
Professor of Sport Management, Eastern Michigan University. @UMich, @UMichLaw, & @EasternMichU grad. Sport law.
Ypsilanti, MI
Joined June 2013
- Tweets3.1K
- Following1.4K
- Followers1.1K
- Likes4.4K
I feel like I’ve been in a hundred meetings at this point where an advocate proposes a private, multistate entity funded by participating universities to employ athletes and bargain with their representative as a way to overcome restrictions on collective bargaining at public universities.
As always, I’m happy to engage here or elsewhere, but I’m skeptical that this resolves the legal problems as readily as its advocates suggest.
Let’s start with the basics: the assertion that “schools would not be the employer” requires explanation. Creating another entity to sign contracts and issue paychecks does not resolve the significance of universities selecting athletes, employing coaches, supervising their work, imposing discipline, etc. What changes under this proposal?
There is modest precedent supporting the approach. In Teledyne Economic Development v. NLRB, 108 F.3d 56 (4th Cir. 1997), for instance, the court upheld a bargaining obligation for a private Job Corps contractor despite substantial government control. Retained university control therefore would not automatically defeat federal jurisdiction over a private employer.
But three questions must remain separate: federal employer status, state-law authority to make the necessary commitments, and enforceability.
Establishing that a private entity can bargain does not establish that a public university can lawfully make every commitment necessary to implement that bargain.
The NLRB cannot compel an exempt public university to bargain. Where a university retains exclusive authority over a working condition, proponents must explain how negotiations with the central employer would produce enforceable protections. Where authority is shared or transferred, they must identify the legal basis for that allocation.
Even the entity’s status requires scrutiny. Under Hawkins County, an entity may be an exempt political subdivision if created directly by the state as a governmental arm or administered by individuals responsible to public officials or the electorate. Its formation and governance—including who appoints and removes its leaders—matter.
State law presents additional complications. The University of Tennessee assigns control of athletics to its chancellors under trustee oversight. Texas prohibits specified collective bargaining contracts concerning public employees. Proponents must explain which powers universities would relinquish or contractually limit, what authorizes those commitments, and why the arrangement complies with each state’s restrictions.
Enforcement matters, too. If a university suspends an athlete or imposes practice requirements inconsistent with the agreement, who can enforce it, against whom, and through what remedy? Sovereign immunity does not necessarily foreclose enforcement--Tennessee permits certain authorized written-contract claims--but the model must explain whether athletes can obtain timely compliance or only compensation after the opportunity to participate has passed.
I could go on, but advocates keep assuring us that this works under existing law and that accomplished lawyers have vetted it. I'm a broken record, but show your work.
Identify who controls each significant term, who can commit to changing it, and who can be held to that commitment.
I’ve asked these questions repeatedly and have yet to see a legal analysis that answers them. That gap between the confidence of the claim and the explanation offered is why I remain skeptical.
1
475
#SMGT363 - TBD and see the hazing case in the last issue of the SLA.
EXCLUSIVE w/ @Dave_Boucher1: Sexualized abuse akin to "torture" became the norm in ritualistic hazing among members of the University of Michigan's men's hockey team from 1984 to 2001, according to a new federal lawsuit filed by 16 former team members.
freep.com/story/sports/unive…
653
A's denied 'Athletics' trademarks ahead of move to Las Vegas - ESPN espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/4753…
Another one #SMGT363….
Ohio has fired its football coach Brian Smith for cause.
The school says Smith engaged in "serious professional misconduct" that violated his contract.
264
For cause #SMGT363…
Michigan has fired Sherrone Moore for cause, according to @DanWetzel and @AdamSchefter.
elevenwarriors.com/the-big-t…
3
329
Indiana's Moore wins suit vs. NCAA, can play rest of season - ESPN espn.com/college-football/st…
1
285
Erica Zonder, J.D. retweeted
Georgia announces its rev-share breakdown, which mirrors the House settlement back pay distribution model: 75% to football ($13.5M), 15% to men's basketball ($2.7M), 5% to women's basketball ($900K) & 5% to others. The school will add 100 new scholarships and cut 75 roster spots.
Inside Georgia athletics' plan for $20.5 million revenue sharing with players
onlineathens.com/story/sport…
Erica Zonder, J.D. retweeted
Thanks Cincinnati and Applied Sport Management Association for another great conference. Our students rocked their research and case cup presentations and of course @EricaZonder stole the show in our presentation.
Erica Zonder, J.D. retweeted
I've reached out to a spokesperson at the Department of Education to clarify whether this means the Title IX memo regarding NIL has been officially rescinded.
Will report when I hear back
In other news, it seems the ED no longer has its memo regarding Title IX impacts on NIL on its website. ed.gov/media/document/ocr-fa…
NWSL settles abuse case, creates $5m player fund - ESPN espn.com/soccer/story/_/id/4…
197
Trump to sign executive order banning transgender athletes from women’s sports, directing DOJ to enforce - ABC News abcnews.go.com/Politics/trum…
210
US colleges returning to campus sexual assault rules created during Trump's first term | AP News apnews.com/article/title-ix-…
Terrible tragedy. Preventable #SMGT363?!? Errant hammer throw at youth track meet kills spectator - ESPN espn.com/olympics/story/_/id…
282
Erica Zonder, J.D. retweeted
Division II Sonoma State is cutting its entire athletic program, among other university cuts. buff.ly/42ouYZF
Dartmouth Men’s Basketball Players Withdraw Petition to Unionize frontofficesports.com/dartmo…
133
Well #SMGT363? Does this meet the threshold we discussed?!?
267
Federal report on Baylor finds delays in Title IX cases - ESPN espn.com/college-football/st…
138
Erica Zonder, J.D. retweeted
Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia is suing the NCAA, arguing that the association’s rules limit his NIL earning potential because he went to junior college.
More details on the case ⬇️
Florida basketball coach Todd Golden facing Title IX stalking probe - ESPN espn.com/mens-college-basket…



















