
I sell apartment buildings in Los Angeles | #1 LA CRE Podcast Host “No Vacancy” | $488M+ in sales | The Group CRE↓
Los Angeles
Joined September 2019
- Tweets4.2K
- Following1.4K
- Followers12.9K
- Likes6K
Pinned Tweet
If I had unlimited money, this is how I would dominate CRE brokerage:
1. Get Data
- Hire VA's to scrape data providers
- Get TLO for mobile and emails
- Have cold caller's verify ownership
- Build Top 150 clients list, cambridge analytica that shit
2. Top of Funnel
- Built Newsletter personalized content based on FB, IG, credit card, and user intent data
- Hire content team, produce 150-300 pieces of content per week
- VA Cold Callers call owners to see if they would sell. Low fruit.
- VA text outreach with personalization based on data
- Drip email sequences, hyper-personalized
3. Client Retention
- Hire people to create "unreasonable hospitality" magic moments for my leads/clients
- Find charitable causes I believe in, invite owners to event for charity
- Poker Nights
- Client Events
- Bfast Meetings with top 150 everyday
- SOP's for market updates and automate news
4. Sales Execution
- Mass texts with pre-market/off-market deals
- AI buyer and seller match system based on previous purchase history and current buyer criteria
- AI OM and single property website creation
- AI Social Media graphics for listings
- Mass email based on buyer criteria and data
- 1031 exchange tracker and fund lifecycles
5. Team Building
- Full SOP and video recordings for agent training
- Team events for rapport building
- Daily training calls/ meetings
- Round Robin lead distribution
- Personal Brand infrastructure for agents to plug into
- CRM supersystem included
This to me would be a tech company that sells real estate. The scale and speed would be unmatched and the amount of personalized data would be the winning ticket. The main differentiator would be the level of personalization as not to spam owners but provide real value based upon their data and conversations.
These are the systems I think about when I lay in bed at night. One day, I will make this a reality.
In 2008 he bought 804 units across eight buildings.
A million dollars down. 60 days. All cash. No contingencies.
The morning after he closed, a big player asked him the cap rate.
"I don't know."
The gross rent multiplier?
"I don't know."
His answer: "It's 80,000 a unit. You can't replace it for double that, triple that."
I just sat down with Tom Safran, chairman of Thomas Safran & Associates, for No Vacancy. 50+ years developing and managing affordable housing in Southern California.
His dad was a scrap metal dealer. He took a HUD internship in 1969 planning to quit after three months. He stayed about four and a half years.
When he left in 1974, his rent was $220 and he had about $5,000 from his HUD retirement account.
Then he gave a speech in his UCLA MBA class on how to do a hypothetical 100-unit senior project in Inglewood using the new Section 8 program. Mid-speech he asked himself: why don't you actually do it, Tom?
He tied up a one-acre lot from a man raising chickens on multifamily land, plus the two neighbors. He had the money to tie it up. Not to build it.
So he went to a developer he knew from HUD. 20% of the deal, his deposit reimbursed, and his job was HUD and city approval.
It became Eucalyptus Park. 93 units. Under construction in less than a year. He still owns it today.
"He or she who has gold rules in real estate. The person who has the property is the one who rules."
4 lessons from Tom Safran:
1. Control beats capital. If you control a good, valuable piece of property, you can make the deal. Inglewood and the 2008 portfolio were both tied up first and capitalized second.
2. Hire your own attorney. "I don't care what it costs." His early partnerships used his partners' family attorney and didn't have good buy-sell agreements. Decades later he's dealing with their widows, kids and grandkids. "Don't think these things don't happen."
3. Make the incentive to sell the same as the incentive to own. On a Redwood City deal, the equity investor made twice as much percentage-wise on a sale.
4. Buy the ugly. "Some of my best deals are buying the unattractive, the ugly, the not well done, buying properties with decent to good locations." Today those eight buildings are rehabbed, refinanced with HUD and tax credits, 100% occupied, and the partners have no money left in them.
Full episode live now.
hubs.ly/Q04FLw7X0
He had a Long Beach apartment deal under contract at the end of 2019.
Then in January 2020, statewide rent control hit. So he picked a place outside California.
Six years later he has about 3,500 apartments in the Southeast.
I just sat down with Robert Pereira of ARC Multifamily Group for No Vacancy.
Born and raised in Toronto. Engineering degree. Moved to California for a tech company. Graduated business school in 2008 with a real estate focus. There were no real estate jobs, so he made his own.
Started buying foreclosures at the courthouse steps. Built that into a luxury spec home business doing $3 to $8 million homes. Got to about $50 million in real estate.
Then he pivoted to multifamily for what he calls hold economics. In a downturn, you can hold longer.
His capital went from zero to about $20 million between 2009 and 2020. Today it's around $200 million of capital across $600 million of property.
One complex they bought in June of '23: 147 doors at about $930 a month. Now approaching $1,400.
"I'm an operator first and investor second."
He raises with Alex and Layla Hormozi's Acquisition.com. And the structure isn't what you'd expect. The GP puts its dollars in first, and gets its capital back only after everyone else has received their equity back.
"Every investor who's worked with me for going on 18 years has always made money. I'll be the first to say I haven't always made money, but I've always taken care of our investors."
4 lessons from Robert Pereira:
1. Don't value-add into a concession war. "The spreads between A and B is so compressed that A seems like the obvious choice right now. Won't always be, but it is." On B product: "I don't want to be adding value when there's a bunch of class A's that are in lease up that are offering two to three months of free rent."
2. A third-party manager is not paid to create $10 million of value. On a 400-door Atlanta class A doing about $8 million a year, adding $500,000 of income is about $10 million of value at a 5 cap. The manager at 3% makes $15,000 a year on that, on a contract you can cancel in 30 days. That's why he went vertically integrated.
3. Don't manufacture the IRR with the exit cap. "You can turn a 12 into a 25 if you just drop the cap rate. So we're conservative with our cap rates." What he trusts is a "realistic cash on cash return," and "where we are right now in the cycle we're looking for positive leverage." "Better to under promise and over deliver."
4. The bet is the supply cutoff, not a rate cut. Atlanta got "record delivery" when rates went to zero. "That supply spigot, once interest rates went up starting in '22 and peaking in late '23, the spigot cut off." "We've started pushing rents in '26." "'28 we think it's going to be a banner year for operations."
Full episode live now.
hubs.ly/Q04Fr80H0
A 179-unit building in Anaheim that nobody wanted to touch.
Owned by a Korean church. Age-restricted. The tenants were church members. In-place rents were around $500 a month. Market was about $1,100.
Eric Sussman bought it, got 120 of the 179 units designated Section 8, and sold it for about three and a half times what he paid. In about 18 months.
I just sat down with Eric Sussman (@erichsussman) of Clear Capital for No Vacancy.
He's a UCLA Anderson professor and founding partner of Clear Capital. More than $2 billion and nearly 2 million square feet acquired, developed, and managed. And he has been doing this since the early 90s.
He started Amber Capital in 93 or 94 with about $53,000 in student debt from Stanford. Taught CPA review nights and weekends, 6:30 to 9:30 Monday through Thursday and Saturday days, just to make money. Joined the UCLA faculty in the fall of 95.
His first deal was a sandwich lease on Native American land in Palm Springs. A condo project. A week or two before close, the Bureau of Indian Affairs called and wanted to buy the ground lease back. He was in his mid-20s. He told them he didn't think they could afford it. They made him an offer he couldn't refuse. He double-escrowed, took title, and transferred it to the BIA. That paid off the student debt and launched the firm.
He had already started raising capital for that deal in $25,000 increments. His father, a doctor, introduced him to every doctor in the Valley. He never took their money on that deal. He still paid them their share of the profits. They were not legally owed it. They stayed with him as investors for years.
The 90s, he said, were a deal decade. The 10-year Treasury was probably 8 or 9. He did retail, office, apartments. His first apartment deal was in 95. He saw 10 and 11 cap deals on real income. There was no internet. Owners didn't know what they had. Starting in 2000 he focused on multifamily.
He and a partner were among the first to do cash-for-keys brick deals in LA. They bought around 30 of them. The only lenders were Washington Mutual and Hawthorne Savings. He said their IRRs were 35% across the board for 15 years.
On the first two syndications, he took no carry. Just a management fee.
"I was a nobody. I had no track record whatsoever."
"I had to make the economics attractive."
"Charisma counts. It can get you pretty far."
Those deals were home runs. He left the promote on the table and bought goodwill. After that the structure was simple. He recalled an 8% pref and a 75/25 waterfall, then a 6% pref as rates fell.
Then Miracle Terrace, around 2012. 179 units in a workforce part of Anaheim, not Disneyland. No one wanted to touch it. It was a political hot potato. There was no rent control, so in theory you could serve 60-day notices and raise rents, and you'd be on the front page of the Orange County Register.
They served the notices. Tenant-rights lawyers threatened an injunction. Eric got about 10 of them on a conference call and told them he had a solution: protest outside Loretta Sanchez's office and get the project designated Section 8.
Tenants were paying about $500. At 30% of a $1,100 market rent they'd pay about $330. The landlord would get market. It was an election year. To his knowledge it was the fastest Section 8 approval in Orange County history. 120 of 179 units went Section 8. The rest were market. They sold it to an affordable housing group for about 3.5x in about 18 months.
In 2017 he sold his last four LA assets to Blackstone and CityView in a bulk sale. The buyers thought LA rents were going to New York levels. He thought they were nuts.
"You see this writing on the wall, the trend towards socialism and rent freezes and rent control on steroids. I saw that coming."
Those buyers later sold the assets at big losses.
He went to other states. Some of that worked. Arizona and Colorado got hit with a wall of supply he said he never saw coming, cheap capital and a record drop in rates followed by a record rise. After what he called a 30-year run that was unbelievable, he is putting some chips back in.
On the 2020 to 2023 syndications, on a time-value-of-money basis, he thinks very few will make investors whole. You may get your money back, just years later than the business plan said.
"If you play the real estate game long enough and you don't have some losses, you know, you really haven't been playing the game."
He'd buy in LA again, but only as one-off asset plays, not a broad bet. He said they did about 30 deals in Koreatown when they were scaling. He doesn't think you could do that now.
4 lessons from Eric Sussman:
1. Get nichier than your asset class. "If everyone has the same information, your ability to make money is significantly impaired." Owners already know what they have, and brokers already know the rents and the comps, so "today you got to be super nichy." "Otherwise you're basically banking on macroeconomics, what we call market risk, which everyone can do."
2. Affordable housing takes carrots, not sticks. "Rent control is a stick. Inclusionary zoning is a stick. Those don't work." His alternative: lease to tenants at X% of AMI, and give the landlord a property tax abatement or two years of utilities at no cost. "Landlords are capitalists. They're ROI driven." Make the expenses lower, "they'll do it."
3. Population and jobs, in that order, drive real estate. Entertainment, one of LA's traditional engines, is in what he called a "terrible bear market," and "California immigrants are renters." His read, a lot of it policy-driven: "LA has bad fundamentals now."
4. He's on record, and he knows it's an outlier: "I believe single family homes are going to have negative real returns over the next decade." "Multifamily will be the beneficiary of it," because the job market has changed and "you've got student debt. So you're going to be renting." He still flags a supply overhang, so the timing isn't clean.
A professor who actually did the deals. Still teaching. Still in the game.
Full episode live now.
Thanks for coming on, Eric.
hubs.ly/Q04Fhwjq0
There are multiple large portfolios under contract in Los Angeles right now that are going to fuck up the comps.
Some of the prices I am hearing feel unreal.
Prime real estate trading at 2009 prices.
Wild.
My long time Transaction Coordinator has retired.
I am in need of a Badass TC who is familiar with LA and LA County Multifamily transactions.
Please who has a great rec?
I need to know how many buyers have actually bought properties from Loopnet?
I am getting my renewal soon and the Rates per month per property are absurd.
How is Costar going to survive?
Wow
Didn't know the election would effect the multifamily market this fast.
Had a full price offer on Tuesday for a building in LA.
Today after @nithyavraman won the LA mayoral race, they have decided to pause any buying until policy clarity shakes out.
@nithyavraman do apartment owners need to worry about rent regulations getting worse? Is this city going to become un-investable?
So you want to know what the LA multifamily market looks like right now?
Current Listing Cap/GRMs
33 Units | 90004 | 6.30% / 6.69x
3 Units | 90026 | 4.61% / 14.44x
13 Units | 90019 | 5.65% / 9.37x
10 Units | 90027 | 5.77% / 10.95x
10 Units | 90029 | 6.54% / 9.47x
52 Units | 90057 | 7.69% / 6.79x
91 Units | 90028 | 5.08% / 11.8x
13 Units | 90057 | 7.76% / 8.58x
9 Units | 91601 | 5.95% / 9.49x
Yep. Generational buying opp in my eyes.
This is LA real estate.
How TF can Siri not create a contact for me when I ask it to when they have their name and phone number on my screen.
Just make the contact.
4
12
1,801
Calling all LIHTC buyers, I have a 22 unit in Oxnard CA. Preservation play.
DM me if interested
2
11
1,807
Yeah this is real. been just yapping on tiktok about the CRE market in LA if you want to follow along
This is INSANE 🚨 Democrats new “mansion tax” has already collected $1.2 billion, it’s supposed to be spent on things like building affordable housing
But the housing that’s being built it ultra expensive. There are projects costing $600k–$1 million+ per unit when the actual cost of the same comparable units should only be about $200k–$300k spending on location
“Absurd, I have to say that. There's a deal in Westlake, $560,000 per unit, a deal on West Hollywood for $750,000 per unit.
A deal in Pedro, $1 million a unit. Northridge, $750,000. Hollywood, $871,000. Del Ray, $1 million a unit. Insane.
There are developers right now who will build brand new sick apartment units for $300,000 per unit. Like the sickest apartment buildings that you and I would live in, anyone would live in. They're sick. But affordable housing, because of bureaucracy, is $1 million a unit. It doesn't make any sense”
This is such a scam, and I can tell you exactly why they’re doing it this way
When these new developments do “affordable housing” the developers get the money from Democrats but in the contract they only have to be “affordable housing” for a set amount of years. After that they can transition them into being market rate
So developers are just building luxury properties for $1m per unit with our tax money then will cash in again when they switch from “affordable housing” to market rate
Another Democrat scam
4
51
5,859
Taylor Avakian retweeted
This is INSANE 🚨 Democrats new “mansion tax” has already collected $1.2 billion, it’s supposed to be spent on things like building affordable housing
But the housing that’s being built it ultra expensive. There are projects costing $600k–$1 million+ per unit when the actual cost of the same comparable units should only be about $200k–$300k spending on location
“Absurd, I have to say that. There's a deal in Westlake, $560,000 per unit, a deal on West Hollywood for $750,000 per unit.
A deal in Pedro, $1 million a unit. Northridge, $750,000. Hollywood, $871,000. Del Ray, $1 million a unit. Insane.
There are developers right now who will build brand new sick apartment units for $300,000 per unit. Like the sickest apartment buildings that you and I would live in, anyone would live in. They're sick. But affordable housing, because of bureaucracy, is $1 million a unit. It doesn't make any sense”
This is such a scam, and I can tell you exactly why they’re doing it this way
When these new developments do “affordable housing” the developers get the money from Democrats but in the contract they only have to be “affordable housing” for a set amount of years. After that they can transition them into being market rate
So developers are just building luxury properties for $1m per unit with our tax money then will cash in again when they switch from “affordable housing” to market rate
Another Democrat scam
Here is my take on LA multifamily right now:
Smaller banks are not accepting that many of their loans are under water, they wont accepts the current offers we are bringing.
They will end up selling for a bigger loss than the offers im bringing them today.
The pain is coming.
Taylor Avakian retweeted
“Work life balance? No. The more you work the more balance you can afford”
Great quote I heard this morning from @TAYVAY_ recent podcast.
Happy Tuesday!!!
What Austin has been able to do in a City like LA over the last 2 years is quite incredible.
If you want to hear how an owner is actually getting deals done in a highly regulated city like LA, I recommend listening.
Thanks for coming on @atnissly
Thank you @TAYVAY_ for having me on your podcast!
youtu.be/ieQpUgpH8Zs?si=cJXE…
7
1,299
Taylor Avakian retweeted
Thank you @TAYVAY_ for having me on your podcast! It was a lot of fun!
I Found A Solution To California Housing But... youtu.be/ScvEMiuPrhk?is=vGAE… via @YouTube
There is this one wholeseller who responds to my listing emails with the most Chat responses of all time.
It makes me not want to sell him a deal ever.
"Send it" is so much better than a paragraph about the local foot traffic and why your offer is 75% below asking.
If I get another unsolicited calendar invite to some zoom webinar I am going to file some complaints with google.
Is this the new BDR?
Just send me a calendar invite for "Beating Berkshire Hathaway Returns with AI", and think we are cool now?
5
12
1,306





