
Former boss of @CPSThinkTank and @CapX, Sunday columnist for @thetimes, author of 'The Great Acceleration'. Politics, policy and parenting.
London
Joined December 2008
- Tweets1K
- Following2.9K
- Followers66.3K
- Likes76.3K
Just the 86% of the vote for @JamesCleverly in the Tory mayoral contest...
Robert Colvile retweeted
Exactly. This amounts to stripping opportunity from those out of work.
Google really has made search impossible if you're looking for something more than a couple of years old.
Useful guide to the most dickish football players from a referee's perspective nytimes.com/athletic/7793263…
2
1
1,366
Robert Colvile retweeted
And the more likely it is the company fails to grow or goes under
Not boasting (OK, massively boasting) but when children were much younger we overheard the steward saying as we filed off that he'd never thought about having kids but they'd been so cute/well behaved/responsive that maybe he had a gift for childcare
Robert Colvile retweeted
That the Elizabeth Line is now one in six journeys also tells us that the rest of the network was designed for a Victorian economy, not a modern one.
Robert Colvile retweeted
Musk is wrong here, of course. What he says is untrue and Kremlin propaganda. I was on Maidan, every day from start to finish. (I even wrote a book about it.) There are few people who can organize and mobilize like Ukrainians. The CIA wishes it could foment uprisings as quickly and efficiently as Ukrainians can.
The simple facts are:
Ukrainians came out to protest Yanukovvych's turn away from the EU and towards Russia.
Those protests turned to large-scale uprising after violence perpetrated by Yanukovych's security forces.
It swelled into a revolution by Ukrainians who were fed up with state violence and worried about the direction Yanukovych was taking their country.
Yanukovych agreed a deal for power sharing and early elections, but then fled.
After Yanukovych fled and abandoned his constitutional duties, Ukraine's parliament voted to remove him.
Moreover, Putin and Russia began preparing for the invasion of Ukraine before Yanukovych was ousted. You can look at the Kharkiv Pact in 2010, and the start of operations in February 2014, before Yanukovych fled.
Robert Colvile retweeted
Study of inclusionary zoning in California (US equivalent of UK's affordable housing regs) shows that it cuts housebuilding by a third, drives up rents for everyone. The evidence is increasingly overwhelming for the damage these policies are doing.
Robert Colvile retweeted
A thought on the productivity revamp - if the big problem is not working enough hours (vs output during those hours), doesn’t it make tackling tax/benefit cliff edges even more important? Artificially constraining hours worked all over the place.
A thought on the productivity revamp - if the big problem is not working enough hours (vs output during those hours), doesn’t it make tackling tax/benefit cliff edges even more important? Artificially constraining hours worked all over the place.
Robert Colvile retweeted
The evidence is become clear - we YIMBYs over in the UK need to start having this debate about the benefits of removing or lessening affordable home requirements.
People can be convinced but it's going to take time.
Study of inclusionary zoning in California (US equivalent of UK's affordable housing regs) shows that it cuts housebuilding by a third, drives up rents for everyone. The evidence is increasingly overwhelming for the damage these policies are doing.
Full paper here, via @Noahpinion. See also @CPSThinkTank's report last week on components of UK housing costs, which estimated a £200k affordable tithe for the average London flat. bpb-us-e2.wpmucdn.com/sites.…
7
1,105
Full paper here, via @Noahpinion. See also @CPSThinkTank's work on UK costs! bpb-us-e2.wpmucdn.com/sites.…
748
Robert Colvile retweeted
The English used to LOVE violent entertainment. A German visitor, stuck at Harwich in 1710 with nothing to do, reports:
"As we were about to go home, we saw on the shore a truly English, or rather devilish, entertainment.
Some lords who were also waiting, like us, for the packet-boat to sail had promised two young boatmen a crown, to pass the time, if they would strip naked to the breeches and fight each other with their fists for it.
They did so with such violence, and grew so enraged with each other, that not only were their faces quite bloody, but their bodies were so covered in bruises that they looked as if they were wearing a blue apron.
Whenever they wanted to stop, the Englishmen threw them another shilling to keep them going. It was getting dark, and it looked so disgraceful that we went away.
We were assured that this is a regular pastime of English passengers here. The dissolute young boatmen do it every day for the money, and after they have drunk together again they become the best of friends."
Robert Colvile retweeted
This morning's @nypost cover
Robert Colvile retweeted
.@paulfchristiano thinks that on the current trajectory (absent any slowing down), there is a 1 in 3 chance that we could have superintelligence powerful enough to overthrow the government within a year. (He articulates a concrete scenario).
He argues that the labs should pause further algorithmic progress until they can secure their weights and research secrets. Otherwise China could simply steal the superintelligence in the middle of the intelligence explosion, and the labs would no longer be able to slow down even if they saw their models going off the rails.
He also explains how AIs will be trained during the intelligence explosion, and why even a system trained entirely inside a data center could still have the capabilities profile such that humans would have very little chance of competing with it or controlling it.
And he discusses the plan for alignment - basically, making a superintelligence that actually does what we ask the way we mean it. Fixing reward hacks and building better graders will help up till the next few model generations, but he thinks that no single current approach has better than even odds of letting us control superintelligence. The hope is that the AIs figure out the solution to this problem during the intelligence explosion.
Paul is head of the Alignment Research Center. Previously, he was head of AI safety at the US AI Safety Institute. Before that, he led alignment at OpenAI, where he invented RLHF. He’s recently joined OpenAI’s board (though here he is speaking as a private citizen).
Robert Colvile retweeted
What if I told you that a fifth of people coming here on “Global Talent Visas” aren’t paying a penny of income tax?
Not because they’re getting a tax cut, but because despite being considered exceptional “global talent” they earn less than £12,570!
The Global Talent visa is supposed to bring in only the very best and brightest people. The next Elon Musk. The next Einstein. Not the next welfare recipient.
It sounds mad, but that’s what the Government’s Migration Advisory Committee admitted this week. And the visa is becoming more popular no wonder!
Last year alone, 16,700 of these visas were granted – a new record.
I know previous governments got a lot wrong on immigration; there’s no shying away from that. But let’s be clear now: anyone who comes here should earn enough to support themselves and be a tax net contributor.
The numbers should always be low, that’s why we would set a cap on immigration.
Over the past 4 years, 55,200 people have come here on global talent visas — and as many as 21% in some years earned less than £12,571. That’s ridiculous.
And the median income for main applicants is just £42,800. Barely above the average full-time salary in Britain. And that ignores their often-non-contributing dependents.
That raises a lot of questions.
Why are the salaries so low? Why are large numbers of supposed global talents earning less than half the minimum wage? How are they supporting themselves? Why are they here? And who is making these assessments and getting it so wrong, so often!
We saw how in the past how easily a visa route intended for “skilled” migrants ends up being abused to give visas to curry houses and kebab shops.
The committee estimates that the bottom 20% receiving a global talent visa could actually cost the taxpayer money over their lifetime.
The government should act now to prevent this.
It makes sense to have visas for the very small number of people who are genuinely incredible global talents. People who found businesses worth billions and employing thousands. Creatives like Steven Spielberg, or a scientist who will invent the next cure for cancer.
But immigration has been too high for too long, and it’s the British taxpayer being forced to pay the bill and see their communities change. The rules need to be tough and they need to applied rigorously and with accountability for those making decisions.
As Shadow Chancellor I am working closely with the Shadow Home Secretary to ensure we control and reduce immigration.
The government has shamefully bottled their reforms to ILR, they should act now before things get worse.
Robert Colvile retweeted
Replying to @rcolvile
The ONS Labour Market Survey stats July 2024 to Nov 2026 show that micro-firm hiring has collapsed. 38% down on the year. The cost of dealing with a termination post 6-month, if the ex-employee makes a vexatious claim is £50K+ for legal fees - none of which are claimable, after a 4-year wait to get into the ET. That's a game no-one wants to play. Vexatious claimants know it is cheaper for firms to pay up - but micro firms don't have that sort of money to pay out. Hence, no hiring.
















