John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Brilliant insightful piece from Daisy that unpicks many of the frustrations so many of us currently feel.
What impact will the government's new education policies have on standards?
substack.nomoremarking.com/p…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
What impact will the government's new education policies have on standards?
substack.nomoremarking.com/p…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Daisy is brilliantly - and painfully - on the money….
What impact will the government's new education policies have on standards?
substack.nomoremarking.com/p…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
There are some interesting debates on US edutwitter right now. Similar in structure and tone to a lot of the debates that English edutwitter had in 2014-2019.
There are things we got wrong at that time, and I can see them going wrong for the US too.
One is fixating on interesting ideas that are unlikely to work at scale. For example, E-edutwitter got really excited about some strategies like the use of knowledge organisers. They went big, but probably didn't affect all that much and weren't executed well outside of a handful of adherents. I suspect similar is the case for "scripted lessons" and formal Direct Instruction, which is US-edutwitter's current big thing.
The second is harder and it relates to interlocutors. It's really easy to fall into a camp or tribe. Some people are bad faith interlocutors, and need to have their arguments dismissed. But others aren't. They are people who broadly agree with you, but have issues with some of the recommendations, positions amd positionings. We didn't always disagree agreeably with those people, and I can already see some of that happening in the US. Not everyone who disagrees with you is an idiot or evil or whatever. If you sit too securely in your camp, you end up losing quite a lot of valuable insight.
I personally am a lot more chill on here than I was back then, and I really regret that style of debate. I've worked hard on this vice of mine, because I could have learnt more and developed faster. My advice to US-edutwitter: not everyone who disagrees with you is doing it in bad faith. Try and listen and learn. You don't need to agree, but it's worth paying attention.
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
The term “oracy” won’t float everyone’s boat, but there’s no doubt that oral language abilities need to be developed (a) in their own right and (b) to support reading and writing skills across the curriculum and across year levels. Oral language is not “set and forget”. I’ve written about this in a number of open access publications, including this one:
scholar.google.com/scholar?h…
Student Talk: It matters - not only to deepen learning but because it also just does. teacherhead.com/2026/04/02/s… via @teacherhead
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Such an odd and disturbing response.
Jews remain the only minority group that are not allowed to define what discrimination against them looks like.
We are consistently told that our concerns should be wrapped up in generic "antiracism", lest we construct a "hierarchy of racism."
It's just silly and overwrought. There is lots of antisemitism. Some of it is outright and obvious to everyone (Jews control the world), some of it is outright but not obvious to everyone (shouting "free Palestine" to random Jews in the street), and some of it is harder to determine, and needs unpicking and sensitive thought (e.g. "Zionism is racism").
The NEU's statement contains neither subtlety nor empathy. Instead, it sidelines our community's very real concerns, and tells us that in fact we have misunderstood our own oppression.
Poor show, but not entirely unsurprising.
The NEU responds to the Bell review
neu.org.uk/latest/press-rele…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
To love France was always a little cheesy, a touch of a cliché. Yet if you’re a romantic, it simply can’t be helped.
France, to me, was the cradle of European civilization.
We think of the Enlightenment and its luminaries, Voltaire and Diderot; of the Impressionists who rebelled against it and in Monet’s dissolving light and Debussy’s dreamy melodies, produced art of staggering beauty; of those long, searching existential conversations through the haze of cigarette smoke at the Café de Flore; of a nation that raised art, wisdom, and love itself to life’s highest purpose.
Civilization, as Werner Herzog once put it, is a thin layer of ice upon a deep ocean of chaos and darkness.
For France, the ice has cracked.
Excellent piece by @DouglasKMurray
Of all the things that have been hardest to communicate in my life, this seems the most impossible: that our civilisation is not, by some law of nature, immortal. It has no right or likelihood to continue existing if it insists on committing harakiri.
The people who are welcomed onto our airwaves, work in parts of our government and lead some of our political parties include those who would burn down this country in a heart-beat. They would look us in the eyes and kill us. And we know that because they have done it elsewhere.
They don't do it at the moment because the time is not right. But when they feel it is, they will act. At which point I suppose people will have to decide whether they wish to be spectators at their own funeral pyre or not.
✍️ Douglas Murray
Article | spectator.com/article/france… | @DouglasKMurray
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
In which Chen, Marcus and Sweller park their tanks on the constructivists' lawn.
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
I will do a Strictly podcast about the insanity of Lucy Powell’s policies and how she makes Bridget Phillipson look perfectly reasonable soon…
But my goodness, do we have an Education Secretary determined to ruin the lives of disadvantaged kids!! 🤯🤯
Whenever a government minister cites the advent of artificial intelligence as the justification for a policy, you can be certain that there has been an absence of actual intelligence in the reasoning behind it.
Nowhere is that clearer than in the Education Secretary's embrace of 'oracy' as the new priority for our schools. 'With AI on the rise,' Lucy Powell asserted, 'we need to go harder on the skills that make us human, like oracy.'
Ms Powell refrained from explaining what it is about large language models that requires a different approach to language teaching in our schools.
✍️ Lara Brown
Article | spectator.com/article/lucy-p… | @lara_e_brown
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
This would be obviously gameable and gamed, and hence lack validity or usefulness.
Key Stage 2 exams have been necessary and desirable to help drive up standards. I can think of no good reason to remove them.
What would life be like without KS2 Sats? @IPPR is recommending the DfE replace them with random sampling from Year 3 onwards
tes.com/magazine/news/genera…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Forensic analysis here from @BodilUK
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
We beschikken over meer onderzoek dan ooit naar hoe het brein daadwerkelijk leert. En toch worden in het ene land na het andere juist onderwijsmethoden gepromoot die volgens dat onderzoek het minst effectief zijn voor beginners. Blog van @Barbara97881398
kirschnered.nl/2026/10/18/de…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Good relationships are the outcome of a successful school culture, not its cause.
If you want relationships built on trust, first:
1. Be trustworthy
2. Create predictable systems of behavioural expectation
3. Imbed these as routines
4. Uphold, monitor, challenge and support
5. Relationships flow from these mutual, authentic expectations.
Relationships in a school are not based on affection. Nor is that the purpose. The purpose is the flourishing of all
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
I’ve posted a child’s poem daily for a month. Katya’s incantation seems a great way to end. Magical. I’ll put them all into a PDF so you can have the series plus a few extra notes.
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Only one more day to go - this was an amazing moment as she dictated the words transfixed by the primulas. 6 yrs old. A real Ted Hughes moment.
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
Look at the magnificent turnout for researchED Santiago today. LOOK #rEDchile So proud of Rodrigo and his team at @Aptus_org for bringing the dream to LATAM
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
I’m not interested in hearing about your “passion for social justice and equity” if you promote inquiry-based learning over explicit instruction, believe ambiguous, skills-based education is superior to knowledge-rich, content-focused education, and advocate for restorative circles instead of clear, consistent discipline.
You can’t say you’re passionate about social justice and equity while supporting practices that perpetuate inequitable access to knowledge and policies that harm students who are victims of verbal and physical abuse at the hands of their peers.
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
The one thing I’d want everyone to know about Direct Instruction is that the methods, materials and routines are far less important than the underlying drive behind it: the unswerving belief that EVERY child can achieve, regardless of circumstance.
DI is based on a deeply held conviction that if a child didn’t learn, it was because the teacher (or curriculum) didn’t teach them properly. In that sense, it is a movement rooted in social justice but one which takes responsibility for outcomes.
In the 60s and 70s, there was a view in the education academic establishment that formal academic work was premature for 4-year-olds, and doubly so for poor ones; so what they needed was enrichment and play.
Worse still, in the early 70s, some academics described DI as a racist enterprise*. Engelmann's own memoir notes that he and Bereiter were called “Nazis” and “kid-haters.”
Despite this, Engelmann taught disadvantaged 4 year olds to factor and to solve simultaneous equations, and filmed it. Bereiter and Engelmann’s argument, set out in ‘Teaching Disadvantaged Children in the Preschool’, was that the disadvantaged child was not “behind” in some general developmental sense but behind in specific, teachable things, that all kids could learn with the right scope and sequence.
The preschool they opened in the mid 60s ran for two hours a day, with three twenty-minute lessons in language, arithmetic and reading, taught to small groups by a teacher following a specific DI sequence. Those kids made huge gains which faded when they went to normal public schools.
DI has its limitations like everything but the drive behind it is sincere. As #SoldAStory season 2 will show, it has been portrayed as something very different to what it actually is and the animating principles behind it.
*Baratz and Baratz, ‘Early childhood intervention: the social science base of institutional racism.’
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
History catches up with the education establishment in this important Season 2 of Sold a Story. Meaningful education advances could have been made in the last 50 years, as has occurred in other fields, where evidence is weighed more carefully and objectively. But they weren’t, and socioeconomic status continues to drive education outcomes, where classroom instruction should have the upper hand on this.
The new season of Sold a Story is coming tomorrow. I've seen speculation about it. I think there will be some surprises. I'm interested to know what you think.
First two episodes tomorrow. Then one a week on Thursdays until Nov 19. features.apmreports.org/sold…
John Walker, Sounds-Write retweeted
The Secretary of State can not mandate oracy any more than he or she can mandate formative assessment, or peer tutoring, or anything else in the EEF T&L toolkit. The SoS can use the levers at their disposal: Ofsted, KS2 tests, National Curriculum, and GCSE specs. 🧵





























