Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ) profile picture

Curicano de nacimiento, portenio por adopcion.

Joined July 2011
Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)Photo by Robin Andres (@RobinAndresQ)
You said that net zero cost $900B with marginal temperature reduction. I said that's not why net zero was commited. I mentioned the World Bank model used in 2020 by the ministry of finance that provided confidence to them and the president that this was the right thing to do. You attacked the model used by Chile by support of the World Bank , and you used a general estimation with no local contest as a better estimation talking about $900B for next zero? The 2020 report by WB says $49B by 2050, with savings of $80B, net $-31B. In 2025 UNDP did a new study for MOF and it was $62.3B, this time including adaptation, bringing net savings of $30B. Mitigation benefits were 6/1 vs costs. I said that investments were moving faster than expected. Over $34B in last decade, with no subsidies, just to reduce costs of energy. 3 million air conditioners were installed (I heard somebody recommend that once). They contribute to lower heating costs and displace wood burning in the winter. This is roughly 20% of homes with AC in 4 years. You said that why if it was profitable do we need a net zero law. The authors of the law (more than one minister, and heads of division) reminded me of some other things I had forgotten (I was focusing only on net zero target being law). The law says the following. 1. Yes, the law sets the goal, but it isn’t a spending bill. Congress passed carbon neutrality by 2050 into law. The law sets no technologies, no spending amounts and no list of projects. What it creates are tools for managing the transition: to reach that goal, it sets up management instruments at the national level, plus regional and municipal climate plans. Lomborg’s figure comes from a model of one possible pathway. It is not in the law. bcn 2. The law requires the cheapest effective measures. Cost-effectiveness is one of the law’s principles. Article 2(b) says climate management will prioritize measures that are effective for mitigation and adaptation and have the lowest costs. You ask for “smart, cost-effective climate policy,” . This is precisely what the law mandates. 3. Carbon budgets are split by sector based on cost. The Long-Term Climate Strategy sets a national greenhouse gas emissions budget for 2030 and 2050 and divides it among sectors according to cost-effectiveness and equity criteria. Sectoral budgets for later periods are set when the Strategy is updated. So the pathway gets revised as technology costs fall. It isn’t locked in at 2022 prices. 4. The target is net zero, not zero. Native forests, restoration and carbon removal count toward the target. The strategy has to set guidelines on ecosystem conservation, ecological restoration, afforestation and reforestation with native species, and technologies and practices for capture. Chile’s forest sink makes net zero much cheaper than cutting gross emissions to zero across every sector. 5. Half the law is about adaptation, and Chile keeps those benefits. The law also covers resilience and water security through adaptation plans and targets. Those benefits stay in Chile whatever happens to global temperature, so judging the law only by the °C it avoids by 2100 misses half of it. Its principles also include a scientific basis, cost-effectiveness, an ecosystem approach, non-regression and progressivity, which set up a process that adjusts as evidence comes in. 6. For the financial sector, the law requires disclosure and risk management. It doesn’t direct where money goes. The law requires fund managers and pension funds to explain how they manage climate risk. It doesn’t tell them what to buy or sell: Article 51 (fund managers, Ley 20.712, Art. 48): their investment policies must include the information the CMF requires on how environmental factors, including climate impacts, are incorporated into strategy, governance, risk management, and investment and diversification decisions, with the CMF considering national or international standards. Article 52 (pension funds, DL 3.500, Art. 50): the investment policy rules must include, at a minimum, how AFPs incorporate environmental factors, including climate change, into their strategy, governance, risk management and investment decisions. The these latter elements are implementing principle 5 of the coalition of finance ministers for climate action which Chile launched with Finland. Two right wing, pro market ministers. Some great ideas that even @Jou_Kaiser can agree on. There's no $900B anywhere. I'm pretty sure any skeptical environmentalist would agree this is a good path.
Marcelo, calling this a dishonest straw man is beneath someone of your standing. I answered exactly what you raised: the World Bank report, the IDB study and the NGFS scenarios, with tables and quotes. I sourced everything for you. Now you give all of that up for hand-waving about other reports, without a single source. It's hard to escape the conclusion that you were simply wrong. But let me add something constructive. My point isn't that Chile shouldn't clean its air or buy cheaper electric buses. If something pays for itself, it happens without a net zero law. The question is the part of climate policy that doesn't pay for itself. That part should pass a cost-benefit test, and that's what you miss. Chile's net zero fails it: 871 trillion pesos for 5 pesos back per 100. And those 5 pesos are the benefit to the whole world. Chile's net zero cuts global warming by 0.003°C by 2100, and Chile itself will receive just a tiny sliver of that. Even if Chile's damages were ten times higher than the peer-reviewed estimates I've shown you, Chile would get back well under one peso for every 100 it spends. A 0.003°C cut makes no material difference to Chile's forests, farms or copper mines. Health benefits are real, and a good reason to cut air pollution directly. They aren't a reason for net zero. I like climate benefits. I just want to know they're worth what they cost. The best climate policy, for Chile and the world, is investing in green energy R&D, so clean energy becomes cheaper than fossil fuels and everyone switches, including China and India.
2
4
12
1,128
Se habla mucho de Sam, Dario, Elon... pero poco de Demis Hassabis. - Fundó DeepMind y se la vendió a Google. - Desarrolló AlphaFold, una AI que logró predecir cómo se pliegan las proteínas. Algo que la ciencia intentaba resolver hace más de 50 años. - Esto es clave para entender enfermedades y desarrollar nuevos medicamentos. - Liberó el código como open source y millones de estructuras de proteínas gratis para todo el mundo. - Ganó el Nobel de Química en 2024. - Lideró los avances de AI en Google. - Fundó Isomorphic Labs con el objetivo de curar todas las enfermedades. - Y ahora acaba de anunciar USD 5.000 millones de inversión para acelerar ese objetivo. Una locura lo que está haciendo.
Thrilled to announce $5B in funding for @IsomorphicLabs to accelerate our mission to Solve All Disease. We continue to make rapid progress reimagining drug design from first principles with AI to radically cut the time & cost to find new medicines. Gradually, then all at once...
32
415
23
3,172
128,453
Candidato, los ahorros se adelantaron. Los costos bajaron antes. El mercado pudo derrotar a la contaminación. Debería estar contento. La transición energética de Chile ya no es solo generación: es almacenamiento, flexibilidad y redes. 🔋☀️ 📊 Según Generadoras de Chile (sept. 2026):
• US$ 11.650 MM y 7.865 MW renovables + almacenamiento en evaluación ambiental
• US$ 6.620 MM y 3.447 MW aprobados en 2026
• 99,2% de la capacidad en evaluación es renovable
• Baterías: 3.565 MW en operación y 5.346 MW en construcción El almacenamiento lleva la energía solar barata del día a la noche y reduce la dependencia de combustibles fósiles en las horas más caras. Está ocurriendo. Y es el mercado el que gana.
2
14
36
1,656
The argument is direct . You say that climate action is too expensive for Chile because it does not bring climate benefits. Y say that we do so because of multiple other benefits . the model used was developed by one of the ministers of finance as a professor, and it provided the confidence in doing net zero with a set of assumptions from 2020. They we conservative . Investment is going faster. We did evs because of air pollution first. Like China did too. I acknowledge that it’s not the climate benefit that drives action first . I mention NGFS as recent evidence of higher valuation. But still not what drives Chile. The straw man fallacy is true because you are not valuing any of the reasons that were taken into the decision of net zero. And again what should Chile do then? Not invest in the cheapest energy possible? Continue to depend on fossil fuels?
1
1
6
210
And they are. Do you think the energy sector became woke all of the sudden? Chile's renewable energy transition is also generating substantial investment opportunities. Importantly, the transition is not limited to electricity generation: it increasingly includes energy storage, grid flexibility, and complementary infrastructure. According to the September 2026 bulletin, the investment pipeline includes: Investment indicatorReported value Renewable and storage projects under environmental assessmentUS$11.65 billion Renewable and storage capacity under environmental assessment7,865 MW Investment associated with projects approved during 2026US$6.62 billion Generation capacity receiving environmental approval during 20263,447 MW Battery storage capacity in operation3,565 MW Battery storage capacity under construction5,346 MW Source: Generadoras de Chile, The investment pipeline is overwhelmingly concentrated in low-carbon technologies. Approximately 99.2% of the generation capacity under environmental assessment is classified as renewable. The expansion of battery storage is especially relevant. Storage enables the system to shift low-cost solar electricity from periods of abundant daytime production toward evening and nighttime demand, potentially reducing reliance on fossil-fuel generation during higher-cost hours. It is happening. Maybe not in your parallel world.
Replying to @chris_harrod
If sun and wind are the cheapest option, Chile will use them anyway, and the models count that. The cost is the extra cost of forcing net zero by 2050: 871 trillion pesos ($958 billion) for 0.00306°C less warming in 2100. NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Chile
1
7
29
1,179
Como si el único efecto de disminuir GEI fuera cambio climático... Los beneficios son cientos. Solo por contaminación atmosférica local perdemos 1,9 años de vida aqli.epic.uchicago.edu/count… ¿En cuánto valoramos ganar 34,6 millones de años-persona?
Chile has promised net zero by 2050 The bill: 871 trillion pesos ($958 billion) for 0.00306°C less warming in 2100 One of the worst deals of any country: 5 pesos back for every 100 spent NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Chile…
4
6
1
22
1,195
Lo importante es que la motivación no es solo el clima. Crecer 5% más . Depender menos de fósiles que se subsidian para no alterar crecimiento. Generar demanda de minerales críticos. Descontaminar ciudades . Lamento que eso reduzca emisiones te ofenda. En todo caso en efectos locales las vids des descontaminadas tienen un beneficio directo de reducción de temperatura de 0.5C. La menor emisión de carbono negro local evita derretimiento de glaciares. La forma en que Chile mitiga es así. Sorry que te gatillo sentimientos negativos
Replying to @marcelomena
Que bonito texto, Pero no contrafice lo que dice el video. Vamos a lo importante, es cierto o no?
4
2
1
23
1,328
Robin Andres retweeted
9) Bienvenido el debate con números. Pero para Chile la pregunta no es si podemos pagar el Net Zero, sino cuánto nos cuesta seguir sin avanzar en acción climática, cuantas personas moriran por no adaptarnos al cambio climatico o seguir respirando aire contaminado.
6
1
1
22
587
Robin Andres retweeted
8) Por último, Chile es muy vulnerable al cambio climático: megasequía, incendios como el de Viña del Mar en 2024, marejadas, lluvias extremas. Invertir en mitigación y adaptación es lo más patriótico que podemos hacer para evitar nuevas tragedias y estar mas preparados.
1
3
14
441
Robin Andres retweeted
6) Es también un tema de soberanía. Esa cuenta sube y baja con el precio internacional del petróleo y el gas: en 2022 llegó a 7,2% del PIB (~US$20 mil millones). Ese vaivén termina en la cuenta de la luz, el transporte y los alimentos de las familias.📊
1
1
11
421
Robin Andres retweeted
5) Si ese gasto se mantiene entre 2027 y 2100, suma ~US$910 mil millones: prácticamente lo mismo que el “costo” del cero neto. Es plata que hoy se va al extranjero y que una matriz limpia puede dejar en Chile. 📊
2
2
16
479
Robin Andres retweeted
4) Lo que el cálculo no muestra: Chile ya paga ~US$12.300 millones al año en combustibles fósiles importados (2025). Importamos ~93% del petróleo, ~76% del gas y prácticamente todo el carbón que usamos. 📊
1
2
16
527
Robin Andres retweeted
3) Además, a Chile se le asigna el mismo % del PIB que al promedio de su región en un modelo global. No considera que tenemos algunas de las renovables más baratas del mundo, ni que ya generamos más de dos tercios de la electricidad con fuentes limpias.
2
2
18
563
Robin Andres retweeted
2) El cálculo supone que SOLO Chile llega a NetZero mientras el resto del mundo no hace nada. Así, cualquier país que emite el 0,25% del total “pierde”. Pero más de 140 países tienen metas de carbono neutralidad: El esfuerzo es colectivo y el costo queda sobredimensionado.
1
1
17
596
Robin Andres retweeted
1) Interesante (o no?) lo dicho por @BjornLomborg. Su calculadora dice que el cero neto le costaría a Chile ~US$900 mil millones hasta 2100 y que devolvería 5 centavos por dólar. Revisando los números y supuestos, cualquiera da cuenta que cambian bastante 🧵
Chile has promised net zero by 2050 The bill: 871 trillion pesos ($958 billion) for 0.00306°C less warming in 2100 One of the worst deals of any country: 5 pesos back for every 100 spent NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Chile…
1
26
2
57
4,671
The World Bank report (which we can acknowledge also used higher cost estimates, resulting in a projection of 2GW of battery storage by 2040 when we have 10GW now). It did not consider the subsequent reports showing 2x copper demand and 10x lithium demand. It only saw internal changes. The IDB report expanded the model scenarios using the same model, including evaluating net zero sooner (5% growth by 2040). Much of this is no longer theoretical; you know well how fast cost curves developed. Later, power sector generators submitted a new report incorporating the health benefits of net zero, increasing the B/C ratio to over 5x. We did not foresee also that EVs and electric buses would drop in cost so much that capital costs are lower than diesel. The 2020 report was not replicated but I believe we can agree that numbers would be probably better as cost curves accelerated in drops and fossil fuel costs are more expensive. On NGFS, the Kotz paper had problems but is not unique. And I'm not talking about any of those benefits. Simple valuation of climate damage in Chile by sector (forest, agriculture, or reduced copper production) far exceeds Nordhaus's numbers. Why do we need a climate change law? It was a consensus law that allows predictability of what we need to do, and carbon budgets are allocated. This is state policy. I frankly do not know what your proposal is? that we don't electrify heating to reduce pollution? that we don't adopt EVs to save transportation costs and reduce fiscal stress due to subsidies and inflation? It is a dishonest, smart-sounding point to say why mitigate if we do not reduce temperature, without accounting for what has made Chile's policy exceptional in aligning the economy, health, and climate. But it is a straw man fallacy. We reformed energy to reduce energy costs and improve competitiveness. We cleaned our bus fleet because of rising pollution. We electrified heating for the same reason (and guess what, it's the AC's youv'e been promoting too). I am sorry this brings climate benefits, which seems to be problematic to you.
2
1
10
330
Parece que al candidato nacional libertario le gusta importar desinformación internacional que va en contra de los intereses del país. Ignora cuando se le muestran los estudios del @BancoMundial que muestran los mayor inversión, crecimiento y empleo de net zero para Chile. Ignora cuando se le explica que hubo 34 billion en inversión renovable esta última década. Ignora que se requiere 10x litio y 2x cobre por más renovables y eso explica el alza de precio y demanda de esos commodities. Ignora los buses eléctricos permiten aislar el transporte de los precios de la volatilidad fósil, y permite no tener que subsidiar el alza de precio como se hace con sectores no electrificados. @Jou_Kaiser tus ideas estorban los intereses del país y van contra el mercado. A nivel global las empresas energéticas y de petróleo estatales son las principales opositoras a la transición. En Pakistán instalaron más paneles domésticos que toda la red eléctrica nacional, a un costo que es un tercio de lo que vende la red. Encantado de discutir cómo los mercados abiertos y la acción la privada lidera acción climática . Y nuevamente si no me crees , pregúntale a @grok.
Hasta en el extranjero se rien de nuestra locura. Y la política, la prensa y la academia siguen empujando esta agenda que enriquece a unos pocos, a costa de la pobreza de toda nuestra nación.
21
87
4
252
11,035
Robin Andres retweeted
¿Es razonable que un candidato sostenga una cosa y, al llegar a la Presidencia, diga o haga exactamente lo contrario? ¿Dónde termina el pragmatismo de Estado y comienza la contradicción? Si todo puede cambiar al asumir el poder, ¿qué valor tiene la palabra de un candidato?
225
591
39
1,742
32,622
Robin Andres retweeted
"Ahí estaba ella (Bachelet) poniéndole florcitas, ¿y dónde quedan los derechos humanos de los vietnamitas?" En fin, la incoherencia
72
753
41
1,278
23,451