
PK-5 Principal of Lake Mills Community Schools. University of Northern Iowa grad #unifight#gobulldogs
- Tweets1.6K
- Following729
- Followers1.7K
- Likes4.5K

ALT Research Report A Survey of K-12 Iowa School Practitioners on Implementation Fidelity Practices Research shows that implementing evidence-based practices with fidelity is associated with improved students outcomes in reading. Accordingly, monitoring implementation fidelity is essential for understanding the extent to which practices are implemented as intended in school settings. As schools across Iowa seek to align literacy instruction with evidence-based practices, the Iowa Reading Research Center conducted a survey on the procedures, practices, and perceptions around implementation fidelity in Iowa schools.

ALT Key Findings Approximately 57.0% of Iowa practitioners who completed the survey reported implementation is monitored externally at least sometimes. Survey participants most often identified: (a) instructional coaches and principals as individuals responsible for monitoring implementation fidelity, (b) adherence to instructional components and student engagement as priorities during fidelity checks, (c) direct observation as a method for monitoring fidelity, and (d) time needed to visit classrooms to collect a representative sample was the most common barrier.

ALT On average, respondents affirmed use of 7.2 of the 13 fidelity monitoring practices (SD = 3.47) included on the Implementation Fidelity Practices Index. Item 1: Training is provided on implementing instruction or intervention with fidelity. Item 2: Fidelity data are collected as part of regular practice. Item 3: Fidelity data are collected on a clearly defined schedule or frequency. Item 4: Teachers are informed of fidelity criteria before a fidelity check. Item 5: Teachers are provided coaching, PD, or other resources to support implementation fidelity. Item 6: Observers use a rubric or checklist to monitor teachers’ delivery of a program or practice. Item 7: Teachers are involved in developing fidelity rubrics or checklists. Item 8: Teachers can view the fidelity rubric or checklist before an observation. Item 9: Teachers receive or discuss feedback about implementation fidelity after a fidelity check. Item 10: Teachers are provided with both quantitative and qualitative feedback af

ALT Overall, respondents held generally positive perceptions of implementation fidelity monitoring, with about two-thirds endorsing its importance and instructional value. Item 1: It is important that teachers implement a program or practice the way it is described in a manual or during training. Item 2: Adherence to a program or practice restricts teachers' flexibility to tailor instruction to meet students needs. Item 3: Fidelity monitoring is a tool to improve student learning. Item 4: Fidelity monitoring is not necessary. Item 5: Fidelity monitoring affects school culture negatively. Item 6: In my school setting, there is a collaborative and positive culture around fidelity monitoring. Item 7: Essential components of programs or practices have not been defined clearly enough to justify fidelity monitoring. Item 8: Fidelity monitoring is an essential practice for improving reading/ELA instruction.

ALT Support Literacy Research! The Iowa Reading Research Center is seeking elementary and high schools to partner on classroom observation research during the 2026–2027 school year. These studies will examine typical reading instruction practices in Iowa classrooms, with a particular interest in elementary schools using the Walk to Read model or classroom-based approaches to differentiated core or tiered intervention as well as high schools providing reading intervention for students receiving special education services. To express initial interest in collaborating or to request more information, please contact [email protected]. Iowa Reading Research Center





























