustrates how today's scandals are nothing new and Scotland has had its share. Distinguished broadcaster Esther Rantzen had a brief affair with the ever inebriated Scottish barrister, politician and Tory MP Sir Nicholas Fairbairn in 1966 when she was 26 years old. She recounts the affair in her autobiography with the unoriginal title: 'Esther - The Autobiography'. The affair lasted ten years. Police spent five years investigating claims that several lawyers abused children in the 1970s and 1980s. Fairbairn was one of them. This is the information many consider to be the link that saw chairman of the SNP Willie McRae assassinated on a remote Highland road in 1985. A few days earlier he was heard to remark "I've got them!" [the Tory party] but when found in his car his briefcase was empty. The prominent Scottish lawyer and anti-nuclear campaigner was referring to sensitive, classified documents and evidence he believed he had compiled regarding UKGov's plans to dispose of nuclear waste from Dounreay in the Scottish sea (including an underwater burial site off Applecross). Of the 'Disappearance of Incriminating Papers' colleagues noted McRae was carrying when he left his office, none of the Dounreay-related documents were found in his car after he was discovered close to death by Loch Loyne in April 1985. Nevertheless, so people feel the missing documents relate to child abuse by various MPs. Among those accused of involvement in the paedo ring were Fairbairn QC and the late Robert Henderson QC. By sheer coincidence [sarcasm] Fairbairn was in charge of all the major child abuse investigations in Scotland. Looking into events for COPFS was Lord Advocate James Wolffe QC, a name readers will recall involved in holding back evidence of Alex Salmond during his trial that proved Salmond's innocence. In the child rape scandal, Wolffe was the legal eagle who decided whether anyone should be charged in connection with the allegations. Henderson’s daughter, Susie, (pictured) claimed she was raped repeatedly by her 'vile' father and others between the ages of four and 12. “The awful things I went through as a child, things no child should ever experience, affected every day of my life, and continue to haunt me,” she said. “To see even one man on trial and having to answer for what they did to me would mean that the last five very difficult years had not been for nothing.” Fairbairn was a favourite of Margaret Thatcher and has been linked to fellow paedophile MP Cyril Smith, a perilously fat Liberal politician who enjoyed spanking the bare bums of young boys. Later in life, Rantzen set up the children charity ‘Childline’ with the help of notorious paedophile Jimmy Savile and other paedophiles. She seems in retrospect, fantastically naive initially though latterly constructive helping vulnerable children. In 2014, historical documents emerged linking paedophile Fairbairn to London's Elm Guest House, and evidence from a 1982 police log showed he raped many male children there. He visited the Elm Guest House often, a gay brothel in Barnes, west London, where under-age boys from a nearby care home were allegedly plied with drink and drugs and sexually abused. He was often accompanied by serial child rapist Cyril Smith (pictured) along with other prominent high-level figures visited during the 1980’s. The other MP was Sir Peter Morrison, another Scots minister close to Lady Thatcher, who was also a prolific child abuser. The trio feature in documents apparently penned by the owner of the guesthouse, which state that ‘N Fairburn’ (sic) and ‘C Smith’ (who asked to be called Tubby by staff and boys), visited on June 7, 1982. The documents add that ‘Fairburn’ had ‘used boys in sauna’. Given the very public opposition to homosexuality that Fairbairn expressed in Parliament, allegations that he abused boys at a gay sauna have shocked his former colleagues. In 2014, fresh claims came to light and it was reported that the daughter of a high level QC said she was sexually assaulted by her father and the Fairbairn when she was 4 years old in the 1970s. The aggrieved daughter is quoted saying of Fairbairn, “I hated that man, more than I hated my father. He just really wasn’t a nice man. I want it acknowledged that my father and Fairbairn did something very evil. Not just to me. There are other children out there [who suffered].” The compulsions probably account for Fairbairn's heavy drinking, a sign of self-loathing, but what can be attested is, he was an arrogant, loathsome, far-right snob. And a House Jock. Despite his reputation as a womaniser and fondness for malt whisky, a daily habit that brought about his premature death aged just 61, the funeral of Fairbairn in 1995 was marked by an outpouring of respect and admiration. As more than 1,000 luminaries crammed into St John’s Kirk in Perth, the Tory MP’s significance as a political figure was underlined by the presence of the loopy Lady Thatcher, who had promoted the solicitor to her first Cabinet in 1979. A self-styled eccentric, Fairbairn lived in the 13th-century Fordell Castle near Dunfermline, Fairbairn (pictured) was considered a political talent. He had been Scotland’s youngest QC before being elected MP for Perth and Kinross in 1974, at the age of 40. In Westminster, where his initial rise was swift, he cut a dandyish figure, often seen in blue baronial tartan adorned with two miniature (working) silver revolvers, which he loaded with blanks and fired when drunk, often. When speaking in the Commons, he sometimes wore an enormous Highland smock (‘I know I look like an ironmonger, but I don’t want my suits to glitter like other MPs’), or a kilt teamed with double-breasted scarlet jacket, gold watch chain and lurid pink shirt. In addition to being a drunk and an inveterate womaniser, the famous Tory also stood accused of being a predatory paedophile - one of two abusers now identified in Thatcher’s inner circle. Waiving her anonymity, Susie Henderson claimed that Fairbairn had sexually assaulted and raped her on several occasions, beginning when she was four years old. Fairbairn was a close friend of Susie’s late father, Robert Henderson, a fellow leading light of the Scottish legal establishment, who regularly held decadent private parties at his family’s large and smartly decorated townhouse in Edinburgh. It was during one of these sordid events in about 1970 that Susie says her father came into the kitchen with Fairbairn. ‘I was maybe four years old,’ she told the Mail. ‘I had a skirt on and Nicholas and my dad had been drinking, and my dad told me to sit on Nicholas’s knee. I sat on his knee and he put his hand up my skirt and abused me. My dad just stood there laughing.’ During another party, Susie says she was raped by Fairbairn and another man in a guest room at the top of her parents’ five-storey home. Take an extended look at his life, however, and some astonishing secrets emerge. For in his younger days, this obsessive womaniser turns out to have been something rather different: a highly promiscuous gay liberation activist with murky links to the now-notorious Paedophile Information Exchange (PIE). And indeed, those who knew him before he entered politics say that Fairbairn grew up aggressively bisexual, but suppressed his true desires in order to advance in the Tory Party of the mid-Seventies. They believe this left him hopelessly conflicted, leading to his chronic drinking and the predatory and often hugely offensive nature of his advances to women. The story begins in a deeply dysfunctional childhood. Fairbairn was born in 1933. His father was a prominent psychoanalyst, his mother an aristocrat. ‘By the time I was born,’ he recalled, ‘they were totally estranged.’ Fairbairn was in fact married from 1962-79, to Elizabeth Mackay, the daughter of the 13th Baron Reay, mother of his three surviving daughters. But in the circles in which he moved, this was not uncommon. It was a time of free love. Homosexuality was still illegal in Scotland until 1980, gay and bisexual men were supposedly happily married. In 1970, Sir Nicholas became honorary vice- president of the Scottish Minorities Group (SMG), a new, radical gay liberation organisation founded by a man called Ian Dunn. The SMG campaigned for homosexuality to be legalised in Scotland, and for the age of consent identical for gay and straight sex. But it also had a more contentious place in history. For in 1974, Dunn and another SMG activist, Michael Hanson, co-founded the Paedophile Information Exchange (PIE). The self-serving organisation, which lobbied for child sex to be legalised, was for the first year of its existence a sub-committee of the SMG. Fairbairn had dozens of female lovers. One, a Commons secretary, attempted suicide outside his London home in 1981. Another, as already stated, the broadcaster Esther Rantzen, says he plied her with Krug and beluga caviar. ‘The rest was inevitable,’ she wrote in her memoirs. Ian Pace, a lecturer at City University in London, and a campaigner and researcher on organised abuse, believes Fairbairn’s behaviour during this era was part of a concerted effort to ‘cover the tracks’ of his bisexual past. A few years before his death, Fairbairn called for Leveson-style curbs on Press freedom amid newspaper claims (dismissed by an inquiry) that a so-called ‘magic circle’ of Scots judges, sheriffs and advocates in his former professional set were conspiring to ensure that homosexual criminals were given soft-touch treatment by the courts. After he was buried at Fordell Castle, obituaries talked of him as one of Westminster's great womanisers. He died unrepentant. "I have had a hell of good time on Earth,’ he told Martin Robb, a fellow Tory. ‘It has been Heaven.’
15
77
5
165
66,575