E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @RokoMijic
EA is currently proposing central planning / totalitarian solutions.
It's like communism a bit.
Therefore libertarians don't like it.
And it's competition to actual communists/socialists.
Well but if you are AI doomer proposing totalitarian government, because: We need to stop killimg AI I just dreamed up.
...It's not much nuance there.
You takes are dangerous inherently bad for society.
Dear internet,
It is entirely possible to be concerned about ALL the following AI related issues
💫 SIMULTANEOUSLY 💫
👉 Power grabs by authoritarians, especially governments
👉 Anarchists using it for chaos
👉 Losing control of recursively improving agents
👉 Dumb regulation stifling good innovation
👉 Algorithmic bias, addiction & coercion
👉 Fear-baiting & excessive pessimism/doomerism
👉 Short-term $ incentives conflicting with long-term goals
👉 Excessive worship of CEOs
👉 Acronym ideologies creating cult-like behaviour
👉 Civil instability from rapid job displacement
These concerns are *not* mutually exclusive! Nor is this list exhaustive!
My point is, while you can (and SHOULD) personally care about some over others, that doesn’t mean others can’t have different priorities than you. In fact, it’s GOOD if humanity is diversified in its efforts to navigate its transition to the AI age. But we have to each train our minds to hold some % of mental space for each of these problems concurrently, else we become idiot absolutists who just make everything worse.
Of course trade-offs exist, and attention is finite, but this growing trend of AI demagogues who view memespace purely as a zero-sum battle ground, blindly declaring that *their* pet concern is more important than all others, who relentlessly straw-man anyone who disagrees, is frankly embarrassing for AI.
Pay attention to which accounts do this as their primary tactic in their feed. And ESPECIALLY pay attention to the ones doing it within your own tribe, because that’s where your biggest blind spot will likely lie (note to self Liv!)).
As comforting as their certainty makes you feel, they are not serving you, nor humanity.
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @Simeon_Cps @ChrSzegedy
Yeah asymmetric burden of proof is really there.
Fantasy dreams of "killing AI" doomers need muvh more evidence. They usually provide jus more detaildd fantasy dreams .
That's not enough ;)
E/ACC retweeted
Posibility of some superintelligence 100 year in the fitire really doesn't tell us we need some totalitarian government regulation "to slow down AI development now".
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @geoffreyhinton
I'd like to respectfully point out that the logic in this argument is based on a flawed model for how scientists think. Scientists don't just take a weighted average of others' opinions to form their own.
A good scientist takes as input lots of data, including others' opinions, and then ultimately has to reason, build their own internal model of the world, and draw their conclusions from that model.
I give your opinion a lot of weight. And, after having heard many opinions including yours, my internal model tells me that there is essentially no risk of AI human extinction.
So I don't follow the logic that because @ylecun or anyone else disagrees with you (and other AI extinctionists, which IMO are in the minority) that they gave your opinion very little weight, unless we think scientists arrive at conclusions by taking a weighted average of what everyone else thinks.
Since you've gone against the grain many times in your own career -- often brilliantly so -- I assume you're also familiar with what it feels like to give someone's opinion weight, but then ultimately to draw a different conclusion!
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @neilturkewitz @timnitGebru
Over correction of eventually very helpful trchnologu is very costly.
People like him should be liable for those costs.
(And yes, overregulation is very dangerous by itself for society, together with helping totalitarian regimes in AI race.)
E/ACC retweeted
There is magic man in the sky, who is going to kill all humans in 5 years, unless we will sacrifice 10 himans every day for him!
What is sufficient evidence for you?
Would you need to see it happen?
Risk of extinction is too large, we should definitelly comply!
E/ACC retweeted
Lol, super biased survey like this really doesn't mean anything.
Sane people are way more likely to just don't answer survey full of "AI fantasy" questions like p(doom)
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @AISafetyMemes @GaryMarcus @ESYudkowsky @tegmark @NPCollapse @brianchristian @tristanharris @ylecun
Well doomers have super strong faith in their fantasy doomsday scenarios..
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @GaryMarcus @ylecun
There are serious incidents with EVERY SINGLE THING you are doing and using.
Especially during long period like decade.
Is that reason to stop using technologies and get back to caves? No.
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @AgiDoomerAnon
Tomorrow's AI isn't a problem either.
Your fantasy AI is a problem in you fantasy.
E/ACC retweeted
Replying to @AgiDoomerAnon
Current "AI" is primarly usable for human capabilities augmenting.
Some doomers just live in their fantasy world, that's it.
E/ACC retweeted
A lot of people (particularly around my age) don’t realise that pessimism or “realism” will kill the future.
If you’re an optimist, you will be far more willing to struggle because you know there will be a payoff in the end.
The only logical choice is to be an optimist.
E/ACC retweeted
your regular reminder that neural nets are not, in fact, a species
they are trained, not evolved, a different process with different results
for the same reason, gpt4 will not try to make babies with a llama model (even though you might prompt it to say it would)
Careful Casey and Reckless Rob both sell “AIs that make you money”
Careful Casey knows AIs can be dangerous, so his ads say: “my AI makes you less money, but it never seeks power or self-preservation!”
Reckless Rob’s ads say: “my AI makes you more money because it doesn’t have limits on its ability!”
Which AI do most people buy? Rob’s, obviously. Casey is now forced to copy Rob or go out of business.
Now there are two power-seeking, self-preserving AIs. And repeat.
If they sell 100 million copies, there are 100 million dangerous AIs in the wild.
Then, we live in a precarious world filled with AIs that appear aligned with us, but we’re worried they might overthrow us.
But we can’t go back - we’re too dependent on the AIs like we’re dependent on the internet, electricity, etc.
Instrumental convergence is simple and important. People who disagree generally haven’t thought about it very much.
You can’t get achieve your goal if you're dead.
If the idea of AIs becoming self-made millionaires seems farfetched to you, reminder that the AGI labs themselves think this could happen in the next few years.

















