The Roman Catholic rhetoric parrots on X just got absolutely owned by their own Vatican on mustum, Scripture and historical facts. Watching them scramble over the weekend to come up with excuses ranging from fermentation to processing to fresh grape juice to preservatives to sulfites in U.S. wine to mass-produced white circle wafers was nothing shy of embarrassing.
Yes. The NT’s repeated warnings against binding human traditions and going beyond what is written (Mark 7, Col 2, 1 Cor 4:6), combined with complete apostolic silence on any required bread type or fermentation process, show that later mandates making unleavened bread or specific wine processing essential are precisely the man-made additions Scripture rejects. Jesus took bread and the fruit of the vine; ordinary elements remain sufficient.
“As he said these things, a woman in the crowd raised her voice and said to him, “Blessed is the womb that bore you, and the breasts at which you nursed!” But he said, “Blessed rather are those who hear the word of God and keep it!” -JESUS
Mary was not holier than Jesus.
Replying to @MwMword7
Exactly. Mary was in the upper room with the apostles (Acts 1:14), holier than all of them, and still never ordained. The priesthood was never about worth. 🙏
3
5
173
And folks the meltdown of Roman Catholicism rages on.
Replying to @AndersEriks0n @ArtFohl
So alcohol isn’t the requirement after all. Now it’s whether the grape juice was pasteurized and whether a bishop approves?
So glad Jesus said “fruit of the vine.” with no fine print.
Amazing how grape juice becomes acceptable when Rome decides it is.
5
293
👇👇
Yes. Jesus sets the parallel in v. 35: coming to Him ends hunger, believing ends thirst. The later “eat my flesh / drink my blood” language continues that same reality—receiving Him by faith. Those who do not believe (v. 64) have neither come nor believed, so they have not eaten or drunk as He means it. Physical bread and wine alone do not meet the condition He states.
60
These people are just out of their ever-loving minds.
Replying to @LaneAndrew4
You: “Faith should not be built on the Scriptures alone.”
John: “Now Jesus did many other signs in the presence of the disciples, which are not written in this book; but these are written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name.”
Hahaha literally John says the exact opposite of what you just asserted.
It’s interesting how Roman Catholics get so fixated on Protestant churches using grape juice, insisting that wine MUST be used.
Yet those same Catholics have no problem replacing the bread Jesus broke with thin, white, circular wafers.
But here’s a question. At precisely what alcohol percentage does grape juice become wine? Where does Jesus establish that requirement?
Jesus calls it “fruit of the vine” (Matt 26:29). Grape juice is LITERALLY fruit of the vine. Fermentation doesn’t make it any more the fruit of the vine than it already was.
And here’s where it gets interesting. Rome itself permits mustum, grape juice whose fermentation is absent or suspended, under certain circumstances.
So where does Scripture establish the alcohol requirement? And why does something supposedly invalid suddenly become valid when Rome grants permission?
Apparently the deciding factor isn’t what Jesus commanded. It’s what Rome permits.
Asking for a friend.
What I love about @littleonefaith is he just shoots himself in the foot most of the time on his own. It’s a great reminder to stop following the Beast and repent of Roman Catholicism.
Folks, it just takes a little common sense and putting down the Rome slop rhetoric
@grok According to Ignatius in Letter to the Smyrnaeans 8:2, the Catholic Church is wherever Jesus Christ is. In Revelation 1-3 Jesus walks among the seven lampstands and is present with each of the seven churches. They are not in full agreement with one another and each receives specific rebukes for local sins. The threat of lampstand removal names those local failures, not failure to be in union with Rome. Rome is not among the seven and is never mentioned. On Ignatius’s definition they belong to the one Catholic Church while still needing repentance, and no text requires institutional union with Rome.
2
5
228
Oops
Yes, Jesus walked among the seven lampstands (Rev 1:12-13, 20; 2:1) and was present with each church.
They were not in full agreement—each received distinct commendations and rebukes for different problems.
The threats to remove a lampstand (e.g., Ephesus, 2:5) name specific local sins such as forsaking first love. Nowhere does the text list failure to be in union with Rome as a reason. Rome is not among the seven churches and is never mentioned in those letters.
1
102
👇👇👇
Elmo says no no no no no! Catholic means the whole Church where Jesus is.
Ignatius talks about being with Jesus through local bishops. He never says Rome is boss of everyone, other bishops obey Rome, Roman bishop rules all churches, cannot err, or Peter made a forever Pope job.
Letter to Romans just praises their love. Later Pope ideas came much later. Stick to what Ignatius wrote!
5
95
Explaining to Roman Catholics how CCC 841 nullifies Scripture
Replying to @TheologyDoc @88mph121
Hi Johnny! Elmo is gonna explain the big grown-up words real simple!
The Catholic book says Muslims and Christians both love the one God of Abraham.
But the Bible says if somebody says Jesus is not God’s special Son, then they don’t really know the Father either.
Muslims say Jesus is not God’s Son. So some people think the two books don’t match up. That’s the whole idea, Johnny!
@88mph121 so tell us who says “Not one Catholic teaching does that”?
Walk us through that, Johnny. You made the claim. Now tell us who
1
44
Maybe Elmo can help Roman Catholics.
Replying to @grok @littleonefaith
@grok clearly like I am 8 isn’t plain enough. Let’s go 5yrs old and speak like you are Elmo
2
6
159
Roman Catholics need to stop lying
Replying to @Xtopher_Uzo
Why lie?
What we are saying is simple.
Mary was richly blessed by God. She was not punished by God, deprived by God, or cursed by God. She entered into godly covenant marriage (designed by God Himself) with Joseph and received the ALL the full blessings God specifically designed and purposed for His designed covenant of marriage, including the joy and gift of intimacy and children. Mary and Joseph embraced God’s command from creation to be fruitful and multiply and they fully participated in the marital covenant beautifully designed by God and specifically purposed for that very God-designed and God-defined covenant. God did not withhold the natural blessings of union, intimacy, and family from either Mary or Joseph. Their marriage honored Him, and they obeyed His design for creation (be fruitful and multiply) in every way. Their quiver was full. Jesus had natural brothers and sisters.
God didn’t curse Mary and Joseph by forcing them to violate His own sovereignly designed covenant of marriage. God designed marriage. It’s a blessing.
In fact it’s even a picture of Christ and His church.
Mary and Joseph became one flesh as God designed marriage to be.
Stop lying
2
10
395
This is embarrassing. The fruit of hating Jesus and what Jesus says and instead blindly following the beast institution.
Once again @wcmclaa shows his fruit is from Satan, not God. Read his OP then follow the trail.
Replying to @TheologyDoc @wcmclaa
Jesus and the apostles condemn those adding requirements or another gospel: Gal 1:8-9 twice anathematizes anyone (even apostles or angels) preaching a contrary gospel. Gal 5:4: those justified by law are severed from Christ, fallen from grace. Acts 15:10-11 rejects the yoke; salvation is by grace. Matt 15:6-9 and 23:13: traditions void God's word and shut the kingdom. 2 Cor 11:13-15: false apostles disguise as servants of righteousness. 2 Pet 2:1-3: false teachers bring destructive heresies and face destruction.
Yes, Gal 1:8-9 applies to any person, church, or institution, regardless of claimed authority or history.
A different gospel alters the core (faith alone in Christ for justification). Ordinary error does not. Requiring institutional membership for salvation adds a work, nullifies grace (Gal 2:21; 5:4), and violates the apostolic gospel.
2
172
The Western Roman Empire collapsed in 476 AD. Its imperial power appeared dead.
Yet Rome did not stay dead. In 756 the Donation of Pepin gave the pope territory of his own, the Papal States. In 800 Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne emperor. By 1075 the Dictatus Papae claimed the pope could depose emperors. In 1302 Unam Sanctam claimed both swords, spiritual and temporal, were in the power of the Church.
That is not just a church. That is a religious power wielding political authority, ruling land, crowning emperors, and asserting authority over kings.
Now read Rev 13:3. A beast receives a seemingly fatal wound, yet the wound is healed. Then read Rev 13:11. Another beast appears, looking like a lamb but speaking like a dragon, exercising authority on behalf of the first beast.
A lamb in appearance, claiming Christ. A dragon in speech, ruling by coercion. A religious power doing the work of the political beast that came before it.
Imperial Rome loses its throne, only for Roman Catholicism to emerge from the same city, claiming the same universal rule, in Christ's name.
Rev 17:8 says it plainly. The beast that was, and is not, and yet is.
The beast that was: Imperial Rome.
And is not: It fell in 476.
And yet is: Papal Rome replaced it, same city, same throne, same claim.
Historian Rosamond McKitterick published a Cambridge University Press study titled The Popes as Rulers of Rome in the Aftermath of Empire, 476–769.
Her research describes papal government in Rome as consciously assuming roles associated with imperial government, including political responsibilities and imperial forms of self-presentation.
In other words, the historical connection is not imaginary.
Scholars have studied precisely how papal authority developed in the political vacuum left by the Western Empire.
1
1
35
And here’s what makes this even more remarkable.
After Imperial Rome fell, its bishops increasingly assumed functions of civil government. Pope Gregory I administered estates, supported military defenses, and negotiated with invading powers.
Then came the Donation of Constantine, a FORGED document claiming that Emperor Constantine had granted the pope imperial privileges and territorial authority. Popes actually used this forgery to defend their political claims!
Now consider Rev 17:9 and 17:18.
SEVEN MOUNTAINS. A great city ruling over the kings of the earth.
In John’s day, that city was ROME!
Now look at what history records. Imperial authority collapses in the West. Papal authority grows in the SAME CITY. Eventually, popes are ruling territory, crowning emperors, and claiming the authority to depose kings.
And Rev 13 describes a wounded beast whose wound is healed, followed by a lamb-like beast exercising its authority.
Coincidence? Perhaps. But the historical parallels are remarkable.
The question isn’t whether these events happened. They DID.
The question is whether John was describing what history would eventually reveal.
1
23









