Pinned Tweet
Replying to @qayyimtaqleed
I understand that Ibn Arabi and Akbarian thought can be difficult to understand, but that is not what Ibn Arabi meant. Let me tell you what he, and the Akbarians, understand all of this to mean.
1/ 1. First, the poem
١ فيَحمدني وأحمدهُ // ويعبدني وأعبدهُ
٢ ففي حالٍ أُقِرُّ بهِ // وفي الأعيانِ أجحدهُ
٣ فيعرفني وأنكرهُ // وأعرفهُ فأشهدهُ
٤ فأنّى بالغِنى وأنا // أساعدهُ فأُسعدهُ
٥ لذاكَ الحقُّ أوجدني // فأعلمهُ فأوجدهُ
٦ بذا جاءَ الحديثُ لنا // وحقَّقَ فيَّ مقصدهُ
1 For He praises me and I praise Him,
and He worships me and I worship Him.
2 For in a state I acknowledge Him,
and in the entities I deny Him.
3 For He knows me and I deny Him,
and I know Him so I witness Him.
4 So how [is there] self-sufficiency and I
help Him and make Him happy?
5 For this reason, the Real brought me into existence,
for I know Him and bring Him into existence.
6 Thus did the report (hadith) come to us,
and realised its intended meaning in me.
«ويعبدني وأعبدهُ»
"and He worships me and I worship Him."
First, a foundational principle in Islamic jurisprudence, fiqh, is that when a Muslim's statement admits multiple interpretations, ninety nine of which would entail kufr while one admits a sound interpretation, you are obliged to interpret according to the one sound meaning.
Before examining the individual readings of this phrase, one methodological point is essential. The masters of the Akbarian school frequently held multiple, concurrent layers of interpretation. They did not necessarily regard these readings as mutually exclusive; rather, they functioned as successive levels of a single reality. Thus, assigning a particular interpretation to one commentator does not mean that he rejected, or was limited to, the other readings.
Once this foundational premise is grasped, it is also necessary to hold in view the passage Ibn Arabi establishes immediately before the verses:
«فإِن ثبت أنك الموجود فالحكم لك بلا شك. وإِن كان الحاكم الحق، فليس له إِلا إِفاضة الوجود عليك والحكم لك عليك. فلا تحمد إِلا نفسك ولا تذم إِلا نفسك، وما يبقى للحق إِلا حمد إِفاضة الوجود لأن ذلك له لا لك. فأنت غذاؤه بالأحكام، وهو غذاؤك بالوجود. فتعين عليه ما تعين عليك. فالأمر منه إِليك ومنك إِليه.»
“If you are established as the one who exists, then the judgement is undoubtedly yours. And if the Real is the one who exercises judgement, He has nothing except to bestow Wujud upon you, while the judgement belongs to you, upon you. So praise none but yourself, and blame none but yourself; what remains for the Real is only the praise of bestowing Wujud, because that belongs to Him, not to you. You are His sustenance through the determinations, and He is your sustenance through Wujud. So what is incumbent upon Him is what is incumbent upon you; the matter is from Him to you and from you to Him.”
In light of this, the Akbarian school approaches the phrase “He worships me” through five cascading layers: first, Divine obedience; second, mushakala, or rhetorical correspondence; third, the dual linguistic reading of the unvocalised Arabic; fourth, the reciprocity of Lordship; and finally, a dialogue in which the pronouns shift according to the speaker.
1. Divine Obedience, The Hadith (Weak, but commonly cited in heart-softening, rqaqa'iq, tradtions)
Al-Jundi and Al-Qashani cite the Prophet's exchange with Abu Talib:
«ما أطوع لك ربك يا محمد!»
“How obedient your Lord is to you, O Muhammad!”
The Prophet replies:
«وأنت يا عم، إن أطعته أطاعك»
“And you, my uncle, if you obey Him, He will obey you.”
Since obedience, ta'a, is one of the meanings associated with worship, 'ibada, Allah's obedience to the servant can therefore be described as His “worship” of him.
Guys, I will just take a little break then I will get to all the DM's 🌷
Lots of love to my Muslims and non-Muslims.
2
10
883
Guys, I am gonna get to ALL the DM's very soon.
I am more than thankful for each and everyone of you. You rock! 🌷
2
532
Our tradition says 'A'isha was a child.
This is a problem. If the hadith is false, then what about all the other supporting hadiths? And if they are false, then what about the entire hadith corpus and Sahih al-Bukhari?
The whole tradtion now is untrustworthy as rigorous as it was.
unavailable
20
10
5,825
Ziad El Labban retweeted
شاب مصري يكلم جمله المريض عبر الهاتف الجمل عرف صوته وتفاعل معه سبحان الله
#بس_حبيت_اقول
Does this view have any presedence classically or is this a modernist Salafi invention: that Shi'as are not Muslims?
4
7
1,129
I have very severe OCD, to the extent that I was granted a medical exemption from military service because of it. Music therapy is also part of my treatment.
Now, imagine how I feel knowing that the overwhelming majority position in Islamic jurisprudence is against music, especially with my OCD on top of everything else.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Replying to @dmontetheno1 @ZiadElLabban
This is a beautiful statement and I wish we can say he is in our tradition but if we do that, then we need to extend our tradition to be of all Muslims striving for the truth even if they were skeptical of the Hadith system as Nazzam infamously was for.
“He used to not believe in ijmāʿ, he used to believe little in qiyās, he used to believe little in the authenticity of Ḥadīth reports, and he almost used to believe in nothing other than the Qurʾān and logic.”
Source: Ahmad Amin, Ḍuḥā al-Islām
Can someone explain how Islam is supposed to be compatible with modern civilisation if a Muslim president, vice-president, or any other public official cannot even wish their non-Muslim citizens a happy religious celebration?
And can someone explain why the West should not fear Muslims who are genuinely opposed to so many aspects of their way of life, particularly when many become further radicalised by being so far removed from their home countries?
In beauty, we find the Mind of the God.
Yet, a very, very substantial Muslim tradtion bans music and visual art of animate beings.
How? Answer me. How? This is one of the biggest problems I have with Islam.
Yet God says He is The Beautiful and loves Beauty and the Prophet says harshness only mars things while gentleness is in nothing but adorns it with beauty.
What if I think and feel beauty is both beautiful calligraphy and geometric and vegetal ornamentation and a piece of music, a portrait painting and a woman dressed modestly but with her hair showing?
I genuinely can't put any of my doubts into coherent words and it's driving me crazy.
I am not sure whether I am still a Muslim.
I don't really wanna talk about it either.
I am just tired.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Replying to @ZiadElLabban
I thought the game was alright, but what made it truly memorable was its historical detail. I have no trouble recommending it for that alone, as much of a hot take as that may be.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Replying to @ZiadElLabban
They should make an Assassin’s Creed set in medieval or Mughal Northwestern Pakistan/India
Yawn.
I am aware of this hadith.
A) The overwhelming majority of scholars do not accept this hadith.
As the scholar Ibn Qutayba said, "The hadith scholars do not establish the hadith of al-Zutt."
One of the reasons is because the man named 'Amr in the chain is not known to have heard from Ibn Mas'ud.
B) "Ride" ("rakiba") in the Arabic language can mean both mount sexually or crowding around someone so closely that they almost climb over him. And Ahmad al-Sirhindi said that.
This Post violated the X Rules. Learn more
HUH!!!! NO IT WAS NOT.
Watch this. One of the best videos on YouTube and isn't Arab or Iranian supremacist.
youtu.be/NglaUZ2au8g?si=i1Yd…

















