Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34) header
Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34) profile picture

Father, Educator, Auburn Alumnus, Never forget that history is a weapon, wield it carefully. Likes and retweets do no represent agreement. My views are my own.

Austin, TX
Joined January 2015
Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)Photo by Frank Shoemaker (@Frankshoe34)
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Teacher-led, explicit instruction of content-rich, cohesive curriculum is the most effective model for educating students. A true education also involves the formation of the whole person. This is why I am such a strong a proponent of classical education. While the modern education establishment bounces around from one fad to another (often doing everything except what works) classical schools persist in the tried and true method of education. The old saying “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” comes to mind.
12
9
1
139
7,355
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Lauren S. Brown, a history teacher, writes that classes with knowledgeable students spark deeper discussions — one sharp question leads to more questions and real engagement. Classes lacking that background knowledge struggle: more time explaining basics, less engagement, more off-task behavior. Her point: teaching solid content knowledge (history, science) in early grades pays off later, since kids need existing knowledge to build new learning on. laurenbrownoned.substack.com…
4
15
1
46
1,935
🚨NEW STUDY🚨 Debunking the widespread use of accommodations “There was no evidence that any of the academic accommodations significantly improved behavior or academic outcomes”
10
87
4
444
21,469
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Critical thinking doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Knowledge provides the framework students need to evaluate information, recognize misinformation, and distinguish fact from fiction. Without it, almost anything can seem believable. Knowledge matters. solinthewild.substack.com/p/…
1
8
4
28
2,146
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
In which I come out swinging against Canvas. Canvas is why students prefer AI to their professors, and I don't blame them one bit. hollisrobbinsanecdotal.subst…
16
20
15
128
20,663
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Gilbert Strang transformed how generations of students learn linear algebra. His MIT 18.06 lectures (Spring 2005) are freely available, covering vector spaces, eigenvalues, least squares, matrix factorizations and singular value decomposition. His central teaching insight: understand the geometry behind matrix operations. A complete university-level mathematics course, accessible to anyone.
8
59
4
362
14,253
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
In 1982, the U.S. Air Force shared a reading-improvement guide to help senior military members handle heavy reading loads. I read all 63 pages so you don't have to. Here are the 10 most interesting quotes from it: 1) "Reading is more than picking up word after word. Reading is picking up ideas, sorting them, weighing them, and then throwing away the useless and saving the good." 2) "Reading habits matter more than most people realize—lighting, posture, distractions, and especially interest. There is no spur to concentration like honest interest." 3) "Are you careful about having good lighting when you read? Do you read with the radio or television on? Do you pay any attention to having a comfortable position when you read?" 4) “Different materials have to be read at different speeds. As Francis Bacon wrote over 300 years ago, ‘Some books are to be tasted, others to be swallowed, and some few to be chewed and digested'…You have to vary your reading speed according to the kind of material you’re reading and what you want to get out of it.” 5) "You don't drive at the same speed in traffic or over a bumpy road as you do on an interstate highway. In the same way, you have to vary your reading speed according to the kind of material you're reading and what you want to get out of it." 6) "One of the basic reasons for reading loss is the lack of an incentive–that is, lack of purpose or direction. A man wandering about in a snowstorm or otherwise without sense of direction will travel in circles. That holds true also for a man who reads aimlessly." 7) "When you read, read for a purpose. Tie your reading to your work, your hobby, or your personal life. If there is no real connection there and you still feel you ought to read the material, set it up as a challenge–a mental contest between yourself and the author." 8) "You have to push yourself hard in your regular reading, find out where you are weak, and concentrate on strengthening those points. This will require concentration and perseverance. It will also take time. But if you follow through conscientiously, your efforts will pay off." 9) "By reading, we gather all the accumulated knowledge of all the generations all over the world." 10) “There is no magic formula. You have to find out what the essentials of good reading are and in which of those essentials you are weak. Then, by special exercises and by particular attention to those essentials in your daily reading, you can gradually increase your speed and understanding. It takes work and more work, but if you stick with it, the results will amaze you.” And my favorite line from the guide: “Good reading is not like good looks—it doesn’t come naturally. You have to work at it.”
27
164
14
971
37,476
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Most people do not realize just how easy the AP exams have gotten. They are not college level. Why/how have they become so easy? What's going on? This might shock you... A brutal new piece in Education Next just dropped, saying the decline in rigor of the AP in the last two decades is, in large part, because the content has been GUTTED. For example: — AP Biology cut 40% of its material — Required lines from the Aeneid in AP Latin halved — Spanish Lit reading list cut from 56 works to 38 Then the questions themselves have become absurdly easier. Readability measures show English passages have fallen multiple grade levels, and some now include footnotes defining basic words... A 2025 AP English prompt included footnote definitions for words like "optimism" and "pessimism." At the same time, scoring was recalibrated so that more students pass: guessing penalties disappeared, rubrics grew more generous, readers were told to give students the benefit of the doubt, etc. — "no one at College Board had any incentive to maintain rigor." College professors are now seeing students arrive with AP credit who lack basic content knowledge and writing ability. The College Board insists the exams have not become easier, but everybody familiar with them knows they've become an absolute joke. Advanced Placement is no longer advanced. This is not college level. It must be replaced.
216
671
205
5,761
1,798,471
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Yes: handwriting still matters. A new study has confirmed that writing by hand activates far more complex and widespread neural networks in the brain than typing, underscoring its importance for learning and memory. Researchers at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology used a high-density EEG cap with 256 electrodes to record brain activity in university students. They found that the intricate, sensory-rich movements involved in handwriting, especially cursive, trigger highly synchronized brain waves across extensive areas of the parietal and central regions. These coordinated patterns are strongly linked to memory formation, cognitive processing, and encoding new information. In contrast, typing, which involves repetitive, simpler finger movements, produced significantly less neural connectivity and engagement. The difference was striking: the brain appears much less active during digital writing. The researchers conclude that the unique motor and sensory experience of holding a pen plays a key role in brain development and learning. As a result, they argue that handwriting instruction should remain a core part of education to support deeper comprehension and cognitive growth in the next generation. [ “Handwriting vs. Typing: A High-Density EEG Study on Brain Connectivity During Learning” — Norwegian University of Science and Technology (published in Frontiers in Psychology, 2025)]
69
369
32
1,140
58,946
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
“Critical thinking” without knowledge is just confidently not knowing what you’re talking about.
10
29
7
116
3,789
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
NEW POST: The Untold Story of Bloom's Taxonomy and the Pyramid That Never Was. - link in reply ⤵️
🤖 Made with AI
17
88
29
268
57,532
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
❓ What do the highest-performing education systems have in common? Excellent teachers, a knowledge-rich curriculum, demanding evaluations, and high expectations for students make all the difference!
7
19
2
106
3,791
Parents are waking up to the problem of grade inflation. This would be a great time for schools to take it more seriously.
9
10
1
49
2,713
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Research has found that sitting close to a high performer improved performance by 15%. Sitting close to a low performer decreased performance by 30%. Surround yourself with people who lift you up. thegrowtheq.com/good-vibes-a…
6
17
1
179
22,936
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
🤔 Some students have worse memories so we shouldn’t emphasize math fact memorization? ❌ I think that logic is wrong. It’s even more important for those students to memorize math facts so they can easily retrieve them from long term memory. And they CAN do it! If not, every math task that uses math facts places more demands on working memory, making later math even more difficult. The below argument against memorization came up in CBC’s audio documentary on math education.
13
12
3
112
3,734
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
🎥 The latest short video explainer. This time, looking at how to design instruction around the limits of working memory — with 5 evidence-backed strategies to reduce cognitive load and protect the mental space students need to think. Got 3 minutes? 👉 youtu.be/D9bsjqNqf-g
2
37
2
104
15,446
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Dan's argument is sharper than "use AI carefully." His real claim: students should only use AI for things they already know how to do *well*. Not brainstorm-with-AI-but-draft-yourself, which is basically what every district policy says. He argues that's the wrong line entirely. His point is that those policies borrow a workplace model — AI as associate, student as lead, product is the thing. But for students, the product isn't the point. The essay itself has no value; it exists so the student practices building an argument, integrating sources, thinking like a reader. Skip that mental work and the assignment is hollow, even if the output looks great. So his real test isn't "how much AI is too much" — it's "would doing this yourself teach you something." If yes, no AI. If you've already mastered it and repeating it teaches nothing, AI's fine — like a calculator once you know arithmetic. I like this argument a lot. And I noticed he never once says "offloading." That word already carries a verdict — like something was shirked. Dan just asks whether a step was a *learning* step or a merely *supportive* one. That's why it matters to me. Most discourse treats any AI use as offloading — a small moral failure — instead of asking Dan's actual question, which is whether that specific step is where the learning happens. His framing lets the answer be boring and mixed: fine here, real cost there. dtwuva.substack.com/p/studen…
11
78
7
370
22,649
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
Learning needs friction. The brain is fundamentally resistant to cognitive friction (bone-lazy) and will always take the path of least resistance unless certain constraints are put in place. This is why discovery learning is so ineffective and why careful instructional design is so crucial. Also a nice illustration here why chatbots should be banned in the classroom. arxiv.org/abs/2603.10025
10
108
11
373
21,593
A genius response to the most common argument for AI in schools.
New Substack: : Students should only use AI for things that they already know how to do well. dtwuva.substack.com/p/studen…
1
21
1
88
4,684
Frank Shoemaker retweeted
UC Berkeley Professor Zvezdelina Stankova reveals the semester she first watched a third of her calculus class collapse, having to lower grade cutoffs and redesign her syllabus on the fly "In spring 2023, I'm teaching calculus two, second semester calculus at Berkeley." "I had something between 12 and 1400 students in two classes." "And for the first time, I noticed that about a third of them were disengaged with the class after week two." "They would not come to lecture. There would be a missed quiz here, not submitted homework there. The first midterm was a disaster. I never seen anything like this before." "And don't get me wrong, we have still fantastic students at the higher end. But the lower end was so far behind, so many standard deviations behind their classmates." "So I on the fly had to redesign the syllabus to make it easier, more accessible. I introduced bonus points. I introduced polls in class just for participation. Come and answer these multiple questions on your phone and we will give you some credit." "And even then, this bottom third did not come to class. I had to revise my grade cutoffs, I lowered them down in order to help students pass the class. And belatedly now, in retrospect, I find that this was a wrong decision."
"I teach mathematics at UC Berkeley. Three days a week, I stand in front of lecture halls with 500 to 1,400 students. By the second week of the semester, I already know who is in trouble. Some students are five to eight years behind in mathematics. Office hours that should be spent discussing integrals instead become lessons on fractions and basic algebra you would expect students to learn in middle school." sfstandard.com/opinion/2026/…
85
203
112
2,466
1,396,770