Sonic XG is 4:3 because we designed the game to be 4:3. Accommodating the game to be in multiple aspect ratios requires way more work then you think. I'm sorry you don't like that choice but i would love to know how that compromises playability!
I wonder if Sonic XG being 4:3 is a technical issue or an attempt at being nostalgic… I hope it’s not the latter, bc a) that would be a stupid reason to compromise playability and b) the Saturn could *do* widescreen; in fact, ST’s NiGHTS is one of the most noteworthy examples!