Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99) profile picture
Joined July 2009
Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)Photo by Andrew BArnes (@barnzi99)
I want to begin with a word of thanks, and I mean it sincerely. Starlink has played an enormously important role in maintaining communications in Ukraine since the beginning of Russia’s full-scale invasion. And in February of this year, SpaceX, working with Ukraine, introduced measures to block the unauthorised use of Starlink by Russian forces. This helped counter Russian military operations, including the use of attack drones. We remember this, and we appreciate it. But I would like to explain what the current controversy is actually about. Musk argues that Ukraine wants to use commercial Starlink for offensive military operations. He emphasises that Starshield is a separate system controlled by the US government. However, this explanation does not address the specific question Ukraine has raised: why are Starshield restrictions interfering with Ukrainian interceptor drones designed to protect civilians from Russian aerial attacks? Russia uses jet-powered Shahed drones that travel at speeds well above 161 km/h. According to Ukrainian military reports, Starshield terminals lose connectivity once they exceed that speed in areas where the restrictions apply. This makes it more difficult to operate interceptor drones that need to catch up with Russian targets. On 12 November, President Zelenskyy explicitly stated that these restrictions allow more Russian strikes to reach their targets, resulting in the deaths of Ukrainian civilians. So this is not simply about the ability to strike Russian military targets. It is about Ukraine’s ability to intercept a Russian drone heading towards a residential building, a hospital, or a power station. This is defence in the most basic, human sense of the word. Now, who made the decision? Musk maintains that Starshield is controlled by the US government and that decisions concerning its military use fall under the Pentagon’s authority. On 21 October, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said he was unaware of the administration having been informed in advance about the restrictions, and that access and speed limits were governed by the relevant commercial contracts. The Wall Street Journal, citing its sources, reported that Musk personally made the decision to impose the restrictions. Reuters, meanwhile, cited other officials who pointed to the White House. The Trump administration denied involvement, while SpaceX disputes reports of new changes to the restrictions in November. I do not know which of these accounts is correct. But I see an obvious problem: Ukrainian military personnel are reporting restrictions that affect their defensive capabilities, while responsibility for those decisions remains unclear. This uncertainty has also raised questions in the United States. On 13 November, US senators formally called on Musk and SpaceX to preserve technical records, correspondence, and documents that could establish who authorised the restrictions, when and on what grounds, and whether their consequences for Ukrainian air defence and the civilian population had been assessed. There is another contradiction. When asked directly in the interview whether Ukraine actually uses Starshield, Musk responded by saying that Zelenskyy was not telling the truth and that what he really wanted was to use commercial Starlink for offensive operations. Yet back in December 2024, Bloomberg reported on Pentagon contracts with SpaceX providing Starshield services for a total of 3,000 terminals in Ukraine. A US government agency confirmed that figure to Bloomberg. And in October of this year, Musk himself publicly explained that decisions concerning Starshield restrictions fell under the authority of the US government. This does not prove that every Ukrainian terminal operates through Starshield, but it does establish that Ukraine had access to the system under these contracts. Therefore, accusing Zelenskyy of being untruthful requires a specific technical explanation, not simply a denial. I also want to acknowledge Elon Musk’s personal role at the beginning of the full-scale invasion. On 26 February 2022, just two days after the invasion began, Mykhailo Fedorov appealed to him to provide Starlink connectivity to Ukraine. Musk responded immediately: the service was activated, and the first shipment of terminals arrived in Ukraine on 28 February. SpaceX had also been preparing to launch the service in Ukraine before the invasion. This was critically important assistance at a moment when Russia was attempting to destroy Ukraine’s communications infrastructure. The speed of Musk’s response, his personal involvement, and his willingness to provide Ukraine with technology on which communications, defence, and human lives depended deserve genuine gratitude. I want to thank him once again for that. A few words about history, because accuracy matters here too. The Maidan was not a coup organised by the United States. It was a months-long popular protest movement that began after the Ukrainian government abandoned preparations to sign the Association Agreement with the European Union. The protests were marked by violence, and dozens of protesters were killed in February 2014. After Yanukovych left Kyiv, the Ukrainian parliament, the Verkhovna Rada, adopted a resolution on 22 February declaring that he had withdrawn from exercising his constitutional powers and calling early presidential elections. The legal aspects of that decision, the role of external actors, and US diplomatic influence can all be debated. But none of this constitutes evidence that Washington organised a coup. Mr Musk presented no such evidence. Instead, this version of events is one of the central narratives Russia uses to justify its aggression against Ukraine. I find it deeply disappointing to hear it from Elon Musk. And finally. Musk speaks about the need to have empathy for those who die in war, including Russian soldiers. I understand this argument: every human life matters. But empathy should not erase the distinction between the responsibility of an aggressor state and the right of a country under attack to defend itself. Moreover, the moral consequences of restricting communications cannot be judged solely by whether the technology helps carry out strikes. We must also consider how many lives it helps protect. If a Ukrainian interceptor drone loses connectivity and can no longer catch a Russian attack drone, that does not mean the use of lethal force has been avoided. It means that other people are placed at greater risk — civilians in their homes, in their beds, in the middle of the night. So my request is simple. Whoever makes these decisions must explain them openly, and responsibility for their consequences must be established. Restrictions on critical communications infrastructure, on which the protection of civilians depends, should not be introduced without proper justification, advance warning, and coordination with those directly affected.
125
517
40
1,751
73,566
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Putin is the greatest mass murderer of this century, and Trump absolutely loves and worships the guy. This clip is the only clip from this summit that history will remember.
22
183
7
742
9,351
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Q: I know you're working with Europeans on satellites in space so as not to become dependent on Starlink. Carney: “We've seen cases, like in Ukraine, where a dependence on Starlink or Starshield has gone from being an advantage to a huge vulnerability. Like that [snaps fingers]. You can't unsee that once you've seen it. Particularly given the integration of space technology and defense technology, drone technology, I mean, all the aspects. So the issue for us, the issue for the Koreans, the issue for the Japanese, the issue for the Europeans is: Can we build, at a minimum, a redundant system or a sovereign system? With whom do we pool in order to do that? How are we going to protect the Arctic and the High North? Whose system are we going to rely on? Can we rely on that system when push comes to shove? Who will make the decision as to whether that system is on? These are fat-tail risks that have been realized in the recent past by some of our allies. That's the situation in which we and others are making those determinations.”
54
822
20
3,738
63,646
Andrew BArnes retweeted
“If they want to talk about territories and compromises, then I’ve always said; you want to talk about territories? Then Speak with me. You don't want to speak with me? Then maybe it's not so important for you.” There’s a lot of really good quotes from this Q &A with president Zelenskyy, but the very best might just be this one at the end 🤌🏼👏🏼
6
47
149
2,206
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Sleepy Donnie
27
144
6
1,605
16,702
Andrew BArnes retweeted
🇬🇧 PM Burnham: “I hope this message is heard very clearly in Moscow. For as long as it takes, we will be there at the side of Ukraine and we will not falter. Our support will be unwavering. That is the biggest weapon we have together: the solidarity of all of Europe, which has been on display today, and which I hope has been seen around the world. This is a lose-lose situation, but the biggest loser is Russia. They are losing as many men every two to three months as they lost in the whole nine years of the conflict between the Soviet Union and Afghanistan. That was judged a disaster, but the loss of life is on a much greater scale here. How much land have they taken? No more than an additional 0.2% of Ukrainian territory for that huge human cost. So let’s be clear: Russia is losing men, Russia is losing ground, and Russia is losing the battle to break Ukraine. From what I’ve seen of the resilience of the President and of the Ukrainian people, they are unbreakable. They should know that with us at their side, they can carry on fighting this with everything we’ve got. But this clearly has to be a moment to move towards peace, because of the US involvement we’ve seen today and the progress that is clearly being made. Europe is ready to enter these negotiations. We are clear about what we will accept and what we won’t accept. But we are also clear that we stand with Ukraine today, tomorrow, and for as long as it takes until this unjust war is over.”
251
972
46
4,009
50,351
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Zelenskyy was asked whether he was prepared to die for Ukraine. He replied that everyone wants to live, but he is simply doing what a president is supposed to do.
10
140
3
1,367
27,415
Andrew BArnes retweeted
‼️ ELON MUSK, LET ME FUCKING EXPLAIN SOMETHING TO YOU. American billionaire Elon Musk is once again calling for sympathy for Russian soldiers who, according to him, are forced to go to the front lines and die in drone strikes. He also complains that the world supposedly views the war too simplistically, through the idea that “Ukraine is good, Russia is bad.” NOW LISTEN TO ME, ELON. Ukraine has an official government project called “I Want to Live” (Хочу жить). It was created specifically for Russian soldiers who do not want to fight against Ukraine and want to stay alive. They can contact Ukraine’s Coordination Headquarters in advance, receive instructions on how to surrender safely, and save their lives. Ukraine guarantees prisoners of war food, medical care, opportunities to contact their families, and treatment in accordance with the Geneva Conventions. And I’m not saying this based only on what other people have told me. I PERSONALLY VISITED A FACILITY WHERE FOREIGN PRISONERS OF WAR RECRUITED BY THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION ARE BEING HELD. I saw their living conditions. How they eat, where they sleep, how they live, and how they communicate with one another. I conducted interviews, documented their daily lives, and spoke with people off camera. And you know what? MY JAW IS STILL ON THE FLOOR BECAUSE OF HOW DIFFERENT THE CONDITIONS I WITNESSED WERE FROM WHAT I EXPECTED CAPTIVITY TO LOOK LIKE. I’m not claiming that my visit proves conditions are the same in every detention facility. But what I personally witnessed is a fact of my own experience. Now let’s talk about Ukrainians in Russian captivity. About torture. About sexual violence. About executions. About people who have been held for years without contact with their families. About Ukrainian prisoners of war and civilian hostages who have endured horrific treatment. WHERE IS YOUR COMPASSION FOR THEM, ELON? You talk about Russian sons who will never see their parents again. What about Ukrainian children whose fathers were killed by Russian soldiers? Ukrainian mothers who have spent years searching for their sons? Families who don’t even know whether their loved ones are still alive in Russian captivity? You want us to sympathize with Russian soldiers, but why does the most important fact disappear so easily from your arguments? RUSSIA INVADED UKRAINE. UKRAINE DID NOT INVADE RUSSIA. Russian soldiers are on our land as members of the armed forces of an aggressor state. Ukrainians are defending their homes, families, cities, and right to exist. Yes, some Russian soldiers may have been forcibly mobilized. Yes, human life has value. But compassion does not erase responsibility. And the forced mobilization of some individuals does not justify Russia’s invasion. THOSE WHO DO NOT WANT TO KILL UKRAINIANS HAVE THE OPTION OF SEEKING A WAY TO SURRENDER. Official project: hochuzhit.com/en/ And one more thing. You have enormous influence, money, technology, and an international audience. Your words are therefore not just a private opinion. When you repeat claims that blur Russia’s responsibility for this war, you help normalize the dangerous idea that the aggressor and the victim of aggression bear equal responsibility. ELON, WE ARE NOT OBLIGED TO DIE SO THAT YOU CAN FEEL SORRY FOR RUSSIAN SOLDIERS. We have the right to defend ourselves. We have the right to live. And we have the right to demand accountability from those who came to kill us and those who justify this war. GLORY TO UKRAINE! 🇺🇦 🔥 #ElonMusk #RussiaIsTheAggressor #FreeUkrainianPOWs #RussianWarCrimes #StandWithUkraine
576
2,501
185
7,818
122,109
Andrew BArnes retweeted
If only there was already an example of a country that has given up its nuclear weapons. The respect shown for their sovereignty afterwards would serve as the example for all other countries considering whether to disarm.
20
173
4
1,116
12,851
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Telling to literal invader war criminal that you are going to protect him from International Criminal Court is just... wow
Trump tells Putin and Xi that he will be suggesting ways to protect their countries from the International Criminal Court
139
1,073
45
3,758
33,233
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Who is he❓️ He is #DonaldTrump—America’s eternal disgrace in historical perspective!
31
51
6
157
1,313
Trump is truly doing everything he can to help his friend, the mass murderer Putin. As Politico reports, Trump criticized spending on aid to Ukraine during a summit of the "Coalition of the Willing." The U.S. President joined the meeting in Berlin by phone from aboard Air Force One. He called his special envoy, Jared Kushner, who put the call on speakerphone so that everyone could hear. According to two summit participants, Trump effectively confronted the heads of state and government in attendance over the billions of dollars in aid being provided to Ukraine.
80
309
18
714
10,869
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Zelensky paused to think when a journalist asked whether Trump had called him his friend “He told me a lot of different words. Positive ones also.” The Ukrainian president also commented on the strikes against the Crimean Bridge: “Crimea is Ukraine, and we can do whatever we want with what belongs to us.”
Karma is a subtle thing: first the Crimean Bridge damaged the environment, and now it's getting what's coming to it The construction of the Crimean Bridge disrupted the natural balance of the Kerch Strait and the Sea of Azov. Its embankments and supports altered water exchange and sea currents, affected ice movement and threatened fish and dolphins. Tuzla Island suffered the most: its natural ecosystem was effectively destroyed. In addition, sand from an area contaminated with toxic waste was used during construction. According to Ukraine’s Ministry of Reintegration, chromium levels in the sand exceeded permissible limits by 1,420 times, while arsenic levels were 500 times above the norm. The construction of the bridge cost Russia approximately $5 billion.
12
229
2
1,407
60,128
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Russian drone slammed into a residential area in Kyiv in broad daylight today.
42
311
26
1,000
47,736
Not only is this complete bullshit, but Ukraine has had multiple democratic elections and changes of government since 2014. • Yanukovych — 2010–2014 • Turchynov (acting) — February–June 2014 • Poroshenko — 2014–2019 • Zelenskyy — 2019–present The only people still pushing this "coup" bullshit are either genuinely ignorant or deliberately parroting Kremlin propaganda. Which category Musk falls into is anyone’s guess.
Elon Musk spews Kremlin propaganda: “We Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine. That’s an offensive action.”
43
384
10
1,986
33,096
Putin: We didn't start the Ukraine war. We didn't start any wars. Ukraine was already waging war, and we tried to put an end to it. Comment from me: He's lying, of course. Russia is an aggressor.
726
1,266
168
7,436
126,417
Putin stated that if EU representatives want to participate in negotiations on Ukraine, they first need to come to Moscow to discuss their demands. Comment from me: Moscow is not a neutral venue. Full-fledged peace talks or preliminary consultations cannot take place on the territory of the aggressor state. Neutral international platforms exist for this purpose, where the parties are on equal terms. This proposal is a distraction from the aggression. As Kaja Kallas has repeatedly emphasized, the Kremlin is trying to shift the focus from its own unprovoked aggression to abstract discussions about "European security." In this war there is one aggressor and one victim, and the threat to European security is created solely by Russia. Europe has already clearly defined its format of participation (a team of representatives of EU institutions and the E5 format countries) and its position. It consists of unconditional support for Ukraine’s sovereignty and the restoration of a just peace based on the UN Charter. Therefore, traveling to Moscow to "clarify demands" makes no sense.
Putin: We didn't start the Ukraine war. We didn't start any wars. Ukraine was already waging war, and we tried to put an end to it. Comment from me: He's lying, of course. Russia is an aggressor.
55
296
14
911
25,775
Andrew BArnes retweeted
Poland’s foreign minister and deputy prime minister sets Elon Musk straight.
No, @elonmusk. Stop mouthing Russian propaganda. I was there and there was no coup in Kyiv in 2014. And the US contribution to stopping the pro-Russian President Yanukovych’s massacre of Ukrainians on the Maidan was Victoria Nuland handing out cookies in the streets and saying ‘ Fuck the EU.’
13
151
1
947
9,805
No, @elonmusk. Stop mouthing Russian propaganda. I was there and there was no coup in Kyiv in 2014. And the US contribution to stopping the pro-Russian President Yanukovych’s massacre of Ukrainians on the Maidan was Victoria Nuland handing out cookies in the streets and saying ‘ Fuck the EU.’
Elon Musk on Ukraine: It's true that from an invasion standpoint, Russia is the aggressor, but it is also true that we Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine. Without U.S. State Department and other agency help, this would not have happened. That is obviously an offensive action.
1,646
5,268
194
25,064
431,216
Andrew BArnes retweeted
A convicted felon and an indicted war criminal are being hosted by a dictator-for-life who's ethnically cleansing his muslim population. It's not a "summit". It's a criminal conspiracy.
33
339
7
2,157
23,387