Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
The Forged & Tested Catalyst
A built to the nines minimalist trainer
This shoe is extremely well thought out & as soon as their on foot, you can tell
3mm drop
Wide toe box
Grippy yet flexible sole
The perfect amount of lateral support
The only downfall Iāve noticed so far is my heel feels a bit numb(?) the longer I wear them. Somewhat of an odd feeling I havenāt noticed in a shoe before. Not sure if itās due to the small amount of drop, or in the heel cup structure itself. I only notice it after about 1.5 hours of wear.
The shoes do feel freakin great straight out of the box, but Iām curious if the weird heel sensation will decrease as I break them in.
Loving these for the gym & they look good enough to wear casually.
This is F&Tās first batch ever & it makes this shoe that much more impressive
Iāll keep yall updated as I continue to use!
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Google's AI Overviews = theft šØ
And Google just got smacked with a lawsuit by Chegg -- and it's utterly fantastic āļø
I'm a former commercial litigator turned online travel publisher -- here are my notes from reading the complaint (link in next tweet) š
(warning, this summary is long & took me all morning to put together -- if you're a publisher please take 10 minutes to actually read it & share it with others)
1) Chegg is represented by the Susman Godfrey firm -- which means they are not messing around. Susman has quite the reputation as savvy, hard-charging litigators
2) Importantly, the compliant is grounded in antitrust law (NOT copyright, as I initially expected). And, goodness, it's a real banger ....
3) The complaint says the "exchange of access for traffic is the fundamental bargain that has long supported the production of content for the open commercial Web." šÆ
4) It continues: "But in recent years, Google has begun to tie its participation in this bargain to another transaction to which Chegg and other publishers do not willingly consent. As a condition of indexing publisher content for search, Google now requires publishers to also supply that content for other uses that cannibalize or preempt search referrals."
5) Chegg talks not just about AI Overviews, but also references featured snippets
6) š«¶this part -- "Googleās foray into digital publishing is designed to make Google a destination, rather than a search origination point to other websites."
7) Even if Google provided a separate opt-out for AI Overviews, it wouldn't work - because Google's monopoly power creates a collective action problem
8) A lot of fantastic points about how Google unfairly leverages its monopoly power to bend the open web to Google's will
9) Paragraph 13 is chef's kiss š«°... "Googleās conduct is already eroding incentives for Chegg and other publishers to produce such valuable and useful content. If not abated, this trajectory threatens to leave the public with an increasingly unrecognizable Internet experience, in which users never leave Googleās walled garden and receive only synthetic, error-ridden answers in response to their queriesāa
once robust but now hollowed-out information ecosystem of little use and unworthy of trust."
10) Search engines are supposed to be intermediaries between users and web publishers. The complaint quotes old-school Google saying "We may be the only people in the world who can say our goal is to have people leave our website as quickly as possible."
11) Search is a uniquely important channel for publishers. Other channels of traffic like social media can never replace search, because that traffic is not intentional
12) "Put simply, Googleās search monopoly gives it control over online distribution for digital publishers. Google uses that power to force digital publishers to give up their content. Google then itself acts as a publisher, either by republishing portions of other digital publishersā content or by using GAI to summarize the content. The end result is that users increasingly consume other web publishersā content on Googleās SERP, either in abridged or derivative form, which starves those publishers of traffic and revenue."
13) Chegg calls Google's strategy for publishers "embrace, absorb, extinguish"
14) Next is an entire fantastic section recounting the history of "Googleās Transformation from a Search Engine to Web Publisher"
15) Google appropriated publisher's content in 2 phases. Phase I it calls the 'republishing phase.' The complaint talks about featured like featured snippets & People Also Ask
16) Hilariously, paragraph 63 includes a screenshot of Sundar Pichai's mug inside a SERP for "who is google's ceo"
16) "Google refers to Featured Snippets, Top Stories, and People Also Ask as āsearch features.ā But they are separate and distinct products from search results. This is Google acting as an answer engineānot a search engine."
17) Republishing is not automatically bad, but the problem is that Google forces it on publishers as a condition for appearing in Search (of which it has a monopoly)
18) "The decision to opt out of republishing by disallowing snippets or withholding Search Index Data is a Hobsonās choice. "
19) Phase II of Google's strategy to dominate online publishing centers around AI Overviews ("GAI")
20) Complaint notes that the non-monopolists like OpenAI and Perplexity have been forced to do licensing deals with many publishers, whereas Google has largely avoided this cost thanks to its search monopoly
21) Complaint walks through the differences between LLM pre-training and RAG (a point I've been trying to educate publishers on for months and months)
22) Next is a recap of Google's LLM product history: Bard, SGE, Gemini & AI Overviews
23) @rustybrick commentary is cited quite a bit (see footnotes on pages 40, 41)
24) The transition to AI Overviews "all but completes Googleās evolution from a āsearch engineā to an āanswer engineā that publishes answers to userās queries. Its formerly symbiotic and complementary relationship with publishers has now become overwhelmingly parasitic and competitive."
25) Google's own marketing language directly admits that the purpose of featured snippets & AI Overviews is to prevent users from clicking throughs to publishers
26) Next section talks about how Google's unauthorized use of publisher content for AI training
27) "Google has been intentionally vague in identifying the precise data sets used to train the LLMs underlying Gemini and AI Overviews"
28) "Googleās Terms of Service indicate that it uses all the information that it collects for search indexing to train its LLMs, including Cheggās data. "
29) Google announced Google-Extended in Sept 2023, but blocking it doesn't change that Google trained on your content or that Google uses it for RAG
30) Next section: Google poses a "fundamental threat" to online publishing šš
31) Lots of discussion on how AI Overviews directly compete with and seek to replace online publishers
32) Oh WOW - in paragraph 121, Sussman dug up a pretty damning admission in a 2023 Google DeepMind presentation: Google admits Generative AI in search would "reduce referrals to content providers hurting their ability to monetize"
33) Lots of outside observers recognize the risk AI Overviews present to publishers. Footnotes cite @timsoulo among others
34) AI Overviews increase "zero click" searches
35) AI Overviews will cause a downward spiral in publishing quality - as the incentive to create gets less, quality degrades, and the whole web suffers
36) Google has put publishers in an awful position - by publishing content, they feed the very AI beast that is consuming publishers alive
27) Next, the complaint walks through the actual legal claims -- which, IMHO, are quite strong
28) First - "reciprocal dealing," an antitrust concept which "occurs when a firm with market power refuses to sell product X to a customer unless that customer agrees to sell (or give) product Y to it. In this case, the product Google is selling to (and threatening to withhold from) digital publishers is Search Referral Traffic."
29) Second - "monopoly maintenance." Basically argues that Google's use of AI constitutes a form of "rent extraction" on publishers.
30) Google is using AI to illegally entrench its search monopoly
31) Third - "Unjust enrichment" - which basically means Google has unfairly benefited at the expense of publishers via wrongful conduct.
32) "The value of Googleās models and AI products is directly related to the quality of the works that it acquires to train them and ground their outputs."
33) Finally - a recital of the counts:
I - Reciprocal Dealing in Violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act
II - Reciprocal Dealing in Violation of Section 2 of the Sherman Act
III - Tortious Conduct in Violation of Section 2 of the Sherman Act
IV - Unlawful Monopoly Leveraging in Violation of Section 2 of the Sherman Act
V - Unlawful Monopolization in Violation of Section 2 of the Sherman Act
VI - Unlawful Attempted Monopolization in Violation of Section 2 of the Sherman Act
VII - Common Law Unjust Enrichment
34) Lastly, Chegg's request for relief is of course damages and attorney fees, but also for a permanent injunction preventing Google from engaging in unlawful conduct
35) Chegg demands a jury trial
***link to complaint in next tweet***
My overall takeaway?
This is a truly fantastic complaint.
The only thing I think it missed is Google's admission in a blog post in summer 2023 that robots(.)txt is not a sufficient consent mechanism in the AI age. But, other than that, they really did their homework and hammered a ton of points I've been railing about for years.
If you are a publisher - please share so others see! ššš
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Google Search Ranks AI Spam Above Original Reporting in News Results wired.com/story/google-searc⦠from @wired with quotes from @lilyraynyc @5le and a link to @sengineland
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
This discussion with @reckless for @verge's Decoder podcast helped me clarify my thoughts about what Google Zero means both for the future of @ThisHouseFresh and for the future of the open web.
Feat. @Jake_Boly @mountainweekly @anibundel @RasmusBarslund
open.spotify.com/episode/6vnā¦
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Replying to @homemadehooplah
Exactly. Google is putting small creators in an impossible position. How can we justify spending so much time & energy creating original content when it will get copied moments later? If the trajectory continues and they continue to tip the scale in favor of the big brands who dominate the web, there will be no way to compete anymore. Less voices = less helpful + insightful content.
Google needs to roll back these site-wide classifiers and allow the little guy to compete on some level again. Rather than putting their finger on the scale, let the users decide whatās valuable content. Metrics like ātime on pageā, āsession durationā and ābounce rateā should be able to distinguish who the good sites are versus the spam ones.
As it stands right now, there isnāt a single instance of a niche site that has recovered from the recent HCU/Spam updates. Even when we do all the right things: establishing clear EEAT and providing specific and valuable info & a top-notch user experience in alignment with Googleās guidelines, itās impossible to move back into the top positions.
Let the usersārather than Googleās AI algorithmsādecide whatās helpful content.
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
People giving all sorts of theories as to how Jake can improve his content when it boils down to the fact that it likely got filtered as a niche affiliate site.
Unless you're a Forbes or ecom site, you just don't really get to rank as well any more. Even if your site is epic, like Jakes.
Absoloutely mad how many crap amazon affiliate sites have ranked in the SERPs for years and sold for $500k+ and now people like Jake are going above and beyond what has been considered to be good content, and still can't rank.
I'm waiting for someone who loves EEAT to say he can't rank because he isn't well known enough in the space. š
So, basically, unless you are Forbes or Arnie, don't bother writing reviews of fitness products.
Replying to @Jake_Boly
Trying to figure out exactly how to improve the site/content further has been a little frustrating because I don't know why the site got hit so hard in the first place.
Content gets comments, I have an active community, and I try to keep everything in-house for consistency.
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Iām impressed by Jake for having the courage to speak up. His site is legit & unfairly hit by Google
Many similar legit site owners have privately messaged me. I will of course hold in confidence anyone who wants to connect privately
But I hope more will decide to speak up!
Replying to @Jake_Boly
Trying to figure out exactly how to improve the site/content further has been a little frustrating because I don't know why the site got hit so hard in the first place.
Content gets comments, I have an active community, and I try to keep everything in-house for consistency.
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Jake has one of the best fitness sites on the web. He actually buys & uses the products he reviews.
This is what his traffic looks like since HCU.
He used to rank #1 for [best gym shoes]. Now, he's nowhere to be found. In his place?
Fitness authorities like GQ, Forbes, NY Mag, NBC News, Rolling Stone & ā of course ā Reddit (twice).
teapawt.org/Jake_Boly/status/17690ā¦
Replying to @searchliaison
@searchliaison and @dannysullivan shot in the dark here, but can you share any info as to why my site thatfitfriend.com/ has been ravaged by Google's updates? I run the site by myself, buy the gear I review, have a background in the field, and film YT videos for every review
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Your glutes are probably less active than they should be. Fix it and improve your squats: buff.ly/2RukYrp #weightlifting #powerlifting #bodybuilding by @jake_boly
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Create a shelf when you squat... wait what does that mean? How do you do it right? buff.ly/2QyQK7n by @jake_boly
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
NOBULL is giving away a pair of shoes and a canvas duffelback! That's a dufflebag that's also a backpack. Here's how to win: buff.ly/3400Wt7 @justthehorns
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
The ultimate deadlift warm up: get moving the right way! buff.ly/2rhzWbp by @jake_boly #powerlifting #crossfit #weightlifting #bodybuilding
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
New video: 4 ways to improve hip stability and your IT band function: buff.ly/2R9plJY with @jake_boly
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
New Video! Probably one of my favorite ones yet where my super strong and acrobatic friends @jake_boly and... fb.me/8AxhXl73T
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
Another insane feat of strength for @eddiehallWSM. What could he squat in a #powerlifting competition?!
barbend.com/eddie-hall-squatā¦
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
What does a heavy barbell have to do with life?
barbend.com/5-life-lessons-oā¦
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
A powerful look at losing ā and why it's not all so bad. #strongman #strongwoman
barbend.com/love-loss-losingā¦
Jake Boly | That Fit Friend retweeted
#Powerlifting fans, take note!
barbend.com/watch-2016-worldā¦














