Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone) profile picture

Mathematical statistician. Conservative. Skeptical. Vietnam veteran (Army medic). Emigrated from California over 5 decades ago. Even stranger to be 80.

Joined June 2014
Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)Photo by Robert Tarone (@RobertTarone)
A balanced and careful (typical for Mathison) discussion of the latest MAHA paper on possible reproductive effects of glyphosate.
Glyphosate & GBH Exposures Male Reproductive Health Effects (DTT/NIEHS) substack.com/@allthingstox/n…
12
Excellent critique of the latest MAHA attempt to scare the public about glyphosate. The grift continues.
Replying to @30ASeawitch
Stupid, misrepresented MAHA “study”. Anti-glyphosate activists are at it again, promoting disinformation about the world's most widely used weedkiller. This time, they're trying to scare men into believing glyphosate makes them impotent. The latest scare, pushed by some MAHA activists, is that glyphosate is destroying men's sperm counts and testosterone levels. There's just one problem: Based on the evidence, it's not true. The alarm comes from a review of 55 animal studies requested by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s Department of Health and Human Services. Kennedy is hardly a disinterested observer. He spent years fighting glyphosate in court and earned millions of dollars as a lawyer involved in Roundup litigation. politifact.com/factchecks/20… Let's be clear: This is no new revelation about glyphosate damaging human fertility. Researchers have been studying glyphosate's reproductive effects in animals for decades and have not found that glyphosate causes reproductive harm in humans. The new review doesn't change that fundamental fact. The animal research itself is contradictory. Some studies have raised concerns about sperm counts and testosterone, while others found no reproductive damage, even at high doses. Anti-glyphosate campaigners have turned conflicting experimental findings into a warning about human fertility that the evidence does not justify. The European Food Safety Authority examined reproductive toxicity in its comprehensive 2023 glyphosate assessment. In one major animal study, researchers found reproductive effects only when rats were given enormous quantities of glyphosate, far beyond anything people encounter in everyday life. At lower doses, they found no adverse reproductive effects. In 2017, the European Chemicals Agency concluded that glyphosate is not toxic to reproduction. It reaffirmed that conclusion in 2022 after reviewing additional scientific evidence. EFSA incorporated that finding into its 2023 assessment, which drew on thousands of scientific studies and identified no critical areas of concern for glyphosate's approved uses. echa.europa.eu/en-US/-/glyph… doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2023.… efsa.europa.eu/en/news/glyph… There is no evidence that glyphosate exposure at levels people encounter in everyday life is destroying men's sperm counts or testosterone levels. The anti-glyphosate campaigners have found yet a new body part to scare people about. What they haven't found is the evidence to back up their claims.
11
Here’s a summary of the recent hysteria about chemicals in food and farming, including over glyphosate, the most commonly used herbicide. ********* Understandably, nobody wants harmful chemicals in the food they serve their families. I understand why many people might choose organic food, believing it's safer. But that's a misconception. Both organic and conventional farmers use pesticides, and some used in organic farming are far more hazardous than synthetic alternatives. Pesticides help farmers produce the healthy, safe food we want on our family's dinner table. They're the good guys in this story, not the villains. The campaign to demonize conventional farming, particularly glyphosate, generates needless fear about our food. Ironically, glyphosate is among the least toxic herbicides. Yet it is the poster child for everything supposedly dangerous about modern agriculture. There's also a widespread belief that buying organic food, which is grown without glyphosate, protects families and the environment from harmful chemicals. Not true. Take grapes. Organic grape growers in California use roughly twice as much pesticide by weight as conventional growers. Pests don't distinguish between organic and conventional farms. Both need pesticides to prevent diseases that can devastate harvests. Does that mean we should avoid California organic wine? Absolutely not. Both organic and conventional wines are safe to drink. This may startle naive consumers, but European farmers generally far use more pesticides per hectare than American farmers, with France and Belgium among the heaviest users. These include copper-based fungicides, a mainstay of organic grape growing. Copper compounds are highly toxic to aquatic and other animals, accumulate in soil, contaminate waterways and seriously poison humans. Yet organic and conventional vineyards alike depend on them to prevent devastating fungal diseases. Let's focus on the main concern, glyphosate. It' the most studied ag chemical in history. European agencies recently re-reviewed glyphosate, evaluating 2,400 studies, producing an 11,000-page assessment report and examining a supporting dossier of roughly 180,000 pages. The European Chemicals Agency unequivocally concluded just two years that glyphosate is not carcinogenic. efsa.europa.eu/en/topics/top… More than 20 scientific and regulatory bodies have evaluated glyphosate, including the U.S. EPA, Health Canada, European regulators, authorities in Germany, Australia, New Zealand and Japan, and the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization's joint pesticide panel. None of these pesticide risk authorities conclude that glyphosate poses a cancer risk at ordinary exposure levels. Health Canada stated the consensus: “No pesticide regulatory authority in the world currently considers glyphosate to be a cancer risk to humans at the levels at which humans are currently exposed.” geneticliteracyproject.org/2… The most convincing evidence comes from farmers, who face far greater exposure than consumers. The National Institutes of Health's Agricultural Health Study tracked pesticide use and cancer diagnoses among American farmers for decades. Its analysis of 54,251 pesticide applicators, nearly 45,000 of whom used glyphosate, found no association with non-Hodgkin lymphoma, the cancer at the center of the Roundup lawsuits. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2913… The traces of pesticides in our food are extraordinarily small, often measured in parts per billion. And even trillion.The glyphosate we consume in food is far below harmful levels, even over a lifetime. It doesn't build up in the body. Finding a micro/trace of a chemical tells us nothing about its danger. I understand concerns about chemicals in our food, particularly glyphosate, but the debate has become wildly disconnected from decades of research on chemical exposure and human health. Our food supply is safe, and glyphosate is a central component in ensuring that.
1
8
12
697
Outstanding discussion by Taubes of the dangers of cherry-picking evidence to wrongly claim scientific consensus in the face of considerable evidential controversy. uncertaintyprinciples.substa…
1
1
115
Apparently there have not yet been enough documentaries and films celebrating the heroic tort lawyers involved in frivolous Roundup litigation. Zaruk nails it again.
The film, "Monsanto", will likely be a tragic comedy showing how the US litigation industry is full of vain creatures willing to pay to produce films they themselves (or their family members) wrote about things they did almost a decade ago. Sad...
3
119
Zaruk’s “Firebreak” and Schachtman’s “Tortini” are must reads for anyone concerned about the current dismal state of environmental science.
Nathan Schachtman's publication, #IARCsPrecautionaryScience puts the cancer agency under the microscope. @zaruk reviews the book, the failed science, special interests, non-transparency and links to the US litigation industry. Conclusion: Shut IARC down. thefirebreak.org/p/putting-i…
1
2
55
Superb post by @zaruk. Hazard versus Risk explains many of IARC’s gifts to US predatorts, but glyphosate does not satisfy the IARC criteria for a cancer hazard. As the ECHA hazard assessment (more comprehensive and open than IARC’s) concluded, glyphosate is not a cancer hazard.
Why have I been getting so involved in the tobacco harm reduction debate? Have I given up on glyphosate, chemicals and plastics? Far from it. My latest piece shows how these issues are about the same things: zealots, poor science and bad risk management. risk-monger.com/2026/06/02/f…
1
1
48
On the incongruous exemption of the predatort litigation industry from activist concerns about industrial conflicts of interest.
Behind many high profile academic paper retractions, we find the litigation industry pulling the strings. What if the papers supporting Predatort interests were retracted following the same standards. My latest explains why such integrity isn't possible. risk-monger.com/2026/05/04/s…
30
Robert Tarone retweeted
In an executive order last week, Trump declared glyphosate an essential protected resource. Despite MAHA outrage, he's right. @zaruk explains why glyphosate is essential for sustainable farming and who is behind the activist onslaught against the herbicide thefirebreak.org/p/the-great…
2
9
6
34
10,130
Robert Tarone retweeted
Why is the State of Florida pushing disinformation about food and farming? Their new website misrepresents risk from common chemistry, further stoking distrust in farming and our institutions. My latest . @AmericanBakers @wheatworld @NAMAmillers geneticliteracyproject.org/2…
2
10
2
38
4,023
Robert Tarone retweeted
Currently- Child hitting a Kristi Noem pinata in Minneapolis
9
22
212
31,025
Agreed. Their efforts to besmirch the accurate reporting in Reuters by Kate Kelland were particularly offensive.
It's frankly stunning that the people engaged in this chicanery at IARC accuse everyone else of corruption.
1
102
Robert Tarone retweeted
I win again! This newly-released CDC data shows us that the rise in autism in the United States between 2000 and 2016 was (drumroll)... ENTIRELY (98.25%, not significantly different from 100%) DRIVEN BY A SHIFT IN DIAGNOSTIC STANDARDS. The autism epidemic is incredibly fake.
210
928
120
6,790
714,743
Robert Tarone retweeted
The scientific method is being strangled by two old activist warriors, Oreskes and van den Berg, who were up to their old tricks trying to raise fears on behalf of their special interests. Hard to imagine how they can remain credible outside of their little activist circles.
Last week, two academic papers were retracted. One was about climate change and one about glyphosate. The climate paper had errors in data and methodology, the glyphosate paper had an angry activist campaign. @zaruk argues how this is a problem for science thefirebreak.org/p/a-tale-of…
1
8
9
974
Superb commentary on the use of weak science to promote alleged health risks (also the topic Kabat’s excellent book, “Getting Risk Right”).
Our world is full of agents that may (or may not) kill us prematurely or inflict grievous harm: cell phones, vaccines, chemical toxins, pick your poison. But the evidence that fuels our anxieties manifests a familiar pattern: It look like exactly what you'd expect from pathological science, or "the science of things that aren't so." It's why some of us remain hopelessly skeptical that these are legitimate fears. Signs of Bad Science open.substack.com/pub/uncert…
60
The litigation industry is running the Trump White House. @zaruk adds details on how - the Tylenol-autism correlation was orchestrated by lawyers suing Kenvue - their scientist published their research - litigation finance investors are pulling the strings thefirebreak.org/p/tylenotor…
1
11
2
19
6,429
Hazard, Risk, and the Precautionary Principle
Is there such a thing as too much safety? The evidence suggests yes. Our new video looks at how a scientific concept intended to keep us safe has led the country to systematically misjudge risk.
2
103
Excellent update on the status of mRNA vaccine research.
This quoted post is unavailable.
2
64