Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2) profile picture

Full Professor Applied Economics Head of Applied Economics Department University Oviedo Research member of @Gen_Uvigo

Oviedo (Asturias, Spain)
Joined December 2019
Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)Photo by Matías_Mayor (@MatasMayor2)
Matías_Mayor retweeted
i want to bring to the attention of people outside spain what i think is a pretty sad hijacking of a public institution, one that should serve everyone, to favour the party in government. the CIS (centro de investigaciones sociológicas, or centre for sociological research) is spain's public polling institute. it goes back to 1963, when its predecessor was founded, and it took its current name in 1977. its president is appointed and removed by the government, but by law it must act with "objectivity and neutrality". this institution is a big provider of public goods: besides its flagship product (the monthly political barometer), it runs dozens of surveys a year on things few private firms would pay to ask about, from taxes and inequality to sexual health or love and relationships, and it makes the microdata freely available. it has resources no private pollster has, and researchers and journalists (me included) use its data all the time. in june 2018, a few weeks after pedro sánchez became prime minister, his government appointed josé félix tezanos as president of the CIS. tezanos is a sociology professor and has been a member of the socialist party (PSOE), the party that leads the government, since 1973. when he was appointed he sat on the party's national executive (its top leadership body) as head of research and policy programmes, which put him in charge of the party's election manifestos (he left that post about ten days later, after criticism from the opposition). since then, the CIS's vote estimates have leaned systematically towards the socialists. one can show this with a very simple exercise. for each general election, wikipedia compiles the results of every published opinion poll (for the 2026 election, they are here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinio…). using those tables, for every CIS vote estimate since 1997 i take the PSOE lead over the centre-right people's party (PP) and subtract the average lead in the private polls whose fieldwork ended within 21 days of the CIS's. i leave out polls commissioned by the parties themselves and the re-estimates that other analysts make with the CIS's own raw data. each firm counts once, even if it published several polls in the window (in that case, i take the average of its polls). from 1997 to 2018 the CIS was in line with everyone else: on average, a difference of about zero (+0.1 points). but since tezanos was appointed, the CIS has given the PSOE a lead 8.4 points larger than the average of private pollsters. in 91% of its estimates it gives the PSOE a bigger lead than every single private pollster in its window. if i showed this chart at an economics seminar, i think most people would find it pretty convincing evidence that something changed at the CIS in 2018. but let's go through some potential objections. suppose private pollsters have drifted to the right since 2018 (it would be odd for them to jump so sharply just after tezanos was appointed, but for the sake of argument let's treat it as a real possibility). in that case, a CIS that stayed put would look more and more pro-PSOE simply because everyone else moved. or the mirror image: everyone, the CIS included, leaned to the right before 2018, and the CIS was the one that fixed it after that. the data suggest this is not what happened. first, the gap holds no matter who you compare the CIS with. against 40dB alone, el país's pollster (el país being a centre-left newspaper), it is 7 points since march 2019, compared with 9.2 with all firms on the same dates. dropping five firms that mostly work for right-leaning outlets (sociométrica for el español, nc report for la razón, data10 for okdiario, target point for el debate and hamalgama métrica for vozpópuli), it is 7.9. second, if private pollsters had drifted right, then their final polls would miss towards the PP more often after 2018. across the 90 general, regional and european elections since 2008 for which the CIS ran a pre-election survey, that is not what we see. private final polls missed the PSOE-PP lead by 0.1 points in the PP's favour on average before 2018 and by 0.4 points in the PSOE's favour after. in both periods they erred towards the PP about half the time. the CIS's average miss, meanwhile, went from 0.8 before tezanos to 3.5 points in the PSOE's favour after. this also rules out the mirror story. before 2018 there was no right-wing bias to fix, since private polls were mostly on target, and after 2018 it is the CIS that ends up further from the results. needless to say, the result does not depend on the time window used to pick the private polls the CIS is compared with. with 7, 15 or 30 days, or comparing with the polls of the same calendar month, the gap since 2018 stays between 8.2 and 8.4 points, and the one before 2018 stays at about zero. so what changed? kiko llaneras (@kikollan) has looked at this in depth. since tezanos arrived, the CIS has overestimated the left in practically every election (general, regional and european). even in the two general elections where "it did well" (april 2019 and 2023), its only merit was that it overestimated the left when everyone else underestimated it (and it still missed, just in the other direction). for instance, in 2023 the PSOE and sumar (another left-wing party) won 152 seats. the polling average gave them 142, and the CIS gave them 171. that fits what i find. a large part of the bias seems to come straight from the sample, which overrepresents PSOE voters. for example, take the CIS's huge pre-election survey for the 29 november election (45,000 interviews). among respondents who report how they voted in 2023, 41.8% say they voted PSOE, when the PSOE actually got 31.7% of the vote. PP voters, meanwhile, make up 23.6% of the sample, compared with an actual 33.1%. in other words, PSOE voters are overrepresented by 10 percentage points, and PP voters underrepresented by almost as much. until 2018 the CIS corrected this kind of imbalance in its estimate by weighting the data according to what respondents say they voted last time (you can check its own methodological notes here: cis.es/documents/d/cis/es320…). in september 2018, less than three months after tezanos arrived, it stopped doing that (compare the note on the vote estimate in july, cis.es/documents/d/cis/es321…, with the one in september, cis.es/documents/d/cis/es322…). i am not a political scientist, and i don't know what tezanos's intentions are, or whether this even helps the PSOE win votes. but missing in the same direction in almost every election for eight years looks like a deliberate choice. i hope this reaches as many people as possible. the CIS does a lot of valuable work and it should belong to all spaniards, whoever they vote for. running a public institution this way should not be acceptable, and watching its credibility erode is genuinely sad, especially because that gives people a cheap excuse to distrust every other statistical body whose work depends on being seen as independent and reliable.
19
251
19
775
55,354
Esto de las camisetas y los bailes me recuerda un poco a Trump
24
Como simple ciudadano demócrata, como socialista y ante el dolor de las víctimas y de las familias, NO entiendo, no justifico, la ausencia del Presidente en el funeral .
231
202
20
1,170
67,280
Tampoco hay que exagerar. En España hay mucha gente valiosa, también en el PSOE, por supuesto. Seguro que incluso hay dirigentes que saben defender sus ideas sin necesidad de levantar el tono ni recurrir a descalificaciones personales
32
Airef: "una evaluación ex post de los 4 corredores de Alta Velocidad[...] Losbeneficios sociales no compensan los costes fijos de la construcción y no ofrecen seguridad en escenarios sujetos a incertidumbre y en los que el coste de oportunidad de los fondos públicos es elevado"
1
29
Matías_Mayor retweeted
Sin presupuestos no se puede gobernar Esa es la realidad lo demás es aparentar que gobiernas 👇👇
7
123
1
402
4,059
Matías_Mayor retweeted
Da igual que no seas del PP, vas a disfrutar de este corte como un niño con una piruleta. Estoy seguro de que Silvia Intxaurrondo tenía un papelito con varias posibles respuestas, pero es que la ha destrozado. Hija mía, ve buscando curro.
283
2,273
51
12,777
1,007,674
Es que hemos apostado por otro modelo, o más bien no hay modelo.
Perfectamente explicado. ¿Nos podemos permitir pagar el mantenimiento de esta enorme (e infrautilizada) red? No recuerdo haber dicho nada en política tan polémico como cuando dije (en 2015, en la segunda presentación del programa de Ciudadanos), que no, que debíamos parar de construir líneas de AVE y, en su lugar, invertir en innovación. elpais.com/politica/2015/04/…
26
Ahora hay elecciones (y espero que finalmente presupuestos). Es urgente atender el mantenimiento de la red de carreteras del Estado, por seguridad. El estado de la A-8 es lamentable, agujeros, baches, juntas de viaductos (Avilés-Navia). ¡ Es un peligro! @transportesgob
27
Matías_Mayor retweeted
Falla el sistema de seguridad, a investigar a fondo antes de señalar culpables. Un nuevo y trágico accidente, en el contexto de incidentes y retrasos. La prioridad debe ser resetear un modelo de AVE tensionado. Apuntar solo al mantenimiento sería parcial y una huida adelante.
48
19
2
83
5,843
Ehhh? ¿pero quién gobierna España?
No es asumible para un país como España, con un sistema de alta velocidad tan potente como el que tenemos, sufrir dos accidentes de estas características y de esta magnitud en un año. La labor del Gobierno no es solamente conocer cuáles son las causas, sino también ofrecer soluciones para que una tragedia de esta magnitud no vuelva a suceder. @sanchezcastejon
1
27
Los últimos presupuestos aprobados son de 2023. No hay nada más que añadir.
2
116
Escuchando al Ministro, está claro, la alta velocidad en España no es segura
31
Matías_Mayor retweeted
Tras el nuevo accidente ferroviario, conviene hablar de datos sin aventurar sus causas. En 2025, el capital ferroviario neto seguía 1.256 millones por debajo de su máximo de 2015. Entre 2016 y 2022, la inversión ni siquiera compensó la depreciación de la red. El problema viene de lejos. 🧵con algunos datos👇
7
84
13
194
16,015
Estoy escuchando al Ministro, ¿de verdad, trenes que van a más de 200km/h, después de lo que ha pasado, no tienen más y mejores sistemas?
28
Supongo que habrá dimisiones y que comparecerá Pedro Sanchez
27
Accidente terrible hoy...otra vez...debemos reflexionar
1
121
Matías_Mayor retweeted
La crisis de vivienda en España: lo que creo que puede funcionar para solucionarla... y lo que probablemente no sirva o sea directamente contraproducente. En siete minutos y medio. Dentro video 👇
723
8,933
831
21,975
2,086,471
Sr. Ministro, dedíquese a conseguir que los transportes públicos funcionen. En Ucrania, en plena guerra, he visto trenes funcionar con una puntualidad que aquí echamos de menos. En el Campo de Gibraltar miles de ciudadanos siguen sin conexiones ferroviarias fiables y con carreteras por toda España cada vez más peligrosas. Puede llamarme “cuñado”, hacer bromas o faltarme al respeto. Es lo de menos. Lo importante es que usted es el ministro y responde por su gestión. Menos X y mejor transporte público. Y si no sabe hacerlo, deje paso a quien pueda. Gracias.
El Mundo siempre se agarra a las autoridades en la materia. Hoy tocaba el cuñado en Chef que ha hecho uno de los ridículos más antológicos que recuerdo en esta red social.
3,624
172
15,368
349,338
🧵1/ He analizado el discurso del Papa León XIV en Madrid como si fuera el de un político. El resultado es inquietante. Porque es, técnicamente, uno de los discursos mejor construidos que han sonado en España en mucho tiempo. 👇
63
758
45
3,423
579,034