Paul Warchuk (@PAWarchuk) profile picture

Assistant Professor @UNBLaw. Public lawyer and legal historian.

Fredericton, New Brunswick
Joined December 2015
The Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s Judicial Foundations Project is planning a one-day symposium on “Judicial Power and the Canadian Constitution,” tentatively scheduled for February 4, 2027, at Hart House, University of Toronto. We hope to bring together scholars, experts, and practitioners from across Canada, and potentially the wider Commonwealth, to reinvigorate interest in the development, scope, and exercise of judicial power in Canada. @CopelanPeter @SunKerry @GeoffSigalet
6
3
16
7,406
Judgment length has exploded at the Supreme Court of Canada. The average Wagner Court judgment is more than twice the length of the average McLachlin Court judgment. All at a time when the Court is promoting itself as more accessible to Canadians... papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…
5
9
625
My latest Substack. A question for our next dean - and for every Canadian and American law dean out there: in an age of artificial intelligence, how will you justify law schools' existence? Comments welcome. Link below.
6
3
5
9
5,269
Breaking: major decision from the New Brunswick Court of Appeal today upholding certainty for private property rights in context of Aboriginal title claims: courtsnb-coursnb.ca/content/…
22
51
12
204
26,995
Property rights are on everyone's minds as of late, and for good reason. Whether it is the security of financial assets, the capacity to undertake major resource projects, or the security of fee simple land title, property rights seem not as strong as many have assumed. In fact, Canada is fairly unique among peer countries in our explicit lack of constitutional protections for property rights. There's a better way forward for Canada that preserves the ability of the government to act in the public interest for natural resource extraction, major projects, national security, and to govern for the common good, while strengthening protections for private property. @PAWarchuk argues that “Weak property rights discourage investment, erode public trust, and concentrate power in the state. A society that treats ownership as conditional undermines citizens’ freedom to plan, build, and innovate.” To effectively address the problem, he urges Canada to adopt comprehensive safeguards built on four core ideals: -Fair compensation for all takings -Legitimate public purpose -Due process before deprivation -Proportionality “The question is not whether Canada should protect property rights more robustly, but when and how.” @MLInstitute macdonaldlaurier.ca/beyond-p…
1
5
11
735
It's not going to be easy to explain much about the lengthy Cowichan Tribes Aboriginal title decision post-by-post - I've written some initial thoughts on one big point in my new substack - TLDR is: yes a lot of private land faces new uncertainty - see lawforbreakfast.substack.com…
Some extra reading to add to this weekend - the 600+ page judgment declaring Aboriginal title ownership over land in the City of Richmond, including fee simple (privately owned) lands. Want to read carefully before I say more…
4
29
7
87
21,485
Paul Warchuk retweeted
Ian Holloway (@LawProfHolloway): The Supreme Court is ditching its iconic red robes. Yes, it matters FREE 3-month Hub subscription: thehub.ca/free-trial/ Full article here: thehub.ca/2025/06/30/ian-hol…
3
6
2
32
18,901
Disappointed to learn that the SCC will ditch their traditional robes, which date back 500+ years. It certainly won't be cheap either. 12 new robes for the UKSC cost over $250,000 more than a decade ago: dailymail.co.uk/news/article…
Amid the controversy over Wagner CJ's putative ignorance of who donated the bust of him in the Supreme Court of Canada building, it's worth noting another one of his aesthetic announcements: In a Year Zero move, the SCC will soon be replacing its "Santa Claus" ceremonial robes.
1
10
33
5,602
I certainly hope they don't take the approach that the English judiciary took with their new gowns: telegraph.co.uk/news/1951169… I suspect they'll go for something similar to New Zealand: courtsofnz.govt.nz/learn-abo… I wonder if they will also ditch court dress, like the UK and NZ?
1
4
269
Paul Warchuk retweeted
Prorogation litigation update 🚨 A rare Saturday decision from the Federal Court granting the applicants’ motion to expedite. February 13-14 hearing for the challenge to the lawfulness of the Trudeau prorogation. Impressive speed from Crampton CJ! cdn.cyberimpact.com/clients/…
2
2
8
1,031
Are pre-1970 @SCC_eng @CSC_fra precedents still legally relevant? After analyzing around 1.5 million citations found in 5000 appeal factums and 468,500 judicial and administrative decisions, I think so. Draft paper here: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…
2
16
46
5,600
Good article by @GillisMatilda in the recent Issue of @PL_PublicLaw defending the HRA & arguing that following an adverse ECtHR decision, a new policy can be found which respects rights, but still preserves much of the original policy aims. A moderated and collaborative approach!
3
16
1,221
I asked Claude 3 Opus whether the @SCC_eng majority reasons in the recent Privacy Commissioner case (2024 SCC 4) are consistent with Vavilov. Maybe it's drawing on Côté J's concurrence, but I'm impressed. AI is rapidly improving. What do others think? @pauldalyesq @MarkPMancini
1
4
975
Court declares that the GG must appoint superior court judges “within a reasonable time of the vacancy”, “the Court expects the untenable and appalling crisis, and critical judicial vacancy situation found by this Court as identified by the Chief Justice and CJC will be resolved”
The Court has issued a decision regarding the quantity of federal judicial vacancies. Decision and summary: bit.ly/3oiTAid.
5
12
2,989
Last year, the net cost of the Court's operations was $51,250,996... scc-csc.ca/about-apropos/rep…
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
8
1,788
Paul Warchuk retweeted
I was fiddling with claude.ai, on the rec of @emollick, and I have to say, wow—this is a very plausible game-changer. I've fiddled with Chat GPT and been underwhelmed. But claude.ai is way way better. A few screenshots of essays I asked it to write:
16
31
9
178
140,425
Paul Warchuk retweeted
Hey #lawtwitter, @UNBLaw is getting a new home. Thank you to @INFC_eng and @Gov_NB for your historic investment (combined $45.4M), and to @UNB for sharing this vision. We will serve @CityFredGov and New Brunswick like never before.
📣 UNB Law has a new home! Thanks to the largest ever public investment in a Canadian law school, the Faculty of Law is moving to the Justice Building in downtown #Fredericton. Learn more about this $62M transformation: youtube.com/watch?v=JvdrBvP5… #lawtwitter #nbpoli #canpoli
4
6
1
37
5,158
I am very excited to be joining UNB Law and the Fredericton legal community! Incredibly thankful to @pauldalyesq and everyone else who helped make this possible! I can't wait to get started!😊😊😊
We are thrilled to announce the appointments of Paul Warchuk (@PAWarchuk) and David Matyas (@DavidgMatyas) as assistant professors at @UNBLaw, effective July 1, 2023 and January 1, 2024, respectively. Read more about their impressive backgrounds: blogs.unb.ca/unblaw/2023/06/…
5
1
30
4,713