The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher) header
The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher) profile picture

PhD philosopher and committed Protestant. Teaching The Object Test, a live masterclass on Catholic miracles, Nov 14. Enroll at link below.

Joined January 2022
Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)Photo by The Protestant Philosopher (@ProtPhilosopher)
Enrollment is open for The Object Test, my live masterclass on Catholic miracles. Saturday, November 14, 9–11 a.m. Pacific, on Zoom. I grant every miracle, Fatima, Lourdes, Lanciano, Padre Pio, and show why none of them obliges an informed Christian to accept Rome. We’ll run the test on each case, take on the best-explanation and probability arguments, and answer your questions live. Workbook, three bonus guides and the recording included. Enrollment closes Thursday, November 12. Save your seat: protestantacademy.com/the-ob…
1
8
481
Enrollment for the masterclass on miracles closes tonight at 11:59 p.m. Pacific. Gain a powerful approach to addressing the Catholic miracles. Discover why you can rationally embrace the resurrection yet deny that the Catholic miracles vindicate Rome. Stay Protestant with a clear conscience, even granting that the miracles happened. Don't miss out on this unique opportunity. Enroll now. protestantacademy.com/the-ob…
2
170
Do the Catholic miracles oblige you to submit your mind and will to Rome? Learn why this is not the case, even granting something miraculous occurred. Only two days left to sign up for my live masterclass this Saturday. Get a workbook, three powerful bonus guides, and access to the replay for a year. Get peace of mind surrounding the Catholic miracle claims. Save your seat now: protestantacademy.com/the-ob…
234
Replying to @OrdinariateCath
For the sake of argument, I grant what each miracle was given to confirm, per the actual historical record. Then I show this doesn't get you the conclusion they want, namely you don't get confirmation of the Roman Catholic church as a divine legate such that you are obligated to believe it as such, let alone obligated to submit to it on that basis.
1
49
Good timing on this release. Ethan states his main aim directly. "The main thing we're trying to establish is the claim that the Catholic Church is a divine legate, that speaks on behalf of God, that has divine sanction, that can bind people's consciences, that this is the organ that God has established to transmit and interpret the revelation he has proposed to humanity." That's the exact inference my masterclass next Saturday equips people to answer. I grant the miracles. The question is what each one was given to confirm. protestantacademy.com/the-ob…
Ethan Muse | Out Now on The Daily Wire | YouTube 11/9
2
1
22
1,966
By way of a brief meta-commentary, this is you doing exactly what James suggested. I appreciate the rigor and care in defining terms. My OP just asked for the same thing when it came to titling videos. I would assume this is something you could get behind. Instead, you seem bent on defensiveness and pointing fingers. I never even pointed fingers in the OP, as it's a general thing I come across in many different camps. So, I think James's points still stand, though he admitted they could have been worded less sharply.
2
35
I addressed this above. The grade is not mine. Rome grades the Fatima messages as "probable and credible to peity." It doesn't grade the resurrection that way.
1
28
"Rome says so" isn't a mere implication I'm drawing out. Here is Rome literally saying so: "Private revelation is a help to this faith, and shows its credibility precisely by leading me back to the definitive public Revelation. In this regard, Cardinal Prospero Lambertini, the future Pope Benedict XIV, says in his classic treatise, which later became normative for beatifications and canonizations: 'An assent of Catholic faith is not due to revelations approved in this way; it is not even possible. These revelations seek rather an assent of human faith in keeping with the requirements of prudence, which puts them before us as probable and credible to piety.' The Flemish theologian E. Dhanis, an eminent scholar in this field, states succinctly that ecclesiastical approval of a private revelation has three elements: the message contains nothing contrary to faith or morals; it is lawful to make it public; and the faithful are authorized to accept it with prudence... Such a message can be a genuine help in understanding the Gospel and living it better at a particular moment in time; therefore it should not be disregarded. It is a help which is offered, but which one is not obliged to use." (Ratzinger, "Theological Commentary," in CDF's The Message of Fatima, 2000). The revelations (messages) are "probable and credible to piety." This applies to the messages, not to the miracles as such. And the message is where the case for Rome has to come from. That's why, in part, you don't get an obligation to submit to Rome out of Fatima.
1
36
A couple of clarifications. My claim is about the messages the signs are given to confirm, not simply the signs. I agree human faith doesn't rule out certainty regarding the signs as a general rule. Rather, when it comes to private revelation, which are the sort of claims about the Pope, Russia, etc. that people put to the signs, those are probable and credible to piety. In part, this is because they can mix with natural error regarding their reception, even assuming a sincere and honest seer. The vindicatory argument needs the messages, and the part that might uniquely select Rome is graded, by Rome, as probable. So the sign doesn't result in certainty about the message it was given to confirm. That can be the case even granting that the sun was a certain sign that the Lady appeared to the kids, say.
1
25
Love it! And by way of encouragement you (Kevin) and Wagner are doing interesting work that I hope to address down the road. I will engage your content, and I look forward to our future dialogue.
1
16
My video isn't an example of the pet peeve. I don't make an unrestricted impossibility claim. I offer a restricted claim relative to a base, namely how the Church herself classifies these. I argue that Rome classifies these as private revelation calling for human faith and prudence. They can be mixed with natural error. That means they can't meet the "most certain sign" threshold the vincicatory argument needs. That was my overall claim. It wasn't just, as you suggest, not part of deposit, not part of divine faith, thus doesn't prove Catholicism.
1
1
74
With all due respect, Kevin, you're making my point by providing those thumbnails. None of them makes an unrestricted impossibility claim. My point wasn't a general complaint about a mismatch between title-thumb-content. Rather, my point was about titles that make an unrestricted impossibility claim while the content only delivers something weaker. Your video is interesting because you do try to do more than most videos with that title. But, we only get a contradiction relative to certain assumptions and you quote Hollaz as rejecting one of them. So, you don't end up arguing "Sola Scriptura is Still Impossible." Rather, you end up arguing something like Sola Scriptura is impossible given the canon is known by divine faith and inspiration is knowable only by revelation. Not all Protestants embrace those assumptions, so a more accurate title might be "Sola Scriptura Is Still Impossible Given Divine Faith in the Canon." Unrestricted impossibility claims are misleading in this regard. And, I wasn't offering advice. Rather, I was simply offering a pet peeve.
1
22
Replying to @ewinsberg @rowbott1
I see. I think that might help me. If logical possibility is the only unrestricted form of possibility, then the bare claim 'X is impossible' owes us a contradiction or needs to be stated relative to some base. The video needs to make good on the contradiction or the title should show what the claim is being held relative to, namely 'X is impossible given Y'. Though, as I'm sure you're aware, many in the phil rel space would resist your suggestion that metaphysical modality isn't free floating. If you do embrace that suggestion, do you think it undercuts the debate over whether there's a necessary being?
1
25
Three bonus guides are now included with The Object Test masterclass. Answers to the 34 strongest objections, the 1917 Fatima documents with translations, and the whole argument in nine principles. Live Saturday, November 14. Enrollment closes November 12. Save your seat: protestantacademy.com/the-ob…
1
254
Replying to @rowbott1 @ewinsberg
And, yes, possible world semantics was just one way of making good on the impossibility claim in the title. I'm fine with cashing out modality in another semantics.
1
26
Replying to @rowbott1 @ewinsberg
That's a fair point. Perhaps my original phrasing was too narrow. Nomological impossibility is a legit sense of 'impossible'. I see that's what Eric was getting at. That case works because the argument, if it succeeds, offers the modal force that his claim makes. My overall point, to be more specific, is that there's often a mismatch between titles that claim impossibility and the arguments in the video that only offer improbability.
1
1
16
The Protestant Philosopher retweeted
You claimed it was logically impossible. Ergo, impossible in every possible world. This is precisely @ProtPhilosopher’s point. You guys don’t even seem to understand the extent of the claims you’re making. And this is especially ironic because you’re constantly calling out other Protestant apologists (rightfully so, btw) for being ignorant and overconfident on matters such as sola scriptura, for not being sufficiently well-read, and so forth. For example, you rightly criticize Protestants for making claims without understanding the concepts behind them, or even what the relevant authorities in the field mean by those concepts. You’ve pointed out, for instance, that Reformed scholastics such as Turretin, LeBlanc, and others understood sola scriptura in terms of Scripture being the sole rule of faith, rather than merely “the only infallible authority.” You complain about Protestants being ignorant of these distinctions, and at times borderline mock them for it (as do others in your camp, such as @DoorDashThomist and @WalmartThomist). But then you turn around and do the very same thing when making claims such as “logically impossible,” without apparently understanding even the basic entailments of what you’re claiming. Namely, that to establish logical impossibility, you need to demonstrate that the proposition entails a contradiction, such as P and not-P in the same sense and at the same time. Moreover, your comment about MCU only further demonstrates that you don’t seem to understand the very modal terms you’re employing, such as “impossible.” And this is what makes you guys come across as hypocrites. On the one hand, you mock people and demand precision and accuracy on niche and esoteric theological matters. But on the other, when you make similarly uninformed claims, you either ignore the criticism or brush it aside. You’re essentially doing the very thing you criticize independent fundamentalist Baptists for doing in sola scriptura debates, except now it’s with elementary modal claims. Do better, man.
1
1
3
225
Replying to @ewinsberg
That's a well-qualified statement that concerns a practical matter. I'm talking about an unqualified statement that concerns doctrine (e.g. Sola Scriptura is Impossible).
1
1
204
This article from Dr. Morris is worth checking out. It supports my earlier pet peeve from another angle. A weaker assertion often results in a stronger argument, or, as I'd put it, a stronger assertion in the title of a video often results in a weaker argument (i.e., one that doesn't deliver on the promise in the title).
2
4
438
Replying to @DoloresGMorris
Thanks for sharing your article, Dolores. Well said, "An atheistic-yet-morally-robust universe seems wildly unlikely; the worldview strikes me as highly implausible. Still, it may be possible." Instead of a title like "Sola Scriptura is IMPOSSIBLE" where the person argues it is unlikely to be true given reasons x, y, and z. A weaker assertion that yields a stronger argument is "Sola Scriptura is Very IMPROBABLE." This supports my peeve from another way. A stronger title often results in a weaker argument.
3
37
It doesn’t happen every time, but when I do let the modal reading lead my curiosity I'm almost always let down and feel tricked. I start to make a heuristic like, "If S says 'X is impossible' they don't mean what impossibility typically means in argumentation, they just mean X has problems that they think are really bad," which is why it’s a pet peeve. Just say X faces tough objections. Lol.
2
83