I think the fun thing about Clayface’s critical and audience performance is that it really does leave room for any and all opinions towards the film without one having to overshadow the other. I’ve seen people say that Clayface is better than Joker 1. I’ve seen people say that it’s just okay. I’ve seen people say that it’s a major letdown. There is no correct opinion, and the only definitively wrong one is that it’s DC’s Morbius. I like that tbh, it reminds me of when we could just watch a movie and form our own opinion without someone having to whisper in our ear how popular or unpopular that opinion is. If you said back in June that you actually really liked Supergirl and believe it’s a great film, you’d have several people telling you how bad of an opinion that is solely because it doesn’t match the masses. That’s not really the case here, and I really appreciate that. That’s my kind of cinema.

Wait…. Y’all was being dead serious blaming Matt Reeves for no Batman in the DCU???😭 The guy who made a masterpiece Batman movie that we were all wanting a sequel to?? And has been cooking from all we’ve heard? That’s y’all target right now?? Why not just blame… idk… JAMES GUNN???😭 Nobody told Gunn or Safran that they can’t have two Batman movies in production at the same time. Thats just James Gunn respecting Reeves wishes and wanting to give him space at the cost of his own Batman. I am extremely excited for DCU Batman and I think that character has great potential to be the most definitive Batman ever, but y’all are wylin blaming Reeves as if he told James Gunn he can’t make a Batman movie😭😭😭

They have two. And neither of them are as well written as John Stewart.

To be entirely fair………… When you’re defending peak, you kinda have the right to be a little toxic….

Absolutely not❤️.

All that hate in your soul gonna make your hair turn grey, Mr Rocha💀

Ugh I’m gonna be sick 🫩….

Landing in the top 10 with only 4 episodes at the time is not ‘very poorly’, especially when your numbers increase weekly every episode. Superman released off the heels of 10 years of bad DCEU movies and a tarnished legacy where the last 8 movies couldn’t even crack 400M. Leaving the box office with 600M and pulling off the PVOD numbers it did IS absolutely still a success. Clayface is a low budget low marketed horror film about a C List character and has been received extremely well by audiences both in the superhero and horror realm. Nobody expected it to make 800M. And, yes. Supergirl was a poorly received movie. Every franchise has a poorly received movie. The Incredible Hulk, the MCU’s second outing, was a poorly received movie. The issue with your argument is that it lacks both nuance and context. The DCU doesn’t exist in the early 2000s or 90s where a movie will be an immediate smash hit if it has a superhero in it. It exists in the 2020s where it’s more common for a superhero IP film to flop than it is to make billions. The issue isn’t you saying that DC has untapped potential. The issue is you believing that DC copying Marvel will help them tap into that potential.