Pinned Tweet
Amongst other things, I try & argue 1) banks don’t need funds to give loans - rather, loans create deposits 2) banks can’t lend away liquidity surpluses, or address deficits 3) banks don’t borrow/ lend clean money with RBI - lazy banking can be a misnomer. cnbctv18.com/views/how-the-b…
In my latest Business Standard column, I argue that Indian banking needs its own 1991 moment.
PSBs are healthier today, and remain vital for financial inclusion. But long-pending governance reforms are overdue:
• Separate government ownership from operational control.
• Empower professional bank boards over strategy, appointments and pay.
• Give RBI ownership-neutral regulatory powers.
• Make the costs of public policy mandates transparent.
• Ensure any government ownership entity has genuine independence, not merely another bureaucratic layer.
As in 1991, this requires political leaders and administrators willing to relinquish authority.
The goal: minimum government, maximum governance, and a level playing field for all banks.
Article link: bit.ly/4t2u8Ng
169
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Union Minister for Finance & Corporate Affairs Smt. @nsitharaman chairs the first Pre-Budget Consultation with leading economists in connection with the upcoming Union Budget 2027-28, in New Delhi, today.
The meeting was also attended by Secretary, Department of Economic Affairs (DEA) @FinMinIndia; and Chief Economic Adviser, Government of India, besides senior officers from the DEA.
Ananth Narayan retweeted
India Inc has shown an incremental PAT growth of Rs 1 lac Cr plus for
Sept 26 quarter against most expectations.
Commendable achievement against the backdrop of higher oil prices, below average monsoon and supply chain disruptions.
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Net direct tax collections reached ₹14.42 lakh crore by November 10, 2026, up 11.76% from last year, covering about 53% of the full-year budget target of ₹26.97 lakh crore. Gross collections grew 14.02% to ₹17.50 lakh crore, but higher refunds of ₹3.08 lakh crore moderated the net gain. Corporate taxes led with 17.8% growth to ₹6.32 lakh crore, while non-corporate taxes rose 5.3% to ₹7.56 lakh crore, and securities transaction tax jumped 51% amid market activity. Analysts see robust corporate performance but note slower non-corporate growth as the government targets 15% annual expansion.
1. STT growing at 51% ....killing the Golden Goose by regularly hiking STT . Two years of no returns for investors and huge losses to traders, but govt makes 51% higher tax
2. Corporate taxes lower than personal income tax. Something is not correct when non corporates are paying more tax than firms.
3. Personal income tax growth is slowing at 5.3%. Inflation high, wage growth slow is the obvious inference.
4. Dont have data on STCG/LTCG here, so cant comment on that.
5. Corporate tax growing at 17.8% is pointing to robust earnings growth which is a positive for the markets.
6. Refunds are higher by 25%, these could be for multiple years.
7. Budget target was 15% . Gross collections growth is at 14% and net at 11.76% across the three broad categories.
8. Need to provide more tax relief to Personal income tax payers and capital market tax payers. STT is way too high , will cross Rs 75,000 crores this year at this rate.
Data on Gross Direct Tax Collections, Refunds and Net Direct Tax Collections for FY 2026-27 as on 10.11.2026 has been released.
The data is available on the national website of Income Tax Department at the following link:
incometaxindia.gov.in/docume…
You know GenZ is running the ticker desk when it says ‘FPIs back after ‘Ghosting’ India …’
Loved it 👏 @ShereenBhan @_prashantnair
Ananth Narayan retweeted
A man in the Philippines is seen at home checking his Dentist Licensure Exam results on his laptop, one of the most difficult professional exams to pass. His father stands beside him as he waits nervously.
After tense moments, the result shows PASS, officially making him a licensed dentist
Ananth Narayan retweeted
My interview with @IndiaToday on why we need a Covid like, all of government, Multi- sectoral urgent action on #AirPollution. Science based, public health oriented action is needed - a Swachh Vayu Abhiyaan. indiatoday.in/health/story/i…
Ananth Narayan retweeted
“Chalta Hai” Is Not Good Enough.
A system rarely rises above the standards society is willing to accept.
We aspire to better governance, world-class institutions and a developed India. Yet, too often, we continue to tolerate poor quality, weak enforcement and mediocrity in our everyday lives.
This is how Chalta Hai becomes more than an attitude. It becomes a culture shaping institutions, eroding accountability and making quality optional.@TheEconomist
#TukaramMundhe #GoodGovernance #FoodSafety #Leadership #GenZ
economist.com/asia/2026/11/0…
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Excellent inputs give by @udaykotak sir and @ananthng sir on how can government rationalize taxation on both equity and debt instruments in Indian capital markets.
On the Debt front we need to bring in parity or reduce the gap of taxation on how debt instruments are taxed at the highest tax slab of 33%++ vs the equity getting taxed at 12.5%++
On Equity taxation for FPI taxation needs to be made to zero how it's done globally as a practice.
While both the veterans did speak about how important FII and FPI capital is for our growth story, but for retail investors none of them mentioned that the taxation on equity should be removed or rationalised.
Excellent arguments by 2 of India’s best experts - @ananthng and @udaykotak on why and how capital gains tax needs to be recast @FinMinIndia @RBI
youtu.be/lpQo3rJkX6Y
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Excellent set of arguments. We should definitely reduce FPI taxation on cap gains to zero like nearly all other countries do.
I also think bond taxation through mutual funds is actually worth revisiting since bonds have some inherent risk (fixed deposits don't). But the data is clear: Bank FDs are simply the biggest place that people invest in, period.
The data for FY26:
Households invested 15 lakh crore in FDs
They invested 9 lakh crore in EPF/PPF, which is mostly invested in bonds (govt + some corporate)
They invested 3 lakh crore in NSC/Post Office deposits which is just fixed income
About 5 lakh cr went into insurance (which is partly fixed income/partly equity)
They invested net 5 lakh crore into equity+mutual funds
(Source: RBI Bulletin)
Equity is a very small part of household saving incremental allocations (just 12% of the 43 lakh crore additional savings by households in FY26 went into equity)
We can make equity relatively unattractive, but it's still too small a portion of household incremental flows, even compared worldwide. We should promote the bond market by lower taxation perhaps (allowing debt funds a lower capital gains tax) but not promote FDs any more - they are a HUGE part of all incremental allocations.
Excellent arguments by 2 of India’s best experts - @ananthng and @udaykotak on why and how capital gains tax needs to be recast @FinMinIndia @RBI
youtu.be/lpQo3rJkX6Y
Ananth Narayan retweeted
I like the argument made by @ananthng. We need to follow the global practice and he has effectively shown that the capital gains tax makes a substantial difference in the inflow of foreign investment.
Had a chat with @latha_venkatesh of @CNBCTV18News, following up on this article & others. I believe we need to move to residence-based taxation of foreign portfolio investments. We also need freer fixed income markets, and less taxes on debt would help. youtu.be/lpQo3rJkX6Y?si=Xy4e…
My latest @bsindia column: “Confronting economic trade-offs.”
India has meaningful macroeconomic buffers, but difficult policy choices may lie ahead.
A few key points:
• Credibility matters. Pursuing conflicting objectives across interconnected markets, while seeming to avoid difficult trade-offs, risks undermining market confidence. Clear communication is essential.
• Let both rupee interest rates and the rupee mostly find their own levels. Rather than suppressing rates through interventions and subsidized schemes, let discretionary savings largely finance borrowings. Freer debt markets can support more stable currency markets.
• Reform domestic fixed-income taxation. Lower taxes on interest income, and parity between debt and equity funds on capital gains, can attract savings without requiring higher headline rates. Tax revenue losses may be limited.
• Remove tax barriers to foreign investment. Tax capital gains on foreign portfolio investments in listed equities and corporate bonds in investors' home jurisdictions. Higher STT for foreign investors, particularly on high-turnover derivatives, could help offset tax revenue losses.
• Consult widely on capital-market tax reforms, as financial regulators do.
The objective is not to eliminate intervention, but to reduce the extent of painful trade-offs between growth, inflation, capital flows and external balance.
bit.ly/4i8Mo2z
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Excellent arguments by 2 of India’s best experts - @ananthng and @udaykotak on why and how capital gains tax needs to be recast @FinMinIndia @RBI
youtu.be/lpQo3rJkX6Y
Ananth Narayan retweeted
My podcast. The Global Economy in Transition | Crisil Podcast with Paul Gruenwald & ... youtu.be/g11cySqIFeQ?si=9Th9… via @YouTube
India’s serious ongoing bid for relevance and self-sufficiency in the world of chips: this piece by @dhume is worth a read. wsj.com/opinion/indias-big-s…
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Watch the entire conversation here: youtu.be/N5V-8LMz8vs?si=nSOU…
Ananth Narayan retweeted
“15 years ago, the AUM of debt mutual funds was significantly higher than that of equity mutual funds.”
“Today, equity mutual fund AUM is nearly 2.5–3 times that of debt funds.”
“Even if you offer a 7% return on a high-quality fixed-income instrument, the effective return for someone in the highest tax bracket works out to just 4.2%.”
“If you remove this tax burden, I’m willing to bet that investors would move a portion of their equity investments into fixed-income instruments such as FDs, debt funds and corporate bonds.”
- Ananth Narayan, former Whole Time Member of SEBI (2022 to 2025)
Ananth Narayan retweeted
“2026 was the first year in the history of Indian markets when the combined net FDI and net FPI flows turned negative.”
“Nobody is saying that India is a bad market. FIIs are simply pointing out that they are getting fantastic valuations for their listed and unlisted holdings in India.”
“For example, Korean auto majors have India operations that account for just 5–6% of their global sales, yet their Indian-listed subsidiaries command market capitalisations equivalent to around 40% of their global market capitalisation.”
- Ananth Narayan, former Whole Time Member of SEBI (2022 to 2025)
Ananth Narayan retweeted
He signed SEBI's July 2025 order barring Wall Street trading giant Jane Street.
Before joining SEBI, he spent 25+ years trading currencies, rates and derivatives at Citibank, Deutsche Bank and Standard Chartered.
When YES bank was in crisis, the RBI put him on its board as a nominee director.
He is none other than Mr. Ananth Narayan G. (@ananthng), IIT Bombay and IIM Lucknow alumnus, and former Whole-Time Member of SEBI (2022-2025).
In my recent podcast, he revealed game-changing insights on why foreign investors are selling India, how RBl's interventions are reshaping our markets and what it will take to bring Flls back:
→ Why are Flls exiting India? Low interest rates pushed savings into equities, valuations ran up, and promoters, MNCs and PE investors started encashing. Some Korean auto majors get just 5-6% of global sales from India, yet their India listing is ~40% of their global market cap.
→ How RBI bought Rs. 8.8 lakh crore of bonds in FY26, about 85% of the central government's net borrowing, and then sold $192 billion across FY25 and FY26 to defend the rupee. He calls it pouring water into a leaky bucket.
→ Why fixed income died as an asset class. A 7% fixed deposit earns roughly 4.2% post-tax in the highest bracket. 15 years ago, debt fund AUM was bigger than equity AUM. Today, equity is 2.5-3x of debt.
→ His fix: bring tax parity between fixed income and equity. If that happens and markets correct, he says he would personally be inclined to buy Indian equities.
→ Why India's credit market is just 65% of equity market cap, against a 140% world average and 310% in China, and how SEBI balances type one and type two errors while regulating.
This episode is powered by @_groww.
Check out the full episode with Mr. Ananth Narayan on my YouTube channel!
Ananth Narayan retweeted
Are SIPs making stocks expensive?
“A lot of money is flowing into SIPs because you have killed fixed income, be it fixed deposits, debt funds or corporate bonds.”
“You have killed it by suppressing interest rates and keeping them lower than what savers expect to earn. On top of that, there is usurious taxation on fixed-income investments.”
“So, I’m not blaming SIPs. The conditions created in the debt market have forced money to flow into other asset classes.”
- Ananth Narayan, former Whole Time Member of SEBI (2022 to 2025)


























