Replying to @RobDFB
You’re the fucking idiot. Read dumbass “isn’t that Utah isn’t a legitimate contender”
48
Replying to @RobDFB
My College Football Top 10 — Based on resume Not Just Records
Georgia (8-1)
Notre Dame (8-1)
Alabama (7-2)
Utah (9-0)
Texas (7-2)
Miami (8-1)
Indiana (8-1)
Tennessee (7-2)
UCLA (9-0)
Texas Tech (8-1)
Here’s the reasoning:
Georgia #1: The strongest combination of quality wins, schedule difficulty, and demonstrated performance against high-level competition. One loss doesn’t erase an otherwise superior résumé.
Notre Dame #2: A signature victory over previously top-ranked Miami provides meaningful evidence of championship-level ability. Quality of opposition matters.
Alabama #3: Two losses deserve scrutiny, but so does the difficulty of the schedule. Penalizing teams for facing elite competition while rewarding others for avoiding it creates a fundamentally flawed evaluation system.
Utah #4: Being undefeated is impressive, but it isn’t definitive proof of superiority. The question is whether Utah’s accomplishments against its competition outweigh what other contenders have demonstrated against stronger opponents.
Texas #5: Four ranked victories provide substantive résumé evidence. Quality wins should carry more weight than simply accumulating victories against inferior opposition.
Miami #6: An excellent overall body of work, but head-to-head results matter. Notre Dame’s victory must be reflected in the evaluation.
Indiana #7: A strong record deserves recognition, but opponent quality and schedule difficulty must be evaluated before placing Indiana above teams with more demanding résumés.
Tennessee #8: A legitimate contender with a head-to-head victory over Alabama. That result matters, although the complete season résumé must also be considered.
UCLA #9: Undefeated deserves respect, but a perfect record doesn’t automatically establish top-three superiority. The quality of the tests matters as much as passing them.
Texas Tech #10: Quality victories and a strong overall season warrant inclusion, but the résumé must be measured against the same standards applied to everyone else.
The fundamental issue with Donaldson’s rankings is consistency.
You cannot use strength of schedule to elevate one team, ignore it when evaluating another, and selectively invoke undefeated records whenever convenient.
A legitimate ranking must consider strength of schedule, quality victories, opponent-adjusted efficiency, head-to-head results, and the circumstances surrounding losses.
The objective isn’t to reward teams for having the fewest losses. It’s to identify the teams that have demonstrated the greatest quality against the strongest competition.
Otherwise, you’re not ranking the best teams in college football.
You’re ranking the easiest paths to an impressive record.
2
313
Replying to @atomic_lock @RobDFB
The problem with Utah at #1 isn’t that Utah isn’t a legitimate playoff contender. It’s the intellectual inconsistency required to declare them the best team in college football.
An undefeated record is an accomplishment, not an automatic qualification for the top ranking. Strength of schedule, quality wins, opponent efficiency, and performance against elite competition must carry meaningful weight.
If Georgia has navigated a more demanding schedule and demonstrated comparable or superior performance against stronger opponents, what objective metric establishes Utah as the better team?
You cannot treat all wins as equivalent while ignoring the enormous differences in the quality of competition. Beating nine opponents doesn’t necessarily demonstrate greater strength than beating eight substantially better ones.
And if Utah’s undefeated record is the deciding factor, then you’re evaluating the absence of losses rather than the presence of championship-level evidence.
The burden isn’t on everyone else to prove Utah doesn’t belong at #1. It’s on the person ranking them first to demonstrate why their résumé and performance justify that distinction.
An undefeated record tells us Utah hasn’t been beaten. It does not establish that Utah would beat everyone else.
That’s the fundamental difference between evaluating a team’s accomplishments and actually evaluating how good that team is.
2
2,260
Replying to @RobDFB
The problem with these rankings isn’t simply where Alabama sits. It’s the complete lack of a consistent evaluation standard.
If strength of schedule and quality wins matter, Alabama at #11 and Wake Forest at #7 demand serious explanation. If overall record is the priority, then stop pretending all wins carry equal weight.
A team’s resume should reflect WHO it beat, WHO it lost to, and the difficulty of its competition. Otherwise, you’re rewarding teams for avoiding challenges while penalizing those who actually face them.
You can’t selectively apply résumé metrics to justify rankings you’ve already decided on.
That’s not analysis. That’s confirmation bias disguised as expertise.
1
691
Replying to @SportsDogma
Well, half the fun is waiting for your in game tweets. But the main excitement is cashing the 3U
1
73
Replying to @SportsDogma
You’re going to give me a heart attack. I expected to look at the score and find it still 28-6 with 3:00 left.
1
1
286
Replying to @KirkHerbstreit @cbfowler
Looks like OSU just quit…..used 2 TO to hang around and just absolutely quit. Choked on the FG miss and then just gave up.
1
420
Replying to @GrindingEddie
0-for-9 is impressive. Most people accidentally make one. Have you considered aiming somewhere other than where you’re aiming? However, the good news is your green reading is incredibly consistent.
1
3
212
Replying to @PatrickE_Vegas @CaesarsSports
I’m going to jail if I am Coach LT. I don’t know how B10 explains that call.
1
73
Replying to @PatrickE_Vegas @CaesarsSports
They need to give those guys $600 in free play and 2 buffets tickets tickets. That was criminal!
1
2
211
