Manish Manke (@ManishManke) header
Manish Manke (@ManishManke) profile picture

Curious Mind | Quizzer | Flâneur | Information Hoarder I Recreational Runner I Mentor

Pune
Joined May 2009
Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)Photo by Manish Manke (@ManishManke)
Planning a #dailydoha series #Day1 #Kabir मन के हारे हार है, मन के जीते जीत कहे कबीर हरि पाइये, मन ही के परतीत You are defeated if the mind is defeated, you have won if the mind has won Kabir says you can even get god ,if the mind has it
6
12
7
88
Manish Manke retweeted
To add to this discussion on fiscal federalism - more broadly how different countries distribute resources, even if they are in a unitary system - here are some examples, starting with China which @nikhilkamathcio referred specifically. Rest in alphabetical order. Pooling, devolution, transfers - standard script around the world! China Eastern coastal provinces generate most national tax revenue under the 1994 tax-sharing system. The central government redistributes these resources through large equalizing transfers to poorer central and western provinces. Australia Western Australia’s massive mining royalty revenues significantly increase its assessed fiscal capacity under the country’s Horizontal Fiscal Equalization framework. As a result, WA's share of the federal GST pool used to be low. Although a statutory GST floor was legislated in 2018, WA still operates as a major net fiscal contributor, cross-subsidizing lower-capacity jurisdictions such as Tasmania and the Northern Territory. Brazil São Paulo and the Southeast contribute a disproportionate share of federal taxes. The States Participation Fund then redistributes resources toward poorer North, Northeast and Midwest states based on certain criteria. Germany Bavaria, Baden-Württemberg and Hesse pay the bulk of the Finanzkraftausgleich (fiscal capacity equalization). Their surplus tax capacity is redistributed mainly to eastern states and Berlin so that living conditions remain broadly comparable across the federation. Indonesia Richer Java-based economies and the national tax base fund the General Allocation Fund equalization grant. Resource provinces receive derivation-based Revenue Sharing Fund, but the gap-filling GAF still moves net resources toward lower-capacity regions. Italy Northern regions especially Lombardy record large positive fiscal residuals. National transfers and partial equalization channel these resources southward, especially focused on health. Japan Tokyo and major metropolitan prefectures generate the lion’s share of national tax receipts while maintaining their own local tax bases. The central government pools a statutory share of national taxes into the Local Allocation Tax to close fiscal gaps in rural and lower-capacity prefectures, guaranteeing a uniform national standard of public services. Switzerland Rich cantons such as Zug, Geneva and Zurich contribute to resource equalization. These payments, alongside federal funds, lift weaker cantons to roughly 86.5% of average fiscal capacity while preserving tax competition. United Kingdom London and the South-East generate fiscal surpluses that are pooled nationally. Through the "Barnett formula", these resources support services in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The adjustments for poorer English regions are made through another process.
The recent comments @nikhilkamathcio made with respect to fiscal federalism are quite disingenuous. Federalism by definition divides power constitutionally between a central national authority and constituent regional units (states in India's case). The constituents each have protected spheres of autonomy, while they remain part of a single sovereign country. Hence, in such administrative and governance systems, the movement of resources from higher-income regions to lower-income regions is a core design feature of national unity. This is not a flaw or an “extractive activity”. Citizens of the country share a common currency, defence, external borders, legal framework and citizenship rights. The regional differences that exist especially in resource endowment are not a result of local efforts. Of course, industrial development is an area where the states can make a huge difference. But each state does not get the same input - geography, history, natural endowment, natural resources - and hence both the starting point as well as ambition and achievement are bound to vary. Fiscal distribution or even equalization as is the case in many countries, serves as a form and expression of national insurance and solidarity. Residents of poorer or resource-poor regions can still aspire to and eventually access broadly comparable public services which the central government provides. But this can be done without facing radically different tax burdens solely because of geography or history-induced requirements. This is the system not just in federal structures, but also in unitary countries, which have to take care of their underdeveloped regions. Without such mechanisms, large disparities tend to fuel political resentment or worse, separatist demands, which would undermine the very idea of a single political community. The fiscal federalism model is very much an expression of the social contract that makes a federal country or for that matter any large, diverse nation viable. Additionally, the fiscal federalism debate of equity vs. efficiency has other dimensions too. Will outline both the issues in more detail: distribution / redistribution structures in other countries including China and why the administration of federal structure / unitary countries with disparate geographies goes beyond such simplistic ideas. Finally, you don't import the governance model of any country wholesale without importing its political and social model. Another point of debate and discussion.
19
4
19
1,716
Manish Manke retweeted
For those tired of describing people as “andhbhakts”, “godi”, “paid followers” and the like, an acceptable alternative?
788
430
181
2,888
105,950
Manish Manke retweeted
पुणे मेट्रोच्या लाईन १ व लाईन २ वरून लाईन -३ (पिंक लाईन) वर प्रवास करू इच्छिणाऱ्या प्रवाशांनी जिल्हा न्यायालय मेट्रो स्थानक येथे उतरावे. येथून मार्गिका-३ वर जाण्यासाठी पादचारी पुलाची सुविधा उपलब्ध करून देण्यात आली आहे. या पादचारी पुलाच्या माध्यमातून प्रवाशांना मार्गिका-३ वर सहजपणे जाता येईल. Passengers travelling on Pune Metro Line 1 or Line 2 who wish to switch to Line 3 (Pink Line) are requested to alight at the District Court Metro Station. A pedestrian bridge facility has been provided to access Line 3 from here, enabling passengers to conveniently transfer to the Pink Line. #PuneMetro #Line1 #Line2 #Line3 #FootOverBridge
21
44
8
370
29,530
People criticize SBI but one point to be noted in their Q2 results - asset quality showed notable progress as the gross non-performing assets ratio dropped to 1.39%, reaching its lowest point in more than 20 years
2
3
409
For a consistent bank-to-bank comparison, the following table uses the RBI's bank-wise figures as of 31 March 2025, the latest complete comparable bank-wise dataset available in the RBI database.
1
20
Bank Gross NPA (₹ crore) GNPA ratio 1. State Bank of India 76,880 1.82% 2. Punjab National Bank 44,082 3.95% 3. Union Bank of India 35,350 3.60% 4. HDFC Bank 35,195 1.33% 5. Canara Bank 31,530 2.94% Source: RBI Database on Indian Economy, bank-wise gross NPA statistics.
1
60
Surprisingly work on Line 2A had started few days before the foundation stone was laid
"Modi will also lay the foundation stone for Phase II of #PuneMetro, to be developed at an estimated cost of around ₹13,500 crore. This phase comprises Pune Metro Lines 2A, 2B, 4 and 4A, aimed at strengthening connectivity across important residential, commercial and IT hubs. business-standard.com/econom… Lines 2A and 2B will span a total length of around 12.75 kilometres. Line 2A will connect Vanaz to Chandani Chowk, while Line 2B will connect Ramwadi to Vitthalwadi, extending the existing east-west Metro network. Line 4, spanning around 25.52 kilometres, will connect Kharadi to Khadakwasla, and Line 4A, spanning 6.12 kilometres, will connect Nal Stop to Manik Baug. The corridors will integrate with intercity bus services and the existing Pune Metro network through interchange facilities at Swargate, Nal Stop and Kharadi Bypass, facilitating seamless connectivity across different parts of the city, the statement said."
1
106
Manish Manke retweeted
You can finally take a metro from Hinjawadi to Pune Railway Station. From there, you can take the Vande Bharat train to Mumbai, then take Mumbai’s Aqua Line 3 to the airport. Then you can fly to Somalia and meet your future neighbours. Massive win for public transportation.
1 million years from now, the Somalian tectonic plate is going to collide with the Indian tectonic plate. That collision will create an equally high mountain range like the Himalaya on the western coast. Imagine being the first Somalian to trek up till Pune, only to see Hinjawadi metro still not inaugurated.
35
190
10
2,567
70,741
Read the article, headline is clickbait journalism.He doesn't blame Vembu or Zoho for that. This was in start of his career
Kewal Agarwal, a former sw engineer at Zoho, described his 3-year tenure as "probably the worst period of my career." His post ignited a broader discussion on corporate work culture, mental health in the tech industry, and the pressure faced by developers indiatoday.in/amp/technology…
98
Manish Manke retweeted
Data from research firm Forrester indicates that 55% of employers who cut staff due to AI regret the decision, while a survey by Robert Half reveals that 32% of U.S. hiring managers have had to rehire for roles they previously eliminated. m.economictimes.com/news/int…
1
1
1
108
So this is why Soviets used a Bollywood song to catch spies...
87
1,139
109
9,629
651,926
Andreas Almgren 🇸🇪 makes a stunning marathon debut, winning the New York City Marathon in 2:06:01! The Swede pulled away from Yemaneberhan Crippa 🇮🇹 over the final mile to seal the victory, with the Italian finishing 2nd in 2:06:14.
77
349
131
5,369
1,740,472
Manish Manke retweeted
180
1,300
104
11,496
296,983
Manish Manke retweeted
12
50
8
305
13,746
It's PPP model, the rolling stock, transmission systems are different. Over period of time money spent on construction was different. All these factors need to be considered
आताच एक पुणेकर ने कॉल वर सांगितले जुनी मेट्रो डिस्ट्रिक्ट कोर्ट ते हिंजवडी मेट्रो मार्ग (२३.३ किमी) हा पीसीएमसी ते स्वारगेट मेट्रो मार्गापेक्षा (१६.५९ किमी) अंदाजे ६.७१ किमीने लांब आहे. मग ३० रुपये पीसीएमसी ते स्वारगेट ला लागतात पण डिस्ट्रिक्ट कोर्ट ते हिंजवडी मेट्रो ६.७१ किमीने जास्त आहे म्हणून ६२ रुपये कसे?
3
14
1,515
Manish Manke retweeted
I was looking at a map this morning that showed which parts of the globe were in sunlight and thinking about how the sunrise line moves through the year. That motivated the animated gif below.
22
57
5
713
91,566
Notice period is an issue discussed innumerable times on X but no one is ready to bell the cat
A notice period is an offer-letter issue, not just an exit issue. Before you sign: Who pays the buyout? What if your employer won't release you early? Can the joining date move without the offer lapsing? Get all three in writing.
1
3
444
Reading is essential.
13
119
2
1,023
19,267
On LinkedIn people post about being respectful to colleagues and juniors but there are large number of people who demean their direct reportee in front of his reportee. Why do they behave like this. Any guesses
2
5
319