Stephen Bogner retweeted
🚨 BREAKING: A new report says Ottawa let in 42% MORE immigrants last year than it told Canadians.
Not a rounding error.
42%.
Housing is broken. Affordability is broken.
And the real number was kept quiet.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
You can sit there, sit there longer, then sit some more … thinking how something like this can happen when we have MILLIONS of Canadians visiting food banks so they can eat, all the while 100,000 jobs were lost in the last 3 months alone … and you literally still can’t make this up yourself if you tried …
But guess what, our fearless Prime Minister thought it up … and he went and did it …
Elbows up!
FIRST READING: Canada just gave $560 million in aid to a richer country
Brazil, which has a higher GDP than Canada, is using the money to pay people not to cut down forests
nationalpost.com/opinion/fir…
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Rick Bell's latest Calgary Herald column is a victory lap for a Premier leaning on her own party's local leaders. He calls the 15 riding presidents who won't sign her pledge "rebellious," says they are "double dog daring" Danielle Smith, and treats it all as their problem to fix. It isn't. The party made this problem, and Bell is cheering it on.
"The separatists were stomped." Fine. Three out of four voters said Alberta stays in Canada, and I accept that result, same as I said in my earlier essay (cnm5000.substack.com/p/accep…). But Bell keeps blurring two different things. Accepting a vote is one thing. Signing a paper that says you "recognize, respect and abide" by it, as the price of representing the party, is another. A vote ends the question on the ballot. It does not end the right to keep arguing.
"Captain Obvious could have written these lines. What's the problem?" The problem is what the pledge says and where it sits. CBC (cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/a…) reports it is tucked inside a combined non-disclosure agreement and code of conduct, and that it appears to clash with the party's existing code, which says association board members shall not be disciplined for exercising their freedom of expression unless it breaks the Criminal Code. The presidents' own letter, as the Edmonton Journal (edmontonjournal.com/news/pol…) reports it, says a political position "falls outside the purvey of a code of conduct" and disputes that the party can change the code without a members' vote. Bell mentions none of this. He says "Captain Obvious" and moves on.
"This isn't about free speech." Bell repeats Smith's line that any member can think or say whatever they like, and only spokespeople must follow the party line. But governance expert Nolan Crouse told CBC, "When you're involved in a governing body, you can't pre-commit your political stance." Bell never puts that to anyone.
"If they worked for our company they'd be fired." Bell ends on one guy from the oilpatch saying this, at an oilsands announcement full of what Bell calls smiling execs. Riding presidents are local officers chosen by their own associations. They don't work for head office, and one told CBC the pledge is the sort of thing that will stop people from volunteering. A company can fire an employee. A party that calls itself a big tent should not be telling its own local leaders to swear an oath or step aside.
"Did the separatists really believe they were going to win?" Bell asks this, then says their campaign "consisted of talking to each other and writing off everybody else." He cites nothing. And he skips over a number from his own earlier column (calgaryherald.com/opinion/co…): a pre-vote poll in which 54 per cent of UCP supporters said they intended to vote for Option 2, a referendum on Alberta independence. That is not the same as wanting independence, and I won't pretend it is. But it does say that a majority of the premier's own supporters wanted that vote held. Those are not strangers talking to each other. That is your party, Rick.
"She doesn't need to go immediately to kicking people out." That is Jason Nixon, and notice the word "immediately." Bell adds his own line: "At least not before the UCP shindig the last weekend of the month." So is expulsion off the table, or only until after the convention Bell says will bring 7,000 conservatives to Calgary? Bell doesn't ask, and Nixon doesn't say. His own image is hornets. Hornets get that way when somebody pokes the nest.
And look who is delivering the lecture. Bell writes that the Sundre area Nixon represents narrowly voted yes on a future vote on independence. Nixon is telling these presidents to fall in line, and that's how the area he represents voted. He says Smith's number one job is defeating Naheed Nenshi and the NDP, and that the "devastation" otherwise is "unthinkable." That is a fear pitch. Fear is a poor reason to make local leaders pre-commit a political position.
Now the point Bell never touches: pledges produce recitation, not belief. A clip circulating on X, which its poster credits to Hannah Arendt, makes a point about total control, and I am not comparing Smith to a dictator. But one line in it fits this fight: "You may think what you like, so long as you keep quiet." Smith says almost the same thing, that members may think whatever they want as long as spokespeople stay on message. A person who signs to keep his seat has not been persuaded. He has been taught to stay quiet.
The attribution and the exact wording of that clip are unverified. Arendt's own, well-documented point in The Origins of Totalitarianism is that the ideal subject of totalitarian rule is a person for whom the line between fact and fiction no longer exists. Take the principle on its merits.
Smith admitted she's had "a very light touch" on this in the past. She is the premier, and she can set the line for MLAs and candidates. So why the heavy hand on local volunteers and association leaders, weeks after the vote?
Bell never gets around to the question that matters: whose party is this? As Wade Collinge asked at a party forum, "Is this Danielle's party or is it the members' party?" A columnist who spends a whole piece sneering at 15 local leaders and never answers that is not holding power to account. He is repeating the premier's side and calling it analysis.
Accept the result? Yes. Sign away your voice? Still no.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Study finds restricting use of foreign workers in 2014 "led to a statistically significant increase in wages" for Canadian workers.
Mass immigration is wage suppression.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
This is one of many examples of a failure that, in a real country, would warrant an immediate resignation and election.
Instead, our highest office holders can lie to the citizenry with impunity, and destroy our nation without a single consequence:
REPORT: Canada permitted 42% more landed immigrants last year than claimed. New figures released by @CitImmCanada show PM @MarkJCarney concealed true numbers following widespread opposition to high quotas.
blacklocks.ca/pm-hid-immigra…
#cdnpoli #immigration
Stephen Bogner retweeted
💥REPORT: The Canadian Construction Association wants cheap foreign labour to cover a supposed 100,000-worker shortfall by 2034 — while 70,000 tradespeople sit unemployed and 500,000 students fill trades programs a year.
It's not about a shortage; it's a corporate profit wage-suppression scheme.
They're all traitors.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Smith isn't an independence supporter and never was.
Fair enough. She didn't campaign on that.
But the premier shouldn't be acting as if Ottawa has Alberta's interests at heart.
We need leadership standing up to Eastern incursions.
MORGAN: Smith must quit pretending Ottawa is Alberta's friend westernstandard.news/opinion…
Stephen Bogner retweeted
So taxpayers are on the hook for this pet project after his company chopped down Brazilian rainforests
Amazing
Simply amazing
Canada’s Prime Minister Mark Carney announced funding of as much as C$560 million ($392 million) to a Brazil-led project to invest in protecting the world’s tropical forests bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Accept the Result, Sure. Sign Away Your Voice? Never.
According to a CBC News report (cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/a…) this week, the UCP is demanding that all 87 of its riding presidents sign a document declaring they "recognize, respect, and will abide by" the result of last month's referendum, in which three-quarters of Albertans voted to keep this province in Canada. Sign and return by Friday, said the email from executive director Dustin van Vugt.
The pledge is stitched into a non-disclosure agreement and code of conduct, as if a political conviction were the same thing as a confidentiality clause.
Let me be clear about what I accept. I campaigned for independence, and I lost. The referendum settled whether Alberta begins the process of separation, and I accept that result without reservation. What I will never accept is the idea that losing a vote means surrendering the right to argue for a different future. Those are two very different things, and the people who drafted this pledge know it.
The good news is that the grassroots is pushing back, from both sides of the question. Darrell Komick, president of the Calgary-Lougheed association, told CBC (cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/a…) the party should be trying to unify rather than suppress, and warned that this "is the sort of thing that will stop people from volunteering." At least 15 presidents are reportedly signing a letter refusing the pledge. And here is the detail that should embarrass its authors: the resistance includes presidents who voted to stay in Canada. One of them, unwilling to give a name for fear of retribution, asked why this one issue is singled out when the party argues about plenty of others. "We have back and forth about friggin' abortion," that president said. Fair question.
Retribution. Sit with that word. A volunteer who gives evenings and weekends to this party is afraid to attach a name to a criticism of the party's own paperwork. That is what the pledge has already accomplished, before a single signature is collected.
It gets worse. The party's existing code of conduct (cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/a…) says board members shall not be "reprimanded or disciplined by the party... for exercising their freedom of expression unless such expression constitutes an offence under the Criminal Code of Canada." Read that again. The UCP's own rules protect free expression right up to the edge of criminal law. Now the same party wants presidents to pre-commit their political stance on the defining question of Alberta's future. Nolan Crouse, who teaches board governance at MacEwan University, put it plainly: "You can't pre-commit your political stance." He was surprised the form passed what he called the party's leadership's acid test. So am I.
Premier Smith says the party is clearly pro-unity now, and that no candidates or MLAs may support independence. Setting direction for elected members is her prerogative. Party president Rob Smith defended her at an Edmonton forum this week, insisting she is not asking anyone to be a federalist, only to respect the result of 75 per cent of Albertans. But it was a Sylvan Lake party member, Wade Collinge, who asked the question hanging over all of it: "Whose party is this? Is this Danielle's party or is it the members' party?"
That is the whole argument in one line. Roughly half of UCP supporters backed independence, according to pre-vote polling. Half. You do not unify a party by handing that half a pen and telling them to sign away the subject. You unify it the way conservatives are supposed to do everything else: trust people to argue in good faith, and let the better argument win.
Some will say a party needs message discipline, and of course it does. But there is a difference between asking volunteers not to freelance on policy and demanding they swear, in writing, to shelve a political belief. The first is management. The second is muzzling, aimed with suspicious precision at the one issue where half the membership disagrees with the leader.
Komick said it best: "As the party of free speech, we should understand that that comes with risks as a party, but it also comes with rewards." The cost of this pledge is already visible. Five riding associations have endorsed a leadership review. Pro-independence members are running for the provincial board at this month's convention in Calgary. And the people who door-knock and donate are asking whose party this is.
The referendum is over. I said so at the top, and I mean it. But a vote decides an outcome, not an opinion. If the UCP wants its grassroots to keep showing up, it should tear up this pledge, enforce the free-expression protection it already has, and remember that riding presidents are volunteers, not employees. You can ask Albertans to accept a result. You cannot order them to stop discussing political options.
Sign nothing. Keep talking. Stand by your convictions.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Daniele Smith realizing Carney’s fake unity & pipeline promise was all a lie to get people to vote to remain in Canada is the icing on the cake as she campaigned against the ONLY thing that would have made Alberta sovereign and independent.
Smith says she wasn't consulted on federal immigration changes ctvnews.ca/edmonton/video/20…
Stephen Bogner retweeted
If a billionaire figures out how to build houses for half the price, I want him building millions of them.
If your first concern is how rich that would make him or how much inequality that would create, then we have very different housing priorities.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Globe columnist: “Team Carney is resorting to fudging its immigration books.
Fibbing.
I’m sorry to have to use this word: Lying.”
Record-breaking permanent levels next year will continue the Liberal chaos.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
How deep is the demoralization of the Canadian public? They can watch a Prime Minister who promised to fix immigration, increase it, and do nothing.
Stephen Bogner retweeted
Leighton Grey says he's been in the room and heard Danielle Smith say it: "the most important thing we have to do is to hold on to power."
His question: what happens to principle after that?
@GreyMatterConvo on Ep 322. #abpoli #UCP
Stephen Bogner retweeted
It's always been ridiculous that tax dollars go toward groups that then advocate against our economy.
Time to let them raise funds from supporters rather than bleeding taxpayers.
From environmentalists to indigenous lobbies.
MORGAN: Smith’s suggestion to cut tax funding for advocacy groups is a positive step westernstandard.news/opinion…





























