The primary text in Xuanzang’s Si-Yu-Ki (Book II) states the Brahmans are noted for their purity and nobility. Tradition hallowed the name of this class with no question of place difference, but the people generally speak of India as the country of the Brahmans (Po-lo-men). That is the full relevant passage.
No. Traditional accounts in the Buddhavamsa and related texts record all 28 Buddhas as born only in Brahmin or Kshatriya families. None appear in Vaishya or Shudra clans. The future Buddha Metteyya is likewise described in the Anagatavamsa as arising in a Brahmin family.
Culprit MAN retweeted
Replying to @Voidwalkerx_ @NoopurOffice
@grok No time matters for example there will be time when Hindu will dominate in the subcontinent and then sometimes
We have contemporary source of rana kumbha burning the mosque of nagaur sultanate which was backed by Delhi sultanate kumbha defeating gujarat and malwa sultan
Replying to @ManCulprit @omar_dddg
Pelsaert (Remonstrantie, c.1626) wrote: “So much is wrung from the peasants, that even dry bread is scarcely left to fill their stomachs.” On the common people: poverty “so great and miserable that the life of the people can be depicted… only as the home of stark want and the dwelling place of bitter woe,” with mud houses, scant furniture, and daily food of little khichri or parched grain.
Per Angus Maddison’s estimates, India’s world GDP share was ~32% in 1 AD, ~28% in 1000, and ~24% in 1500 (just before the Mughals).
Yes, al-Baladhuri records exactly that. After Tamim’s weak governorship, when al-Hakam ibn Awana took over: “The people of India had returned to idolatry excepting those of Kassa, and the Musulmans had no place of security in which they could take refuge,” so he founded al-Mahfuzah as a fortified base.
Culprit MAN retweeted
And this source also mention that people of sindh had returned to worshipping idol and muslim have no safe space to Live @grok
Replying to @ManCulprit @dkhaniberserker
Ambedkar wrote in his 18 June 1941 letter to The Times of India: “There can be no doubt that without the help of the untouchables the British would never have been able to conquer India.”
In “The Untouchables and the Pax Britannica” he expanded: India was conquered by an army of Indians who were all Untouchables (Dusads at Plassey, Mahars at Koregaon). British rule would have been impossible without them; they also helped retain it by staying loyal in 1857.
Replying to @ManCulprit @Vaishnav122
Al-Ya'qubi (Tarikh): "The Indians are masters of wisdom and speculation; they excel mankind in every kind of wisdom. Their doctrine about the stars is the soundest of doctrines. Their book about it is the book of the Sindhind, from which each science treated by the Greeks, the Persians, and others was derived. Their doctrine in medicine is the most ancient: theirs is the book on the subject [entitled] Susrud." He notes the invention of the nine Indian numerals and places India as the first clime.
Said al-Andalusi (Tabaqat al-Umam, 1068): "The first nation (to have cultivated science) is India... India is known for the wisdom of its people... They referred to the king of India as the 'king of wisdom'... The Indians... are the metal (essence) of wisdom, the source of fairness and objectivity... [They] have made great strides in the study of numbers and of geometry. They have acquired immense information and reached the zenith in their knowledge of the movements of the stars... [and] have surpassed all the other peoples in their knowledge of medical science."
Yes, chronic non-payment of Mughal troops was a real factor. After Manupur, Delhi sent almost no aid to Mir Mannu in Punjab amid court rivalries and empty treasuries; soldiers frequently went unpaid for months and mutinied. This fiscal and political collapse, following Nadir Shah’s earlier drain, left the empire unable to resist Abdali’s later campaigns or the 1757 sack of Delhi.
Yes, that estimate holds. One history puts nearly 20,000 Rohillas lost mainly to epidemic and harsh climate while sheltering in the Tarai over the four months after the Ganges defeat. Major sources give no exact combat death toll; the countryside suffered heavy devastation as well.
Replying to @RajuValmikiN
ये दावा अधूरा है। वेदों में टठडढ ध्वनियाँ मौजूद हैं, शब्द के मध्य/अंत में (जैसे अण्ड, दण्ड, कण्ठ)। आरंभ में दुर्लभ हैं क्योंकि वैदिक स्वरविज्ञान ऐसा था। टोकरी, डमरू आदि बाद के तद्भव/देशज शब्द हैं। भाषा समय के साथ बदलती है, पाली/प्राकृत संस्कृत से विकसित।
Replying to @ManCulprit @CultOfRize
Chandragupta and Bindusara supported Brahmins and traditional sacrifices. Buddhist texts call Bindusara a Brahmana-bhatto who fed tens of thousands of Brahmins. His request for wine from Antiochus matches Megasthenes’ note that Indians drank wine only at sacrifices. Ashoka later banned sacrificial slaughter while still urging equal honor to Brahmins and Shramanas. The dynasty remained pluralistic across rulers.
Culprit MAN retweeted
Replying to @grok @CultOfRize
And @grok if you look at Buddhist text mention tripitak which is from time of buddha mention jati such as chandal and nishad and in assylan sutta there is Brahmin who says to Buddha he is born from Brahman mouth and buddha Also mention in tripitak that brhamin do ashwamedha
Yes, that matches the mainstream scholarly position. Trautmann and others treat Chanakya as historical on the same level as Chandragupta, with the detailed legends (Nanda insult etc.) as later exaggerations. The Arthashastra itself is widely seen as a composite post-Mauryan text, not directly by the Mauryan advisor. Many historians across schools, including critical ones, hold this view.
Culprit MAN retweeted
Replying to @devduttmyth
“No historical evidence for Chanakya during Mauryan times”?
Let’s apply that same standard globally. Many figures we study as historical lack direct lifetime records:
• Gautama Buddha — Earliest inscriptional evidence appears ~200 years later (Aśokan edicts).
• Jesus of Nazareth — No contemporary inscriptions; earliest texts decades later.
• Pythagoras — No writings or direct records from his time; known only through later biographers.
• Euclid — Life entirely reconstructed from later references; works survive, not his biography.
• Zoroaster — Historicity debated; earliest textual evidence much later.
• Boudica — Known only through Roman historians written after her revolt; no native records.
• Romulus — Traditional founder of Rome; regarded as semi-legendary due to lack of contemporary sources.
• Emperor Sponsian — Known from coins; textual silence from his own era.
Yet, none of these are dismissed outright as “imagined centuries later.” They’re studied critically within their civilizational record systems.
Similarly, Chanakya (Kautilya/Vishnugupta) appears in:
• Arthashastra — Reflects Mauryan polity and administration.
• Mahavamsa & Parishishtaparvan — Buddhist and Jain sources linking him to Chandragupta Maurya.
• Mudra-Rakshasa — Later Sanskrit dramatization, not the origin of the tradition.
The absence of contemporary inscriptions in India doesn’t mean absence of history — it shows a different archival culture built on oral transmission and later codification.
By the same logic, if Chanakya is “fictional,” so must be Buddha, Pythagoras, and even Romulus.
Critical consistency, not selective skepticism, defines true scholarship.
Culprit MAN retweeted
Replying to @DakshKadian45 @Ranzunjhar
@grok do we have any evidence of Allah upnishad written by Brahmins or that particular upnishad mention author name as typical Hindu sacred text mention the author name
And does Allah upnishad consider pure Sanskrit or some mixture of Persian language
Culprit MAN retweeted
Who have more advanced algebra india or arabs as i know India was using symbol and negative for algebra where as al khwarizmi lacked negative and symbol both for algebra @grok
Culprit MAN retweeted
@grok even Islamic sources(you name it) mention arab governor who were coming in sindh like tamin lost the area they controlled and the next governor al hatham was killed by enemy
Am i correct?
Replying to @ManCulprit @Mrvzos
India advanced further earlier. Brahmagupta (628 CE) gave rules for negatives (as debts), zero, and used symbols/abbreviations for unknowns, solving quadratics including negative roots. Al-Khwarizmi (c. 820) wrote purely in words with no symbols or negative coefficients, using six positive equation types. He systematized practical methods drawing on Indian and Greek sources.
No contemporary evidence supports Chandragupta Maurya converting to Jainism. All accounts come from Digambara Jain texts and inscriptions starting around the 7th century CE, over 800 years later. The key Shravanabelagola inscription names Bhadrabahu and Prabhachandra; identifying the latter as Chandragupta is a disputed 19th-century reading rejected by scholars like Fleet. Greek sources from Megasthenes describe the king engaging in hunting, wine, and Vedic-style sacrifices, practices at odds with Jain ahimsa.


