
ALT Official UF faculty portrait of Dr. David Cuillier, director of the Joseph L. Brechner Freedom of Information Project, a Florida institution since 1977. He has spent "40 years of my life" on the public's right to know and told Congress that agencies weaponize "delays, confusion, and excessive fees." UF's own website quotes him: "Delay is denial and they know that." In March 2026 a Florida lawyer brought his Project documented proof that a circuit court and the Florida Bar were withholding paid-for public records, with litigation pending. Dr. Cuillier would not put one Project resource behind it, would not review the documents, would not comment. March 19: "Sorry to bum you out. As I said, it's not our mission." Asked to confirm all of that in writing, March 25: "Yep, that is correct." The records request went to UF the next morning. Under oath, September 2: "I don't really focus on Florida ... I'm not that familiar with Florida public records law." (Tr. 17:8-11) Tips: tips.fbi.gov

ALT James W. Kirkconnell, Assistant Counsel, UF Office of the General Counsel. He signed every UF filing in this case. July 7, to the court: all responsive records "were produced in their entirety." UF's own log records four deliveries, 1,158 pages. UF produced 53, all of them the requester's own emails. July 30: he put 426 of the purportedly located pages on the public docket instead of producing them, a stranger's home address unredacted, under a footnote saying they "have been redacted." He skipped both noticed depositions. Answered no discovery. Called it an "undue burden." The requests for admission he ignored are admitted under Rule 1.370: over 470 pages gathered, 53 produced, no exemption asserted. September 2: 538 pages emailed to the judge without copying the requester. No index. No certification. Then he asked the court to find the requester acted for an "improper purpose." It's knowing and intentional dishonesty. Tips: tips.fbi.gov

ALT Judge Donna M. Keim, Eighth Judicial Circuit. Three months on the case, two hearings, and not one ruling from either reduced to a written order. August 24: thirty minutes for three motions. UF's protective order granted verbally, but never explained. The requester's cross-motion never called. The depositions UF skipped and the discovery it ignored never reached. To the requester: "Sir, there's no additional time on the record." August 25: final hearing set eight days out, ninety minutes - over Petioner's objections. September 2: UF objected 46 times; she sustained 37, including 16 of 17 on UF's own documents and search. The requester's videographer was denied access; the circuit's Zoom log shows her removed by the host at 9:05 AM, never admitted, recording FALSE. Judge Keim cut every examination by time, never reached the requester's testimony, and ended the hearing while he was speaking. September 16: she granted the motion to disqualify her. Tips: tips.fbi.gov

ALT Judge David P. Kreider, Eighth Judicial Circuit, Division CA4. UF, B.A. 1989, J.D. 1992. September 18, 2026. 8:37 AM: the case is reassigned to him. 1:34 PM: he signs UF's protective order on a hearing he did not attend. 3:28 PM: he signs the final judgment for UF. No hearing. No stipulation. On testimony he never heard. That speed is not diligence. It is desperation to shield UF from the statutory and constitutional consequences of its own records. His one finding: "all materials requested by Petitioner that meet the definition of a public record were produced to Petitioner prior to the filing of this action." Not a word about the 340 pages UF located and never accounted for. Not the 621 pages logged in UF's file and missing from what it sent him. Not the 88 pages pulled for the judges' names. The objection and motion aimed at that submission: never ruled on. Three orders in one afternoon: astonishing neglect, or intentional unlawful acts to protect Clearly acting in bad faith

ALT "The University of Florida, in its own words," Hanson v. UF Board of Trustees, 01-2026-CA-001794. Lie #1: "This completes the public records request." UF, May 4, 2026, 3:22 p.m. That morning its IT office reported the search had "stalled," and its legal office logged 109 more pages "for approval to be released." Lie #2: "No exempt information was withheld or redacted from the records responsive to your request." UF, May 5, 2026. July 30, to the court: records "have been redacted" under FERPA and a bank-account exemption. Lie #3: "some records did not meet the definition of public records." UF's custodian, sworn, July 7, 2026. Sept. 2: UF sent those pages to the judge, saying they "contain some exempt information." Lie #4: "Q Did the University of Florida assert any exemptions? A No." UF's custodian, under oath, Sept. 2, 2026. Sept. 18: UF posted new "_Redacted" copies, citing federal student-privacy law and a bank-account exemption. Bottom line: The truth would have been one Band-Aid.

ALT Timeline card. May 4, 2026: UF sent Chris Hanson 53 pages and wrote "This completes the public records request," while its own file had logged 340 pages on March 30 and 109 rerun pages at 11:11 that morning for General Counsel review. May 5: UF wrote him "No exempt information was withheld or redacted from the records responsive to your request." July 7: answering the court's order to show cause, UF said "over 470 pages," an adjustable ceiling with a floor of more than 470 pages located, adjusted at least three times since. July 30 it filed 426 pages he had never received from UF.

ALT Timeline of UF Associate Counsel Amy B. Quillen's acts on Chris Hanson's March 26, 2026 records request. April 23: she told staff to let him know his request was "undergoing the legal review." May 3: she wrote that his email to Professor Bambauer "was not included in the results from UFIT for some reason." May 4: UF's IT office, copying her, reported the Bambauer search "stalled"; at 2:12 PM she wrote "Yes, please produce by end of business, today"; at 3:22 PM UF sent him 53 pages: "This completes the public records request." May 7: she had UF's IT office pull 88 pages on his cases and judges, kept out of his request. May 8: she wrote UF's reply about records that "relate to individuals who are not you." Strip: UF's lawyer decided what he got, and when.

ALT Timeline of UF Assistant Counsel James W. Kirkconnell on Chris Hanson's March 26, 2026 records request. March 26: UF's records office asked him and Quillen to discuss it. July 7: he signed UF's response saying its IT office "identified over 470 pages." July 15: he told Hanson by phone UF located 478 pages; Hanson confirmed it in writing July 16. July 30: he filed Exhibit D, pages 1 through 479. Sept. 2: he sent the judge's office six files, "Total 538," with a table naming two files for the 109 rerun pages, files UF's own May emails never name. Sept. 15: Hanson asked him whether the files are "precisely the same files that were identified during the initial searches." Sept. 17: his brief called the 109 pages "the same one submitted to Court," with no hash or native file. Strip: four page counts, one unanswered yes-or-no question, no proof the files are the files.

ALT Timeline of the two mailboxes in UF's search record for Chris Hanson's March 26, 2026 records request: Dr. David Cuillier, Director, Brechner Freedom of Information Project, and Professor Jane Bambauer, Professor of Law, Brechner Eminent Scholar Chair. March 30: UF's IT office isolated 330 pages from both mailboxes, saved in a named folder for General Counsel review; Bambauer offered to forward an email Hanson sent her. April 22: after 27 days with no word from UF, Hanson asked for the status and results of the search. April 23: UF said the request was "undergoing the legal review" and sent no results. May 4: UF asked Bambauer for that email; its IT office reported her mailbox search "stalled" at March 9 and a second search isolated 109 more pages; at 3:22 PM UF closed the request with 53 pages, all his own emails, only 3 from the 109. Sept. 2, under oath: Bambauer said no one told her; Cuillier said it "wasn't my business to say something."

ALT Ladder card. After its July 7 answer of "over 470 pages," UF's count moved: 478 pages on July 15 (stated by UF's lawyer by phone, per Chris Hanson's written record the next day, which UF never corrected), 479 pages filed July 30, and, on Sept. 2, 538 pages sent to the judge's office that afternoon. That morning UF's records custodian, under oath, was asked "how many total pages did University of Florida identify across all searches related to my public records request?" He answered: "I don't know the answer to that." (Sept. 2, 2026 transcript, p. 103, lines 7-11.) UF kept using the adjustable ceiling it created for itself and has never reconciled the numbers.

ALT Left: the header blocks of Exhibit D pages 401 and 440, filed by UF July 30, 2026, the same 39-page email from a private third party, name and addresses redacted. Below: Sept. 2, 2026 hearing transcript, page 127, UF's lawyer questioning UF's custodian: "did the University eliminate redundancies within those productions? A Yes." Pages 401-439 and 440-478 of UF's 479-page exhibit are one email, twice.

ALT Sept. 2, 2026 hearing transcript, page 103, UF records custodian John Hines under oath: "Q how many total pages did University of Florida identify across all searches related to my public records request? A I don't know the answer to that. Q Sir, you're the records custodian; correct? A Yes, sir." Page 100: "I did not read the 340 pages" and "I did not handle any of the review, legal review for this request." His July 7 affidavit, sworn under penalties of perjury: "I worked with UFIT and UF's legal department to parse through the 470+ pages." Twenty-four transcript pages after "I don't know," asked by UF's own lawyer, he said: "The 479 pages were an accumulation of all of the various IT searches that were conducted."

ALT Three excerpts. Sept. 2, 2026, the court ordered "every page accounted for" and UF's lawyer answered "Yes, ma'am." That afternoon UF's lawyer emailed the judge's office six files totaling 538 pages, "the files forwarded to the public records office as part of fulfilling this request," and wrote that Chris Hanson "has not been included on this correspondence." The transmittal carried no sworn certification of completeness and no page index tying the pages to UF's search batches. On May 7, UF's legal office wrote in the file for Hanson's request: "In addition to the 621 pages received from UFIT on 04/24/26." UF has never produced or indexed one of the 621 pages.

ALT Closing card. The counts the University of Florida gave for one records request: 53 to Chris Hanson (May 4), "over 470" sworn to the court (July 7), 478 by phone (July 15, per his written record), 479 filed (July 30), 538 to the judge's office (Sept. 2), and the custodian's sworn "I don't know" (Sept. 2). Verdict: Counted. Recounted. Unreconciled. Truth over chaos. Always.

ALT Closing summary card titled "What it means." UF: called Chris Hanson's records request complete May 4, 2026 while its own file logged more, and has never produced the files as its searches created them, with native form, metadata or a hash. Law and media: the records he asked for were those of UF's freedom-of-information center in its College of Journalism and of a professor holding a Professor of Law post and the Brechner Eminent Scholar Chair; the search of her mailbox "stalled," and UF closed his request that afternoon. The court: on Sept. 18 it found every public record produced before he sued, after reviewing 538 pages with no hash, no certification and no mention of 621 pages UF's legal office had logged; rehearing was denied "without the need for further briefing or hearing." Article I, section 24 puts the burden on UF; UF never carried it, and the court let that stand. The appeal is pending.









![Page 2 of 4, UF section of the email: Brechner's director wrote "Now [sic] rule or policy, I just have to triage"; UF later said it "does not have public records responsive" to who made the determination. Asks whether UF created new files after the May 4 objection.](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HVy2-7aWwAAJQSD.png?name=small&format=webp)





