Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1) profile picture

Critical pro wrestling fan. Calling out hypocrites, tribalist fans, and wrestling "journalists" since 2021. Not a Dave Meltzer puppet.

Joined March 2021
Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)Photo by Vic Neumann (@VicNeumann1)
Stop lying. Johnny Gargano isn't the worst wrestler in this video. If he left WWE and jumped ship to AEW tomorrow, you'd do a complete 180 and start glazing him. You're just pretending the Creed/Kasper Brothers are better, because they work for your preferred promotion.
Worst wrestler in this video still in da fed fml
5
1
110
2,593
If you think one wrestler is better than another, simply because of where they work, then you're toxic and just fanning the flames of tribalism. Both companies have great talent. There are some wrestlers in AEW that are better than some wrestlers in WWE, and vice versa.
1
12
414
I get what Drew Kasper/Brutus Creed was going for, but it doesn't work. 1) He's not a Bret Hart in 1997-level talent. 2) He's not making a statement. Bret spelled W-C-W in the air on WWF programming. We know he's in AEW. Spelling A-E-W on AEW programming means nothing.
55
63
2
1,006
67,560
Remember how WrestleMania 35 was universally panned for being entirely too long and a chore to sit through? It was. The main card was 5-hours long with 12 matches. The preshow was another 2 hours, with 4 matches. Sounds almost like an AEW PPV structure, doesn’t it? (1/3)
54
25
19
460
100,466
It’s funny how, in a few short years, many of the same fans who condemned WrestleMania 35 for being too long are willing to accept a show that length every month from AEW. Any criticism is met with the same tired “Lobster too buttery, steak too juicy” response. (2/3)
5
6
103
13,629
It made sense when AEW had four PPVs a year. Every show felt bigger and more important, because you weren’t getting one every month. Does WWE’s current PPV format offer too little? Absolutely, but I’d argue AEW’s is excessive and they’d both benefit from changing it up. (3/3)
9
6
88
11,928
I’m a little tired of the music playing throughout Anarchy in the Arena. It was kind of fun at first, but it’s played out now. It’s always reminded me of a Saturday Night Live sketch that they beat into the ground until it isn’t funny anymore. It’s played out. #AEWFullGear
14
1
1
13
1,374
I’m going to play devil’s advocate here. Ciampa’s booking in AEW hasn’t been markedly better than his booking in main roster WWE. Sure, he’s had two midcard titles, but both reigns were a week or shorter in length. If WWE booked him like that, you’d say he deserved better. (1/2)
I’m happy for Ciampa, and I’m glad he’s being booked and utilized better in #AEW than he ever was on the #WWE main roster. But let’s not push the whole “betting on yourself” narrative. It’s not exactly betting on yourself when you have a fat contract waiting for you the moment your WWE deal expires. #AEWCollision
35
6
7
136
44,164
In WWE, though, he was a two-time tag champion with Gargano. Their second reign was longer and better than the first, but neither one particularly memorable. He’s been a fine midcard/tag guy in both AEW and WWE, but that’s about it. He hasn’t felt like a top guy since NXT. (2/2)
4
1
1
31
4,956
Of course, because Tony Khan can’t help himself from signing whichever ex-WWE wrestlers hit the open market. Good for them for finding work, but I would’ve preferred to see them elsewhere. AEW hasn’t had enough TV time for everybody for a few years now. (1/2)
THE CREED BROTHERS ARE IN AEW!!! H O L Y S H I T !!!!!! #AEWFullGear
10
2
34
2,101
Some contracts have expired, but there’s still more talent coming in than leaving. I know places like MLW and TNA don’t pay as well, but I feel like they’d get to shine more there. Their rosters aren’t as bloated as WWE or AEW’s. They wouldn’t get lost in the shuffle. (2/2)
1
7
342
P.S. While it’s good they found work, I don’t feel like the grass will be any greener in AEW. With how deep the AEW roster is, I can see them being used for a few weeks before being relegated to Collision/ROH-only. I could be wrong, but how many times have we seen this?
2
1
8
263
I’m sorry, but who is asking to see the Costco Guys on AEW programming in 2026? Their 15 minutes of fame were in 2024. As a one-off, whatever. It’s been two years since they were relevant, though. You can’t even use the “they’re getting new eyes on AEW” argument anymore. (1/2)
Big Boom AJ & QT Marshall issue a challenge to RPG Vice for a multi-man tag team match at AEW Full Gear! Big Justice & The Rizzler will be there too!
37
5
5
81
11,399
AEW hasn’t had effective TV time for everybody on their roster in years. I’d rather see AJ’s spot used by someone currently sitting at home or otherwise left off the card. No use for this, just as I had no use for Lil Yachty vs. Baron Corbin at SNME. (2/2)
9
1,204
We're 25 minutes into Dynamite, and the first match is still not underway. Don't get me wrong, this Ospreay-Fletcher promo is great, but Isn't that what AEW fans hate about WWE? All talking, and no in-ring action. #AEW #AEWDynamite #AEWonTBS
31
1
2
56
6,433
If I say something vaguely critical of AEW, I'm an E-drone. If I say something even vaguely critical of WWE, I should stick to AEW. I'm a wrestling fan, first and foremost. I'm not going to incessantly praise either promotion, when they both have things they can improve upon.
12
11
1
76
1,505
I have enjoyed both promotions in the past, even though much of what they're both currently doing isn't clicking with me. If you're enjoying either one or both, the more power to you. That said, to me, 2026 hasn't exactly been a boom period for wrestling.
1
7
225
I can't believe it needs saying again, but I have never personally attacked anyone using racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, or otherwise discriminatory language. Disagree with me over wrestling, but you'll be getting blocked/reported if you come after me personally.
13
413
Remember when WWE started recruiting college athletes and some fans hated it? It was taking away spots from “real wrestlers.” Now, AEW has signed ex-WWE D1 recruits and the same critics are noticeably silent. In fact, some are even trying to get the Creed Brothers to come to AEW
40
20
9
198
21,634
Let me guess, the same people who usually claim that ratings don’t matter are taking a victory lap because their preferred promotion had more viewers. Either they matter or they don’t. They can’t only matter when the numbers favour AEW, and not when WWE beats them.
Ratings for this week’s head-to-head programming between WWE and AEW: NXT: 552,000 viewers | 0.13 in P18-49 Dynamite: 792,000 viewers | 0.24 in P18-49
14
3
29
930
If fhe ratings didn’t matter when NXT beat AEW Grand Slam: France, then keep that same energy now. If the ratings matter now, then they did on October 6th too. You can’t pick and choose when they matter, based on what paints your preferred promotion in a positive light.
2
5
175