Pranath Fernando retweeted
How can we reframe the discussion about AI to ensure everyone is comfortable weighing in? Because a technology built in the "image" of humans means we all have something meaningful to contribute. Thanks @LivingDataLab for the invitation to your show! youtu.be/G7V2Gesw2Fo?
Pranath Fernando retweeted
In AI, the ratio of attention on hypothetical, future, forms of harm to actual, current, realized forms of harm seems out of whack.
Many of the hypothetical forms of harm, like AI "taking over", are based on highly questionable hypotheses about what technology that does not currently exist might do.
Every field should examine both future and current problems. But is there any other engineering discipline where this much attention is on hypothetical problems rather than actual problems?
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Parrots are intelligent enough to understand touch screen interfaces and they prefer watching videos of other parrots.
[📹 insta.beakk]
Pranath Fernando retweeted
In case you don't recognise the name, Vijay was Stanford Professor of Chemistry *and* Structural Biology *and* Computer Science prior to joining A16Z.
Few other people in the world have such a relevant background for this particular question IMO.
1/ Some people have been suggesting that this work shows how AI is dangerous -- AI can design molecules that are toxic.
This is doomerism BS. Let me explain why ...
theverge.com/2022/3/17/22983…
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Whilst @geoffreyhinton is a *brilliant* scientist, scientists are *not* the people to teach us about risk management.
The project manager for the Nuclear Information Project has already warned us about these "muddled analogies", leading to a "calorie-free media panic".
Replying to @ylecun
Let's open source nuclear weapons too to make them safer. The good guys (us) will always have bigger ones than the bad guys (them) so it should all be OK.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Laws to ensure AI applications are safe, fair, and transparent are needed. But the White House's use of the Defense Production Act—typically reserved for war or national emergencies—distorts AI through the lens of security, for example with phrases like "companies developing any foundation model that poses a serious risk to national security."
Yes, AI -- like many technologies such as electricity and encryption -- is dual use in the sense it can be used for civilian or military purposes. But conflating AI safety for civilian use cases and military applications is a mistake.
It’s also a mistake to set reporting requirements based on a computation threshold for model training. This will stifle open source and innovation: (i) Today’s supercomputer is tomorrow’s pocket watch. So as AI progresses, more players -- including small companies without the compliance capabilities of big tech -- will run into this threshold. (ii) Over time, governments’ reporting requirements tend to become more burdensome. (Ask yourself: Has the tax code become more, or less, complicated over time?)
The right place to regulate AI is at the application layer. Requiring AI applications such as underwriting software, healthcare applications, self-driving, chat applications, etc. to meet stringent requirements, even pass audits, can ensure safety. But adding burdens to foundation model development unnecessarily slows down AI’s progress.
While the White House order isn’t currently stifling startups and open source, it seems to be a step in that direction. The devil will be in the details as its implementation gets fleshed out -- no doubt with assistance from lobbyists -- and I see a lot of risk of missteps. I welcome good regulation to promote responsible AI, and hope the White House can get there.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
The heretofore silent majority of AI scientists and engineers who
- do not believe in AI extinction scenarios or
- believe we have agency in making AI powerful, reliable, and safe and
- think the best way to do so is through open source AI platforms
NEED TO SPEAK UP !
Replying to @sriramk
yes - the deck is stacked
Decades of dystopian sci-fi and talk of extinction create the fear required to limit development
open-source advocates need clear, tangible examples of the tech's value and the importance of US leadership
who do you think is doing this best?
Pranath Fernando retweeted
If you work in AI and you are against open source you should be barred from using any open source tools. Good luck building your models then. No Pytorch for you. No Linux. No Kubernetes. No distributed training frameworks. Nothing.
I never thought we'd be fighting the open source battle twice in my lifetime but here we are.
Don't believe anyone, ever, who tells you that only them and the other "trusted" people can protect you. Kings and Queens and the old church have been running that scam since the Dark Ages.
It was bullshit then and it's bullshit now.
Nobody should be the overseer of AI for the rest of us.
This is written without any wild eyed fear mongering, and I like some of the historical perspectives, but he is clearly a statist. He previously worked in government, expresses concern for the government almost as often as concern for people, and wants to see powers expand in scope and across national borders.
There is an undercurrent of “we obviously can’t let the peasants have crossbows”.
I also don’t like the bundling of biotech risk and AI risk; it feels like a “big tent” play to raise more concern and grow more levers of power.
At the end, he suggests making high end open source AI work illegal, and imposing censorship on the dissemination of prohibited AI research. Cheers for openly saying what you want instead of leaving it all vague, but I am not aligned.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Meta starts open-sourcing a lot and is now becoming one of the best companies in the world at shipping AI features. Coincidence? I don’t think so.
Contrary to popular belief, a company (or a country) sharing their research, models and datasets publicly in open-source makes them MORE competitive, not LESS, even more so in AI. IMO, that’s how the US and some companies like OAI & Google established their leadership in the past few years (even though they are not so open anymore).
Some of the reasons why open-sourcing makes companies more competitive:
- Open science and open source attracts and motivates the best talents who want to to contribute to the field
- It focuses organization on the speed of building - not on taking advantage of the current tech - especially important on a fast moving domain like AI
- It motivates the whole field to improve what you’re building on (bug fixing, optimization, new capabilities) that you can then really easily integrate in your products).
Is your company sharing their research, models and datasets? If not, they’re missing out!
Source: wired.com/story/meta-ai-chat…
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Exactly.
It feels so weird to me that people talk about open source as reckless and a risk when it comes to AI model.
Open source has been responsible for the last 20 years of technological revolution. Builders sharing their free knowledge to the world to benefit us all.
But suddenly now the only safe option is to let only big corporations have AI?
Like… what?
Pranath Fernando retweeted
2023: The New York Times cites seriously academics who say AI might end the world
1881: The New York Times cites seriously academics who say telegraphy might end the world newsletter.pessimistsarchive…
Pranath Fernando retweeted
One distance metric does not fit all embedding models 📏
For example, the @cohere multilingual model uses dot product, whereas the English model uses cosine.
Read this blog post by @ecardenas300 where she covers the various distance metrics in Weaviate: weaviate.io/blog/distance-me…
Pranath Fernando retweeted
"I discovered, to my amazement, that all through history there had been resistance…vand bitter, exaggerated, last-stitch resistance…vto every significant technological change that had taken place on earth" - Isaac Asimov
People resist new technology, new ideas. As Dostoevsky opens Crime & Punishment with: "Taking a new step, uttering a new word, is what people fear most." I think fear points the way toward progress. Here's an ad from 1915 (via @PessimistsArc) suggesting a horse outperforms a car.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
If you can’t take being publicly dunked on then be sure to avoid taking any risks and stay away from all leadership roles. Don’t build or disrupt anything. Stay small and invisible and most of all, be silent and afraid of what others think.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
AI, RPG, FPS, gangsta rap, Scandinavian monster heavy metal, internet erotica: all causes of unwarranted moral panics.
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Filmmaking 2.0
TUTORIAL
Here's how I made a Barbie video using only Al.
Create your own in 7 easy steps!
Let's go! 🧵👇🏼
#AiArt #BarbieMovie #Oppenheimer #RunwayML
Pranath Fernando retweeted
"A Taxonomy of AI Panic Facilitators"
A visualization of leading AI Doomers (X-risk open letters, media interviews & OpEds).
Some AI experts enable them, while others oppose them.
The gender dynamics are fucked up.
It says a lot about the panic itself.
Your thoughts?
Pranath Fernando retweeted
Ditto.




























