Matthew Hartke (@MatthewHartke) header
Matthew Hartke (@MatthewHartke) profile picture

Post-Christian Bible nerd endlessly fascinated with the historical Jesus and the origins of Christianity (he/him)

Portland, OR
Joined February 2020
Why am I still so interested in Christian origins? The way I figure it, either the birth of Christianity tells us something incalculably valuable about the nature of the universe, or it tells us something incalculably valuable about ourselves. There’s gold there either way.
14
9
2
87
Matthew Hartke retweeted
Plagiarism is a moral issue, not just something for those pesky academics to care about. It is very concerning to see Christians who 1) have no idea what plagiarism is and 2) have no concern for plagiarism. Thankful that @CharacterGap covers this in his excellent book! 1/5
3
6
68
2,267
Massive respect. I can’t imagine how hard it must be to make a video like this calling out your friend. This is a beautiful example of how to uphold love and truth at the same time.
I’ve waited to say more until Wes could give his update. But I feel morally compelled to share this now and hope it is a service to the Christian community and that things move in a more transparent direction soon with my friend, Wes Huff. youtube.com/live/_oDotgbGbF0…
8
53
2,056
Matthew Hartke retweeted
A lot of apologetics is just assuring Christians that they don't, in fact, have anything more to learn. – at Redmond, WA
10
19
4
177
10,181
The absolute imbecility of claiming, when your sacred book includes Joshua and Deuteronomy, that senators of other faiths shouldn’t be free to swear on their sacred texts because those texts deny the freedom of religion… it’s beyond irony
Agree. You can't believe in the Qur'an, which denies freedom of religion, and then swear to support and defend the freedoms enshrined in the US Constitution-- the two documents are contradictory. Thoughts?
2
9
44
1,243
Matthew Hartke retweeted
Replying to @jasonstaples
The organizations/communities who platform apologists are in a catch twenty-two. The experts who know what they're talking about won't say what these organizations want to hear. And the "experts" who say what these organizations want to hear don't know they're talking about.
3
8
2
51
4,156
Nobody makes a draft by pervasively copying & selectively rewording other people’s work like Wes did if the intent is to remove all of that before submitting. That would be like mixing chocolate chips into your dog’s kibble & then picking out every chip before giving it to them.
8
9
3
97
4,130
Matthew Hartke retweeted
Honestly, from Wes, that seems like an underwhelming non-apology to what looks like real plagiarism. Context matters, but the documents authored by Wes appear to contain overtly plagiarized materials throughout. Focusing on academia and your email is not the main issue. A final point. This isn’t about canceling. I’m not a fan of that. It is about academic standards and integrity and accountability. As a Christian, this matters and I know it matters to Wes. His response: youtu.be/RdrHr819rzU?is=q5Vp…
30
6
5
99
26,996
I don’t know fellas, maybe this isn’t the best way to persuade women that their liberal values go back to Christianity 🤷‍♂️
3
1
19
2,116
A couple problems here: 1) Sayings about the Gospel going out to all the nations reflect the situation in the life of the early church better than they do the ministry of Jesus 2) Even if Jesus did say something like Mk 13:10, you still have to explain that in light of Mk 13:30
I will probably make a video explaining why this is an implausible reading of Jesus' words one day if anyone is interested. One piece of data that makes me think this is the case is the scope of the Great Commission needing to go to all nations.
5
17
1,379
What really gets me is how sloppy it all is. Changing “transcriptional” (a word) to “transcriptrural” (not a word), replacing “Note, however” (makes sense) to “Similarly” (makes no sense) and changing the citation of Ehrman “n. 183” to page number “183”…
I found Wes Huff committing plagiarism in another paper. In his paper (left), "Forgiveness in Luke-Acts", (utoronto.academia.edu/Wesley…), he paraphrased a large chunk of Nathan Eubank's text in "A Disconcerting Prayer: On the Originality of LUke 23:34a" (right) in his conclusion.
2
3
25
1,263
Matthew Hartke retweeted
I found Wes Huff committing plagiarism in another paper. In his paper (left), "Forgiveness in Luke-Acts", (utoronto.academia.edu/Wesley…), he paraphrased a large chunk of Nathan Eubank's text in "A Disconcerting Prayer: On the Originality of LUke 23:34a" (right) in his conclusion.
35
47
25
337
43,086
Matthew Hartke retweeted
if god was actually non-binary then church coffee would taste a lot better
25
304
19
5,813
76,565
“if modern miracles can't prove anything, neither can the Resurrection” 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️
Buckle up, Ethan Muse is back! He argues that if modern miracles can't prove anything, neither can the Resurrection. He also takes on the Marian dogmas, explains how he outgrew atheism, and answers the SSPX's case against the post-Vatican II Church. Out Now!
9
2
1
51
3,546
Lol
Even if Wes Huff plagiarizing were the case, it would be weaker violence to scholarship than what Dan McClellan bilges out every week.
3
3
63
3,122
Matthew Hartke retweeted
Yes, I too was plagarized. The black parts are what he didn't change.
Replying to @maklelan
doesn’t seem to be an isolated incident. another one of his academia.edu papers, the one on the textual variant at Gal 2:12, also shows signs of plagiarism from a 2014 article by David I. Yoon and Stephen C. Carlson’s dissertation
61
76
45
683
192,615
Plagiarism is a common practice for apologists whose main interest isn’t the contribution of ideas within a community of learning but rather the display of competence as a means of persuasion. Note here how Huff copies Lydia McGrew, even stealing her title and calling it his own.
Look, I’d take Wes Huff over Billy Carson any day, but Huff is not the paragon of expertise all the chest-thumping apologists are painting him as. At least, not with respect to the Gospels. Exhibit A:
7
11
2
78
17,987
I also love the degree of petty detail Dan goes into here. Really incredible work 👏
2
13
391
Seconded
I was raised in a community that had regular miracles, prophecies ever week from local and traveling prophets, and lots of spiritual warfare. And I've visited many others. I've seen how those plausibility structures work from the inside and out. And I don't share your credulity.
2
6
466