Mark Manger (@MarkManger) header
Mark Manger (@MarkManger) profile picture

Father, curmudgeon, full back in a beer league, Prof of Political Economy at @munkschool at U of Toronto. Here in private capacity.

Toronto
Joined October 2009
Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)Photo by Mark Manger (@MarkManger)
Mark Manger retweeted
have you heard of the gromyko doctrine? it's a soviet era negotiating tactic where you start with maximum demands and offer negotiations as the way out; because the west is divided and impatient, there will always be people who take the bait
17
167
17
567
47,232
Mark Manger retweeted
Phones are one thing, but the effect of COVID policies (whether you think they were necessary or not) was so hugely socially and academically damaging for young people. @ProfEmilyOster took a ton of flak for pointing this out, but expost she was right on the money.
U.S. teens saw notable declines in self-reported sadness and suicidal ideation from 2021 to 2025. Relative to 2021, they were also more likely in 2025 to: 1) play sports (49% to 58%) 2) do strength training (45% to 51%) 2) eat fruit >=twice/day (19% to 28%) 3) eat at least one vegetable/day (55% to 63%)
1
3
25
2,373
Mark Manger retweeted
In this era of artificial intelligence, it is becoming urgent to distinguish human art from what machines produce. There is an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others. Algorithms lack the spark of humanity. For this reason, the Church wishes to renew an alliance with artists and cultural institutions to safeguard our humanity.
4,769
80,104
11,118
458,687
26,335,020
Mark Manger retweeted
Skilled trades are frequently thought of as a route out of poverty. But trades workers tell a different story. @JesseTayRiver, a contractor who works in home remodeling, explains:
1
20
17
205
77,153
Mark Manger retweeted
Er hätte seine Politik nur besser erklären müssen. ☝️
60
531
11
4,734
31,537
Mark Manger retweeted
Since many folks have already asked me about the shocking recent state election victory of the far right in Germany, here is a brief Labor Day FAQ with links. Isn't it really about economic deprivation or inequality? No lol. People vote for anti-immigration parties because they don't like immigration. Anti-immigration parties get more votes particularly when immigration is a nationally salient issue, as it is now: (goodauthority.org/news/good-…). Also see research by @JamesRDennison and @epkaufm. OK, but why does immigration matter so much now, and in one of the Saxonies of all places, where there are relatively few immigrants? Voters care about what they think immigration is doing to Germany as a whole. Their own local community or paycheck is only part of the picture. See more on sociotropic voting and immigration here: (goodauthority.org/news/good-…, goodauthority.org/news/can-t…). OK, but I thought the immigration numbers were going down—why doesn't salience go down too? Voters care about foreigners already living in the country and how immigration is managed. Germany, for instance, has hundreds of thousands of people legally required to leave who remain in the country, often because of administrative reasons—and voters don't like that. Public concerns are also thermostatic and need not track this year's flows. I discussed this in the US context here: (goodauthority.org/news/why-a…). So what should mainstream parties do to win voters back? As I argued after the AfD's breakthrough in Germany's 2025 election, they need to deliver visible improvements in immigration policy. People can support freer immigration (and not vote for anti-immigration parties) when they can see that it benefits their country, without needing experts to tell them so: (goodauthority.org/news/germa…). But doesn't accommodating the far right always hurt mainstream parties since voters go for the real thing? It depends, and the evidence is mixed. As @hannohilbig explains, a tougher immigration position can attract some voters but lose others. Voters also often (rightly!) don't find mainstream parties' new anti-immigration stances credible: (popularbydesign.org/p/why-do…). OK, but immigration is actually good after all—so why are all those people upset about it? Freer mobility is good on net, but Germany has adopted many costly immigration policies whose downsides have often been downplayed in mainstream debate. Turning qualified research findings into reassuring political messages makes sensible immigration policy harder: (faz.net/aktuell/karriere-hoc…). Also see our primer with @KelseyTuoc on why immigration in Germany and Western Europe is so much worse than in the US: (theargumentmag.com/p/why-ame…). I make the full argument behind these answers in my last book, In Our Interest. For a shorter read, check out The Uncomfortable Truths About Immigration here: (popularbydesign.org/p/the-un…).
7
19
4
120
25,776
Mark Manger retweeted
it really does break my balls that mainstream political parties don't want to address the elephant in the room (for more than 10 years now) and as a result people start voting for the only parties promising to address said elephant, but which are completely retarded in every other way
From a motivational viewpoint, this is Germany‘s Brexit moment: a defiant middle finger to an establishment that failed to grasp that what it is has long branded as populist has become popular. Yet the motives of these insurgents are far more hostile than those of the Faragists. They rage not only against Germany‘s elites or the EU but against Germany’s very place in the West.
45
71
3
1,265
82,359
The highly promising results from El Salvador’s first PISA for Schools assessment show what education reform can achieve when student learning is placed at the center—and change reaches the classroom. What is at stake is more than a score. It is a generation’s future and its prospects in the labor market. These preliminary findings, drawn from a group of schools, point to a path worth pursuing. The World Bank Group is proud to support El Salvador’s efforts to strengthen education and expand opportunities for generations to come. More on the assessment: bit.ly/4x7q1zQ
168
437
104
1,956
1,754,200
Mark Manger retweeted
Beaucoup s'étonnent que des centaines de scientifiques défendent Nathan Cofnas. Leur argument principal est que la "théorie raciale » de Cofnas concernant l'intelligence ne serait pas scientifique. Les scientifiques défendant Cofnas seraient donc nécessairement des réactionnaires pseudoscientifiques... Cofnas est un philosophe, avec une spécialisation en philosophie de la biologie et en éthique. Il travaille au Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences de l'Ugent. Il n'est pas un scientifique. Si on exige que le travail des philosophes respecte les critères de scientificité, il ne va pas en rester beaucoup dans les universités... En tant que biologiste, je ne suis pas d'accord avec la thèse de Cofnas. Je vais essayer de formuler ça simplement. Les différences individuelles de performance aux tests cognitifs présentent une composante génétique importante. C'est un fait bien établi, même si cela en dérange certains. L'héritabilité de l'intelligence est également documentée. Mais une forte héritabilité au sein d'une population ne permet pas, à elle seule, d'expliquer les différences moyennes éventuellement observées entre populations. Le véritable problème de la thèse de Cofnas est de parler de « races » qu'on pourrait hiérarchiser en termes d'intelligence. Il n'existe pas, chez l'être humain, de races biologiques discrètes et génétiquement homogènes correspondant aux catégories raciales ordinaires. On peut comparer des groupes génétiquement hétérogènes et constater que certains réussissent, en moyenne, moins bien aux tests de QI. Mais ça ne veut pas dire qu'il y a des races moins intelligentes que d'autres. Certains disent que la thèse de Cofnas ne doit plus être débattue dans les universités parce qu'elle serait déjà réfutée depuis des décennies. Je pense que c'est une erreur. La génétique humaine a progressé de manière considérable depuis la démocratisation du séquençage du génome humain. Il me semble donc intéressant de confronter, au sein de l'université, la thèse philosophique de Cofnas avec les données scientifiques actuellement disponibles. Ne pas faire cet exercice serait une grave erreur. Car cela laisserait penser que la thèse de Cofnas est rejetée uniquement pour des raisons morales. Cela reviendrait à lui donner de la crédibilité. Si une thèse est fausse, la meilleure manière de le montrer est de l'examiner sérieusement et de confronter ses arguments aux données disponibles, pas d'empêcher qu'elle soit discutée. Indépendamment de cette question de la véracité de la thèse de Cofnas, la principale raison pour laquelle il faut défendre Cofnas tient aux raisons invoquées par l'UGent pour le licencier. Cofnas ne travaille pas à l'UGent sur sa "théorie raciale". Il fait un postdoc sur un autre projet philosophique. Il a été engagé pour travailler sur ce projet par l'UGent en toute connaissance de cause concernant sa "théorie raciale". Au vu du timing, il est difficile de ne pas mettre sa situation actuelle à l'UGent en relation avec sa dénonciation du caractère frauduleux du travail de Jason Arday. Il est triste qu'Arday se soit donné la mort. Mais Cofnas n'est pas responsable de cela. Arday avait déjà été mis en cause à plusieurs reprises des années auparavant. Si Cambridge avait enquêté sérieusement sur ces accusations, Cofnas n'aurait pas eu à intervenir. La responsabilité de cette situation ne peut donc certainement pas être imputée à Cofnas. Il serait inacceptable qu'un philosophe soit écarté d'une université au motif que ses travaux ou ses opinions mettent certains collègues et étudiants mal à l'aise. Il serat également inacceptable qu'un académique soit écarté pour avoir critiqué le travail d'un autre académique. Si on adopte ces normes, c'en est fini de la liberté académique et de la critique argumentée dans les universités.
107
132
30
641
73,408
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
142
1,311
135
11,117
1,098,124
Mark Manger retweeted
Football won
24,341
417,630
20,828
1,942,817
69,935,478
Mark Manger retweeted
Be a Jude. Not a Messi.
451
4,830
313
61,254
1,020,787
Mark Manger retweeted
The reason Ethiopia doesn’t win the Super Bowl is because all of their best athletes are in long distance running.
The only reason why the US doesn’t win every World Cup is because our best athletes choose football, baseball, basketball, and hockey over soccer It’s like we are sending our 5th string up against everyone else’s best
126
4,999
35
45,641
1,076,767
Fucking bagged milk again because God forbid your production team hires anyway who's ever lived west of Kitchener.
The World Lives Here. Canada is all together different. Truly unique. And so is our relationship to the beautiful game. This is our opening to the 2026 World Cup. Narrated by Kiefer Sutherland. #FIFAWorldCup
18
9
1
172
40,504
Mark Manger retweeted
“At a meeting of the college faculty, an angel suddenly appears and tells the head of the philosophy department, ‘I will grant you whichever of three blessings you choose: Wisdom, Beauty or ten million dollars.’ Immediately, the professor chooses Wisdom. There is a flash of lightning, and the professor appears transformed, but he just sits there, staring down at the table. One of his colleagues whispers, ‘Say something.’ The professor says, ‘I should have taken the money.’”
14
40
2
333
17,489
Mark Manger retweeted
If the EU built Claude
291
1,282
167
15,240
985,950
Mark Manger retweeted
A smart-sounding dumb idea The Carney government’s plan for a public AI supercomputer is the kind of idea that sounds bold and strategic until one pauses to think about it for more than a few seconds. The premise, championed by AI Minister Evan Solomon, is that Canada needs sovereign computing power to compete in the AI race. But the proposal is less a serious economic policy than a symptom of a broader and worrying shift toward renewed economic nationalism. Consider the scale of the industry in question. The global AI leaders—Anthropic, Google, Meta, OpenAI and others—are spending hundreds of billions of dollars annually on chips, data centres, energy infrastructure, and cloud capacity. Their yearly capital expenditures rivals or exceeds Ottawa’s total budget. Against that backdrop, the idea that the federal government will build and operate a globally competitive AI supercomputer borders on absurdity. This is, after all, the same government that spent years failing to implement a functioning payroll system. Canadians are now supposed to believe it can successfully manage one of the most capital-intensive and technologically dynamic sectors in the world. Yet this proposal matters beyond its own merits. Before Donald Trump’s election in November 2024, Canada’s secular stagnation seemed to be producing a healthier policy conversation. There was growing recognition that weak productivity and low investment required more competition, greater openness, and structural reform. Even previously untouchable issues, such as foreign ownership restrictions in protected sectors, were beginning to face scrutiny. Trump’s repeated attacks on Canada have changed the mood. They have created political space for a new sovereignty economics: subsidized supercomputers, state-backed satellite launch capacity, and other industrial policies justified in the name of national independence rather than market dynamics. That would be a costly mistake. Canada’s main economic problem isn’t that the state owns too little. It’s that the private economy invests too little, builds too slowly, and faces too many barriers to growth. We don’t need a public AI supercomputer. We need a more competitive economy.
39
73
15
349
32,070
Mark Manger retweeted
Replying to @VoloUkraine
Food for thought: Abrams tanks are safer for pedestrians than these things.
10
44
4
489
12,176
Mark Manger retweeted
It’s amazing that this even needs to be said in 2026, but the collapse of communism was a good thing:
269
2,961
166
13,928
500,203
Mark Manger retweeted
A hero of the global left dancing on the graves of massacred Ukrainians. They always show their real colours eventually
Guess it was always going to happen… Yanis Varoufakis dancing at a conference in Moscow to the viral techno track about himself, made by Russian DJ Sasha Melior.
38
578
7
3,128
98,615