Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife) header
Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife) profile picture

Demanding accountability for Oakland District 3. Public records show Carroll Fife’s pattern of self-dealing and failed leadership. Join the recall effort!

Oakland, CA
Joined June 2026
Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)Photo by Recall Carroll Fife (@RecallFife)
The People of Oakland vs. Carroll Fife and her Husband. It’s time to recall her from the Oakland City Council. Public records, state investigations, and her own voting record reveal a consistent pattern of SELF-DEALING, family enrichment, and policies that have damaged District 3. Here’s the full picture: 1. The $2.1 Million Self-Dealing Scandal During her 2020 campaign, Fife was listed as President of Affect Real Change when her husband’s group submitted a bid for a massive security contract at Peralta Colleges. She resigned just 10 days before the board approved the $2,100,000 deal. One official contact number on the documents rang her personal cell phone. The organization had no required state security license and was later fined $5,000. The contract collapsed in embarrassment. 2. Family Enrichment at Public Expense After she took office, her family-controlled non-profit saw revenue explode from roughly $100,000 to over $3,100,000 in a single year. In 2022 alone her husband received $147,000, her mother received $84,791, and a close associate received $105,361. The same non-profit received $400,000 from an anti-police group she has repeatedly supported with city policy. 3. She Helped Defund the Police Fife was a primary architect of the 2021 budget move that stripped $17,400,000 from the Oakland Police Department. Mayor Schaaf warned this would cost 50 officers and delay emergency response times. She then cast the lone dissenting vote against $2,250,000 for automated license plate readers — tools proven to recover stolen vehicles and catch violent offenders. District 3 has suffered the consequences. 4. Radical Rejection of Property Rights Through the Moms 4 Housing operation she orchestrated, Fife publicly defended the ILLEGAL occupation of private property and told the press “there’s nothing more American than taking over a property.” She framed private ownership as colonialism and systemic violence. This is not mainstream Oakland. 5. Loyalty to Recalled Failures Fife was one of the loudest defenders of Mayor Sheng Thao and DA Pamela Price — both removed from office by decisive voter recalls in 2024. She dismissed the recalls as attacks by billionaires rather than legitimate public frustration with crime and dysfunction. She remains the highest-profile survivor of that FAILED coalition. 6. Pattern of Steering Contracts to Allies A formal complaint to the Oakland Public Ethics Commission alleged she interfered in city operations and attempted to steer lucrative trash-capture contracts to her domestic partner. While dismissed on narrow jurisdictional grounds, the pattern mirrors the earlier Peralta scandal. – at Oakland, CA
5
5
2
41
2,094
Carroll Fife built her career defending squatters and campaigning to defund the police. City Journal just named her as one of the officials responsible for Oakland’s experiment in anarchy. The Manhattan Institute piece lays out the results. Oakland’s violent crime rate is still roughly four and a half times the national average. The city solves property crimes at a rate of about 0.1 percent, meaning one arrest for every thousand reported crimes. It hauls away 20 million pounds of illegally dumped trash every year. Landlords now hire private “squatter removal” crews because the sheriff’s office takes months to act. The article puts Fife in the same sentence as recalled former mayor Sheng Thao and Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas. It says a powerful subset of Oakland’s political class seems to encourage the ambient anarchy. Fife rose to prominence defending the rights of squatters. She campaigned on promises to defund the police. She has spent years opposing practical public safety tools while her district lives with the consequences. This is not a messaging problem. It is the record. She defended the behavior. She voted against the tools. Oakland is still cleaning up the mess. city-journal.org/article/oak… – at Oakland, CA
2
9
38
583
Carroll Fife is the most disliked councilmember on the Oakland City Council. The Oakland Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce commissioned a poll through FM3 Research of 720 likely voters. When District 3 residents were asked about their own councilmember, Fife came back at 37% favorable and 40% unfavorable. Every other councilmember on the list is net positive with the voters in their own district. She is the exception. These are the people who live with the results of her tenure. They see the vacant storefronts, the violence, the meetings she misses, and the developers she poses with. They have decided the record does not match the rhetoric. Citywide the council is already weak. In her own district the rejection is personal. Oakland’s District 3 has already told her no. It’s time we #RecallCarrollFife! – at Oakland, CA
2
9
1
40
839
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
🦇 Gotham Oakland, The Final Season: Secret FBI Recordings Expose $85M Corruption Deal! On Day 9, secret recordings presented in court reveal conversations involving David Duong, Mario Juarez, Andre Jones, an $85 million Oakland housing deal, alleged demands for money, and efforts to influence city contracts. The FBI evidence also includes surprising references to Councilmember Carroll Fife and Moms 4 Housing. 🎧 Hear the recordings and judge the evidence for yourself.
6
30
1
78
2,173
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
🦇 Gotham Oakland, The Final Season: Carroll Fife's $85 MILLION Contradiction Exposed in FBI Wiretap! Somebody’s lying. Is it Carroll Fife or Andy Duong? An FBI wiretap reveals Andy Duong claiming Fife discussed $85 million in approved funding in January 2024. Six months later, Fife told The Oaklandside there was no funding for her homeless shelter proposal. Why Fife isn't being called to testify in the Sheng Thao corruption trial? Watch and find out!
2
8
1
32
988
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
East Bay Insiders just published the Alameda County Ballot Watchdog Committee’s review of November measures, and Oakland’s Measure EE got the worst score of the entire county: 1.8 out of 5. The committee does not take sides on policy. It only grades whether the ballot summary is accurate, impartial, and informative. EE failed. They said it crams too many changes into one question, uses vague language about “additional provisions,” and never explains the financial consequences. That is not an accident. Measure EE rewrites the city charter so the mayor becomes CEO with a veto over laws and a line-item veto over the budget. It also hands the Public Ethics Commission power to reset elected pay. The City Auditor’s impartial analysis puts the annual cost at $2 million to $2.6 million, with council raises estimated at $36,000 to $108,000 each. None of that is clear on the ballot. Barbara Lee broke a 4-4 council tie to put this on the ballot for the office she holds. The official argument against it, signed by Loren Taylor and others, already called it a power grab. Now the neutral ballot watchdogs are saying the language itself hides what voters are actually approving. When City Hall writes a ballot question that scores a 1.8, the safest vote is no. Do not hand Barbara Lee more power. Vote NO on Measure EE. Ballots are already out. OaklandPowerGrab.com – at Oakland, CA
1
3
2
14
463
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
“IT’S NOT REALLY A DATA CENTER” The Carroll Fife Remix
1
3
11
766
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Oakland councilwoman Carroll Fife seeks to spin her press conference with data center CEO. 🎥 Carroll Fife (District 3) posted a video of her remarks at a recent city council meeting, stating, "I wanna be clear once and for all that the reason I hosted that press conference was so that the [data center] developer could talk to the public through the media." 🎥 At that August 14 press conference, Fife defended the proposed data center as “not the large-scale mega facility that people have expressed” — directly contradicting anti-data center activists' claims about the project. oaklandreport.news/x/h-oakla…
1
2
1
4
562
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Since 2022, I have been sounding the alarm about Sheng Thao, Carroll Fife, Rebecca Kaplan, Nikki Bas, and the culture of corruption, backroom dealing, incompetence, and political protection that has infected Oakland City Hall. Very soon, the entire city is going to have to confront just how much of what I warned about was real. Remember what happened along the way. City resources were used against me. Our City Attorney’s Office came after me. Oakland officials sought restraining orders against me. I was attacked, smeared, called crazy, dismissed, and repeatedly portrayed as the problem while I kept documenting what was happening in this city. It didn’t work. I kept talking. I kept organizing. I led the recall of the mayor. And for hundreds of episodes of Gotham Oakland, I kept the receipts. Now Sheng Thao is federally indicted, the Duongs are headed to trial with her, witnesses from across Oakland government are being called, recordings are coming out, and years of relationships and decisions inside City Hall are about to receive a level of scrutiny they have never received before. The train has left the station. And when more comes out, remember who was willing to say these things publicly when doing so came with a price—and who attacked the messenger, looked the other way, or defended the machine. So if you spent the last four years silent about Oakland corruption but suddenly have something to say about me, PLEASE DO. I want everyone to see it. They tried to make me shut up. I didn’t. They tried to discredit me. They couldn’t. They tried to make me go away. I’m still here and still fighting corruption in Oakland City Hall. And I am going to be EXTREMELY vocal as the receipts come out. Game on. NO CORRUPTION IN OAKLAND!!!
8
38
3
215
2,643
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Whose district is it? Carroll Fife promoter of failed socialist extremist DSA-ALIGNED policies!
1
1
58
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Oakland data center moratorium: council member juices stats, plays both sides of issue. Carroll Fife stood with the data center's CEO last month and said the proposed Oakland data center 'is not the large-scale mega facility that people have expressed.' Now she is proposing a moratorium citing 'mega' data centers that use 5 million gallons of water per day. But Oakland's would only use an estimated 5,100 gallons. A baseball field uses more. oaklandreport.org/p/data-cen…
2
6
10
610
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Oakland council member trying to stop a data center going in at 415 20 Street. The building previously housed a supercomputing facility. Did anyone complain about that? And, technically, what's the difference? Both need power and water. oaklandside.org/2026/09/11/d…
12
11
2
68
1,189
People are saying Carroll Fife got bought. Then she got scared and reversed course. Behring Capital hired a City Hall lobbyist to “establish a relationship” with Oakland elected officials. Weeks later Fife stood next to CEO Colin Behring and sold his project on camera. She said she was still forming her opinion. She gave him the photo op anyway. That is what a bought politician looks like. The lobbyist opens the door. The councilmember shows up. The developer gets the shot. Residents get a lecture. Then the petition exploded and her own base turned. She scolded them for tone. “I’ve got y’all,” she said, after already standing with the CEO. Now a council meeting is coming and she wants a 45-day moratorium so she can pretend she was leading. She did not grow a conscience. She got caught. First the lobbyist. Then the cameras. Then the flip. Allegedly paid or not, she chose the developer when it was easy and the pause when it got hot. Oakland should treat that like what it is. Recall Flip Flop Fife. – at Oakland, CA
2
8
2
41
923
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
Told ya so..... Carroll Fife's name is ALL OVER ALL OF THESE FBI wiretaps. It's a wrap for her, I have told y'all for YEARS, and also PROVED that she's corrupt. I CANNOT WAIT for this trail. It's time to CLEAN UP OAKLAND
8
34
2
151
1,972
Recall Carroll Fife retweeted
That her at his funeral. Wearing RED 😡
1
6
25
562
Just 3 weeks after Oakland Police Officer Tuan Le was murdered in the line of duty, Andy Duong told another official what Carroll Fife’s reaction had been. Le was 36. He was a Vietnamese immigrant, a West Oakland community resource officer, and the first Oakland cop killed on the job in nearly 15 years. Mayor Sheng Thao said the tragedy cut the city deep. According to a newly filed court transcript from the Thao corruption case, Fife was furious about that statement. Duong said Fife hit him up wanting Evolutionary Homes units placed in West Oakland for a press release. He said she was “hella mad” that Thao talked about Le’s death. Then he quoted her: “What the fuck about all these other women that lost their life? You didn’t say shit about it.” That is how she treated a murdered officer. Not honor. Not condolences. A complaint that the mayor had dared to name him. The same filing puts Fife in the middle of the Evolutionary Homes push with the Duongs, the company now at the center of a federal bribery trial. She wanted the units and the press hit. She did not want the city lingering on a dead cop. Oakland buried Tuan Le. His partner watched him get shot in the head. His family sat through the memorial. Fife, in Duong’s account, used that moment to score a political point and hustle a housing photo op. This is the public safety record in one conversation. An officer is killed. She argues about the statement. Then she asks where the units can go. Recall Carroll Fife Now! – at Oakland, CA
4
12
1
44
755