Pinned Tweet
My book, The Open Field, isn’t an anti-MLS book.
MLS owners took the risk and built the foundation — stadiums, academies, real infrastructure.
But if we want to compete for a World Cup, have domestic games where something’s genuinely on the line, and develop world-class (maybe transcendent) players — the structure has to match that ambition.
An open ecosystem fully connected from youth to pro with promotion and relegation is how we get there. It also happens to be the greatest opportunity in American sports today.
The Open Field is about what it takes to meet that ambition.
Out now on Amazon. Link in bio.
Michael Page retweeted
There is a third option: @ussoccer could establish its own professional league or exercise its regulatory authority to create a unified competitive framework in which every stakeholder competes on sporting merit, independent of commercial affiliation.
Unfortunately, that would require something American soccer has historically lacked: a federation willing to govern rather than simply accommodate competing interests. Our antitrust framework further complicates any attempt to impose such a structure.
The fundamental problem is that every stakeholder wants to control the sport rather than compete within it.
Publicly, they champion growth, opportunity, competition, and, my personal favorite, “standards.” A conveniently subjective term often weaponized to imply institutional superiority, even when the underlying evidence suggests otherwise.
Privately, their decisions are largely driven by the preservation of their own commercial interests. And frankly, who can blame them? We operate in a capitalist economy. Self-interest is not inherently objectionable.
But therein lies the great irony of American soccer: everyone claims to want a stronger ecosystem, provided they get to own it.
You cannot build a coherent sporting pyramid when every stakeholder is busy constructing a kingdom on its own island.
Yet perhaps this fragmentation ultimately becomes @ussoccer’s greatest opportunity.
Imagine an American soccer landscape with two or three Division I leagues, four or five Division II leagues, and ten to fifteen Division III leagues, each competing for clubs, investment, talent, and market share.
At that point, the federation would have little choice but to confront its most fundamental responsibility: establishing and enforcing a transparent, equitable regulatory framework that serves the sport as a whole rather than the commercial interests of any particular league.
Of course, that requires genuine institutional independence. And it’s difficult to credibly claim independence when the very organizations subject to regulation have current or former executives occupying positions of influence within the regulatory body.
The federation should not exist to protect leagues from competition. It should exist to protect competition from leagues.
Perhaps the solution to American soccer’s fragmentation isn’t another monopoly.
Perhaps it’s finally having a federation that understands the difference between governing the game and controlling it.
E pluribus unum. Out of many, one.
It's one of the ideas America was built on. It may also be the missing idea in American soccer.
We've built a lot worth crediting. A first division that survived and grew. Youth clubs with real resources. Lower divisions and amateur leagues full of people who love the game.
But we're not yet an elite soccer nation. And in a global game where the best have been building for over a century, we won't get there as separate pieces.
Most coaches will tell you eleven connected players beat eleven great individuals. The power isn't in the parts. It's in the relationships between them.
That's synergy. Connected parts make each other stronger, and the whole becomes far more than the sum.
American soccer has great parts. What it mostly lacks are the connections.
And without them, competition happens in the wrong place. Leagues compete with leagues, for players, for status, for territory. In most of the soccer world, it's clubs competing with clubs, on the field, that pushes everyone to get better.
Connected as a system. Competitive as clubs. That's when the parts start magnifying each other instead of each one only adding up to itself.
Five commitments would get us there:
1. We earn our place. Players and clubs rise on performance, so every level is chasing the same thing: getting better.
2. We compete at every level. Real stakes from youth to the top, so development never stalls.
3. We build for communities. Every town has a stake in the whole game, not just its own club.
4. We grow one game. Leagues feed one pathway instead of competing for players. Clubs do the competing, on the field.
5. We measure ourselves against the world. Every decision faces one test: does this help us compete there?
None of this means tearing anything down. It means connecting what we've built.
Many pieces. One game.
5
165
Michael Page retweeted
I’ve been seriously exploring the potential for a new California-based professional soccer project—market TBD—built around the @USL_HQ pathway.
Could a California community without professional soccer rally behind a truly family-first, soccer-focused club—one committed to affordability, traditional values, and putting the sport itself at the center of everything it does?
I’d value honest feedback from my community here on @X. Is this a vision you believe people would support?
One of the most common objections to an open ecosystem in America isn't financial. It's cultural. "Promotion and relegation works in England because soccer is woven into the fabric of English life. You can't import the structure and expect to import the passion. Fix the culture first."
I don't think that's quite right. It assumes the arrow only runs one way, culture first, structure second. In practice, they reinforce each other, continuously. The arrows go both ways.
And it's usually American soccer fans themselves who say we don't have the culture yet. But we do. Millions of fans from soccer-first countries live in this country right now, they grew up on real stakes, promotion, relegation, consequences that mattered. MLS just hasn't captured this audience yet, and that's why most of them are still watching somewhere else.
Combine that passion with the passion MLS fans already bring, and you're looking at one of the biggest untapped opportunities in American sports. Build a structure with real stakes, and both audiences finally have the same thing to rally around.
And that's just the fan side. Layer in everything else a real open ecosystem brings, more money flowing throughout the entire system, genuine meritocracy, a system that actually finds a huge chunk of the talent in this country we're currently missing, and real help solving pay to play.
No other country on earth has the sheer cultural mix we do, all in one nation, all carrying the game with them. That's not a weakness to work around. It's the single largest reservoir of soccer culture and talent on the planet, sitting inside one country. Give it the right structure, and it might just become the most powerful engine in world soccer.
If all of this comes together, the potential is enormous. I believe we start producing world-class players, maybe even a transcendent one, and our national team raises its ceiling and gets into the conversation to actually compete for a World Cup.
And a domestic league here has the potential to become one of the top three leagues on the planet.
I thought about a story the other day that I hadn't thought about in years.
Back in 1998, a top marketing person I knew from my earlier days at MLS called me, since they knew I was a coach and understood the youth soccer market in Southern California. They needed help preselling tickets to MLS Cup at the Rose Bowl and were nervous that attendance could be poor if the Galaxy didn't make the final.
I started reaching out to the youth soccer market, and one of the leagues I reached out to was the Coast Soccer League. It was considered the best youth league in the country, and it was a true pyramid, bronze, silver, silver elite league up to gold, and at the top one premier bracket at the oldest age groups that was team based instead of club based. A real meritocracy.
I actually knew the leaders in the league, since I was a coach myself at the time, but they initially wouldn't return my calls. So I did some research and faxed them a list. MLS had 12 teams then, 18 man rosters, about 216 players total. Seventy two of those players, roughly one third of the league, had come up through Coast Soccer League. I listed each player and their MLS team next to their former Coast club and sent it over with one message: we need to be promoting this.
They called back within the hour. I ended up preselling a little over 20,000 tickets to that final, working with them and a few other youth soccer organizations.
I thought about that fax the other day for the first time in years, and it stuck with me. I can't prove the pyramid structure is why that league produced so many MLS players. Correlation isn't causation. But the best true pyramid in the country, in a soccer hotbed, produced a third of MLS's entire player pool.
I wish I'd put this in The Open Field. Might be worth its own chapter someday.
I’ve noticed the pro/rel debate goes back and forth without getting anywhere, because each side is entrenched, arguing from its own interest. Owners talk about protecting the investment, etc. Advocates talk about fairness and tradition, etc.
I believe it’s worth recognizing that as pro/rel advocates, we’re the ones asking MLS to change. MLS seems fine with the current structure, as incoming commissioner Larry Berg recently confirmed.
In my view, the choice comes down to either we convince them to do this, or we build an open pyramid without them. For a lot of reasons, getting them on board is the better path, and that means we have to sell it. We have to show why this is a win-win for MLS and the overall ecosystem.
I’m a pro/rel advocate myself, and I’m not interested in being right. I’m interested in getting this done, because I know the overall benefits it will have on the entire ecosystem. That means we have to make the case on their interest, not just ours.
We don’t have access to MLS’s books, so we can’t know the exact numbers. But we can still build an honest, generally informed financial case, and the competitive and legacy cases are ours to make in full.
Let’s start with the financial case: how does an open system from youth to pro make MLS worth more, not less?
It's not fair or accurate to say MLS isn't competitive. It has real stakes, especially in the playoffs. Anyone who says otherwise is just trying to knock down MLS and isn't being intellectually honest.
But MLS supporters need to be just as honest, because there's still something real underneath the criticism, and it's worth putting in proper context.
Here's how I look at it. Put an MLS team in Bundesliga 2, with real promotion and relegation on the line. Could they compete at that level? I think so. But would they have to perform differently, game to game, than they do now? You bet they would. Would a high salaried name player still start over a younger player who's actually outperforming him, week after week? Probably not. And if MLS fans were sitting in that stadium every week, would their tension and energy be higher, knowing what a bad run of games could actually cost? Of course it would.
MLS has genuinely high level players, some who'd start for good sides anywhere in the world. What's different is that MLS games simply don't carry the same magnitude of consequence that an open league carries every week. That's not a knock on the players. It's a fact about the structure they're playing inside of. That structure was originally built for survival and stability, not maximum stakes.
Both leagues are in the sports entertainment business. But maximum stakes produce better decisions, more drama, more stories, and a more intense connection between fans and their club. It's simply a better product, and a better product is one that could command higher global broadcast rights than the current version of MLS.
That's the case I make in The Open Field for MLS taking the lead to transition to an open ecosystem. Not tearing down what's been built, but unlocking it. And if it does, it has the potential to be the greatest opportunity in American sports today.
Michael Page retweeted
PAUL SPACEY PODCAST
#28 - Promotion & Relegation Is Coming To America
Why pro/rel is on the way and reaction to viral video criticizing MLS quality of play, featuring many of you who commented.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and overview of MLS and promotion-relegation debate
02:30 MLS as an entertainment league versus a competitive sport
05:09 The inevitability of promotion and relegation in US soccer
08:50 Criticisms of MLS level of play and comparisons to college soccer
11:59 The importance of consequences and competitive intensity
14:48 Addressing criticisms and misconceptions about MLS
18:06 The cultural differences in football competitiveness
23:56 The role of criticism and open debate in growth
30:01 The future of MLS and systemic reforms
37:05 The growth of soccer culture in America
39:59 The systemic benefits of promotion and relegation
47:12 The competitive nature of top leagues and the importance of meritocracy
49:55 The global dominance of soccer and its future in America
Posted on LinkedIn
MLS turns 30 next year and honestly, credit where it's due. Stadiums, academies, training facilities, valuations in the billions, a solid media deal, attendance that's been strong. That's real.
But let's also be real about the other areas of the ecosystem. Our national team's ceiling has remained frustratingly the same. We still haven't produced a single world class player. Not because the talent isn't there. Because we don't have a system that finds it everywhere, or a connected structure that forges the best of it all the way to the top. Our youth system is currently a patchwork of mainly closed, competing leagues with no real connection to each other, no connection to the professional game, and no clear path up for a kid outside the right one. It's every man for himself.
Remember Project 2010? Back in 1998, US Soccer put out a real plan, real money, real ambition, to make the national team a legitimate World Cup contender by 2010. Where's the follow-up? Where's the next version of that ambition?
New commissioner Larry Berg was asked about promotion and relegation this week. He said it's not appropriate for MLS as it continues building stadiums, facilities, and rosters. Fair enough, that's his and MLS's call to make. But it's also a small example of a much bigger pattern: every part of this ecosystem making decisions for itself, with little regard for how it connects to everything else.
Look around the world. In nearly every elite soccer nation, the national team is a unifying source of pride, and the pyramid underneath it is genuinely connected, with a clear pathway from the bottom all the way to the top. We don't have that here. We're not connected, and the pathways are closed throughout the ecosystem.
I'm a coach. I've spent 35 years teaching kids that a team only becomes something greater when everyone actually plays for each other, not just for themselves. The individual rewards, the scholarships, the pro contracts, the caps for the national team, they come out of what everyone puts into the whole. American soccer needs to embrace that same concept on the institutional level.
Do we still want to compete to win a World Cup? Do we want to produce multiple world class players in order to get there? If so, then our structure needs to match that ambition. I believe MLS needs to lead this transformation. They have the capital, the infrastructure, the stadiums.
Truthfully, we all need to lead. We all need to look at the bigger picture and the long term if we actually want to get there. If we don't, it stays every man for himself, and the ceiling remains the same. If we do, America might finally break through that ceiling.
In The Open Field, I argue MLS is best suited to lead the transition to an open ecosystem. Not to diminish the USL's work, but because of it, and because of the grassroots foundation laid by the UPSL, NPSL, and other adult leagues.
With their Division One announcement, three levels of pro/rel by 2028, USL has captured the intellectual and operational heart of this movement, betting real capital that open competition and a merit-based structure can work on American soil.
But a pyramid can't be unlocked from the middle down.
MLS holds the stadiums, the media rights, and the commercial platform to open it from the top. Without that, American soccer stays two fractured stories instead of one connected system.
If MLS leads, it doesn't make USL's or the grassroots leagues' work obsolete. It finally validates it, and in doing so, creates the legacy of fully unifying the American soccer pyramid for the first time.
If MLS doesn't lead, the USL will, and it's the USL that ends up owning the narrative of being the authentic, merit-based version of this sport in America, a narrative MLS cannot afford to cede.
The pro/rel debate in American soccer usually gets framed too narrowly, focusing only on competitive pressure at the top. But the true systemic power of an open ecosystem runs from the grassroots upward.
In a closed system, talent identification is concentrated. MLS academies scout broadly within their reach, but below that level, investment drops, scouting is inconsistent, and the path to the pros is tenuous at best.
The result? Thousands of players are left out. If you don't live near an academy, can't afford expensive club fees, or happen to be a late bloomer, the system misses you.
An open ecosystem changes the incentives entirely.
When promotion, relegation, and roster value exist at every tier, every club, from the local UPSL side to League One, becomes an active talent identification node. Finding and developing a talented young player in their own backyard offers real competitive and commercial value.
Instead of a centralized, expensive system trying to cover a massive country, an aggregate scouting network naturally emerges. Thousands of clubs, each pursuing their own growth, collectively comb the American landscape with a thoroughness no single entity could ever replicate or afford.
When every community is scouted and every player is given a clear path forward, opportunity becomes universal. It's not just that the cream rises to the top, it's that the cream gets forged along the way, tested by real competition at every level, in a system our current one never puts them through.
What could be more American than that?
1
91
A few days ago, it was pay to play. Today, everybody's debating whether Pochettino was the right hire. I'm personally fine with the hire. But we need to be debating something far more important.
The coach shapes culture. He doesn't shape the ceiling. That's set by the depth of the player pool, and ours isn't even close to deep enough.
England can leave Phil Foden and Cole Palmer off their World Cup squad entirely and barely blink, because Morgan Rogers and Eberechi Eze are right there on their heels and a dip in form cost them. We don't have that luxury at a single position.
Until we have a system that's actually incentivized to produce that kind of depth, from youth to pro, our ceiling stays pretty much where it is, regardless of who's on the sideline.
We should be debating how we build that depth. Not who's on the sideline.
3
102
Check out my latest article: From the Inside Out: Why I Wrote The Open Field linkedin.com/pulse/from-insi… via @LinkedIn
1
3
135
Thought experiment: if failure wasn't a risk, no financial downside, no operational headache, and you were just designing the best system to make America competitive on the world stage, youth through pro, which would you build? A closed system, or a fully connected open ecosystem?
Most people, if they're honest, land on the same answer. An open pyramid.
That tells you something. The disagreement was never really about whether an open ecosystem is the better model. It's about whether it's financially and operationally viable to get there from here, and whether what gets built is stable enough to last. Fair question. But it's a different question, and conflating the two is what keeps this debate stuck.
If we agree on the destination, the conversation should shift from "should we" to "how." What does relegation protection look like? How is revenue structured so clubs don't collapse on the way down? What's the transition path that makes the whole thing durable?
Those are solvable problems, the same way every country that's built this has solved them. That's what my book, The Open Field, actually spends time on: not just the why, but the how. Mapping a real, stable plan to get there. Not the final answer, just a starting point for the conversation the sport actually needs to have.
The Open Field. Link in bio.
113
We’re stuck in a cycle: after every disappointing World Cup, everyone has ideas about what needs to be tweaked, fixed, improved — pay-to-play, coaching quality, player development, etc. We implement some of it. Four years later, we’re right back where we started, having the same conversation again.
Here’s why: each of those fixes deserves to be taken seriously, because none of them is wrong. That’s exactly what makes them dangerous as a substitute for the real thing. You can regulate certain elements of a closed system to improve them, but you can’t regulate that system into genuine excellence.
Look at U.S. airlines before 1978 when the government mandated safety standards, set fare minimums, even subsidized routes, but service stayed mediocre and fares stayed high, because no airline actually had to fight for its survival. Deregulation opened the system to real competition, and in a few years the industry did what decades of regulation never could.
Better coaching and pay-to-play reform work the same way: they can raise the floor. They cannot raise the ceiling, because the ceiling was never a regulation problem, rather, it’s an incentive structure problem.
Here’s what’s strange: every elite soccer nation on earth has a different playing style, a different culture, different philosophies but they all share the exact same incentivized structure. We keep circling that fact without ever really looking at it seriously, because looking at it means admitting the fixes we keep reaching for were never going to be enough.
We don’t need another round of tweaks. We need to open our eyes to the one thing every elite country already has in common and consider that it also happens to be the greatest opportunity in American sports today, one that could transform this country from the youth game all the way to the pros.
1
252




