Tom Stringham (@TomStringham) header
Tom Stringham (@TomStringham) profile picture
Joined December 2012
It speaks well of us that we provide worship space to groups who would not do the same for us. “Interfaith” might be a stretch in these mostly one-way relationships. I lived within walking distance of four mosques in my old neighborhood; zero such events there to my knowledge.
3
97
Replying to @jkenney
Architects unfortunately claim not to like beautiful buildings if they are new! Their preferences depend on how old they believe the building is. It’s a bit of a cult and it’s very silly.
3
362
That's overstating it; as a metro area it's still more dense than every metro area in the US great plains.
15
439
Some people might just know Canadian geography better than you do? Had you heard of the Canadian Shield before today? Otoh, did you recognize the Palliser triangle on your map? The US has an extraordinary bounty of habitable land for its size; Canada does not.
3
68
Either way, polygamy probably hangs on longer in this scenario, though I would guess not forever. BC ends up bigger and the island much more developed, and Canada a richer, more interesting country, while Utah remains a desert wasteland. 9/9
1
10
348
Possibly Canada would have agreed to let the Saints keep polygamy in exchange for joining. Or maybe not, leaving LDS BC to go on its own, maybe declaring independence from Britain at some point or maybe eventually getting swallowed into the US after all. 8/
1
5
368
But then what would have happened in 1871, when Canada begged BC to join Confederation? An LDS BC would’ve been considerably more populous and powerful than the small frontier colony that was won over with the promise of a railroad in 1871, giving them a lot of leverage. 7/
1
4
376
A big sticking point would’ve been polygamy. That may well have been why the British didn’t grant the petition in the first place. But as the HBC recognized, if the Saints had decided to settle on the largely uninhabited island, no one would have been able to stop them. 6/
1
3
398
that the Saints had “no rights of occupation whatever”. For all we know this could have been the plan; BY was willing to burn everything down if needed, and if the church hadn’t been able to strike a deal using their contacts with the US who knows what would’ve happened. 5/
1
3
422
HBC was nervous when the Saints arrived in the valley and started trading with their posts in now-Idaho. During the Utah War they feared the Saints would abandon Utah and make the trek to Vancouver Island. So did the imperial government: the island’s governor was instructed 4/
1
7
440
permission to settle Vancouver Island and help doing it. The British were looking for settlers so it wasn’t a crazy idea. At least one MP wrote back asking for more details. But the Hudson’s Bay Company was very against the idea; they ended up getting control in 1849. 3/
1
5
500
the reach of the US government. They looked seriously at Texas but it was headed toward annexation, and California wasn’t isolated enough. They liked the idea of being under British rule. They went as far as sending a petition with 13,000 signatures to Parliament, requesting 2/
1
6
541
There’s a fun alternate reality where the Saints settled Vancouver Island instead of the Salt Lake valley and Canada is 15% LDS instead of the US being 1-2% LDS. Even before JS died, the church was looking for places for the Saints to settle that were beyond 1/
1
1
39
3,694
Cities are also in the wrong places and the physical geography is all wrong; much of the Shield is in green.
1
10
Otoh, Calgary and Edmonton are both denser than any city on the US plains and have been for some time. Houston is a whole different world.
1
14
If the US was as dense as Canada by region, it would have 450-500 million people.
30
This isn’t the same thing as being out of land, but it would make much more sense to, e.g., densify Kansas City and Omaha than Calgary and Edmonton, both of which are considerably denser than every US plains city.
1
49
habitable land is prairie/plains, less suitable for dense habitation, compared to only about a quarter of the US’s habitable land. When you adjust for environment finely enough, Canada is in fact more densely populated than the US.
1
55
Replying to @RichardHanania
Looking only at habitable land, the Canadian prairies are denser than the US Great Plains, BC is denser than the US west of the Rockies, and Ontario+QC+Atlantic provinces are denser than the US east of the Mississippi. It’s a simpson’s paradox thing!! 55-60% of Canada’s 1/
1
194
The orthodox bishops at the council of Nicaea tried to write down the doctrine using biblical language, but ultimately gave up and used nonbiblical language (homoousios). The Bible simply did not express their false belief that the Father and Son were the same substance.
1
2
40