Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs) header
Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs) profile picture

Passionate about independent journalism. Free Speech and keeping our liberties. Editor at @heartlandstrib #GTTO #LeFT #ClassWar

Chesterfield
Joined August 2019
Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)Photo by Paul Knaggs (@PaulKnaggs)
Labour has always been the Party of Betrayal. Ed Miliband represents Doncaster North, part of a city where nearly 69% voted to leave the European Union. That was no narrow protest vote. It was an overwhelming rejection of an economic and political settlement that had failed much of the working class. Yet here he is, telling Sophy Ridge that people voted Leave for a better economy and haven't got one. He's missing the point of why so many voted Leave in the first place. Miliband wants to talk economics. Fine. The IMF forecasts British growth of 1.3% in 2026 against 1.1% for the eurozone. Hardly the economic catastrophe we were promised. France faces serious economic difficulties, Germany has struggled with industrial decline, and the EU has its own problems with sluggish growth and public finances. Yet Miliband and Burnham would have us believe that closer integration with Brussels is somehow the answer to Britain's economic troubles. And here's what Miliband conveniently overlooks. Doncaster didn't become deprived after Brexit. Neither did Barnsley, Mansfield or the former mining communities across the North. Their factories closed, their pits shut and their industries disappeared during decades of membership of the European project. Britain had almost seven million manufacturing jobs in 1979. By the time of the referendum, fewer than three million remained. Brussels didn't cause every closure, but membership certainly didn't save those communities. The EU worked rather well for the City of London, with its financial passporting rights, and for multinational employers enjoying access to a vast single market and a mobile labour force. But where was the great European prosperity for the former miner, the redundant steelworker or the families watching their towns decline? GDP figures might have impressed bankers and politicians. They didn't pay the bills in Doncaster. Of course Brexit brought additional trade paperwork, and some exporters have suffered. That deserves an honest answer, not another round of political dishonesty. Britain still trades extensively with Europe. Official figures show UK services exports to the EU continuing to grow. We can negotiate away unnecessary barriers without restoring unlimited freedom of movement or surrendering democratic control. And while we're discussing economics, perhaps Miliband could explain why he measures the success of Brexit against economic promises made in 2016, but refuses to measure the success of EU membership against what happened to the working-class communities he represents over the preceding four decades. Andy Burnham is now helping reopen the very argument Labour promised to settle. Once again, the political class appears more interested in its relationship with Brussels than its broken relationship with the electorate. The people voted, the establishment lost, and ten years later Labour's answer is to question the settlement rather than confront its own failures. The working class didn't vote to exchange one set of distant decision-makers for another. They voted to have a say in their country's future. Labour would do well to remember that. Labour has always been the Party of Betrayal. "‘twas always thus, and always thus will be..."
25
136
11
385
18,966
Before anyone takes Alan Milburn's latest pronouncements as the wisdom of an independent policy expert, perhaps they ought to know who he is and whose interests he's been involved with. Milburn was Tony Blair's Health Secretary from 1999 to 2003, a driving force behind NHS market reforms that expanded opportunities for private healthcare providers. After leaving government, he built a lucrative career in consultancy and corporate advisory work, including relationships with businesses operating in and around the healthcare industry. His consultancy, AM Strategy Ltd, reportedly paid out more than £5 million in dividends between 2017 and 2024. Today, he is back inside government as the Department of Health's lead non-executive board member. Yet the department's own register confirms he remains a shareholder and adviser to private equity firm Bridgepoint Capital, holds shares in healthcare technology company Huma Therapeutics and advises PwC. Now consider what this means when Laura Kuenssberg introduces him to BBC viewers simply as a politician and policy expert. He certainly has expertise. But viewers are entitled to know about his commercial interests, particularly when he's discussing public services and government policy. There are formal arrangements intended to manage conflicts of interest, but those arrangements are no substitute for transparency. The question isn't whether Milburn is entitled to speak. Of course he is. The question is whether the public is being given the full picture of the man offering advice. When someone has helped reshape a public service, subsequently earned substantial sums advising businesses, and then returned to help oversee government policy, scrutiny is essential. Before asking the public to trust his judgement, the BBC should give viewers the information they need to judge it for themselves.
3
50
2
74
1,490
More than 100 data centres are currently being planned or built across the UK. Imagine living next to one of these monstrosities. Just listen to it.
225
1,408
81
2,523
160,819
While mortgage payments bite and rents rocket, energy bills go through the roof, public services are cut to the bone, and tens of billions are committed to Ukraine with no end to the war in sight, our Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, and Foreign Secretary, Ed Miliband, are thousands of miles away in the Caribbean, playing steel drums and cricket. Meanwhile, back in Britain, the working class is struggling to keep the lights on, put food on the table and access the public services their taxes are supposed to pay for. Of course, international diplomacy matters. But isn't that what the King's doing??? But there's something painfully absurd about watching our political leaders enjoying a Caribbean photo opportunity while the people they represent are counting every penny. Dennis Skinner had their measure more than forty years ago. Speaking in Parliament in December 1984, he observed that MPs' winter fact-finding tours always seemed to take them somewhere "between the Tropic of Cancer and the Tropic of Capricorn". "There are never any fact-finding tours of Greenland in winter," he remarked. Forty-two years later, the faces have changed, but the political spectacle looks remarkably familiar. And that's what Westminster still doesn't seem to understand. People are fed up. Fed up with the excuses, the political theatre, the endless demands to tighten our belts while those at the top appear to inhabit an entirely different world. The government might be playing Mary Had a Little Lamb in the Caribbean, but back home, the sheep have had enough. We really are living in a clown world. 🤡🌍 @PaulKnaggs, The Heartlands Tribune
4
87
6
128
2,475
When a banking collapse locked three million ordinary people out of their own wages, the working class of Paraguay did not write polite letters to parliamentary committees. They took to the streets, broke into the halls of power, and removed the politicians who enabled the theft. The political class will tell you this is chaos. They will say that order, legal patience, and established procedure are sacred, even when the law exists primarily to protect the men who looted the vault. That argument fails because it demands that citizens respect a social contract that the state tore up long ago. Order without justice is merely quiet subjugation. Parliaments do not concede power out of goodwill; they concede it when the fear of the people outside outweighs their greed inside. If the working class cannot strike, protest, and disrupt, then politics becomes nothing more than a private auction between bankers and ministers. A system that robs three million families of their livelihood is not broken: it is doing precisely what it was designed to do until someone forces it to stop.
70
718
77
1,368
34,179
Paul Knaggs retweeted
A lesson from history on the importance of food security.
In the winter of 1069 William the Conqueror put down a rebellion in the north of England by killing the animals. The people died afterwards, on their own. Three years after Hastings, Yorkshire rose against him with Danish help. William marched north, bought off the Danes, and then decided the region would never trouble him again. He did not need a battle. He split his army into small bands and sent them through every valley between the Humber and the Tees. Their orders were to destroy what kept people alive. They slaughtered the cattle, the sheep and the plough oxen. They burned the stored grain and the seed corn. They broke the ploughs. Then they left, in midwinter. A monk who wrote the history of those years, and who admired William, could not excuse it. He recorded that the survivors ate horses, dogs and cats, and then each other. Some sold themselves into slavery for a meal. He put the dead at 100,000. The corpses lay unburied on the roads, because there was no one left with the strength to dig. Sixteen years later the King's surveyors rode through the same country compiling Domesday Book. Against village after village in Yorkshire they wrote one word. Waste. William is said to have confessed it on his deathbed as the sin that weighed on him most. It became the standard method. Sherman used it in Georgia. The United States Army used it on the Plains, against the bison. Every commander who has wanted to break a people for good has understood the same thing. You do not have to fight them. You only have to get to the herd first.
1
2
12
437
Come back to the EU, they said. It's a wonderful peace-loving project, they said. A beacon of prosperity, stability and European harmony. Just ignore the riot police, burning barricades and angry crowds on the streets of France, Germany and Belgium. It's all part of the European experience. Every citizen is entitled to their daily Two Minutes Hate, provided it's directed at someone Brussels approves of. The economies are struggling, industries are under pressure, public services are stretched, and ordinary people are wondering how they'll pay their next energy bill. But never mind. There's always money for another round of rearmament and another lecture about the virtues of European unity. And if you question any of it, you'll be informed that you're an ignorant Little Englander who simply doesn't understand the benefits of belonging to this wonderful European family. George Orwell gave us three memorable slogans in Nineteen Eighty-Four: "War is Peace." "Freedom is Slavery." "Ignorance is Strength." They were supposed to be warnings, not a suggested rebranding exercise for Brussels. Still, look on the bright side. At least the EU has achieved one remarkable feat of unity. From Paris to Brussels, ordinary people seem increasingly united in their anger at the political establishment. But do come back, Britain. The European dream is apparently going splendidly. #YesToEuropeNoToTheEU
4
17
1
38
974
Biology is not a state of mind. #MaterialReality
2
10
533
Copenhagen, Denmark. More images from enlightened Europe, where democracy, rights and freedoms are supposedly cherished, unlike those barbaric corners of the world we're forever being lectured about. 👇 Albania. France. Italy. Spain. Portugal. Belgium. Germany. India. Brazil. Across Europe and beyond, young people are taking to the streets against soaring living costs, the erosion of social protections, militarisation, conscription and wars. They're watching political elites gamble with their futures while demanding ever more sacrifices from those who can least afford them. Apparently, democracy means having the freedom to protest, provided nobody in power has to listen. Their message is simple: "Invest in our futures, not your wars!"
43
175
24
333
15,531
Is it any wonder there's growing anger across Britain and Europe when so much of the wealth is concentrated in the hands of so few? Look at the figures. And these aren't the calculations of some radical socialist organisation. They come from the Office for National Statistics, the European Central Bank and Eurostat. 🇬🇧 BRITAIN: A COUNTRY OF ENORMOUS WEALTH, UNEQUALLY SHARED. In the UK, when you account for hidden offshore assets, the top 1% controls nearly a quarter of all wealth, while the bottom half of the population scrap just 10%. The wealthiest 1% owned approximately 10%, as much as the entire bottom 50% of households combined. And the geographical divide is staggering. Median household wealth in the South East was £489,800, compared with just £179,900 in the North East. Decades of economic growth, privatisation, deregulation and promises that wealth would trickle down. Yet entire former industrial communities remain deprived of the investment and opportunities they were promised, in or out of the EU. Well, we've had decades of that experiment...it failed, and no wonder... 🇪🇺 THE EUROPEAN UNION: DIFFERENT FLAG, FAMILIAR ECONOMIC DIVIDE. Across the continent, the political class preaches strict fiscal discipline to the public while presiding over a rigged economy. In the European Union, the top 10% own around 60% of total financial assets, leaving millions trapped in stagnant wages, inflated rents, and insecure gig-work. The bottom 50% own just 5%. Meanwhile, Eurostat reports that 92.7 million people across the EU, equivalent to 20.9% of its population, were at risk of poverty or social exclusion in 2025. Nearly 93 million people, in one of the wealthiest economic blocs on the planet. And yet we're continually told that the free market, competition and economic integration are delivering prosperity for everyone. We have stripped millions of young people of property, pension, and prospects, and then we express polite establishment bewilderment when they turn to political extremists. You cannot construct a stable democracy on the foundation of feudal inequality. Michael Parenti exposed the fundamental lie of this consensus: the mythology that the most relentless, opportunistic plunderers, operating under the cold pursuit of capital accumulation, will somehow serve the public good through the "invisible hand". We do not have a free market in Britain or Europe. We have privatised monopolies, state-guaranteed asset inflation for landholders, and endless austerity for everyone else. When you tell a society that democracy cannot touch the economic rules, the so-called fiscal rules, do not be surprised when people start trying to smash the building down. And if the rising anger across Europe tells us anything, it's that people are growing tired of being told how fortunate they are to live in economies where so much wealth exists but so little reaches them. Society does not break because voters suddenly lose their morals; it breaks when the economic contract becomes an open fraud. #eu #Brexit
5
47
4
57
2,576
I'm old enough to remember Ukraine before February 2022. Before the great PR makeover. Before billions in British public money started flowing. Before the swastikas were quietly airbrushed out of the picture and yesterday's neo-Nazi problem became today's inconvenient history. Back in January 2015, Ross Kemp travelled to Ukraine for his Extreme World documentary series, investigating the rise of the far right and the Azov Battalion, including its neo-Nazi elements and symbolism. This was British mainstream television, not Russian propaganda. Funny how quickly history gets rewritten when the geopolitical interests change and the public chequebook comes out. Of course, Ukraine's corruption, extremist movements and internal divisions didn't magically disappear in February 2022. But suddenly, mentioning what British journalists had openly reported for years was enough to get you branded a Kremlin sympathiser. Well, here's Ross Kemp reporting from Ukraine in 2015, long before the political rebranding. No Russian bots. No Kremlin script. Just the history they would rather you didn't remember.
409
4,534
429
10,118
283,262
Germany, Britain, France and Italy. Four of Western Europe's largest economies, producing a combined $16 trillion in economic output this year. Yet food poverty remains a serious problem across all four. In Germany, 11.1% of people cannot afford a proper meal every other day. In France, it's 11.2%. In Italy, 9.3%. These are the latest Eurostat figures for 2025/26. * Germany: 9.3 million people * France: 7 million people * Italy: 5.5 million people * UK: 6 million people Europe's largest economies, 2026 IMF October 2026 projections, nominal GDP in US dollars. These measure annual economic output, not personal wealth. 1. Germany $5.47tn 2. United Kingdom $4.27tn 3. France $3.55tn 4. Russia $2.86tn 5. Italy $2.70tn 6. Spain $2.09tn 7. Netherlands $1.42tn 8. Switzerland $1.14tn 9. Poland $1.13tn 10. Belgium $773bn Four of Europe's largest economies, and millions of their citizens, cannot reliably afford one of life's most basic necessities. Economic output tells us how much a country produces. It doesn't tell us how fairly that prosperity is shared. The latest French survey, commissioned by Action contre la Faim, found that 13% of adults sometimes or often lack enough food. Among 18- to 24-year-olds, that rises to a staggering one in four. Perhaps we should spend a little less time measuring the success of our economies by the wealth they generate and rather more time asking how much of it reaches the people who generate it. A wealthy country should not need food banks to feed its people. #France #FranceRiots
1
14
1
24
906
We keep being warned about the day AI might go rogue and help bring about an apocalypse. Naomi Klein’s point is far more uncomfortable: stop looking into the future and look at what the technology is already being used for. Speaking after watching the film NAZA, Klein argues that AI-assisted systems have already helped turn killing into something colder and more distant, with algorithms generating probability-based targets and technology creating a bureaucratic distance between human beings and lethal decisions. Her argument is equally important for what she does not blame: “I’m not saying that it’s the technology that’s to blame.” She blames the marriage of powerful technology with ideology and human decision-making. That is the debate about AI we ought to be having. Not merely whether machines might one day escape human control, but what happens when extraordinarily powerful machines remain firmly under human control and are used to decide who becomes a target. And there's a British connection we cannot afford to ignore. In our accompanying Tribune investigation, we follow the technology from Gaza to the companies supplying military AI, including Palantir, which also holds a £330 million NHS data contract. We examine what happens when the same powerful systems used to classify and predict become embedded in public services, and who remains accountable when the algorithms get it wrong. As Klein puts it, AI hasn’t “gone rogue”. The decisions remain human. So does the responsibility. Read our full investigation: AI in Gaza: The Machine Hasn't Gone Rogue. It Is Doing Exactly What It Is Told The Heartlands Tribune 👇 heartlandstribune.com/ai-in-… Naomi Klein Substack substack.com/@naomiklein/not… #NAZA
20
1
19
618
𝑻𝑯𝑬 𝑹𝑰𝑻𝑼𝑨𝑳 𝑶𝑭 𝑪𝑶𝑵𝑺𝑬𝑵𝑻 First they make you participate. Then they ask you to sacrifice. In 1940, British families handed over their saucepans and garden railings, convinced they were doing their bit for the war effort. In 2026, the head of the British Army says citizens must “consent to sacrifices”, while the Prime Minister tells households to stock up on three days of tinned food. Different generations. Different props. The same principle: make people feel part of the national effort, and they become more willing to accept its demands. From saucepans to soup tins, the ritual of participation is back. Only this time, the sacrifice is being demanded for a defence spending commitment the government has yet to explain, cost or turn into a credible plan. The warnings. Stock three days of food and water. Keep cash at home. Prepare for emergencies. Then Britain’s Chief of the General Staff said politicians must explain to the public that citizens have to “consent to sacrifices to prioritise defence and security”. Defence Secretary Wes Streeting endorsed him and said military chiefs should be in front of the microphones as part of a “national conversation”. But there is something missing from this conversation. The plan. Britain is being committed to NATO’s 5% defence spending target. Billions more are being promised. Sacrifice is already being discussed. Yet before the public is asked what it is prepared to give up, shouldn’t somebody tell us precisely what we are buying, what threat each capability answers, and what it will cost? Next Wednesday, John Healey delivers his first Budget. The sacrifice is being discussed before the plan has been explained. 𝙉𝘼𝙏𝙊 𝘿𝙚𝙛𝙚𝙣𝙘𝙚 𝙎𝙥𝙚𝙣𝙙𝙞𝙣𝙜: 𝙈𝙖𝙣𝙪𝙛𝙖𝙘𝙩𝙪𝙧𝙚𝙙 𝘾𝙤𝙣𝙨𝙚𝙣𝙩 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙃𝙚𝙖𝙡𝙚𝙮’𝙨 𝘽𝙪𝙙𝙜𝙚𝙩 Read the full investigation: 👇 heartlandstribune.com/nato-d… #autumbudget #budget
17
69
7
100
9,406
France is back on the streets. More than 400,000 people marched across France today in a second national day of mass protest over the rising cost of living, inequality and pressure on education. In Paris alone, police put the crowd at 110,000. By nightfall, the demonstrations had descended into clashes in parts of the capital and other cities. Tear gas and water cannon were deployed, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez says almost 1,000 people have been arrested, with that number expected to rise. This is no longer a single bad weekend for France. The anger over falling living standards and deteriorating public services has returned to the streets for a second successive Saturday. And France is not alone. Protests have taken place across several European countries today. Europe's cost-of-living crisis is becoming increasingly difficult to contain.
1
14
20
855
𝘼 𝙜𝙤𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙣𝙢𝙚𝙣𝙩 𝙬𝙞𝙩𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙩 𝙖 𝙥𝙡𝙖𝙣 𝙞𝙨 𝙖 𝙜𝙤𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙣𝙢𝙚𝙣𝙩 𝙡𝙤𝙤𝙠𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙮𝙚𝙨𝙩𝙚𝙧𝙙𝙖𝙮'𝙨 𝙖𝙧𝙜𝙪𝙢𝙚𝙣𝙩𝙨. Andy Burnham has picked at the Brexit scab, reopening a debate Labour promised to leave behind. Labour was elected in 2024 on a manifesto ruling out the return of freedom of movement. Now, with working people facing pressing problems at home, we're being invited to revisit the old arguments about Britain's relationship with the EU. Where is the vision for rebuilding Britain? Where is the plan for our industries, public services and communities? The direction of travel is becoming clearer. Closer alignment with the EU brings Britain towards a familiar trap: accept rules made in Brussels without a vote on them, or be told the sensible alternative is to rejoin. Rule takers, not rule makers. And eventually, rejoining is presented as the only escape. This is the danger of allowing the EU debate to substitute for a proper economic programme. Nye Bevan warned against treating the Common Market as a substitute for socialist planning, allowing market forces to take the place of political responsibility. That warning remains relevant today. Britain needs investment, industrial renewal, functioning public services and a government prepared to use its democratic powers. Instead, Labour appears increasingly interested in reopening yesterday's constitutional arguments rather than confronting today's economic failures. This is not a vision for Britain. It is a government running out of ideas, reopening old divisions and drifting towards a settlement it has no mandate to impose. The answer to Britain's problems isn't to surrender more economic decisions to the marketplace. It's to use democratic power to rebuild the country. A government out of ideas, increasingly looking like a lame duck, and heading towards an electorate whose trust it cannot take for granted. #Brexit @AngelaRayner
3
8
15
634
Paul Knaggs retweeted
Worth a read this . Well said @PaulKnaggs
To be honest, it's the bloody lies that get me. The sheer hypocrisy of it all. We're pouring billions into Ukraine while we can't even fix the potholes in our own roads, and we all know what's coming in the Autumn Budget. More belt-tightening, more sacrifices, more lectures about living within our means. Funny how that never seems to apply when they're funding a war. You see, I'm not particularly interested in what Putin does or doesn't do. When I was in the British Army, Russia and Ukraine were both part of the Soviet Union. They wore the same uniform, and either would have been perfectly willing to put a bullet in me. And I don't believe there's a cat in Siberia's chance of Putin rolling his tanks down the Champs-Élysées, heading for Calais, climbing into a bloody rubber dinghy borrowed from one of those gangs Starmer was supposed to be stopping, dodge customs and raise the red flag over Downing Street. We still have nuclear deterrence. MAD hasn't suddenly stopped working because the arms industry needs another order book filled. What does bother me is the butcher's bill in Ukraine. The hundreds of thousands of Russians and Ukrainians killed or wounded, families destroyed, entire towns reduced to rubble. And for what? How many more must die before somebody seriously pursues a negotiated settlement? Russia chose to invade on February 22; the moment it did, it stopped the Ukrainian civil war in Donbas. But pretending this conflict has nothing to do with decades of NATO expansion, Western geopolitical ambitions, military contracts and the enormous wealth tied up in oil, gas and energy markets is treating the public like fools. Remember Hunter Biden? The son of the then US Vice President somehow ended up on the board of Burisma, one of Ukraine's biggest private gas companies. That appointment certainly raised legitimate questions about political connections and influence. And then there's Nord Stream. German prosecutors are now alleging that Ukrainian operatives, acting under Ukrainian state orders, sabotaged the Nord Stream pipelines. A former Ukrainian military officer is standing trial in Germany, although he denies involvement and Kyiv denies responsibility. Meanwhile, Europe's energy market has been transformed, with American LNG exporters gaining an enormous new market as Russian pipeline supplies collapsed. Who benefited from that particular geopolitical disaster? It certainly wasn't the ordinary European household paying the gas bill. But put all that aside for a moment. Britain has now committed £25 BILLION to Ukraine. Some of that is military equipment, some financial assistance, some loans and guarantees. And even the Treasury's own accounts acknowledge significant uncertainty over recovering the £2.26 billion loan secured against profits from frozen Russian assets. Yet we're expected to tighten our belts. Schools struggling, hospitals under pressure, a housing crisis, crumbling infrastructure and an energy system that should have been brought into public ownership decades ago. Think what a serious programme of public investment could have achieved with that sort of money. As President Eisenhower warned, the military-industrial complex has an enormous appetite, and every pound spent on armaments is a pound that cannot be spent elsewhere. He understood the price of militarism wasn't measured solely in military budgets. It was measured in schools, hospitals and homes that never got built. And here's the part that really sticks in my throat. I'm old enough to remember Ukraine before February 2022, when its corruption, organised cybercrime, online fraud, human trafficking and sexual exploitation were serious international concerns. In 2021, Transparency International ranked Ukraine 122nd out of 180 countries for perceived public-sector corruption. Remember the 2017 Politico investigation reporting that Ukrainian officials had tried to help Hillary Clinton and undermine Donald Trump during the 2016 American presidential election? Remember the Ukrainian members of the FIN7 hacking organisation, responsible for enormous financial losses through international cybercrime? Or the US State Department's reports documenting human trafficking, official complicity concerns and a justice system where convicted traffickers routinely avoided prison? The Internet Watch Foundation even identified Ukraine as the world's tenth-largest hosting country for the child sexual abuse material it was trying to remove in 2020. That didn't mean Ukrainians had produced all that material, but it was a serious problem. These weren't inventions of Russian propagandists. They were documented by Western governments, investigators and international organisations. And corruption didn't magically disappear when the first Russian tanks crossed the border. Ukraine has continued to face corruption scandals during the war. Yet now we're endlessly lectured about Russian bots, foreign influence and threats to Western democracy, pushed by useful idiots and sock puppets on social media while questions about Ukraine's own record are treated as though asking them makes you a Kremlin sympathiser. I don't buy it. None of this diminishes the suffering of ordinary Ukrainians. But it doesn't oblige me to abandon my judgement, overlook corruption or accept that British taxpayers should finance an open-ended military commitment without proper scrutiny. £25 billion committed, with more to come. All going to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky who rode to power on pledges to clean up the Eastern European country, but the Pandora Papers reveal he and his close circle were the beneficiaries of a network of offshore companies, including some that owned expensive London property. I want a full, independent audit. How much has actually been spent? Where has it gone? Which companies received the contracts? Who has profited, and what has been delivered? Because when the Autumn Budget arrives and we're told there's no money for our schools, hospitals, housing or infrastructure, I'd like to know why there's always another few billion available for Ukraine. Before they ask the British working class to tighten their belts again, they can bloody well open the books; let's see where all that money's going. @PaulKnaggs , @HeartlandsTrib occrp.org/en/project/the-pan…
1
1
33
🔴Manchester City Scandal: Andy Burnham By @HeartlandsTrib and @PaulKnaggs The Manchester City scandal has opened a door. Behind it sits @andyburnham, a Gulf billionaire, £55.7 MILLION in public-backed loans and nine Greater Manchester councils underwriting financial risk. And here is the real scandal. Across a £1.2 BILLION public housing loan fund, 11,000 homes were built. Fewer than 500 met the affordable housing threshold. The loans were repaid with interest. But that is not the question. Who was this public money really meant to serve? Burnham calls his economic model 'Manchesterism'. He presents it as the end of neoliberalism. Our investigation follows the money, the offshore companies and the council documents to examine what that really means. The workers built Manchester. But who owns the hive? Should public housing funds be judged by the profits they return or the affordable homes they deliver? Read the full Tribune investigation: Manchester City Scandal: Inside Andy Burnham’s Manchesterism 👇 heartlandstribune.com/manche…
FOOTBALL IS A GAME OF TWO HALVES. THE SECOND HALF IS PLAYED WITH YOUR MONEY. The Manchester City scandal has opened a door. Behind it sits Andy Burnham, a Gulf billionaire, £55.7 MILLION in public-backed loans and nine Greater Manchester councils underwriting financial risk. And here is the real scandal. Across a £1.2 BILLION public housing loan fund, 11,000 homes were built. Fewer than 500 met the affordable housing threshold. The loans were repaid with interest. But that is not the question. Who was this public money really meant to serve? Burnham calls his economic model 'Manchesterism'. He presents it as the end of neoliberalism. Our investigation follows the money, the offshore companies and the council documents to examine what that really means. The workers built Manchester. But who owns the hive? Should public housing funds be judged by the profits they return or the affordable homes they deliver? Read the full Tribune investigation: Manchester City Scandal: Inside Andy Burnham’s Manchesterism 👇 heartlandstribune.com/manche… #ManchesterCity #AndyBurnham
5
11
649
Thorough analysis in a terrific piece by @PaulKnaggs @HeartlandsTrib on the relationship between women and unions, who are supposed to represent all workers. ‘It is a statement released on the day of the Women’s Conference, by a movement whose largest affiliates are made up overwhelmingly of low-paid women. The word “women” does not appear in it once’ Headlines: The Women’s Rights Law the Unions Want Changed Section 28 Comparison is the Wrong Ghost to Summon What Happened to the Darlington Nurses? Who Represented Women When the Unions Did Not? Sandie Peggie’s Case Against the RCN Women’s Rights and the Limits of Union Solidarity ‘Eleven unions found one voice this morning to say that trans rights are workers’ rights. They are. There is one more sentence the movement needs to say just as clearly, and today, on the day of the Women’s Conference, not one of them could bring themselves to say it.’ 👏👏👏 heartlandstribune.com/labour…
4
57
4
145
5,707
FOOTBALL IS A GAME OF TWO HALVES. THE SECOND HALF IS PLAYED WITH YOUR MONEY. The Manchester City scandal has opened a door. Behind it sits Andy Burnham, a Gulf billionaire, £55.7 MILLION in public-backed loans and nine Greater Manchester councils underwriting financial risk. And here is the real scandal. Across a £1.2 BILLION public housing loan fund, 11,000 homes were built. Fewer than 500 met the affordable housing threshold. The loans were repaid with interest. But that is not the question. Who was this public money really meant to serve? Burnham calls his economic model 'Manchesterism'. He presents it as the end of neoliberalism. Our investigation follows the money, the offshore companies and the council documents to examine what that really means. The workers built Manchester. But who owns the hive? Should public housing funds be judged by the profits they return or the affordable homes they deliver? Read the full Tribune investigation: Manchester City Scandal: Inside Andy Burnham’s Manchesterism 👇 heartlandstribune.com/manche… #ManchesterCity #AndyBurnham
6
44
3
50
2,442